From reports I don’t think the actual repossession is the issue but rather the manner in which the repossession was carried out I.e in the middle of the night, breaking into property leaving family traumatised! If I do recall Mattie spoke out about this in the Dail before, will search for article so maybe family asked him to assist them!!

Friends First what an appropriate name

Without the internet Damian how will you get you’re message out to the people. Also a certain irony in that you used a comment on a web only publication to give out about using the internet to make a difference. The internet as a forum for getting things to change has the same effect or perhaps more of an effect from what I have seen over the last few years than a street protest has.

Telecommix wouldn’t allow it to be switched off.

Dear sweet Lords of Irony, Damian.

You’re being Ironic, right. I mean seriously, taking to the internet to complain about how bad the internet is at spreading change. This is actually happening? On a news forum. On the internet?!?!?!

Not only that, your comment could only be more misinformed if you signed off with Betamax will win the video format wars!!!!!

Heard of the Arab Spring? I think it had something to do with a revolution somewhere that only happened because of the internet.

FREEDOOOOMMMMM!!!

Can I give u a green thumb in support of your comment. Now I gave to get back to my tea.

What are the facts ,
I guess there will be sharp practice by the financial company.

Rather sweeping comment there Rory.

True Rory but, I guess people see a bank involved and that is more then enough for most people.

Do you know the facts of the case? Just a request for information on it.

People of this country are being crucified with debt (billions paid to bondholders). Those are facts enough.

Jim – We have some details of the story, as given by one side but disputed by the other.

If we were to publish the details as we understand them, and they turned out not to be true, we would be in a gravely difficult legal situation.

Fair enough Gavan. Can you not put such a disclaimer in front of those facts as in “So and so claimed that…”. Does that not cover you in those sort of circumstances. I mean its very hard to comment on this without knowing the full facts (not that its stopping some from their usual assumptions!).

Thanks for your understanding Jim. Unfortunately, no – even if we attribute the comments or allegations to someone else, we are liable for them by virtue of having published them and giving them a larger audience than they would otherwise get.

For example: let’s say Ann’s mortal enemy Eve starts making up rumours about Ann. “Ann kicked the crap out of Bob in the middle of a street” or something. We can’t report that rumour – even if we say, “Eve has made allegations about…” – because if it turns out Eve is wrong or lying, we will have published the untrue rumour and therefore Ann can sue us for the damage we caused to her reputation.

Libel laws are a tricky business sometimes!

You can put an air to that and sing it.
Looks like the people have had enough.

These financial institutions think they can do as they please. Patients are running out, People Will revolt.

no they won’t! if u haven’t noticed yet Irish ppl are all talk!!

@Mike, wait till you see whats going to happen, after the budget.

We heard all the same stuff before every budget since this crap started slapstick.
We won’t do shit. We never do.

Nothing, that’s what

I have to reluctantly agree with ManontheStreet. The only sector of society who have stood up in a meaningful way against the austerity have been the elderly on the medical cards issue. There have been numerous threats by other groups such as nurses and students but these have been hot air. About as much chance of real revolt here as Kate Middleton’s child being called Paddy,

Well He is representing a constituent so He is carrying out His public duty & fair play to Mattie & lot of FG/FF/LAB politicains wouldn’t go these levels to get fair play for Our People as is the case here finance company playing hardball & coming to this resifdence at 5.30am & you can be sure this wasn’t an arranged time with the farmer involved to try come to a resolution they had come to take this tractor under the cover of darkness whilst these people slept. People Power this is the start of it.

Except Monaghan, Mattie is a TD for Tipp, the farm is in Wexford. Nonetheless, whatever the full facts, which will no doubt come out in time, someone somewhere is trying to do something about anything. Cause most of the time we have noone, nowhere doing anything about nothing.

As was said, we irish are nothing but full of hot air and fat asses. The turnout at the last march and demonstration on the 24th Nov was abysmal. Whether it was 5k, 10 or 20k, its a disgrace that we didnt at least get half million on the streets. All the internet warriors can chew the cud all they like, but doesnt matter a damn. Heres a thought. Since your sitting in front of your screen, how about challenging your local TD to explain why they voted as they did in any of the last Dail votes, particularly the Home Help one. They wont reply immediately, none of mine did, but you have to hassle, harry and badger them. They wont like it, but who the bloody hell cares. The more uncomfortable we can make it for them the better. Stop howling at the moon, and make your voice heard somehow. We’re being raped and pillaged by bankers and their political protectors.lets grow a feckin backbone and show these 107 men and women who are runing our lives that they cant just roger us anymore

but I expect this will just fall on deaf ears and blind eyes again….as is typical of the modern irish citizen. Suppose we get the representation we deserve then.

I suppose we are due another eye sore outside the central bank!! #alltalk

Name a Fianna Gaeler that isn’t a gombeen….

haha your having a laugh where would you get a Fine Gaeler to stick up for an ordinary citizen

Lambs have to be led to the slaughter. The Irish will happily walk themselves up the ramp. A nation of castrated bulls.

ouch,,,crossing legs now!!

Quit your typing and pull me another pint!

#Declan, Don’t block up the GP0 for jasus sake I have stuff coming from the USA that was bought on the internet.

