TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Quinn says no to ‘narrow focus’ on university performance

The Times Higher Education world reputation rankings failed to feature an Irish university – but the Education Minister indicated this is not a cause for concern.

Education Minister Ruairí Quinn
Education Minister Ruairí Quinn
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

THE ABSENCE OF an Irish university in the Times Higher Education world reputation rankings is not a cause for concern, the Education Minister has indicated.

Minister Ruairí Quinn was asked by Deputy Robert Troy in a recent parliamentary question if the fact the recent ranking failed to feature an Irish university is a cause for concern and how he intends to address this continuing fall in rankings among Irish universities.

Minister Quinn said:

There is significant debate around the relative importance attached to rankings criteria and on their capacity to fully capture the quality of what is on offer in higher education institutions. The Times Higher Education world reputation rankings are a new set of rankings in its second year and are based on reputational surveys only.

He continued that “the catastrophic reputational damage caused to Ireland by the inept economic management of the previous Fianna Fáil – Green Party government is perhaps the most influential factor affecting Ireland’s international reputation”.

Minister Quinn said that the current Government “has embarked on a conscious strategy to improve our reputation abroad since taking office”.

Despite some decline, Irish universities continue to figure prominently in world rankings, continued the Minister, saying that Irish institutions are featuring in the top 1 per cent in the world.

In 2011, two Irish institutions were in the top 200 and another three in the top 400 Times Higher Education World University ranked institutions out of some 15,000 universities worldwide. Moreover, the overall performance of the Irish system was highly ranked; 17th place overall and 6th place globally relative to our GDP.

Minister Quinn concluded that delivering high-quality higher education within the government’s current resources “will mean that we need to maintain a clear focus on system performance overall rather than a narrower focus on individual institutional performance”.

Read: Green light given to most third level colleges graded on litter and cleanliness>

Read: Irish university lecturers ‘work longer hours’ than European counterparts>

Read next:

Comments (6 Comments)

  • I always thought the Shanghai rankings were taken more seriously than the Anglo-Saxon centric Times ones.

    We do a bit better there with Trinity in the top 300 and UCC and UCD in the top 400.

    Reply
  • I would be more concerned about the quality of the innovation, creative visionary output of universities than a rubberstamp of approval of a subjective academic ranking table.

    I see evidence that creative thinking outside of Universities when coupled with some serious innovations that are currently being developed by a more creative element within our universities is the way to move towards restoring employment and export opportunities.

    You can’t have one without the other and no amount of flag waving or academic comparisons will change the fact that no matter how exceptional our graduates are, from any University or third level education, without joining the dots to commercialisation those same graduates will emigrate.

    Reply
  • I guess the point is that the system exists, and whether we like it or not, that’s how universities are measured. We can choose to play and enjoy the benefits of having high ranking universities, or we can choose not to and live with the consequences. It is pointless to talk about the problems of a system that no Irish minister can change. Nice one Mr Quinn.

    Reply
  • . We have a diluted education system as a result of lack of interest by Rory Quinn and his predecessor. These guys only have self interest.
    His nephew helped destroy the reputation of Dublin City Council Ethics Committee when he was found guilty of 4 breaches of ethics regarding planning and the ethics committee did not think it serious enough to prosecute. After all he is a developer and a councillor plus a member of the Quinn dynasty like the Haughy mafia.

    Reply
  • About bloody time! The ratings business is a sham. At last, we have a minister with cojones.

    Reply

Add New Comment