TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

Nurses to rally against graduate scheme

Two unions are calling for a boycott of the recently-announced HSE nursing graduate scheme.

A 2011 PNA/INMO protest
A 2011 PNA/INMO protest
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

TWO NURSING UNIONS are to hold a joint rally tomorrow morning to protest against the proposed HSE graduate scheme which will see 1,000 agency staff displaced.

Under the new plans, the positions would be filled by new graduates at a salary of €22,000 – a cut of €11,470 on 2009 pay.

Both the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation and the Psychiatric Nurses Association are calling for a boycott of the programme.

The demonstration, which is due to begin in Croke Park at 11am Saturday, will be attended by graduates, current nurses, agency nurses and undergraduate students.

The HSE claims that a graduate nurse can earn “approximately €26,000 per annum including basic pay and premium pay” but the scheme has been criticised by unions as “cheap labour under a superficial guise of an education graduate programme”.

Graduates recruited under the scheme would be paid the equivalent of 80 per cent of the minimum wage on the staff nurse scale – which the INMO says has already been cut by 24 per cent in recent years.

It believes that young nurses and midwives have already “contributed more than their fair share towards the country’s recovery”.

The unions have asked graduates completing college to refuse to apply for the posts until they are advertised at the salary equal to those afforded to full-time equivalents in the service.

“There are no new jobs attached to this initiative and its introduction will simply put 1,000 experienced nurses and midwives out of work, while giving transient work to the new graduates,” INMO general secretary Liam Doran claimed.

In response to questions from TheJournal.ie, the HSE denied that the net effect of the initiative would mean no additional nurses operating in the health service.

The HSE said: “The high costs associated with agency staff may mean that in some locations, it will be possible to employ more graduates than the number of agency staff previously employed.”

Lack of opportunities

The rally by the nursing unions will be aimed at garnering support for a boycott of the recruitment scheme which the HSE estimates will save it in the region of €10 million next year.

In a fact sheet produced by the unions, it is claimed that the HSE could save 54 per cent on their current costs if they employed newly qualified nurses and midwives on the full salary scale, and not on 80 per cent.

But the HSE said that these figures related only to permanent posts and said that it must reduce numbers employed in the public health service under its service plan and the Croke Park Agreement.

It said: “Taking this into account, the HSE has obtained permission from government to offer two-year fixed term posts to graduates to ensure that they have access to work and associated training in Ireland in the absence of permanent posts.”

The unions also claim that starting salaries for newly qualified nurses and midwives have been cut by over 24 per cent since 2009.

The HSE’s national director of human resources, Barry O’Brien, said he found it difficult to understand the INMO’s position given their previous criticism of a lack of opportunities for nursing graduates in Ireland.

He said: “In the current economic environment, and with very limited recruitment opportunities in the public sector, this is an opportunity for 2012 Nursing and Midwifery graduates to gain substantial clinical experience to further their career and professional development, with the security of a 2 year contract and salary.”

-With Hugh O’Connell

READ: Nurses’ union demands boycott of graduate scheme over pay dispute

MORE: HSE to recruit up to 1,000 graduate nurses and midwives next year

Read next:

Comments (73 Comments)

  • If only there was a bloated layer of administration and middle management that could be tackled before screwing the low paid front line workers.

    Unfortunately the drawbridge is up and the newbies have to take the hit.

    Reply
  • I have seen nurses being verbally abused in A & E and have heard of them being attacked by unstable/drunk patients while they were simply trying to do their jobs. Despite this from what I have seen they should be praised for the job they undertake. Us office workers don’t exactly risk our lives everyday we go to work, they do! In my opinion they deserve every penny they get and much more besides! I hope their petition gets them the attention and wages that they deserve.

    Reply
    • Recall “vote yes for jobs and stability”. It looks like some intellectually stupid voters had another missed opportunity. They knew this would happen if they voted Fine Gael.

