TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 17 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Clerical abuse survivors asked: Has the Church supported you?

Support and advocacy group asks for survivors to complete questionnaire to build picture of official response to abuse claims.

Dr Margaret Kennedy, left, representing MACSAS at a press conference in London.
Dr Margaret Kennedy, left, representing MACSAS at a press conference in London.
Image: AP Photo/Akira Suemori

A SURVIVORS’ SUPPORT group is asking survivors of clerical abuse in Ireland to take part in a research project to discover the extent of the assistance offered to them by the Catholic Church.

The appeal has come in the wake of the recent Vatican Apostolic Visitation.

The Visitation, a group of high-ranking officials from the Vatican which came here in November 2010, was led by Archbishop of New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan. Their mission was to inspect the country’s four archdioceses and seminaries in Maynooth, Milltown, Belfast and the Pontifical College in Rome, along with other religious institutes, to see how child protection guidelines were being understood, implemented and operating.

The Visitation published its findings on 20 March and proposed a number of reforms, including new child protection classes for trainee priests. The Visitation said that it had met with survivors of abuse here so as to better understand their issues. The findings read:

Particular attention has been given to the assistance offered by the Church in Ireland to victims of past abuse. All the Visitators acknowledge that, beginning with the Bishops and Religious Superiors, much attention and care has been shown to the victims, both in terms of spiritual and psychological assistance and also from a legal and financial standpoint. It has been recommended, therefore, that, following the example given by Pope Benedict XVI in his meetings with victims of abuse, the Irish diocesan authorities and those of the Religious Institutes continue to devote much time listening to and receiving victims, providing support for them and their families.

Their meetings with the victims of abuse helped the Visitators to understand better various aspects of the problem of the sexual abuse of minors that took place in Ireland. The Visitators and the Church in Ireland are thankful for this contribution and want to assure them that their well-being is of paramount concern for the Church.

Now, a group called MACSAS – set up in the UK in 1995 to offer support to victims of clerical abuse from all Christian backgrounds but also to be active in promoting child protection – is asking survivors of clerical abuse here if their experience tallies with the assertion of the Visitation that:

…much attention and care has been shown to the victims, both in terms of spiritual and psychological assistance and also from a legal and financial standpoint.

Dr Margaret Kennedy, founder of MACSAS and now living in Ireland, told TheJournal.ie that she hopes to compile the experiences of a large number of abuse survivors to establish a comprehensive picture of the Church’s response to them in the aftermath of the abuse scandals.

Those interested in taking part are being asked to fill out a questionnaire, which can be downloaded from MACSAS’s website or downloaded directly from here. It can then be emailed to macsas1@hotmail.com in confidentiality.

Dr Margaret Kennedy was the focus of an RTÉ Would You Believe documentary in 2010 after a letter she wrote to the Irish Times asked for attention to called “to an almost forgotten report known as the McCoy report, an internal report by the Western Health Board and the Brothers of Charity into abuse carried out against people with disabilities in institutional care”.

Download MACSAS questionnaire here>

Vatican visitors propose Church reforms to deal with abuse fallout>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (6 Comments)

  • Thank You Journal.ie for posting the questionnaire. it is not yet on our website as our websister is on leave due to death in her family.

    I thanks all who download this questionnaire and responds to MACSAS. It is always painful to be part of such research but ‘The Victim’s Voice’ is imperative.

    I would ask those who know of any clergy abuse survivor or anyone abused by religious or religious sisters to let them know about this research.

    All confidentiality will be highly respected. Thank You

    Reply
  • thank you geoff. brave, brave man. i have looked at your blog and can only say, the truth must be out there. we are part of ‘truth-telling’,

    Reply
  • I am a survivor of clergy abuse yet I now feel we are still suffering even more abuse of negligence, negligence of healing properly by both The Irish Government, The Church, Many So Called Support Groups,
    Reason I say this is because through the sheer ignorance of our rights we were forced to obey RULES that were set up for us to follow rather than answers to our life long sufferings, The Support group in Cork and Dublin were the worst.
    These groups contained unprofessional, uneducated, unqualified, inexperienced survivors themselves without Police checks which is illegal to be acting on behalf of the most vulnerable people in Ireland who set THEMSELVES UP AS GROUP LEADERS THAT WOULD HAVE COLLECTED FRIENDS AMONGST THEMSELVES IN THE BEGINNING, EVERYTHING WAS BASED ON THEIR VIEWS ALONE. Or they were elected by others IN POWER other than survivors themselves.

