TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

CIE handed extra €36m ‘to protect public transport’ amid funding fears

The state-run transport company has been given a funding top-up, though it’s not clear what services have been at risk.

CIE's annual subvention has been boosted by €36 million, apparently amid fears that public transport services could be disrupted by cash-flow problems.
CIE's annual subvention has been boosted by €36 million, apparently amid fears that public transport services could be disrupted by cash-flow problems.
Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

Updated, 19:07

THE CABINET has agreed to boost its funding of the public transport provider Córas Iompair Éireann (CIE) by an extra €36 million, saying the extra cash boost is necessary to ensure public transport services remain operational.

The Department of Transport said the Cabinet had this morning approved increasing the CIE subvention to €278 million, the fourth-highest it has ever been.

The €36 million will be found by re-allocating funding from within the Department’s Budget of just under €1.6 billion.

In a statement, transport minister Leo Varadkar and junior minister Alan Kelly said the Department’s “intervention” would ensure that CIE was adequately funded for the immediate future, and could “continue to provide a sufficient service to the travelling public”.

It is not clear to what extent the provision of services had been threatened prior to the extra funding top-up, though the 15 per cent boost to CIE’s annual funding would suggest that services would not be curtailed until later in the year.

The timing of the funding increase may also have been influenced by the political summer recess, with this morning’s Cabinet meeting being the last one before the summer break.

“CIE is lossmaking as a group and its financial position is very difficult,” the ministers said. “The company has run up a substantial debt. However, we are working on a solution.”

Underlying problems

The ministers added that while the extra funding was enough to plug any immediate gap in its services, it would not be enough to correct “the underlying financial and structural problems in the CIE companies”.

“This funding is being allocated because we are conscious of the need to maintain the public transport service, and because we recognise that the financial position of CIE is very difficult.”

This evening CIE said the extra funding would ensure the various public transport companies could “continue to meet the public service obligations required of the Group, and provide a strong public transport service to commuters.”

It added that CIE was undertaking “an urgent series of actions” to address its finances, which had suffered as a result of falling passenger numbers, increased fuel costs, and the overall contraction in the economy.

“All three companies [Iarnród Éireann, Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann] are urgently progressing action plans to further reduce the cost base, and have engaged with staff and trade unions as part of this,” the group said.

Last week RTÉ had reported that 17 staff of Iarnród Éireann, who were due to retire around that time, had been told they could not retire at that particular time – prompting some suggestions that the company did not have sufficient cash to meet their pension lump sums.

The train operator said the redundancies had been delayed for “cash flow management” reasons – but denied any difficulty in paying the lump sums, which RTÉ said could reach €130,000 each.

The delays came despite Iarnród Éireann seeking 450 voluntary redundancies as part of a longer-term cost-cutting exercise.

Read: 450 Irish Rail job loss news ‘not deferred because of referendum’

Read next:

Comments (31 Comments)

  • Does this mean no more 4 car rush hour DARTs??
    Standing from Tara st to Greystones after paying €1,200 for an annual ticket is not on!!

    Reply
  • Let’s remember this is for Bus Eireann and Dublin Bus too. Not just Irish Rail.

    Reply
  • Why do we need an umbrella company like CIE anyway? Can Irish Rail, IE and Dublin Bus not run themselves?

    Reply
  • I’ve got question marks all over the top of my head here. CIE is being handed another €36m “to protect public transport” while the HSE is being told to cut cut cut ?? Does the health service not need protecting more than transport does or have I got my priorities backwards ?

    Reply
    • I think the biggest problem is both the HSE and CIE are so grossly inefficient that it doesn’t matter how much you throw at them it will be squandered!! They need massive structural change and greatly increased efficiency..

      Reply
  • agree with Rob. other issue is the problem is not just in Dublin .ya think if privatision is the answer the rest of the non profit counties will suffer. the cie group is for the country not just Dublin. remember a public service be it train or bus should not have to make a profit. look at the banks that were privatise. greed and more freed.

    Reply
  • Ypee more private trains in Tipp for our Junior Minister.

    Reply
  • As others already pointed out, the problem lies in the efficiency of using the train. If the quangos are too stupid to realize this, we are simply throwing good money after bad money. Deal with the cause: an extremely slow train compared to high speed trains in Europe. A backward administration who segregate people on the platform prior to boarding – this defeats the whole purpose of on-board inspection. All this adds to delays. Irish Rail employees need to be re-trained or fired if they fail to stop to decline in passenger traffic.

