TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Nurses’ union demands boycott of graduate scheme over pay dispute

The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation says graduate nurses should not have to work for 80 per cent of the usual wage.

Image: hxdbzxy via Shutterstock

THE TRADE UNION representing Irish nurses and midwives has called for a boycott of a scheme announced earlier this month, which would have seen the HSE recruit up to 1,000 graduates into those professions next year.

The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation has described the proposals, announced by the HSE last week, as a “cheap labour scam”.

Graduates recruited under the scheme would graduates paid a wage equivalent to 80 per cent of the minimum wage on the staff nurse scale – which the INMO says has already been cut by 24 per cent in recent years.

“Young nurses/midwives have, therefore, already contributed more than their fair share towards the country’s recovery,” the group said in a statement this afternoon.

The INMO and the Psychiatric Nurses Association also suggested the scheme was merely a way of getting existing nurses and midwives to return to the HSE at lower pay than before.

This reality is confirmed by the circular, issued by the HSE, telling all local health managers that any hospital that has already provided contracts of employment, to the 2012 graduates, should discontinue them immediately”, the groups said in a joint statement.

Both unions have called graduates completing college to refuse to apply for the posts until they are advertised at the salary equal to those afforded to full-time equivalents in the service, and are to organise a rally at Croke Park for January 5.

Read: HSE to recruit up to 1,000 graduate nurses and midwives next year

Read next:

Comments (88 Comments)

  • In my honest opinion, I still think that €20 whatever thousand is a paltry wage for a nurse! With the work they do, and the hours they do,they deserve twice as much! To think that some people (who have never worked and will never work) can potentially earn around as much as this through benefits is dispicible!!!

    Reply
    • is it not 26k starting for the 1st 2 years.??? plus 2k extra Graduate nursing jobs to be made available, correct me if im wrong. im pretty certain its gona be better then what I get after I graduate.. Id fund it odd if people became a nurse for the mobey anyway

      Reply
    • sorry 1k graduate nursing jobs

      Reply
    • 26K average which includes overtime payments.
      The basic rate is 21-22K I think.

      Reply
    • page 11 in the below link says the median salary for all graduates is €24-26k, will the new nursing graduates earn more or less than this.

      http://ahecs.ie/wp-content/uploads/Salary-survey-2012-uploaded-sept-2012.pdf

      Reply
    • The starting salary will be 21-22K as far as I can tell.

      Reply
    • So we should just work for free..u don’t work for the money no?

      Reply
    • @ Sean you fu***ing idiot who study four years and enter a job to work for free get real, I bet you don’t even have a job

      Reply
    • @paul mc kenna…spot on comment, anyone with a job in this bitter, divided country is now fair game for those with chip on their shoulders…Nurses work incredibly hard and the ridiculous comment that nurses don’t graduate for the money is beyond belief…we all graduate for the money…it depends what course you graduate from whether that be medicine, law, nursing, accountancy whatever! There’s nurses gonna be starting on 21k after four tough years while there’s people in arranged separations with two kids getting every benefit under the sun (dole, single mothers, children’s allowance, back to school, free rent, no mortgage, medical card, fuel allowance, etc, etc, etc) and who’ve never worked a day in their lives, these people are being defended by Sinn Fein, ULA every time the government wants to trim these exorbitant benefits….the working poor of this country, the regular tax paying family with combined gross income of 80-100k, with no medical card, no benefits at all, with mortgages and college fees to pay are hanging on, just! Those on benefits are going on sun holidays, have the 42inch plasma and ipads, medical cards, help from SVP etc, I see it going on…it’s a scandal and I feel the nurses should stand firm…constant raping of those who are working or willing to work has to stop…middle Ireland footing the bill for the layabouts and the crooks

      Reply
  • Lets be clear here.
    the reason why the agency costs are so much is because of mismanagement by the HSE.
    The recruitment embargo they enforced for so long was shown to save NO money and the only people who have profited from this are the agencies. Everybody else has suffered, from nurses to patients and the HSE has continued to pay vast amounts to ineffectual management.
    As usual, the people who are taking the pain for the HSE mismanagement are the front line staff who we absolutely have to support.
    The agencies will continue to profit and the diickheads who came up with this will probably get promoted.

    Reply
  • A nurse who is newly qualified is doing the exact same job as one who is there 15 years. This cut is yet another example of when the state can bully its employees in whatever fashion it sees fit and get away with it.