    These dealings are illegal and wrong, the Government still uses these groups right from then to now.
    These groups were founded without the WHOLE story and BEFORE the THE REPORTS SUCH AS THE RYAN REPORT. it was only after they set themselves up, thousands of survivors came forward afterwards so where was the legal side to pass them as representatives? where were the mandates they claimed they had when they were already set up BEFORE survivors came forward.

    REDRESS was paid BEFORE the REPORTS just as the so called RULES were set up by all involved Government, Religious and of course those Groups where evidence of bullying tactics were rampant thus the leader of the Cork group removed.
    To top of all this money, thousands still missing and on top of this, IS it really true that the leader had a free checkbook to hand out cheques for his own popularity during meetings who HE chooses if names from the redress office were checked in banks in Ireland these cheques would show up from the Right of Place . That were handed out like sweets to children? if this be true would it be wise to check the names of survivors on the redress list or those they claim they had mandates for with the cheques paid for their own safety and why they were handed this money by this leader? if there is no records to the cheques of why he did this then questions need to be asked for sure. Because that money is still missing to date. Was this legal behavior IF it is true?

    So how were survivors supposed to know what rights they had from the start as it is plain to see the cart was always before the horse. Everything set up before thousands of survivors came forward.

    A question remains on the funds, education, family tracing and counseling? considering these funds were for survivors and their families and also considering that some families are much much larger in size, who did actually benefit from these funds as many survivors have no families and are very slow in coming forward especially since they have more health and financial problems and are of great age? while this is not clear is it fair to say these REPORTS ARE STILL ON GOING AS TO THE CONCLUSION STILL NOT FINALIZED GIVING THERE IS NO PROOF WHO DID ACTUALLY BENEFIT THESE FUNDS BESIDES GIVING THIS IS ABOUT CHILD ABUSE THEN WHY WAS THE CHILDREN OF SURVIVORS EXEMPT FROM THE FUNDS AS THEY WERE TOO YOUNG? Only for survivors to be sent letters much later when this issue regarding development grants for infants was brought before the Education Office who then accuse the survivors of not having t filled in the appropriate forms so they were refused, what appropriate forms? there were none the children simply were over looked by all involved the Government, the Religious and the Groups who by the way have no young children, yet there is only a very very few.

    Regarding health and the damage done why do survivors have to reapply for medical cards and suffer all the cuts, like dental care eye sight and also have to fill in forms for welfare etc etc etc, giving the ages of survivors and not a large number really why cant the Government just give us permanent Medical cards or a better system? besides now the prices are laid on prescriptions, why again should survivors have to pay for the damages done to them?on and the such knowing that their past is always brought up on these forms like a loaded gun? Due to many many health problems this Government have yet again taken survivors security away for the damage they did as well as the church. This is why i say NEGLECTFULLY DAMAGED YET AGAIN.

    Reply
  • The Catholic Church is now trying to silence victims’ support group in America

    Years after Catholic bishops swore to clean up their act after decades of sexual abuse by priests and cover-ups by their leaders, the Catholic Church is proving that old habits die hard.

    The New York Times reported recently that attorneys for the church have subpoenaed records from the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known to most people as SNAP, as part of sex abuse lawsuits in St. Louis and Kansas City. The subpoenas demand e-mail records and, in some cases, testimony — even though SNAP isn’t directly involved in the suits.

    The Missouri strategy is clear: Make victims afraid to talk to SNAP and bury them under legal fees — the tactic corporations such as tobacco firms use to silence smaller opponents: Intimidate, outspend.

    For decades, the Catholic hierarchy — behind the backs of its innocent clergy and millions of parishioners — used intimidation and secrecy to hide accusations that priests molested children. Now, it’s using the same tactics to silence a group that gives aid and comfort to the priests’ victims.

    The church’s new legal assault on SNAP is unconscionable. For decades, paedophile priests created thousands of voiceless victims. SNAP gives those victims a voice — and now the bishops want to silence that, too.

    Reply
  • i will do it! what the church has done for us…..ah…aaaah!
    mags, you ask this question and i will truthfully tell you

    Reply
  • Margaret Kennedy,please go to

    http://www.abusedbyrobinson.com

    Read the story,the experiences of an 11 year old lad,who had the miss fortune to meet a trainee priest,who introduced me to Catholicism,that was 1961.In 2010,I told the Judge,I didn’t like Catholicism,robinson style,he got 21 years,I came out of it a stronger person,with a willing to fight for others.

    geoff

    Reply

Add New Comment