TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 2 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

One in three people who apply for mortgages are turned down

Figures revealed for the first time show that 38 per cent of mortgage applications were rejected last year.

Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

MORE THAN ONE third of mortgage applications were rejected by Irish banks last year.

The figures, revealed for the first time in a letter from Finance Minister Michael Noonan, show that there were over 28,500 mortgage applications to four Irish lenders last year.

Of these, around 17,700 applications  were approved. More than 10,000 applications – 38 per cent – were rejected.

The four lenders involved – AIB, Bank of Ireland, EBS and Permanent TSB –  are among the biggest mortgage lenders in the State.

The figures were revealed in a letter to Fianna Fáil finance spokesperson Michael McGrath after he asked a parlimentary question about the issue some months ago.

McGrath pointed out the figures do not include the large number of people who do not proceed with formal mortgage applications after making informal inquiries with their bank.

Speaking on RTE Radio One’s Morning Ireland today, McGrath said the figures were worrying and highlighted the stagnating mortgage sector.

“We are witnessing a dysfunctional mortgage market,” said McGrath.

He also said that people working in the mortgage industry have suggested that the level of mortgage refusal could be even higher than 38 per cent.

The figures show the extent of the collapse of the mortgage market in Ireland as lenders continue to tighten restrictions on approving potential homeowners.

Two of Ireland’s biggest lenders, AIB and Bank of Ireland, have repeatedly emphasised the amount of money they have lent to people seeking mortgages but have refused to give figures on exactly how many mortgage applications they have approved.

Read: Mortgage arrears in Ireland rise to highest level yet >

Read: More immigrants buying homes in Ireland than ever before >

Read next:

Comments (48 Comments)

  • So 2 out of 3 get a mortgage approved, which doesn’t seem bad.

    Reply
  • So 2 in 3 ARE getting approval for mortgages. Doesn’t sound too bad to me!

    Reply
  • they can have mine if they like!!!

    Reply
  • Ronan B 13/09/12 #

    As the years 2003-2007 show, restrictive lending practices are a good thing. People proved they cannot be trusted to borrow sensibly in this period, instead they will take as much as they are offered. Then it’s all the banks fault when they can’t repay it. Now banks won’t give them money unless they meet criteria relating to job stability, a proven record of savings, a healthy and well managed current account. And it’s all the banks fault then too.

    Maybe prospective house buyers could do something radical…like saving, and look to borrow a modest amount. That leads to greater financial freedom for the borrower in the longer run.

    Remember, the biggest winner out of you securing a mortgage is the bank – not you.

    Reply
    • See Jane Breslin’s comment above, sensible is fine, but until banks start lending again the Irish economy will continue to slump, the sooner that bank debt is separated from sovereign debt and the banks are free to do business again the better, we are not talking about a return to the good(?) old days, but a return to normal business, and it’s certainly not that at present.

      Reply
    • Yes Ronan B.
      However your comment is a little out of context, as we must remember that reckless lending was the norm in 2003-2007,
      it is very hard to blame a banks customers for the reckless greedy lending that was so corrupt that it broke the country and drove thousands of unfortunate people over the edge.

      Reply
  • The true number of people who are turned down can’t be counted as most are stopped in their tracks by the bank before they submit the loan application. There are told not to bother as they won’t get the loan

    Reply
  • So one in three people who applied for a mortgage were refused.

    What are the bets there are another 7 or so who were told by their bank to not even bother applying.

    Reply
  • But that’s good, isn’t it?

    The banks are being careful and not lending money to everyone regardless of ability to pay it back.

    Reply
    • Seems there are a fair few people being refused who have a good job, savings and a sound financial history. If that is the case then it is bad news as it means the banks are yet again damaging the economy. Someone who is in the position to buy a house will be paying a surveyor, solicitor, maybe a small building firm to make modifications to their new second hand house and possibly buying furniture etc. We need to see that money going into the local economy after all that is one of the reasons we pumped so much money into the pillar banks.

      It would be interesting to see a comparison of the refusal rates BEFORE the bubble took off and the current refusal rate. It might provide a better indication of how our banks are behaving.

