TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

British grandmother gets death sentence for drugs in Indonesia

An Indonesian court has sentenced Lindsay Sandiford, 56, to death for smuggling cocaine worth $2.5 million into the resort island of Bali.

Lindsay June Sandiford of Britain sits at a courthouse during her trial in Denpasar, Bali island, Indonesia
Lindsay June Sandiford of Britain sits at a courthouse during her trial in Denpasar, Bali island, Indonesia
Image: Firdia Lisnawati/AP/Press Association Images

AN INDONESIAN COURT has sentenced a 56-year-old British grandmother to death for smuggling cocaine into the resort island of Bali.

Lindsay Sandiford sobbed as she heard the verdict, which stunned her defence team after the prosecution had recommended a lenient sentence of just 15 years imprisonment.

“We found Lindsay Sandiford convincingly and legally guilty for importing narcotics… and sentenced the defendant to death,” judge Amser Simanjuntak told Denpasar district court.

Sandiford’s lawyer said it was likely an appeal would be launched against the stiff sentence, which came despite the prosecution noting she had admitted her crime and behaved politely in court.

“We object to the sentence. We never expected that our client would get the death penalty,” said counsel Esra Karokaro. “We will discuss it first with her, most likely we will appeal.”

Sandiford, in spectacles and with her hair tied back, hung her head low and cried as the verdict was read out, while her sister Hillary Parson who attended the trial also sobbed.

A British embassy representative who attended the hearing declined to comment.

Sandiford was arrested at Bali’s international airport in May with 4.79 kilogrammes (10.6 pounds) of cocaine stashed in her suitcase.

“Drug-importing ring”

Police said she was the ringleader of a drug importing ring involving three other Britons and an Indian who have also been arrested.

Sandiford argued that she was forced into transporting the drugs in order to protect her children whose safety was at stake.

But the court rejected that argument and said there were “no mitigating circumstances” to allow for leniency.

“All evidence was incriminating against the defendant,” said another judge on the panel, Bagus Komang Wijaya Adi.

The court said that in fact Sandiford had not admitted her crime and that she had undermined Indonesia’s hard-line stance on drugs.

“Her action was against the government’s effort to combat drug use in the country and she insisted that she never committed the crime,” judge Amser Simanjuntak said.

British human rights charity Reprieve said last month that Sandiford “was exploited by drug traffickers, who targeted her because of her vulnerability and her fear for the safety of her children”.

Two other Britons arrested in connection with the case received light sentences last month.

“Stiff penalties”

Rachel Dougall was sentenced to 12 months for failing to report Sandiford’s crime and Paul Beales received four years for possession of 3.6 grammes of hashish but was cleared of drug trafficking.

A fourth Briton, Julian Ponder, is expected to hear his sentence at the end of this month after prosecutors recommended a seven-year jail term.

Indonesia enforces stiff penalties for drug trafficking, but death penalty sentences are commonly commuted to long jail sentences.

Two members of an Australian drug smuggling gang known as the “Bali Nine” who were arrested in 2005 are currently on death row, while the seven others face lengthy jail terms.

- © AFP, 2012

Read next:

Comments (82 Comments)

  • They see drug dealers as murderers.

    Reply
  • They have big signs on there landing cards saying “We execute people for drugs”, what did she expect.

    Reply
    • Damn straight, sorry to seem heartless, but some countries have strict laws to deter people from doing this, but whatever the reason, she committed the crime. How did she not expect this outcome?

      Reply
    • damian 22/01/13 #

      I flew into Malaysia on Malaysian Airlines. They had an automated audio announcement just before landing along the lines of “Welcome to Malaysia, the land of , anyone found importing drugs will be sentenced to death. Enjoy your stay”…. You could see people looking at each other. Did I just hear that correctly?!

      Reply
    • @brian , sure thing one link attached theres plenty of stuff to be read about this subject online , but it was your comment that there was a ‘big drop in associated crime i picked up on ,in Portugal, since decriminalization has been implemented, the number of homicides related to drugs has increased 40%. “It was the only European country with a significant increase in (drug-related) murders between 2001 and 2006″ (WDR, 2009).

      http://www.wfad.se/latest-news/1-articles/123-decriminalization-of-drugs-in-portugal–the-real-facts

      Reply
  • If she was caught with a small amount for personal use I would say give her a chance but 2.5 million dollars worth !!!.

    Reply
  • Death penalties within certain Asian countries are well known and publicised. She knew the end result of getting caught. I have no sympathy for her. As an ExPat worker for many years I know you must respect the rules and laws of other countries.

    Reply
  • Being pro-decriminalization and anti-death-penalty, I find this story very sad and regrettable.

    That aside, smuggling drugs into a country where it’s a capital offense is the height of stupidity, regardless of the circumstances. Every now and again the judges take the opportunity to make an example of someone, and they don’t like to be seen to give preferential treatment to white foreigners.

