TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Blind community to blitz Irish Rail with protest texts

Two staffers at Irish Rail are due to be inundated with texts about the poor quality of audible announcements on Irish trains.

Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

A NUMBER OF people with various vision impairments have banded together to launch a protest against Irish Rail’s (Iarnród Eireann) “persistently poor quality” audible announcements on trains.

The group have called on members of the visually impaired community and its supporters to send text messages to the press officers of Irish Rail on 23 July to signal their disappointment at the lack of audio announcements on Dart services and the poor quality of those on Intercity trains.

They hope the texts which are intended to flood the inboxes of two communications managers will send a message “loud and clear” that they are not happy with current arrangements.

Kerie Doyle, who is a totally blind rail user, explains: “People with a vision impairment are forced to rely on other passengers to assist them when the audio announcements fail. I have had a recent incident where I was put in danger by the inadvertent actions of another passenger who informed me that I was at Tara Street Station, when I was actually at Pearse Street Station.”

Doyle told TheJournal.ie that “we just decided we’ve had enough. There have been various things that have happened to all of us. Irish Rail haven’t been interested so it is time to make our complaints public.”

A spokesperson for Iarnród Eireann said the group empathises with the frustration that visually impaired customers feel because onboard announcements are not working correctly on all Dart services.

She added that all Intercity trains have working, audible announcements.

However, another protest organiser, Tim Culhane said that he is never sure if he can rely on the audible announcements.

“Even when they are available they can be out of sync with the actual station you are arriving at or the sound quality is so poor that they are impossible to hear. As a result, you have to keep track in your mind of where you are at all times, assuming of course that you are familiar with the order of stations.”

Back in 2005, people with vision impairments protested strongly over a move by Dublin City Council to switch off the audible crossings at traffic lights. The decision was eventually overturned and the signals switched back on after a large demonstration outside City Hall during the election of the mayor.

Martin O’Sullivan, who has set up the group’s Facebook page, says the community is reluctant to launch a similar action but would consider it if the situation does not improve after Monday’s protest.

Members of the group, who came together because they all appear on a common mailing list, have asked the public for its support.

“We would like persons without a vision impairment, including TDs and Senators, to send the following text:

Hello my name is [blank], I am supporting the campaign by persons with vision impairment. I am contacting you to highlight the lack of audible announcements on both Dart and Intercity rail services. I would also like to point out that audible announcements are of a great value to our tourist industry. I would be most grateful if you could give me an exact date and time when this problem will be resolved. I would like to hear from you as soon as possible.

In a statement to TheJournal.ie, Irish Rail said 52 per cent of the Dart fleet had a completely new system installed between 2007 and 2009 and that €120,000 has recently been spent upgrading some of the more obsolete functions on non-refurbished trains. This work is almost complete, according to the spokesperson.

The agency has tendered for a new modern replacement system for the remaining DART trains and the NTA has indicated its support for the project. “It is important that any system chosen meets all of the performance criteria expected and this will take time to implement,” concluded the statement.

For more information on the text blitz, visit the Safe Travel for All Facebook page.

More: Free WiFi launched on all Irish Rail Intercity trains

Read next:

Comments (29 Comments)

  • camada 19/07/12 #

    Best idea i’ve heard in a while and i’m sighted!!!!

    Reply
    • Mjhint 19/07/12 #

      Agree.I can never make out whats been said on these trains.

      Reply
    • A number of times I’ve had to check news sites & twitter in order to make out what that crackling noise coming from the platform speakers was trying to communicate.

      When you find yourself having to employ a smartphone, 3G antennas and a communications satellite because Irish Rail couldn’t be bothered to talk to their customers properly, you know there is a problem.

      Reply
  • What a rag tag of an organisation. It’s still ran like a company from the communist era of Russia. Totally unacceptable that people have to protest just to get proper audible announcements at rail stations.

    Reply
  • should have kept their msg to 140 characters so it could go viral on twitter too!

    Reply
  • Or just get some new speakers.

