#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 4°C Thursday 20 January 2022

Over 23,000 formal complaints were made to the HSE in 2016

Community Healthcare Organisations (CHOs) were the subject of 3,984 complaints.

Image: RollingNews.ie

THE HSE RECEIVED more than 23,000 formal complaints about the health service in 2016, newly released figures have revealed.

The complaints relate to hospitals and community healthcare organisations, as well as the National Ambulance Service and Primary Care Reimbursement Service (PCRS).

Reasons for complaints filed by patients and service users included issues with access, dignity and respect, safe and effective care, communication, and clinical judgement.

Statutory hospitals, which are managed directly by the HSE, accounted for 5,019 of the formal complaints received in 2016; while voluntary hospitals, which are publicly funded but run by voluntary organisations, received 7,104 complaints.

Community Healthcare Organisations (CHOs), which are responsible for the delivery of primary care, social care and disability services, were the subject of 3,984 complaints.

A total of 92 complaints were made about the National Ambulance Service, while the PCRS, which is responsible for making payments to healthcare professionals in respect of public services, attracted 63 complaints – all of which related to communication.


The statutory hospital group with the most complaints was Saolta, which runs seven hospitals in the west and northwest, including University Hospital Galway (UHG) and Mayo General Hospital. The group received 1,310 formal complaints in 2016.

Ireland East Hospital Group, which includes St Vincent’s Hospital, Dublin and Our Lady’s Hospital, Navan, received 1,253 complaints. The South South-West Hospital Group, which includes Cork University Hospital, was the subject of 1,033 complaints.

The most common ground for complaints against statutory hospitals was a failure to provide safe and effective care, which was the basis of almost 51 percent of complaints.

According to the HSE, complaints in this category may relate to staff incompetence, misdiagnosis, mislaid test results, tests performed on the wrong patient, premature discharge, poor hygiene, or issues with pest control.

Problems with access, such as delays or cancellations, were a basis for nearly 28 percent of complaints against statutory hospitals. More than one-third of these complaints related to the Saolta hospital group.

There were 615 complaints concerning dignity and respect, which may include allegations of inappropriate behaviour, discrimination, or insensitivity to cultural beliefs and values.

Safe and effective care was also the most common category of complaint received by voluntary hospitals in 2016, forming the basis of 34 percent of grievances. A further 32 percent of complaints related to access.

Records released under the Freedom of Information Act reveal some confusion and concern within the HSE over the accuracy of the complaints data.

No return

The Quality Improvement Division, which was responsible for gathering the records, claimed that no complaints figures had been returned by the HSE West area in 2016, as required.

This was disputed by the regional manager in Galway, who provided national totals that included figures for the western region. However, he said that he could not provide specific records for the west due to structural changes in the HSE.

Internal emails also reveal a level of difficulty in compiling the figures.

One official in the HSE Consumer Affairs Department wrote to a colleague: “I’m attaching the statistics and praying to god [sic] I have them right. They are absolutely melting my head at this stage. It is a nightmare to get them in and then collate what does arrive and no one to bounce them off to make sure they are even correct.”

In a separate email, the same official was queried about data suggesting that there were no complaints received by certain acute hospitals in the southern region. In response, she wrote: “There was a couple further to add (I hope iv [sic] done this right!!)”

When the HSE was contacted for comment, it requested a copy of the data that had been obtained, and undertook to examine this with a view to providing a statement. No further response was received.

About the author:

Darragh McDonagh

Read next:


This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

    Leave a commentcancel