    Regardless of my libertarian view points, one must respect the law as it exists in any country that accepts us as visitors. Breaking the rules abroad and expecting commuted penalties commensurate with the laws of one’s own country is foolhardy, to say the least.

    Reply
  • Coming from a country which like Ireland is soft on drug traders she would be of the mind to laugh at the signs.

    Reply
  • They must do because the death penalty seems VERY extreme …!

    Reply
  • Sad for her, but she made her choices. Now all those drugs will not continue to damage people lives.

    Drugs are one of the worst things the human race has put upon itself and the penalties should be more severe all around the world.

    Reply
  • State murder is still murder

    Reply
  • The “War on Drugs” has failed. A radical rethink of global drugs policy is needed. Humans have used drugs for medicinal, spiritual and recreational use throughout history. Criminalising drug use merely creates a huge black market that allows vicious criminals to prosper and creates a huge policing bill for the state. If we legalise, tax and control all drugs then it will pull the rug out from insidious criminal gangs, clean up our streets and improve public safety. Its a win-win situation, compared to the current un-winable one.

    Reply
    • sean 22/01/13 #

      Drugs war will never be winable because giant corporations are knee deep in the middle of it , its not a mere coincdence that heroin exploded across western Europe and American after the Americans invaded Afghanistan………………….
      ……….this is way way bigger than some drug local drug dealer driving round in top of the range jeeps , how big it is ………we will probably never know , the cocaine trade in America is worth $40bn a year , yes I said $40bn

      Reply
  • Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.

    Reply
  • KEVIN.N 22/01/13 #

    Damn people are ruthless on here. They’re like “stone the b*tch to death”. The death penalty is barbaric/sick. People face the imprisonment/death penalty for alcohol in other Muslim countries. We’re Irish we ought to calm down.

    Reply
  • We’re missing the major issue here – people like this woman are usually just the ‘mule’.
    Her circumstances may have forced her into this desperate bid to make some money – usually just a couple of thousand dollars. I’m not saying that what she did is right but its unlikely she did it to buy herself a villa in Spain and a Porche.
    Many before her have been down the same road while the main suppliers and dealers sit back and enjoy the huge profits.
    Now all the dealer cares about is the 5 kilo of junk that his cartell lost and their search begins again to find another desperate mother to do the ‘run’ for them.
    Such a pity !

    Reply
    • How much profit she stood to make from it is irrelevant. Mule or not, there are other ways to make money that don’t risk the death penalty. For instance, she could have smuggled some drugs into her native England instead. Maybe it’s not as profitable, but there you go. We could all make money on the side, selling/importing/smuggling drugs, but the majority of us don’t based either on principles, or on simply deciding the risk/reward isn’t worth it.

      “I’m not the main dealer” amounts to a Nuremberg defence.

      As I’ve said already, I’m pro decriminalization, but she should show more respect for the law of the land and be mindful of the consequences. Smuggling into Indonesia makes you an idiot. This woman is an idiot, and we shouldn’t play the ‘vulnerable grandmother’ card on her behalf.

      Reply
  • @Jason. In answer to your question considerably less than alcohol but Diageo still free to advertise and sell their nice taxable drug globally

    Reply
  • In the gili islands in bali they sell magic mushrooms in all shops that promise ‘to send you to da moon!’

    …. But sell some Coke and we’ll kill ya

    Seems a tad hypocritical.

    Reply
  • Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time (or death sentence in this case). No sympathy for her.

    Reply
  • Yes it seems a tad extreme but in all honesty if it was a 40 year old man would anyone care, would it even make the news!! I dont think so! In reality she isnt going to be executed, this could go on for a very long time with appeals and such but the british goverment wil do as someone said above, step in nd have her serve sentence in uk and she be out in 5! Seems lenient enough to me! If you cant do the time dont do the crime!!!

    Reply
  • Capital punishment means no rehabilitation, no nothing! Criminals of all kinds need jail sentences relative to the crime committed – there is no justice in handing down the death penalty!

    Reply
    • Come to think of it, she’s get what 15(?) years if in the UK and that at her age might mean a death penalty anyway!

      Reply
    • sean 22/01/13 #

      Death pen , proper order more countries should follow suit , as for someones note above about rehab in jails surely yuor having a laugh , well know drug dealers in my area have more than 50 convictions for dealing drugs , yet they still doing it , same in every city , town and village ,just look at the dude from ardee was cut with €1m worth of heroin , he didn,t even do time and in fact.git a transport licence from dept of trans under noel Dempsey , …………………….drug dealing is the only growth industry in this country , only the death penalty would deter

      Reply
    • It’s a deterrent, which people know and accept the risks and then seem aghast when they don’t get a slap on the wrists for committing the crime. They mention the UK and how they are opposed to the Death Penalty. Seán, you mention her potential sentence if she was in the UK. She wasn’t, so I don’t even get why Indonesia would recognise anyone else’s laws. It’s their jurisdiction. They could also mention the numerous other countries where the death penalty is the defacto punishment for drug smuggling as justification for this outcome.