    Reply
  • Irish Rail my arse. I have never seen such a useless bunch of wasters. Filthy stations, huge delays, rude and uncooperative staff. Let’s start all over again. About a year ago I had to use the men’s toilet in Templemore station. It was filthy (being nice) I reported it to the cashier. I revisited exactly one week later and it was the same mess in the gents. Nothing had been done in a week. God knows how many passed through this station in the week. There is no pride in these cie people. There needs to be a customer charter established and unannounced customer care checks put in place immediately. They have to up there standards. Tara street is a kip as well.

    Reply
    • Rob 24/07/12 #

      Same issue in Galway Train station – the Toilets are sub-human. The civil service staff cannot be fired if they are underperforming – that’s where we went wrong (unlike other countries). Reform of the public sector needs to be imposed by the IMF because current govt’s have demonstrated their failure to address the lack of workmanship in the public sector.

      Reply
  • To put in to perspective there providing a service for a population the same as Manchester ,there been subsidized up to 280 million.Jesus it dosent take Einstein there’s something wrong between the service provided and what its costing.Clear the lot out and bring in people that know what they are doing.

    Reply
  • This is what you get when parish pump politics gets involved in major infrastructure projects. I hope the 700,000 free travel card holders enjoy their day trips on empty trains on the Western Rail Corridor. Commuter trains in Dublin are self funding. Useless intercity services that are slower than a bus are not. Another case of Dublin paying for the rest of the nation.

    Reply
  • FG want to protect their fellow public servants from the real world. Ask yourself why Irish Rail is a loss-making service? Because of no compliance to standards or innovation. Irish Rail have a lazy, corrupt management system with no accountability.

    If we do not address this lack of performance, we are merely making the same mistakes as before. Cut pay increments to ALL public servants who are under-performing… Why can’t we do this? If the unions go on strike, simply hire private workers and fire the others. Why can’t we do this??? We must challenge old inefficient habits.

    Reply
  • Rob 24/07/12 #

    36 million isn’t even a drop in the ocean. They need to spend heavily to modernize the rail infrastructure, E.G.

    1. Electrification (phase out commodity fuel-driven trains which are prone to price increases)

    2. Train Stations (demolish old stations and rebuild modern stations with PROPER outdoor shelters)

    3. Higher efficiency (increase the train speed to eliminate the time gap between a car journey)

    4. Increase competitiveness (we have the most expensive rail fares in the Eurozone – cut the pay of the public workers by a further 10% and pass on the saving in the form of lower fares)

    5. Signalling (new tracks are needed and also new overpasses to replace railroad crossings)

    Reply
    • while i agree with most of what you say surely the exorbitant fares in the UK trump ours?

      the dart is incredibly slow compared to other commuter trains i have travelled on. if they sorted this out and reduced the travel time from bray to pearse by 15 to 20 mins everyone would use the service.

      Reply
    • Rob 24/07/12 #

      Kev Dunne: Britain is not in the Eurozone. The train speeds are incredibly slow over here. For example, the Galway-Limerick Train takes two hours. It only takes 1 hour to drive by car on the newly opened Highway.

      Reply
    • @ Rob: I’d agree with all you say, but unfortunately given the state of the public finances and the fact that we are shut out from borrowing I don’t think it’ll be done.

      Reply
    • Rob 24/07/12 #

      Ryan, we can leave the Euro and print our own money.

      Reply
    • I agree with you Rob. However, this gov’t are in it together. They don’t want their bloated public sector to face the real world. That’s why they are imposing new property taxes to cover the need for pay cuts.

      Reply
    • JTHM 24/07/12 #

      Yes, and it will be worth as much as the paper it’s printed on. How do you think money has value? Ireland doesn’t build trains, so we’d import them. Printing money lowers the value of the currency, so it’s value goes down., and so the price of imports goes up relative to the currency. If you print money you get more money, you don’t get more worth.

      Reply
    • JTHM,

      Printing money minimizes the hardship upon people during austerity. That’s the whole purpose of allowing import costs go up – so that we can start producing in Ireland once again. It’s called devaluing your currency. Every central bank does this.

      Reply
    • JTHM 25/07/12 #

      It won’t make buying imported trains any more affordable, which was the specific point by Rob that I was commenting on. Keep up.

      Reply
  • It’s hilarious the frontline services have been cut eg nurses, garda, Hse an yet the bus service gets 36 million !!

    Reply
  • Peter 24/07/12 #

    Anything the government touches fails… Privatise it!

    Reply
  • Privatise it u eejitts…..

    Reply
  • unbelievable….!

    Reply

Add New Comment