    Reply
    • James, what I’ve noticed is that the newer nurses arent as jaded as the older ones, and seem to work harder to make their name..To me, the regular doctors, nurses and midwifes in the HSE should not have their wages reduced or their contracts altered as they give enough

      Reply
    • While that may be the case, new nurses and midwives are capable of doing the exact same work, they are fully qualified, full member of the team. Asking them to work for anything less than their peers is scandalous.

      Reply
    • Nurses work on an incremental salary. New entrants will always be on a lower salary than those already working. Even more so with the absence of recruitment over the past few years.

      Reply
    • James, experience is recognised with increment payments, newly qualified never got the same pay, but did get the same conditions , this is about an eroding of nurses conditions of employment, which is the reason unions need wake up and earn their inflated pay

      Reply
    • Absolutely – agreed, but this cut isn’t on those scales. This cut is new – it’s a level under what graduates from last year received.

      Reply
    • James, first off the level of responsibility of a staff nurse who has been staffing 15 years would not be the same as a newly qualified nurse. How many newly qualified nurses that you know would be the senior nurse in charge of a ward, and as such would be left running an entire ward on any given day? The fact of the matter is the workload on a ward would be delegated according to the skill mix and experience of the staff who are on duty. At the end of the day, while €22k may represent a drop in the old starting salary, there are other graduates in other disciplines who’s earnings under Jobsbridge is the grand sum of €188 plus €50. The starting salary of a band 5 staff nurse in the NHS is £21,176, so I don’t know where the figure of £26k comes from? I also heard the IMNO stating that this scheme is replacing permanent posts. I would also like to know how this scheme is replacing permanent posts, considering newly qualified nurses don’t start off being permanent!

      Reply
    • Hi Ann, I’m not referring to senior nurses, as obviously they do move up in terms of responsibility.
      My point was that a general nurse is doing the exact same job as a general nurse who is on the job longer.
      In relation to the lower scale – pay scales exist to allow for advancement as career progression occurs.

      Reply
    • Ann, extra responsibility was recognised with increments, pay for new entrants therefore was less as it stood.

      Reply
    • tom 20/12/12 #

      same with new teachers no one is forcing them to take up these positions if the feel too hard done by then it’s their own decision.
      what has to be realised is the well is dry and there isn’t the money out to keep HSA in the custom it’s become use to.
      the only real way to pay all these nurses would be increase taxes as CPA has sealed cuts else where.

      Reply
    • Tom the well is dry , let’s start with politicians extras, not their basic pay, then bonus payed to HSE management, then look at real numbers doing office work ( many are needed but everyone says there are too many), now then nurses pay can be looked at , why always the frontline first , why oh why

      Reply
    • Regardless, there are still going to be graduates (Irish and overseas trained) who’ll be more than willing to work for €22k. Out of interest aside from holding a day of protest, does this mean that nurses who are on the old salary scale are going to go out on strike in support of their junior colleagues? Are they going to refuse to work with new graduates who may be employed on the lower entry scale? At the end of the day everybody has a choice! They can either stay in Ireland and get two years post-qualification experience and head abroad after that, or they can head abroad after they qualify and get their post-qualification experience in another country.

      Out of interest, does anybody ever start to question what they exactly got for all the duties that they willingly assumed under the extended role of the nurse – was it really worth it?

      Reply
    • Cynical Ann, yes I would support striking on this issue, yes the extended role did increase our role without real improvements in conditions, proper showers near wards for staff are in short supply for nurses and care assistance, but office staff have them, go figure

      Reply
    • In saying that, this could be a good thing. (I’m going to play devils advocate).
      Most post graduate nursing program’s require that the nurse has 2-3 years post registration experience.
      It may be a thing that more will consider a return to education and up skill to higher levels of nursing (whether advanced practitioner, or becoming qualified in 2 streams of nursing or prescriber or whatever) after completing this contract.
      That would be good as higher qualified nurses are only a new phenomenon in Ireland, but somehow I doubt that that’s the reality behind this cut.

      Reply
    • Unfortunately Shay it comes from years of experience. It’s something that always stuck with me from my days of training (overseas), where we had a discussion about why we were assuming all these duties under the extended role of the nurse – and whether we were willingly taking on the duties that was traditionally done by doctors to become more recognised as a “profession”. I guess I am cynical, but then again I remember the days where we went out on strike (think it was pay related) and despite paying union dues the INO (as it was then called) didn’t even have a strike fund. Add to that the fact that we were providing emergency cover, which totally defeated the whole purpose of a strike, and typically enough that strike had zero impact, because there were still nurses who were on the wards caring for patients. I also remember the days where the INO went on strike because of overcrowding in ED’s, and 10+ years, our ED’s are still in a meltdown. I just don’t think that the HSE or the DoHC takes nurses all too seriously. I said it back then, our fundamental mistake back then was not threatening an all out strike without providing emergency cover!