And Wexford isn’t even part of his constituency…

yes buying votes

Fair play to mattie standing up for the family who will loose their ability to earn a living by removing the tractor. If you have been listening to mattie he is the only one that has been standing up for the ordinary rural people. Most of the td’s just get elected and disappear.

Provided they aren’t woman.

“women”

I expect to see him at the anti-austerity march tomorrow then if he is so opposed to austerity measures. I’ve haven’t seen him at one yet?

Not a fan of Mattie. There is still a stink of FF about him and that doesn’t square with him actually helping people or doing right by someone, yet this might be an exception to the rule.

It should be welcomed and not whinging.

Sorry DaffodilDaze, but that doesn’t mean we should gloss over the reactionary crap he said about women in the Dail last Wednesday.

Heavy handed? Any farmer would be up by then, and it makes sense to repossess before he drives the tractor out the fields, as they’d need another tractor to follow him otherwise before leaving him stranded out there.

The most likely time to find the tractor still in the yard was observed. This is not some dead of the night smash and grab, just because it happened before you might get up yourself.

Wonderful you are awake you cannot speak for every farmer know lots will not be out of bed.

Wonderful you are awake you cannot speak for every farmer know lots will not be out of bed. oh and less of the yourself as it so happens I am out of bed very early in the am

Oh hang on, you’re right. I forgot about those 9-5 family farms.

So lads I should cancel my monthly payment on the car and the machinery because you all will support me by protesting at the Banks Headquarters. Could you guarantee a couple of wacky TD’s as well because that would really frighten the Bank Executives.
Jeez lads if enough of us did that sure wouldn’t they need another Bailout which we can pay for with another five years of austerity.
Aren’t these Banks who lend money to people like us awful eejits to think that we might pay them back. What a bunch of monsters to even dream of asking us to pay.
Well done Mattie!

Mark – is that what happened in this case?

Nobody should (and most don’t) shirk their responsibility to pay their bills but these days often banks don’t try to renegotiate loans which are capable of performing.

In this particular case one thing we can say is that repossessing farm machinery will directly effect a farmer’s ability to earn. In cases such as this surely every effort should be made by a lender to permit a business owner to continue to earn rather than cutting the throat of a business?

We can assume little else with respect to this case as no further details appear to be available. We don’t yet know if Mattie McGrath’s support is fairly placed or misplaced.

Tony
Mattie wants cheap publicity because he’ll be swallowed whole by the Budget and the Abortion issue over the next few weeks. This helps his credentials with rural voters. Without getting into the issues here I am certain that Financial Institutions don’t repossess farm machinery without cause and cause is always a refusal or unwillingness or inability to pay.
Are we supposed to consider these lending institutions as charities? Not even the Department do Social Protection would extend monies for these purposes.

Starry Eyed Surprise
The repossession of this vehicle took place at five thirty am which is breakfast time for most hard working farmers as opposed to the middle of the night that you claim. I think you will also find that the Bank was at the end of a long long process before they attempted to repossess their property in a lawful manner.We are so quick to come to judgement on Lending Institutions who have seen vast sums of money unpaid by borrowers over the past five years and when they attempt to recover their position they are somehow evil and immoral.
Listen Mr Magic Economics. If the Banks fail to return their businesses to profitability we as taxpayers may have to fork out again to bail them out or never see a penny of the money we have pumped into them in the first place.
Somehow people like you don’t understand basic reason never mind economics and you believe in magic economics and the tooth fairy as far as this country is concerned. Your Social Welfare is not paid by Santa Claus and people who are in business are entitled to make a profit and Banks aren’t the Salvation Army or fools to be hoodwinked and conned out if their monies.

With all due respect Gavin it is available on the public report once a TD/ Senator has made the statement in the Dail! Are u seriously trying o tell me that you can not cover what is on public record! This is a very serious incident and people are only getting one side of the story due to the failure by the media to cover what is on the public record! If the media don’t cover these stories how on earth are we going to stop them!

@SES: I completely understand (and totally share) your frustration. However, with the laws as they are, we do not share a parliamentarian’s right to absolute privilege.

In short, yes, I am trying to tell you that sometimes we are not in a position to tell you things on the public record.

If one of the parties involved in the alleged incident was to face criminal charges in a jury trial, it is possible that our reporting (and that of anyone else) may be seen to influence the case – or, indeed, make it impossible for that person to have the fair trial they deserve.

If it so happens that the person is then acquitted, they can sue anyone who spread the untrue and malicious suggestion about them in the first place. They cannot sue the TD or Senator, because their comments were protected by parliamentary privilege, but we don’t enjoy that same level of protection and could easily be sued – simply for having reported someone else’s claims. (The law is slightly different if the person has been charged, as the courts have enshrined the right of the media to report on matters taking place inside them and the claims made there, but because nobody in this case has yet been charged, any reporting we’re doing would be making allegations against a person who, legally speaking, has not been found to do anything wrong.)

What it boils down to is that reporting something as a ‘rumour’ or an ‘allegation’ is no defence if it turns out to be untrue. Oireachtas members have the defence of their office; we do not. It’s crappy, but as they say: the law is an ass.