      Reply
    • Mark Dalt
      I don’t think we knew it was going to turn out this way .People voted for what FG said ,not realising they were all telling lies. I voted FG . I apologise and I will never vote for them labour, FF, Greens again. However , they were voted in to get FF/Greens out . They lied .
      The nurses are entitled to a proper wage , I wish them well and I support them .
      This all started years ago when they introduced productivity into the civil service and then tried to do the same
      for the frontline public service, which can not be measured in terms of productivity. It has been a down ward spiral since.
      It is an absolute disgrace that nurses who are continually upkeeping their qualifications after 4 years of study are subjected to these petty and ignorant cuts to their pay.

      Reply
    • Eileen – a “proper wage” can only be paid if the employer is solvent. It is bankrupt. Where do you suggest the money comes from?

      Reply
  • If you pay peanuts, you get monkeys!! How can you justify paying a one nurse on a ward €22,000 and his/her colleague €10-15 k or so more for the exact same work? I didn’t go into nursing for the money as I’m sure alot of nurses didnt, but this is a total disgrace. We’ve given our fair share in cuts already……………….

    Reply
    • starting salary of €33,470

      Reply
    • Mark they are after cutting that starting salary already and the one they are looking to offer to new graduates is for 22k! I am busting myself going back to college as a mature student let alone kids going without also but at this rate i must be nuts as i would earn more working in lidl without having to take 4 years out to study and train my butt off! Nurses wages have been hit by about 34% cuts already! Not looking to qualify for money obviously but 22k really is taking the biscuit!

      Reply
  • What time is this taking place? I would like to give them my support and I am sure a lot of readers would support them.

    Reply
  • standing right with all the nurses and midwifes in this. they get precious little as it is and nursing is not easy with long hours and frustration huge factors. to add insult to injury many have had to emigrate to better their prospects. fair play to all who organised this and all who stand together. support your nurses, they will always be there when you need them be there for them now

    Reply
  • Don’t teachers graduate on something in the region of EUR30k? How is it fair that nurses and midwives will qualify on EUR21k? Teachers are incredibly valuable to Irish society, but no more so than nurses…. Student midwives in the UK qualify on £21k, but go to £25,500 after their 12 month preceptorship. If this goes ahead, I can see the Irish state paying for the training of hundreds of nurses and midwives who will ultimately end up going to the UK, or as other people have said, Austalia.

    Reply
    • But nurses get 3 months off in the summer.

      Hang on…….!

      Reply
    • And get off at 3-4pm everyday whilst I work 13 hour shifts. Justice!

      Reply
    • Without wanting to sound like I’m giving out, his isn’t helping. The septic tank protest failed because it became an urban/rural thing, the student protests failed because it became an age thing, and then there’s the constant public/private sector catfight. Teachers and nurses both got shafted, arguably worse than everybody else, and instead of arguing over who got off worse, just remember that you’re in the same boat. How much more of an impact would this protest make if the teachers unions had been invited? I don’t mean that to criticise, but it should be considered in the future. Rant over, see you tomorrow.

      Reply
    • Oh here we go the divide and conquer brigade are here. Get real people . Do not be distracted. Nurses are not teachers. Gardai are not Prison Officers. Firemen are not soldiers. Yet they all ,each do an incredible well disciplined job BUT different disciplines. Support the Nurses. Then maybe the teachers and the gardai Prison officers army will be fairly treated down the line also. Do not allow anyone to divide ,distract and conquer us.

      Reply
    • Brendan ….
      I think you will find that the Septic tank protest has not failed …
      but you are correct , they will do anything to divide us , to conquer us.
      Rant over.
      Eileen.

      Reply
  • 2 year contracts only? What happens after the 2 years? Back to the dole que? The 2 year contract is to give them training? What do they do in the 4 years prior? Nurses are out on training from 1st semester, it’s not like other college degree’s, nurses have class time tables but also have to work long hours on the wards without pay to gain adequate training infact from year 3 student nurses are rostered down as a working nurse to keep ward numbers up and hide how understaffed the Hse really is. Without them the health service would be on its knees. What happened to telling our kids to go to college, get a good job and to not end up like us. I can’t believe how the irish have become so content with being treated like peasants by our masters. We’re like dogs coming back with licks after getting a kicking, begging for some scraps off the dinner table. Fair play to the students, I wish them all the best.