      Reply
    • Ann, I remember it well, true

      Reply
    • Like Ann was saying above there are other graduates who are looking at taking up a 9 month internship which will not pay the colour of 21 thousand. I’m a social care graduate who is about to start an internship for which I will receive the grand total of 183 a week. I wish the government would commit to adding 2000 social care workers at 21 thousand, and I would happily take up a position.

      Reply
    • @nessa, this is after their internship when they ate fully qualified, they are payed less than the minimum wage during internship, please read the article

      Reply
    • And I am talking about taking up an internship after qualifying with a degree. The same way these nurses that the hse want to hire will be qualified. have you herd of jobs bridge internships for people who are graduated. These are a nine month program which pay for me 182. I am a fully qualified social care worker (four year degree as well as 9 months of college placements) and I am starting on of these internship. So what I am saying is that plenty of other graduates would love this opportunity which is offered to nurses. So to let you know I have read the article but you did not read my comment clearly. So please read up in jobs bridge internships for graduates.

      Reply
    • 50euro on- top of social welfare, for people to gain experience, sorry not the same, the jobs are there for nurses already, they just want to pay them less, what your talking about is supervised work, qualified nurses are independant in the care of their patients and must take full responsibility for what happens on their shift

      Reply
    • Please don’t think I’m out to get you , if there are jobs and you do the work , you should be payed the same as you colleagues

      Reply
    • I am about to start an internship where I will have sole responsibility for the individuals in my care also. So I think you are mis informed about the responsibility level while on an internship. It varies from job to job. I am also saying that I would love the government to implement 2000 social care jobs paid at 21 thousand so I would not have to do an internship. But I presume you are going to find fault with me saying that plenty of social care workers would love this opportunity.

      Reply
    • Nessa, no fault with your view, disagree that you would be happy to be payed less than you colleagues for the same level of responsibility, especially when there is no reason to expect that they will ever pay you the correct pay scale , if there is work it’s reasonable to expect equal pay and conditions ,

      Reply
    • Ann you should swap over to siptu if you want your strike pay

      Reply
  • While I agree graduates should not be treated like this and a boycott sounds like a good idea, what are these graduates going to do for work? I doubt the hse will blink on this one as a boycott and therefore less wages to give will probably suit them. Am I the only who thinks that the unions themselves do a lot of talking about protecting the most vulnerable but nearly always protect the paper pushers at the top the most?

    Reply
    • There are not that many graduate nurses unemployed. In fact, most are either gone abroad or about to go abroad (which I would highly recommend), or are doing agency work which is far more beneficial financially than the current situation with the HSE.

      Reply
  • I am a newly qualified nurse, one of the ones that is in for a pay cut, guess what I do the same as other more “experienced nurses”! I have been left in charge of units, I’ve made clinical decisions, I also have four years clinical experience behind me, I have worked numerous 12 hour shifts unpaid for three years and 36 weeks of 12 hour shifts for 60% wages!!! I have also worked a normal job as well as doing college work, I’m not whining about wages or because I hate my job (I actually love it), I’m whining about the fact I like other newly qualified nurses are feeling unsupported by our government and some of the public as it seems, yeah it’s better than the dole or job bridge? But how many of these people work twelve hour shifts day nights weekends??? Maybe if we are to take a pay cut we should take an hour cut too!! Do a regular 9-5 week!!!

    Reply
    • MrKnow 20/12/12 #

      That’s a great post and i agree with you! I have a family member that’s a nurse and her work load is unbelievable! and she is really dedicated to her job. I stand behind your protest, you deserve better wages so don’t let this slide! and for people in this country, hypocrites!

      Reply
    • Kinsale,
      as a nurse of 20 years experience i salute you for what you are doing.
      You should not be treated like this though.
      You should be supported for you are the nurses who are the future of this country. You and the people who work with you are the ones we depend upon. And because you are devoted these prats think they can take advantage of that devotion.
      Selling out nurses like you is like selling out the future of the health system – it should be the last place these HSE bustards look for cuts.
      I have seen governments in three countries now try and pull off this kind of bullshit. They do not get the savings they are looking for and the health system – the people who give up so much to try and make it work – and the public – all suffer.
      The only ones who profit are the arsehooles who implement this sort of nonsense, and the agencies who pick up the pieces.
      The HSE is selling out our country and this arseholery must stop.

