TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Dentists call for public health warnings on soft drinks

Ireland has one of the highest per capita soft drinks consumption in the western world – we drink an average of at least one 330ml can of fizzy drink a day.

File photo
File photo
Image: John Birdsall/John Birdsall/Press Association Images

DENTISTS ARE REITERATING their call for public health warnings to be introduced on soft drinks.

The call from the Irish Dental Association comes as World Diabetes Day is marked today.

The IDA said that it believes the Minister for Health should ensure public health warning labels are carried on all carbonated soft drinks.

It is also calling on the Minister to introduce legislation which would stipulate that the sugar content of food and drinks is highlighted on such products.

Dr Conor McAlister, the president of the IDA, pointed out that half of all 12-year-olds and three-quarters of all 15-year-olds in Ireland have some decay in their permanent teeth – making tooth decay the most common chronic disease among Irish children.

He commented:

There is overwhelming evidence that sugars in food and beverages are the main dietary cause of tooth decay and erosion in children and adults.  In Ireland we have one of the highest per capita soft drinks consumption in the western world at over 100 litres per capita per annum, an average of at least one 330ml can per day.  In addition to dental decay, people who consume excess sugar suffer higher rates of heart disease and diabetes.

Dr McAlister said that similar warning systems on alcohol and tobacco “really worked well”.

Children from deprived backgrounds have a higher risk of decay, and the IDA said that such children are hit hardest by the HSE’s cutbacks in the public dental service.

Recent figures showed a collapse in the number of routine treatments being provided by dentists under the medical card scheme.

The IDA said it was “ironic that Ireland was continuing to cut its spending on dental health at the same time as the United States was singling out oral health for the first time as one of the leading health indicators of the US population”.

A spokesperson from the Department of Health told TheJournal.ie that the issue of warnings on labels on food and drink products is something which would have to be introduced under EU regulation “so as not to distort the marketing of these products”.

An EU nutrition labelling regulation on the provision of food information to consumers comes into force shortly.  One of the main changes in this regulation is the introduction of mandatory nutritional labelling of pre-packaged foods. Among the details labels will have to include are details of sugar content. Food business operators will be given time to implement the new labelling provisions.

The spokesperson added:

It is worth noting that sugar-sweetened drinks not only cause dental cavities and gum disease but also contribute to the problem of obesity

Earlier this week, The Irish Dental Association said it wants any cash raised from a possible ‘sugar tax’ to go to funding public dental schemes that have had their monies cut.

Read: Money from ‘sugar tax’ should go to dental schemes, say dentists>

Column: A sugar tax isn’t just desirable – it’s a necessity>

Read: French parliament votes to levy tax on soft drinks>

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • My worry would be that this pushes people to buy the “diet” or “sugar free” versions.. Which are pumped full of things that are just as bad if not worse than the sugar.. It’s a difficult decision.. Do you go for glucose – natural sugar at its simplest, fuel for the body.. Downsides; digested by amylase in the mouth causing acid erosion, increases insulin levels in excess and can lead to diabetes – in excess.

    Or sucralose – 1 part sugar:2 parts chlorine – which is not supposed to be consumed.
    Sodium Saccharin which is made of coal tar and similarly should not be consumed.
    And Aspartame, aspartic acid (a neurotoxin) and methanol (wood alcohol, causes blindness), breaks down into formalin and formaldehyde (both carcinogens) in digestion..

    Sadly, the only safe option is reducing the junk and going back to real food.. It’s disgraceful that it is cheaper to live on processed muck than it is to feed your family good healthy whole (organic) foods.

    Reply
    • I wish there was a way to like your comment more.
      I had a friend who developed diabetes growing up and thanked one of her friends for “saving her” because she had supplied her with nothing but diet drinks in the months before.
      Turns out it is just as likely it worked the other way round, that her body got so tired of being made to believe it would have to digest real sugar that it just stopped producing insulin altogether.

      Reply
  • There must be a few people guzzling a LOT of fizzy drinks to pull this stat up to that level! There are loads of us who take their whiskey neat.

