TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Martin: EU deal leaves Ireland vulnerable on corporation tax

The Fianna Fáil leader told TheJournal.ie that Ireland will have less influence under the new agreement.

Micheál Martin
Micheál Martin
Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

MICHEÁL MARTIN HAS warned that last week’s EU deal to strengthen fiscal cooperation leaves Ireland vulnerable to attack on our corporation tax rate.

The Fianna Fáil leader also said he believes the agreement, which looks set to be joined by all the EU countries except Britain, will not be adequate to tackle the debt crisis.

Speaking to TheJournal.ie after he was briefed on the content of the deal by Taoiseach Enda Kenny earlier today, Martin said it was “unclear how our corporate tax rate is protected” under the fiscal compact.

He said that Ireland’s influence would be reduced in the new agreement, which strengthens the importance of direct relations between governments rather than EU institutions and excludes our traditional ally the UK.

“I think we’re going to come under increasing pressure in a German-French dominated intergovernmental union,” he said. “I would have concerns about it in the sense that we’re now going down an intergovernmental track without Britain, and our influence is less as a resutl of that, particularly as regards tax.”

He added that the official EU communiqué had been “silent” on the issue of corporate tax.

Referendum

Martin, who met with Enda Kenny this morning along with Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams, and Dáil technical group representative Catherine Murphy, also called for the Government to hold a referendum on the new EU measures – even if they did not involve constitutional changes.

The Fianna Fáil leader rejected suggestions that a No vote would risk leaving Ireland out in the cold. “The Irish people would be saying they didn’t want to be a part of the intergovernmental union, but we would still be a part of the EU and the euro,” he said.

The Government has suggested that a referendum may not be necessary.

He also warned that the new deal would not provide the tools to tackle a eurozone debt crisis which has dragged on for months. He said the deal was focused on fiscal constraints, rather than providing more support to troubled economies.

“It is unlikely to have any impact on the major crisis we’re facing at the moment, which is the refinancing of sovereign debt,” he said. “In my view that can only be dealt with by the ECB taking on a more conventional role and becoming the lender of last resort.”

More: What’s in the new EU deal – and what does it mean for Ireland?>

Read next:

Comments (25 Comments)

  • Lets face it…none of them have an effing clue what’s going on or how to fix it. Recessions and booms come and go in cycles, so all they’re doing in the Govt is riding the wave, getting their own big pay cheques and to hell with the rest of us. It couldn’t be any more clear cut than that!!

    Reply
    • Chris 13/12/11 #

      So what do you propose we do?

      Reply
    • Well for starters Chris, the people of this country could collectively refuse to let these power hungry politicians walk all over us. Believe it or not, but if everyone pulled the plug on their mortgages, loans etc, there is nothing the Govt could do about it. It’d lead to a situation where they’d need us more than we need them, which might lead to them listening to us. Together, the people have more power, but us Irish love complaining from bar stools, so nothing gets done.
      I’m not advocating violence, far from it actually, but we could learn a lot from what happened in Libya; the Libyan people realised that if they wanted freedom and respect, it wasn’t going to be handed to them. Maybe it’s time we realised the same thing.

      Reply
    • Yey Jimmy!!

      Reply
    • Chris 14/12/11 #

      Ya but what do we do once were in power? Who would you elect or what would you do to fix it? How would you ensure that whoever took their place doest do the same thing..

      Reply
  • Considering how much effort went into protecting our Corporation Tax Rate, which is absolutely crucial for our recovery, surrendering it would be out of the question.

    Reply
    • Paul, Martin throwing up this issue of CT now is archetypical of his usual tactic. That is, to foment uncertainty, and hobble the government further during its negotiations. It’s perfectly in keeping with his tactics in opposition to date. It is not constructive, factual, or of any relevance whatsoever.

      It does not serve to inform the people, merely to confuse and worry them.

      Reply
  • Finanna fail know best. Don’t think so’

    Reply
  • Do not lose our corporate tax rate it’s the only advantage this country has left!

    Reply
  • The only thing that’s concerns Martin is Martin and the recovery of Fianna Fail. He will say whatever it takes to cause difficulty for the current Government. Enda Kenny has publicly stated that the Corpo tax is not up for negotiation. FF would love to see him surrender on this even at the expense of the country.
    Don’t get reeled back in by the weezels in FF.

    Reply
    • That’s basically it. I haven’t seen one expansive and constructive utterance from the guy, be it before or after he was forced to give back the Merc he used to swan around Turners Cross in.

      Reply
    • You are spot on Martin Fitzpatrick . I would not trust any more than I Never did . His only concern is the rebirth of FFail ures.. We can never forget what they did to us.
      However , what are we to do ? I do not know . A protest of some sort that will not damage us the people but will show the politicians that we are not happy !Or furious even ….

      Reply
  • O Gawd . This guy again.

    Reply
  • “Cowen-Lenihan bank guarantee left Ireland vulnerable”. Is that what he meant to say, but forgot?

    Reply
  • Aine 13/12/11 #

    All I know is if that happens I will be like many others jobless!!

    Reply
  • I believe that this Martin style waffle is dangerous commentary in the current delicate balance of economic realities and risks to the Euro.
    Why would a Fianna Fail leader want the Government to hold an unnecessary and costly referendum other than to see it defeated…………………….?
    This alone makes him grossly irresponsible in his position within the oireactas.
    Have we not yet seen an end to their destructive capability.

    Reply
    • The Euro is at risk anyway. This deal has done pretty much nothing to ‘save’ it.

      Also I don’t understand how there can’t be a referendum of some sort. If they decide the deal can be signed without one fair enough but from what I can see the whole point of the deal is to enshrine a debt brake in each country’s constitution so how can we avoid that?

      Reply
  • In what way does it leave Ireland is worse position with regard our tax rate? Martin should detail this instead of just saying it. This isn’t an EU treaty therefore doesnt affect anything outside it. Even if it were an EU treaty don’t we have a new protocol protecting our tax rate? This would need treaty amendment to remove?

    Reply
    • One of the proposals of the fiscal union is to introduce a common corporate tax BASE. This is a set of rules that identifies what is regarded as profit and what is exempted from corporate tax and what country may impose the tax on what profit. We seem happy that our rate is not effected. But if we must adopt the rules they use in France where only a small portion of profit is taxed (at a higher %) then we arrive at a situation where we will be forced to increase the rate because less profit is taxable. It’s utterly shocking that very few politicians understand this. Media got it wrong too, Sky, BBC, RTE primetime, Fintan O’Toole, and also some Journal.ie articles mixed up the BASE and the RATE. None seem to see how they are interdependent.

      Reply
  • First thing I’d like to say is, “shut up Micheál”. Second point. He’s right. An EU referendum must be held to give the people of Ireland a say. Kenny is treating us as if he was the father of the state. Daddy knows best is the attitude the ginge is taking.

    Reply
    • If they don’t need to hold a referendum, they won’t, and why should they? Anyway, someone will take a case to the supreme court if they don’t so the judges can decide based on the constitution. Remember that?

      Reply
  • You had a chance to speak up over the last decade Martin and you sat on your hands. Now go away.

    Reply
  • FF = IMF = Anglo

    Never FForget

    Reply
  • Who is he again?

    Reply
  • here here luke

    Reply

Add New Comment