      Reply
  • what happened to the ideals of fair/equal pay?

    Reply
  • Wait. All health managers should discontinue contracts given to 2012 graduates. Surely once a contract is signed it can’t be altered?
    Or am I misunderstanding that part of the article?

    Reply
  • Typical unions wait and wait to assess the mood, then act and place the responsibility on the individual to opt out, if they gave a sh.t they would be calling nurses to strike on this issue in support of vulnerable junior colleagues . It would be interesting to see if existing staff are willing to do so, fifty fifty on my view,

    Reply
  • A boycott won’t work. Foreign nurses will take up those positions and they will more than likely be given long term contracts after the initial contract.

    That’s a risky strategy being proposed by the the nurses union.

    If Liam Doran was serious about this he would have the higher paid nurses out on strike.

    Reply
  • Shay I agree start with elite politicians pay, allowances, pensions, and the peculiar double pay entitlements plus the expenses need to go…..

    Reply
  • Just read nurses pay already cut 24%….. Cut somewhere else so….

    Reply
  • eoghan 20/12/12 #

    They do a great job getting rid of middle mangers and waste in other areas of public sector first .how many 000′s of people in offices in the hse not on the wards or doing anything

    Reply
  • Reading between the lines it sounds like those that left as full time nurses and kept the same job as agency nurses, but on better money, feel threatened – if the HSE hires a load of graduates, they will cut back on agency nurses. Then those agency nurses will want fulltime jobs but will end up going in on a lower pay grade.

    What is the alternative, should the graduate programme be boycotted and all the graduates leg it abroad? Who does the work then?

    Reply
  • Was watching the one show the UK are having a babyboom and urgently need 3000 midwives why would anyone who’s qualified stay here take crappy wages, crappy conditions. I hate to say it but they are better off going getting the experience overseas. Australia is also recruiting 000′s of nurses. I think the only people who will take these positions are those who have to.

    Reply
  • Why don’t the older nurses take a small pay cut to give to the graduates.

    What industries is paying graduates he same as established staff or the same as graduates 5 years ago?

    Reply
  • Shay totally agree with you, why just nurses? Because they’re easier to target than consultants probably. But again, why not cut everyone, experienced and new hires, back office and front line? Fact Health Service is spending too much…. something has to give so why not a little from everyone? I do think anyone subsidised by the Irish education system for key roles should have to contribute 3 years before emigrating or pay back subsidies – nurses, teachers, Drs, Social Workers……if you could find a way to do that for Private workers also then why not. Everyone needs to contribute…. Solidarity brothers and sisters! Oh and burn the bankers!

    Reply
    • Richard , no further pay cut for me, until politicians extras are gone, management manage and not just the HSE, they supply showers for all nurses within the wards they work, they listen to staff about ways to reduce costs, and the management leave there posts to fill in when the wards are short, and I don’t just mean nursing management, they can help patients to toilets and assist at mealtimes to free up my time

      Reply
  • Good luck with this, If they even get out of bed and go to work for 22k it will be 12 to 18 mths maximum before they are poached by private industry or other countries

    Reply
  • I’m sure there are a lot if Civil engineers out there now kicking themselves thinking that they made the wrong career choice. The best job offer they have at the minute in Ireland is a 1 year placement for no pay whatsoever. Maybe the govt should invest in infrastructure and offer 2000 graduated places for e21k. I bet the no of places would be well oversubscribed.

    Reply
    • Daniel, civil engineers did well in the good times, infrastructure seems a good idea , but they were also part of the bad planning of our cities, would you as a recently qualified be expected to take responsibly like nurses, or would a senior civil engineer be the fall guy

      Reply
  • Why not have every new starter contribute in the same way at every level from bottom up, Drs through Nurses? Most organisations in private sector have reduced starting pay at all levels so why not in public sector? It does seem we’re targeting one group though so why don’t those already qualified take a cut and lessen the blow? I don’t know why starting salary is the same as experienced anyway? Anyone?

    Reply
    • Richard starting pay isn’t the same , increments recognise experience and pay increased accordingly. This isn’t about nurses only, why should we be the only group ask to reduce our pay for junior staff when other groups payed by the HSE aren’t , this is an attack on frontline staff, and a funeral group, by a cowardly government and management

      Reply

Add New Comment