      Reply
  • She deserves it. You don’t get targeted by a drugs gang unless you have something to hide from the police, otherwise you would go to the police for protection.

    But wait for all the bleeding hearts to come out against this sentence. Wait for Downing Street to issues a statement against the death penalty, and then look to have the sentence commuted to life in prison. Then they will look to bring her back to the UK to serve her time. Then they will let her out in 5 as that is how much time she would have gotten in the UK.

    Reply
  • I dont agree with the death penalty but a lengthy sentance is deserved. Dont bring drugs into someone elses country as you will only screw up their country. Their country their rules

    Reply
  • She doesn’t deserve to die just because she’s involved with drugs.

    Reply
    • Mick 22/01/13 #

      Tell that to the victims of Gang warfare, intimidation and violent robbery. Besides I would imagine the sentence will be reduced when the appeal is heard.

      Reply
    • Gang warfare, threats of violence and intimidation that flourish because its on the dark side if the law! I think Switzerland pulled the plug on the dealers by opening up heroin houses or something along that line! You basically go in and get your stuff for free! Considerably cheaper than “the war on drugs”

      Reply
    • If so many approve of death sentence for unwanted pregnancies of healthy babies(outside medical emergencies) to respect the “right to choose” the lobby for death penalty must be huge.

      Reply
  • Her defence of ”protecting her kids” is nonsense, her kids are obviously old enough to have kids of their own given she’s a granny, as for the ”behaving politely in court defence” ….you’re in Bali nana not Dublin!

    Reply
  • Shocking news, glad I live in a civilised society

    Reply
  • She got what she deserved as far as im concerned ,, did she think about all the lives at risk from her drug smuggling ..

    Reply
  • No sympathy for her

    Reply
  • They mention about how this old lady who only tried to protect her family, and how it has spoilt the reputation of there country as a tourist destination.
    Then answer me these questions 1, how damaging will it be to there tourist trade if they execute her 2, what would you do if someone had a gun or knife held to your loved ones and told you that if you didn’t do this they would die…
    It’s all right to say these thing unless you are in the conflict your self, let’s face it left with the decision of losing my life to save my family, I would do the same, but at the same point the British government has failed this lady as they seem to fail many others, and if Many of them were to be made account for some of the things they have done wrong in there life, I am sure that there crimes are far worse

    Reply
  • Cant do the time, don’t do the crime…

    Reply
  • No sympathy for her whatsoever,the greedy old cow should know better at her age. She would not be facing the death penalty if she was at home minding the grandkids ,the silly old cnut.

    Reply
  • I wont be going to Bali, lots of nice places to visit without the threat of becoming a drug trafficker with legal or illegal drugs.

    Reply
  • FDL_ 22/01/13 #

    She won’t do it again and I will sleep well tonight knowing that :)

    Reply
  • Hey we all know how powerful drug lords can be and threats to her family she looks decent enough my mum
    Would do it to protect her own!!!

    Reply
  • Gavin 22/01/13 #

    If she got away with it and off loaded the pay dirt she was carrying, how many lives would she have destroyed? How many Mothers and Fathers, Wives & Husbands, brothers & sisters lives would have suffered exponentially. Its hard news to take but she knew the law I’m sure, she ran the gauntlet and came up short. She should accept the cost of her crime, her life sacrificed for theirs and in many ways, rightly so.
    I do find government sanctioned executions difficult to swallow but in some cases it seems very fitting, however, as my profile reads for all to see. “Jesus loves even Me”, even Lindsay can wear those words if she chooses, may God’s Grace be seen somewhere in all of this, that she can take her punishment with a repenting and understanding heart and face that fateful day brave with the knowledge of a God that forgives all our sins on the other side of this world through Christ that paid it all.

    Reply
    • @ Gavin, there just is no escaping that preachy religious nonsense.

      The correlation between fundamentalist Christians and support for or tacit acceptance of the death penalty shows that at least not even fundamentalists take Christianity seriously.

      I am a humanist, I greatly admire the moral and ethical quality of true Christianity, the Sermon on the Mount is a message of exquisite ethical beauty but vengefulness is not Christian.

      It is a pity that Christians do not live up to their own religion in its true ethical beauty.

      Reply
    • Gavin 23/01/13 #

      The point of Christ’s coming was to pay for man’s inevitable failures. No person can “live up to their own religion”.
      I do agree with you regarding the hypocrisy of the vast majority of professing fundamentalist Christians, I’m merely pointing out the human difficulties that we face when trying to determine the cost of a crime.
      Clearly the nation of Indonesia has decided the punishment as fitting and a lot of people in this country seem to also.
      Christ paid it all but we ask the criminal to pay more, however, the death penalty I believe is never necessary, the only thing I hope for is that she can truly repent and come to terms with her wages.
      I cannot say however that no action should be taken against Lindsay, Christ taught us to honour our leaders in established governments and the law of the land, where the law is broken, justice must be exercised.

      Reply

Add New Comment