TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

Latin America to California: Please don’t decriminalise marijuana

The presidents of Colombia, Costa Rica and Mexico say voting yes on Prop 19 would be a contradiction on anti-drug policy.

THE LEADERS OF a number of Latin American countries have appealed to Californian voters not to approve Proposition 19 – a bill which would decriminalise the possession and cultivation of marijuana in the home – next Tuesday, featuring that approval of such a measure would undermine their efforts to eliminate drug cartels from their countries.

The Presidents of Mexico, Costa Rica and Colombia all pleaded with Californians to think of the bigger picture, and not to hinder the decades-long battle against the drug-pushing criminal underworld.

Colombian president Juan Manuel Santos, hosting a summit of Latin American leaders, said: “How can I tell a farmer in my country that if he grows marijuana, I’ll put him in jail, when in the richest state of the United States it’s legal to produce, traffic and consume the same product?”

PA reports that he later added: “It’s confusing for our people to see that, while we lose lives and invest resources in the fight against drug trafficking, in consuming countries initiatives like California’s referendum are being promoted.”

Santos’ position was strengthened by the support of Mexico’s Felipe Calderon – a longstanding opponent of any concession by legalising drugs – who, while declining to mention Proposition 19 by name, said it was “not possible to face (drug trafficking) effectively from our national borders in an isolated manner.”

The speaker of the US House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, has meanwhile also said that she had been lobbied by Mexican leaders trying to secure her public opposition to the bill.

“I have the Mexicans coming in here and saying, ‘Oh, my gosh, this is going to be problematic if in fact there’s the decriminalization of marijuana’,” she told the Huffington Post.

Billionaires in favour

The poll is even becoming a cause championed by billionaire philanthrophists: George Soros, a regular donor to Democratic candidates, told the Wall Street Journal he had donated $1m (€743,000) to pro-Prop 19 campaigns, in lieu of supporting any actual candidates in this year’s elections.

The Proposition 19 ballot is a deeply divisive one, with opinion polls conducted throughout the year showing inconsistent swings to both the Yes and No sides; the most recent substantial poll, by Public Policy Polling, showed a 48%-45% lead for the opponents of the bill.

It has been presented to the public for statewide ballot after a petition collected almost 700,000 signatures – over 50% more than the amount needed to have it put to the public alongside the midterm Congressional and Californian gubernatorial polls.

If approved, the bill would decriminalise the possession of up to 28.5 grams of marijuana for personal consumption, and allow people to the drug in spaces up to 25 square feet at home for their personal use. They would also be permitted to consume the drug in a non-public place, or in a premises licenced for such consumption.

The sale of the drug, however, would remain illegal under federal law.

Read next:

Comments (3 Comments)

  • This article is misleading on a number of counts. Mexico has already decriminalised small amounts of Cannabis and in Uruguay & Argentina (not Latin America, admittedly) it is also decriminalised.

    Apart from the economic benefits of reduced prison and law enforcement costs, taxation and employment one of the main arguments for Proposition 19 in California is that it will simply remove the markets from Mexican Drug Cartels, 70% of whose income comes from selling cannabis to the US. Former Mexican President, Vincente Fox is in favour of US legalisation for this compelling reason.

    Also, the poll that you quote is just one of many and the overall trend has been in favour of the proposal, if you’ve been following this development at all, so it is not just “billionaires” who support the proposition.

    California led on the Medical Cannabis issue, which has spread widely to other US states and led to the American Medical Association’s call to reclassify the drug down from Schedule 1 on a federal level. There is reason to believe, in these cash strapped times, that they could be leading on this one too and that this proposal will have a ripple effect to which federal law will have to respond. Prohibition doesn’t work as the US discovered in their experience with Alcohol.

    I’m surprised to see what appears to be such a skewed article on theJournal.ie

    Reply
    • Mark, first of all, thanks for your comment.

      The poll mentioned is merely – and quite explicitly – stated as being the last major one taken; as it says, opinion has been swinging back and forth, even in the last few weeks (Public Policy poll 47-38 on September 20; Ipsos 44-53 on October 4, EMC 48-43 on October 14, LA Times 39-51 on October 20). It’s unfair to say that the overall trend has been in favour, especially given the largest lead held by proponents in any major poll was a 56-42 lead back in April.

      With the greatest of respect, the article doesn’t try to portray that only billionaires are in favour of the plan. I will happily concede that the piece could have gone into more of the arguments in favour of passing the bill – such as the idea that putting a $50 levy on every ounce of the drug sold would raise $1.4bn a year for the state – because the piece, as it already stands, was pushing the upper limit of our in-house style in terms of word count. (We did, I might add, cover Vicente Fox’s arguments in favour of legalising all drugs two months ago. It is included in the ‘related articles’ at the bottom).

      The single anti-Prop 19 argument mentioned in the piece is mentioned because it was the one made by the Colombian and Mexican presidents. We could have published a many-thousand-word piece going into equal depth on each side but pieces of that length aren’t, for a news piece, what we do at TheJournal.ie.

      Reply
    • I might perhaps add as a disclosure that I, personally, am in favour of legalising all drugs. I believe that if there is a market for drugs, which there quite apparently is, society is far better off bringing it above ground, formally regulating it and incurring levies on their sale, instead of pushing it underground where a black market merely leads to a growing criminal underbelly.

      Reply

Add New Comment