TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

HSE spends €80,000 housing Asian doctors – but many cannot work

Almost half the junior doctors recruited in India and Pakistan earlier this year have not been able to join hospital teams.

File photo
File photo
Image: Rui Vieira/PA Wire/Press Association Images

THE HSE IN Dublin alone has spent more than €80,000 housing junior doctors recruited from India and Pakistan to ease a hospital staffing crisis.

However, almost half of the doctors have not been able to register for work, despite having arrived in Ireland back in July.

Of the 266 doctors who were recruited and brought to this country – in a trip costing the HSE more than €100,000 – just 150 have successfully passed all the administrative hurdles and joined hospital teams. Thirty failed to pass exams set by the Medical Council.

In order to register, the doctors must submit a range of documents proving their qualifications; pass the practical exam;  and secure a declaration from their Irish hospital that proper supervision will be in place.

The doctors are not being paid before they begin work. Instead, they are housed in hospital accommodation or B&Bs and given a small stipend for food. The bill for this in Dublin alone has come to €80,709, Minister for Health James Reilly said in answer to a parliamentary question. He said other HSE regions were yet to submit their spending details.

The minister added the recruitment of the Indian and Pakistani doctors would mean “significant pay savings” thanks to reductions in overtime and agency bills.

Two weeks ago, the Irish Association for Emergency Medicine warned that the health service was at “breaking point” over doctor shortages in hospitals. Spokesperson John McInerney said the system was already under severe strain and a crisis was imminent if demand grew as usual over the winter.

Minister Reilly said the relevant authorities are “working actively” to speed up registration of the medics from India and Pakistan. “The Medical Council and the HSE are working to ensure that the necessary procedures to facilitate the registration of doctors are completed as quickly as possible, so that they can take up duty,” he stated.

Read more: Health service ‘reaching breaking point’ over doctor shortages>

Read more: HSE spent €100,000 on ten-day trip to South Asia>

Read next:

Comments (16 Comments)

  • A simple idea, but should these tests and paperwork not have been completed in India?? Will these stupid civil servants ever learn or were they just after a fully expensed holiday around India?

    Reply
  • Why were they brought over before they could prove the authenticity of their qualifications and pass the required exams? Could we not have setup a recruitment drive at the local Irish embassy, where they come with they certificates sit the exams and then get approval? Similar to the process for a J1 if your heading stateside.

    Reply
  • Another fine mess from government

    Reply
  • Sam Óg 21/09/11 #

    Why aren’t Irish doctors being trained? surely the money would have been better invested in getting some the countries 300k unemployed trained up.

    Reply
    • Its almost impossible for someone who would like to do medicine to actually do it, they have to get a huge amount of points in their leaving cert and then have some serious financial backing. When did you last see an Irish doctor from a council estate, or one who’s parents may have been unemployed, in low income jobs etc? I’m sure someone will say I know of one, but it’ll be the exception not the rule, doctors in this country are still from an elite class, “daddy” is usually a doctor, barrister, solicitor or the like not a butcher, plasterer, brickie, sparkie.
      incidentally, the HSE promised many of these foreign Docs between €95K to €116 to come here, but once they did they found they’d have to work an 80 hour week to earn that, in breach of the European 48 hour working time directive. Ooooppps, the HSE lied to get them here.

      Reply
  • Don’t worry none of the bureaucrats involved in this mess will lose their job. Life at the Health Shambles Executive will drift on sweetly for all the desk jockeys. Minister Reilly promised so much accountability would attach to his stewardship of Health that to be consistent he should resign.

    Reply
  • Nigel Mc 21/09/11 #

    No Way!! I’m shocked that our Irish Government has gone and wasted more money—- Truth is I’m not as nothing surprises me about how this country is ran. Republic of jokers!!

    Reply
  • Can we not get Doctors from
    The European countries and why do we have to go to these places.

    Reply
  • Dare I ask if they fail the initial exam do they get to repeat again and again until they pass? Considering the HSE is involved no level of incompetence surprises anymore. Limping constantly from one crisis to another. The only thing they seem to be consistent at is lowering the bar.

    Reply
  • How can you blame yhe currant Government over this cockup,Were is Mary Harney.

    Reply
    • Dermot D 21/09/11 #

      Every Health Minister can’t just blame their predecessor for the mess we’re in. James Reilly has inherited a health service in crisis but Mary Harney inherited a shambles of a health service from a FF Minister. The backdrop has been a major rise in the amount of people using our health service. We all know how big the problems are. But James Reilly needs to stand over decisions made on his watch and under his leadership. He needs to explain to the Irish people why this money is being wasted in this way when we all know the country is broke.

      Reply
  • So they’ve been sent back?…..right?

    Reply

Add New Comment