    Reply
  • No wonder irish nurses go to Australia! !!

    Reply
  • ITS Student how dare you say people who become nurses do so because they feel it will be an easy ride..what an idiot!!!

    Reply
  • Are they gonna do the same to newly qualified doctors…I doubt it!!!!

    Reply
  • MVM 04/01/13 #

    Couldn’t be right the government said the were creating jobs not extending the dole que..oh right fg are liars

    Reply
    • A hate based policy will not help. A government cannot spend money it doesn’t have.

      Reply
    • MVM 04/01/13 #

      There is loads of money its just wasted by a bunch of half witted mongerals

      Reply
    • MVM,

      You lack even the basic understanding why more people are unemployed.

      Where to start:

      - Since 2008, Ireland has suffered a DEBT crisis due to sharp economic downturn and bank bailouts. Interesting you failed to mention anything about the 32% of GDP going to the Banks.

      - Unions in the public sector feather their own nest egg in order to protect themselves at the expense of the people paying their keep.

      - Croke Park Agreement requires sacrifices from all sides.

      Reply
    • MVM 04/01/13 #

      Aren’t I lucky your here to correct me….? Eh no your wrong money is just wasted

      Reply
    • @ MVM

      Nonsense. The government doesn’t “create jobs”. A government’s responsibility is to preserve the free market. The fact you aspire to becoming a government worker suggests you are a taker who likes an easy ride in life because of the generous conditions in being a public servant in Ireland (severance pay, guaranteed pension, reasonable hours, reasonable perks, etc).

      Take responsibility and look for a job in the private sector if you feel that strong.

      Reply
    • Exactly! The HSE simply cannot afford the massive salary bill and as the vast majority of their budget is allocated to wages and salaries then it is logical certain cuts have to be made here.

      No one wants to see cuts to the wages of frontline staff but the reality of the situation is that the saving have to come from somewhere.

      Everyone has taken cuts along the way at some point.

      Reply
    • MVM 04/01/13 #

      @its… they said they do and promised more jobs..maybe a little more of a background on the government might help you

      Reply
    • @ MVM

      There are plenty of Nurses from Europe to replace you…. So LEAVE… No one is stopping you.

      Reply
    • MVM
      If you work in the Public Service we all have a problem! Your basic English is so deficient that you’re likely to be unable to fulfil your basic function. Too many your when you’re at fault!

      Reply
    • There is No money. We have the second highest deficit in the Eurozone.

      Reply
    • MVM 04/01/13 #

      @its…I’m not a nurse(I do pay myself well and treat my employees fair and lucky haven’t had to make anyone redundant) I just think its a farse how nurses,gards etc are treated maybe when you have to leave the security of sitting in college and try find work your attitude will change

      Reply
    • Get a job in a different trade, you don’t have to be a nurse.
      If you don’t like the wages go elsewhere, nobody is forcing you to work here.

      Reply
    • fred 04/01/13 #

      The health service is in a mess! Chronic problem of overcrowding and understaffing in the acute hospitals and closing some emergency services to other hospitals. I’ve started seeing things that shouldn’t happen.

      Reply
    • Nurses from Europe?
      ITS student – why do you think nurses will come here with the shite conditions (and I’m not just talking about money, there’s the understaffing and the under resourced health system to deal with)
      Nurses from another country are not a solution

      Reply
    • Paul MC 05/01/13 #

      Duh, nurse wage low, try a different job. No brainer.

      Reply
    • You idiot Paul
      You have’nt been in hospital have you?
      Wait till you need a nurse and you’re lying on a trolley for a couple of days, and there is not enough nurses to look after you because the government persists with this nonsense (after all the other stupid policies like the recruitment ban)

      Reply
    • Paul MC 05/01/13 #

      Dave, you plonker!
      They don’t have to take the job, what part of this do you not get?
      Free will etc.
      Just because somebody does a particular job does not mean they are entitled to a particular wage – duh!