      Reply
    • Mjhint 13/09/12 #

      We should have taken that attitude when the banks couldnt pay & still cant. Your comment is based on very simple thinking of how an economy works. There are a lot of businesses gone under in this country because of lack of credit & bank behaviour. The banks are very much needed in a modern economy but as its been pointed out by people in the know we have zombie banks that provide very little support to the state. The banks are meant to provide for us not the other way round. Thats why the country is on its face. Until people get credit it will continue. They are taking no risks at the moment. Investment requires risk as does most good things in life. They are all about self preservation.

      Reply
    • “The banks are meant to provide for us not the other way round.”

      The banks are meant to provide for their share holders.

      Reply
    • Mjhint 13/09/12 #

      Yes they are & they didnt. They are supposed to provide a service for us. Thats how they sell their products. Their shareholders benefit from profits made on that activity. No customers no shareholders not the other way around.

      Reply
    • I’m all for them being careful, AIB are a bit much though.

      We have been approved for mortgage with both Ulster and BOI, who said we were a very straightforward application, low risk. We wanted AIB mortgage as they have better rate at the moment.

      Despite wanting less than a 50% LTV mortgage, and both people with full time PAYE jobs, each employed for over 15 years without a gap, the guy in the branch wouldn’t even submit the application, saying we didn’t have a hope because we have another property rented out with a small tracker mortgage on it (less than 5 years remaining).

      I can see how people would be annoyed by this, we certainly rolled our eyes a bit. We will probably just move the mortgage in a year or two to the cheapest on the market, but it’s more hassle.

      Reply
    • If you take into account what Jane has said that the bank official she dealt with refused to even process her application then these figures mean nothing.
      In fact they are misleading and false .

      Reply
    • ”The banks are being careful and not lending money to everyone regardless of ability to pay it back”???

      You might ask them then what they are doing with the tens of billions that we gave them??

      These diseased corrupt excuses of banks should be shut down

      Reply
    • From first hand experience, the facts are that the majority of these ”approved” mortgages are going to the bank’s and government’s well heeled cronies to buy up repo’s on the cheap.

      Except for the odd PR stunt, the truth is that there are really no mortgages for the average Joe to buy a home for his family (regardless of how much of his hard earned money is pumped into these corrupt, dead, banks).

      It’s really back to the dark 80′s,
      except for that this time these dirty vultures and vested interests are creating a never ending stream of cheap properties and cheap credit (courtesy of the taxpayer) for themselves.

      These filthy inbreeds have always been in bed together (and they don’t get out of it, even if they need to go to the loo)

      Greedy, corrupt, pigs, feeding of other people’s despair and tragedy!

      Vile!

      Reply
    • We own these banks.

      We should know exactly who they are lending to and for what purpose.

      Reply
  • My friend had pre-approval and on the day before closing the sale they were refused – having sold their home – excellent credit/savings – both with good wages – seems like a joke to me

    Reply
  • Bailout the banks they said, be grand they said.

    Reply
  • This is nothing but Spin. When they say approved, its its great, meeting the terms and conditions is another matter. Offered to people but in such a way that they can’t comply. The Bank are then seen to be doing their bit.

    Reply
  • What we really need to know are actual draw downs.

    Lots of people in approval limbo, told that they just have to wait another 6 months.

    Reply
  • I’m sceptical that two in three are being approved, hasn’t been my experience amongst friends.

    Reply
  • Banks need to deleverage so this is good news. Bad news is that they are taking the same approach to business loans.

    Bit cheeky of McGrath to be hurling from the ditch on this seeing as it was his party who took the decision to make them into zombie banks in the first place.

    Reply
  • This is good news. Do we not recall that the banks lashing out credit for property is what has gotten us into this mess?

    Reply
  • Reg 13/09/12 #

    I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, Michael McGrath is a muppet! Fianna Fail still think that property is the be all and end all. Hard to get a word from them when it comes to promoting other areas of the economy. Where’s his pronouncements on things like the Irish manufacturing or the Irish software industry. Haven’t they realised that buying and selling houses to each other at inflated prices with money borrowed from abroad has been a disaster.

    Reply
  • Ronan B 13/09/12 #

    Keith, your comment about the economy only makes sense for business lending. And I agree, credit for businesses is probably too hard to come by, though I have no experience of it personally. The “economy” won’t benefit from the comparatively small amount generated by surveyor fees, etc. You may as well point out that Estate Agents get a commission off house sales, so let’s boost EA’s spending in the economy by increasing mortgage lending! Or let’s try and get that boost in sofa sales for IKEA.

