TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

Man arrested over 2005 murder of Robert McCartney

The 53-year-old is being questioned about the fatal stabbing of the father-of-two.

More than 1,000 people attended the victim's funeral in February 2005.
More than 1,000 people attended the victim's funeral in February 2005.
Image: Paul Faith/PA Archive/Press Association Images

POLICE IN NORTHERN Ireland have arrested a man in connection with the fatal stabbing of 33-year-old Robert McCartney over seven years ago.

PSNI officers have taken the 53-year-old man to Antrim Serious Crime Suite for questioning as part of ongoing enquiries into the murder.

The father-of-two from the Short Strand area was beaten and stabbed to death in Belfast on 31 January 2005 following an altercation in a city centre pub.

The killing had major political implications in Northern Ireland after claims that there had been IRA involvement. The victim’s sisters accused Sinn Féin of obstructing justice and campaigned for the veil of silence to be removed.

They visited both 10 Downing Street and the White House in the aftermath of their brother’s death and international political opinion turned against Sinn Féin for a time as a result. The McCartney family said the IRA intimidated witnesses and destroyed evidence.

The usefulness of the statements given to police was also questioned. According to a Daily Telegraph report, of the 155 people who spoke to investigating officers, 71 claimed they were in the pub’s 4ft-by-3ft toilet at the time of the attack.

In 2008, Terence Davison went on trial but was acquitted of the murder while two other men were cleared of related charges of affray.

Read next:

Comments (11 Comments)

  • About time someone faced the courts for this crime.

    Reply
  • 71 is a lot for a confined space, I wonder did anyone think of contacting the Guiness book of records?

    Reply
  • Baz 31/10/12 #

    Such a terrible horrific murder ..its just such a pity Sinn Fein didn’t give up the culprits ..it would have done so much for their image apart from being the correct thing to do

    Reply
    • “Gerry Adams statement on Robert McCartney case

      March 3, 2005

      Sinn Féin President Gerry Adams speaking today said:

      “I am deeply angry about the alleged involvement of a number of republicans in the killing of Robert McCartney. I believe that I am speaking for the broad republican constituency in publicly articulating my outrage and anger at what has happened. All of those involved in this horrific incident must make themselves fully accountable for their actions. Nothing short of this is acceptable. I have made clear my support for the family in their search for justice and have called upon those involved in the killing and others with information about the killing to bring this information forward.

      As part of these efforts to assist in the search for truth and justice I met the family of Robert McCartney a number of times. At a meeting on Thursday 24th February the family gave me a list of people who they allege were involved. As party President I immediately instructed the leadership of Sinn Fein in Belfast to establish if any of those named by the family were members of Sinn Féin. I was informed that seven of those named are members of Sinn Féin. All were immediately suspended from the party. This is on a without prejudice basis.

      As a political party Sinn Fein is not in a position to carry out an investigation which would adequately establish the facts surrounding the killing of Robert McCartney but those named by the family are suspended from membership and from any involvement in Sinn Fein activity pending the outcome of the legal process. If any of these seven are found to have been involved in the events surrounding the death of Robert McCartney, or if they do not provide truthful accounts at this time as the McCartney family have requested, Sinn Féin will take further internal disciplinary action to expel these individuals.

      All of these people have been personally instructed to provide full and frank statements. I reiterate that anyone with any information should make this available to the courts.I have given this statement to the family and to a solicitor.

      Although I stress that Sinn Féin has no basis to make any allegations against any of these suspended members at this time, and some or all may be innocent of any offence, I have instructed the solicitor to pass the names given to me by the McCartney family to the Police Ombudsman.” ENDS

      CAn’t be much clearer than that.

      Reply
    • Thanks Brian,

      Just to add a bit more historical info. SF and Gerry Adams were criticised at the time for not explicitly telling people to come forward as witnesses to the police. He did so in January 2007…

      Reply
    • What a shame Mr. Adams could not prevent the constant intimidation that drove the family out six months later. I seem to recall that the family were said they would never again vote Sinn Fein, so disappointed were they by Mr. Adams lack of meaningful help.

      Reply
  • this was horrific,an awful way to lose your life

    Reply
  • I just hope this guy gets what he deceivers

    Reply
  • Baz 31/10/12 #

    Nice share Brian and very strong statement from gerry Adams

    Reply
  • What a place.

    Reply

Add New Comment