      Reply
    • @PAUL MC

      So what will you do then Paul when you get sick? Who will look after you? If all the nurses just decide to leave their jobs because ‘nobody is forcing them to work here’ what will you/your mother/your son/your wife do when they’re sick? What an idiotic comment.

      Reply
  • Minimum wage and dole for able bodied people who won’t work are too high, they should be reduced to European norms so as these new roles are in excess on the minimum.

    Reply
  • Mon de Unions!

    All out worker strike representing every industry I say!

    Reply
  • In Germany, Nurses earn €200 less than Ireland every week. We have a higher cost of living with higher taxes too.

    Reply
    • Fair play

      Reply
    • MVM 04/01/13 #

      What’s a nurses wage in Ireland?

      Reply
    • mcgoo 04/01/13 #

      200 euro? a week? Less? I sincerely doubt that you are correct.

      Reply
    • Why so many thumbs down for Danny? Is it possible they come from civil servants who want their pay to be kept a secret from benchmarking to Eurozone levels?

      Reply
    • ITS, I gave you a thumbs down, I am a public servant, after tax I earn approx 24,000 a year, that’s around 7,000 less than the average industrial wage, as an Special needs assistant I get 14 weeks a year off, my pay reflects that, yes I will have a pension at the end-which I have contributed to also, I find it insulting and hilarious that 4 years ago no one gave a shit about me or my job- in fact one friend said’i wouldn’t do your job for love nor money’ yet now I find my job and me vilified every day by the media and ignorant people such as yourself, this job is a vocation to me, I never gave a second thought to my wages or pension, want to swap places for a day?

      Reply
    • Paul MC 05/01/13 #

      That puts in a parallel with Germany then, what is everybody bitching about?

      Reply
    • Oh well done, compare Ireland to Germany, another country where nurses are looked upon like dirt, sure that’ll fix the HSE.

      Reply
    • Paul MC 05/01/13 #

      Not looked on as dirt you twit, nobody said that. The wages are the wages – don’t take the feckin job if the wages are crap.
      Did you ever hear of supply and demand?
      The laws of economics.

      Reply
    • Susan O Connell,

      In my experience, I had to endure a lot of bureaucracy, poor service, and abuse of power for simple things like getting a drivers license. This is the result of a big government – you have to justify your existence and you also have to be paid. I care about my freedom more than anything, but when my freedom is being taken, I don’t care if it mistaken by the government, or by society. I care simply that it is being taken. In reality, your neighbors can take your freedom just as easily as the government can. This is the reason applications are being made more difficult for everything resulting in people not getting their drivers license due to the massive regulatory hurdles caused by a big government.

      We need to downsize the government – for example abolish the RSA, Irish Water, PRTB and free up the market for ordinary people trying to live their lives.

      Reply
  • Most surprising thing in this article is that they used to have a starting salary of 33,470€

    No wonder the country is broke

    Reply
    • Jesus Wiseman is that true, no bloody sympathy so…son did mechanical engineering in TCD four years, just like the nurses, had to leave no jobs here, works in UK, same graft but not same salary, get real unions!

      Reply
    • ?33,000? Thats not alot really, although i know lots of people don’t earn it. But nurse’s are not the sort of public servants that deserve to be squeezed anymore. They are not responsable for the countrys cock up. Hard working, long hours, abused and under appreciated group of people that would nurse people (including the people who tar public workers with one big brush) back to health.

      Reply
    • As a STARTING salary I’d say its terrific – just out of college ???

      Reply
  • paul 04/01/13 #

    Public service employees love Croke Park !!

    Reply
  • Nurses will be looking after the entire nation when they are elderly and sick. They DESERVE a fair wage. How dare this country devalue the vital, life saving work we do every day of the week. I will bring my 4 year honours degree to a country that respects me. I refuse to accept anything less.

    Reply
  • Same ole same ole. Unions completely detached from reality. While there are over 400,000 on the dole.

    Reply

Add New Comment