TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Leaders clash over Scottish independence ahead of Dublin summit

Alex Salmond and Nick Clegg have taken to Irish airwaves to express strong views about the issue of Scottish independence ahead of the British-Irish Council summit today.

Clegg and Salmond in June of last year (File photo)
Clegg and Salmond in June of last year (File photo)
Image: Danny Lawson/PA Archive/Press Association Images

SCOTTISH FIRST MINISTER Alex Salmond has accused the UK government of “bullying and hectoring” as the row over Scotland’s independence intensified ahead of the British-Irish summit at Dublin Castle today.

Salmond was speaking on RTÉ’s Morning Ireland after he heard the UK’s Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg accuse him of having “no answers” to questions surrounding the issue of Scottish independence.

Scotland maintains it has a mandate for holding the referendum on its own terms and wants to do it in 2014 but the British government wants the independence issue sorted out sooner.

“I think it’s time for Alex Salmond to explain to people what on earth he means by independence,” Clegg told RTÉ. ”He’s spent his whole political life  campaigning for it and yet he hasn’t got any answers for very, very simple questions.

Would it [an independent Scotland] have it’s own independent currency, what would it mean for the defence bases? What would it mean for investment? What would it mean for jobs. What share of the UK’s debt would Scotland have to bear?

What would it mean for bailing out banks which have gone belly-up in Scotland which British taxpayers have paid for. All of these questions, curiously enough, he’s got no answers for.

Clegg, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, denied that the UK was interfering in a matter that was for Scotland to decide. He said that there was “ambiguity” over the issue of whether Scotland had a mandate and he said Westminster was helping to “give that power to the Scottish administration”.

Responding in an interview this morning, Salmond said that “bullying and hectoring the Scottish people from London ain’t gonna work”.  He told RTÉ: ”What we’re seeing is the most extraordinary attempt to bully and intimidate Scotland by Westminster politicians.”

Salmond, the leader of the Scottish National Party, said that Clegg was “very much a Westminster politician” and accused the UK Chancellor George Osborne seeming “to think he now owns Sterling”.

He said it was up to the Scottish people to decide the terms of the referendum and said that a consultation document around the matter would be released to the Scottish people in the next fortnight.

Clegg and Salmond will both meet President Michael D Higgins at Áras an Úachtaráin today before attending the British-Irish Council summit at Dublin Castle.

Scotland insists it has mandate for independence referendum in 2014

Explainer: What’s happening in Scotland?

Youth unemployment on the agenda at British-Irish summit

Read next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • Probably wants his freeeeeeedom

    Reply
  • This is gonna get bitter. Westminister will orchestrate a campaign of fear to preserve the Union. I don’t believe the Scots will go for full independence given the current global financial uncertainty. I heard Salmon use ROI as an example of a nation who had prospered after independence from the UK. I suggest he steer well clear of that example this time around.

    Reply
    • The second choice of Devo Max, will be independence but will mean having the same Foreign Office and the same Army. It’s the comfy blanket option for the people that have been taught not to stand on their own 2 feet.

      Reply
  • It’s a clear cut issue really. Salmond and his party won a majority in the last Scottish elections, and have a mandate for this referendum. It is an internal Scottish issue, and not an issue for Westminster.

    Reply
  • Looking forward to seeing the united kingdom being dismantled

    Reply
  • Incidentally, “the banks which went belly-up” to which Clegg refers are RBS and Halifax-Bank Of Scotland (HBOS).

    He really should be aware that HBOS was made a wholly-owned subsidiary of Lloyds Bank, headquartered in London, three years ago. And that Halifax isn’t in Scotland.

    Reply
  • Have to say I can’t really understand the tactics being used by Cameron and Clegg on this issue. It seems to me that they are playing directly into Salmond’s hands in using this approach because it allows him to play the “English politicians interfering in Scotland’s affairs” card and whip up resentment and nationalist support for independence.

    Even if they did force an early referendum the SNP could easily campaign against it, claim it was flawed and then introduce their own version in 2014 as they have said they will.

    Surely the better approach would be to for the UK leadership of the coalition parties to take a softly, softly conciliatory approach whilst using the Scottish leadership of the parties to do the hectoring and arguing against independence.

    Reply
    • Scottish Labour and the Tories up there, do not have leaders at the moment. They certainly have no one of consequence or that can be seen as little more than a person looking to get a plush job in London.

      The tactics of Cameron and Clegg can basically be summed up as “know your place Jock and don’t take your Oil, Water and economy out of the Union, cause our careers are over if you do”.

      Reply
  • Where Spain has led, constitutionally that is, the UK will surely follow!

    Reply
  • Scottish independence won’t happen 100% sure of that

    Reply

Add New Comment