    Reply
  • It’s not just fizzy drinks itsfizzy sweets fruit juices ice pops etc etc are particularly bad for the enamel of teeth. It’s a number of products combined that cause tooth problems. Tackle this at young age I. E parents and schools the % given is particularly high.

    Reply
  • That won’t deter teens another euro on the price still wouldn’t stop some of them buying that crap….

    Reply
  • 5 cent tax per 100ml of pepsi would soon dampen consumption

    Reply
  • Dentists looking to protect the nations teeth?maybe they should stop supporting the toxic levels of fluoride in our water supply.

    Reply
    • P Wurple 15/11/11 #

      Oh dear. A conspiracy theorist!
      Dentists are not out to get us.
      Flouride is good.
      Facts can be your friends.

      Reply
    • Kitalpha 15/11/11 #

      “Flouride is good. Facts can be your friends.” Bbaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahaha You keep soaking up that fluoride P Wurple, its obviously done wonders for you!

      Natural fluoride is good, the fluoride in the irish drinking water is not naturally occuring fluoride, it is hydrofluorosilicic acid. Fact.

      Try looking up some facts on the long term effects of fluoride exposure. Ever wonder why 1 in 3 people have cancer nowadays.

      Bottom line is, it should be about choice, if you want fluoride off ya go, but I should not be forced to consume it or wash in it. It goes against my basic human rights.

      Reply
    • P Wurple 15/11/11 #

      Typing the name of the flouride compound added makes no difference to its effect.

      Bleat away to your hearts content, but it is a bit far fetched to think that basal cell carcinoma, melanoma, cervical cancer, lung cancer etc etc etc are caused by the same thing. Shocking News Flash: Cancer is not one disease.

      Against your basic human rights eh? You are so tortured having clean safe drinking-quality water piped directly to your home for you to flush your toilet with. Better call amnesty international with that one straight away.

      Reply
    • so set up your rain barrel and keep it to yourself

      Reply
  • That woman’s 2 teeth are black. Health labels would be good, not cause they’d deter a 15 year old from buying a coke on their lunch break ( won’t work), but because it would be at least a small step in showing these sugar zombie corporations that were onto them. And I hate the individual responsibility argument- If you’ve been brought up drinking this filth everyday then how can you be expected to ‘undrill it out if your brain’. Everytime you open the bottle and hear the fizz, your liver and every other cell in your body cringes.

    Reply
  • As a dentist and member of the Irish Dental Association IDA I find it hypocritical that my professional body is calling for a sugar tax when they clearly support links to the same industry on their website – http://www.dentist.ie/links/. Wrigleys may have created a website for dentists but the majority of its products have added sugar – Skittles, Starburst, Juicy Fruit etc. In 2008, Wrigleys merged with Mars Incorporated who sell Mars, Twix, Snickers, Milky Way and M&Ms. Meanwhile, many dentists feel increasingly uncomfortable about the links between their professional organisation and a sugar industry which contributes to tooth decay and suffering in so many Irish children.

    Reply
  • Bazza 15/11/11 #

    I reckon the new energy drinks are the worst, and not just for teeth.

    Reply
  • “Dentists call for public health warnings on soft drinks” Never mind that, there should be a public warning on all dentists! Have you seen what they charge?

    Reply
  • dentists join call with pharmacies to end a cartel. a really bad, pervasive cartel.

    then the law profession joins in. then there is a recognition that pharmacies are the olive oil sellers locally, extracting the last insane penny, screaming when the prices are compared the the UK, because that is bad for business.

    then the law profession screeches again, then the pharmacies, then the dentists.

    then we realise we have black limpets built into the republic, and we might as well rip them off unless we enjoy getting suckled dry by a few, amoral, cosseted professions.

    Reply
    • Sorry you feel that way swim. As a dental practice owner I can tell you I’m not feeling at all cosseted at the moment, competition is high, govt funding is gone and many practices are going out of business. I think the idea of pressionals having an easy life and ripping of patients is a bit out of touch really – people are too savvy for that – they demand high quality and good value.

      Reply

Add New Comment