    This is all reminiscent of the booming Celtic Tiger economy, founded on massive amounts of construction jobs that were not sustainable in the longer term.

    Cheap money and loose lending criteria were what got us into this situation. They will not get us out. It was the banking losses (sadly nationalised by an incompetent and morally bankrupt government) run up due to poor lending practices that led to the country’s current woes.

    Incidentally, I’ve noted that no one seems to want banks to be able to repossess properties when the borrower stops paying, but everyone wants the banks to lend more. The two issues are closely related, and more people need to see the connection.

    Reply
    • Why are you talking complete common sense Ronan….This country does not like that sort of talk!!!!

      Reply
    • I’m talking about banking business as a whole, mortgage lending is a fundamental part of that, I don’t think people should be given mortgages like they used to be, but those that qualify under normal circumstances should not have a problem. As an earlier commenter pointed out the bank wins no matter what it does, customers are not as fortunate. There is a lot of other business generated from this activity as was pointed out earlier, not just estate agents, solicitors etc, but builders, carpenters, tilers, electricians, DIY stores, furniture stores, there’s plenty of businesses affected. You can’t just pick and choose parts of banking business that should work. I struggled getting a relatively small car loan, they wanted me to pay it back for a longer period than I wanted to, when buying the car the dealer told me 4 out of 5 sales were falling through because people couldn’t get finance.

      Reply
  • We went and were rejected primarily because I own an apartment which the mortgage would be covered almost by rent. We were told specifically that AIB would not lend to anyone who has less that €2000 minimum disposable income after any potential loans, mortgages and bills. They also said they would not take any rental income into account. They said they wouldn’t even process it.

    Who in the hell in this country has 2000 disposable income after a mortgage payment? Onto the other banks it is!!

    Reply
  • Why are we still so obsessed with getting a mortgage?

    Reply
  • The figure of approvals is somewhat misleading as according to what I have read, many applicants are being approved for mortgages below what they sought which is effectively a refusal. And before you ask, I think it was The Irish Times.

    Reply
  • 66.67% percent of mortgage applications being successful is a good figure in any economy!

    Reply
  • 62% being approved, thats quiet high.

    Reply
  • Spin ..

    Reply
  • dave 13/09/12 #

    Why don’t they lend it’s 100% risk free for them all the risk is on the borrower. They approve the mortgages and whether you can pay it off or not down the road is your problem not theirs. they can still sell your house and make you pay the balance regardless or your situation risk free lending can’t go wrong they never take a hit on reckless lending just another BIG BONUS for the crooked bankers.

    Reply
  • money is once again going to the big lads who are buying up estates and houses under the hammer,, otherwise known as people getting kicked out of their homes,,, i am one of them on the way, bank has told me they will sell my home, and if there is a difference i am responsible,, i owe 94 so if they sell it to someone for quick sale for 50 or 60 i still owe 30 or 40 thousand,, and i will be homeless with my kid in a car,, if you take unemployment for 170 instead of a wage of 500,, and the way they are taxing us out of homes that was taken into consideration for my repayments and i cant do it,,, so 10 years of paying and 35 down,,, they have nearly got all there money back but i am still paying interest in their eyes,,, i will get a job again when time improve,, but all we have down here is 2nd hand shops and those are same as working for dole,, i need a real job,, 5 days or nites,, will work 7 will do anything to get out of this house,,, i am 50 worked all my life never a day unemployed and here i am now,, on the eviction line,, i have tried,, starved myself , no heat,, dress warm and loads of blankets,, but things go wrong in house and one cannot afford to pay mortgage, when tiles come off roof,, pipes break, electrical gets screwed up,, i should have just paid mortgage and let the water in,,, same thanks at end of day,, i wish jobs would come back to ireland,, i wish i pray just for a job,, will do anything

    Reply
  • @Gordon Bernard.Very few people who purchased there house during the”get on the property ladder before its too late”years will ever own there own property before they hit retirement age…..My advise is,live life to the fullest without the burden of massive debt.Leaving bricks & mortar when im dead is not a legacy i care for.

    “owns”

    Reply

Add New Comment