    Reply
  • From the Facebook page: ” we are calling on you to send a text at Exactly 09.30 on the morning of Monday 23rd July. Please send texts to:
    Barry Kenny( manager of corporate communications, Iarnród Éireann) 0872381224
    Jane Cregan ( corporate communications executive, Iarnród Éireann) 0868531098

    I think everyone should schedule their webtexts now so we won’t forget !!

    Reply
  • What’s the number for those that don’t have Facebook !!!

    Reply
  • The exact same thing happened in Canada with their public bus service – and it’s true it not only improved customer service for people with vision impairments but it also increased the number of tourists using public transport services – Irish Rail have a great opportunity now to engage with a wider customer base by introducing inclusive/ accessible features in their services! – there is a real business case behind including people with disabilities within business! one that benefits both business and people with disabilities.
    http://kanchinetwork.com/about/the-business-case-for-disability/

    Reply
  • I can sympathise with the blind here, & I can see the technological maintenance challenges in keeping a system like this in sufficient working order as to be reliable enough for blind people to use.

    As a stopgap measure I would quickly audit which trains were suitable & which weren’t, then set those trains as “blind friendly”. These trains would be allocated certain parts of the schedule, and be audibly announced at the stations as “suitable for unassisted visually impaired persons”. As the upgrades continue, the trains without would become fewer and fewer, until the announcements accompanied every train arrival for a time, and then were discontinued.

    Reply
  • In London on the tube the audible announcements are on constantly every 5 seconds they say something, a little OTT i think. The Dart is quiet compared to quiet, i think the visually impaired community has a point. They should get some assistance from audible announcements rather than having to ask another passenger what station they are at.

    Reply
  • The Luas audio system works very well. I’m sighted but it’s saved me missing my stip a few times when I was absorbed in reading, etc. It’s always perfecly synchronised with the stops and loud emough to hear. Maybe Iaranrod Eireann should check what system the Luas use and adopt that.

    Reply
  • why cant the train driver male the announcements it isnt exactely rocket science .

    Reply
  • On the subject of Irish Rail I find that the non automated announcements on Irish Rail are the biggst bug bear. Tonight I was on the limerick to Limerick Junction and the announcer – I can only assume it was the driver – told passengers that the train from Dublin was waiting for them at the opposite platform, it was in fact the train heading to cork.

    There are almost no clear announcements at Limrick Station, and announcers at Limerick junction sound like your man from the Meteor advert.

    There are other issues which Irish Rail, and indeed Bus Eireann need to address, such as the lack of connectivity in relation to city buses at Limerick Station. There is no city route stopping at the station.

    Reply
  • oh and the next time i am on the train I will try to get you an up to date stock photo :)

    Reply
  • Mind the gap…

    Reply
    • I wouldn’t be joking about vision impairment. It can happen to anyone at any time through ilness, tumour, stroke, diabetes and head injury. I’ve been visually impaired for 12 years now through serious illness and although only portions of my vision are missing I still rely on tannoy announcements at stations and the beeping at pedesrian crossings. To those with visual impairments these can be lifesavers.

      Reply
    • I’m registered blind and even I taught that was funny.

      Reply
  • Texting is a brilliant idea! Isn’t it fantastic what they can train those guide dogs to do nowadays??

    Reply
  • Total disgrace…. I was actually getting the DART form Clontarf to Lansdowne a number of weeks back and on the info screens it said that were at least 5 stations with lifts not working…. Clontarf lifts werent working for weeks, have no idea about the others

    Reply
  • Great idea- once Irish Rail improve the sound QUALITY not just have the announcements blaring. The Maynooth regularly has announcements so loud that passengers are wincing and flinching… Anyone I know who has complained about this have been told the driver can’t change the volume, that this in done in the garage only?!

    Reply
  • We must have a rail worker among us lol

    Reply
  • The people in Irish Rail put more effort into putting information in Irish on the electronic signs and on printed timetables although people don’t understand it. What is the point in wasting money? The tourists and the natives must be confused. We just need information not a language lesson. Irish speakers in the Capitol city and all other cities can read English so keep it simple and print only in English.

    Reply

Add New Comment