TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Minister: Online news outlets could be regulated

Minister for Communications Pat Rabbitte suggested that defamation and regulatory rules could apply to online media outlets.

Image: Eleanor Keegan/Photocall Ireland

MINISTER FOR COMMUNICATIONS Pat Rabbitte has suggested that online news media outlets could be be regulated in a similar way to print and broadcast media.

The Minister said that defamation laws are still struggling to come to terms with the implications of online media.

“In time, there may be a place for the inclusion of established online media organs in a system of non-statutory and independent self-regulation in the digital media, possibly even having afforded recognition in the Defamation Act,” Minister Rabbitte told a conference on media diversity in Dublin today.

Minister Rabbitte praised the internet for “democratising” news and devolving power “down to the level of the citizen”.

He also told the conference that the government is intending to publish draft legislation on media mergers in the coming months.

Regulate media ownership

The conference also heard from the head of National Union of Journalists in Ireland who spoke in favour of introducing legislation to regulate media ownership in Ireland.

Secretary of the NUJ Seamus Dooley said that while concentration of ownership and powerful individuals is not as acute in Ireland as in other countries, there are still fundamental issues of ownership.

He pointed to the UK as an example where failure to regulate had caused huge problems in the media and said that journalists in both countries had paid “a very high price” for the failure of their Governments to control media ownership”.

Social media

Another speaker told the conference that using social media can limit the diversity of information and opinions that people are exposed to.

Karin Wahl-Jorgensen of the Cardiff School of Journalism said that despite a “staggering variety of news and opinion at our fingertips”, people increasingly are exposed to algorithms which calculate what they will be interested in or agree with. She told the conference:

Having a wide range of opportunities for participation does not necessarily guarantee a more varied set of voices in the public sphere. Rather, in all likelihood it results in the proliferation of the same voices that would otherwise assert themselves to represent polarised points of view.

Alan Crosbie

Earlier, comments by the chairman of a major Irish media group caused a furore on social media channels when he said that new media had the “capacity to destroy civil society“.

Alan Crosbie of Thomas Crosbie Holdings said that newspapers should benefit from the new broadcasting charge as they provide as much of a public service as RTE.

- Additional reporting by Michael Freeman

Crosbie: newspapers should get a slice of any new broadcasting charge >

Read next:

Comments (44 Comments)

  • The internet is slowly dying. BTJunkie closed today :( All the torrent sites are closing, MegaUpload. Twitter and google agree to censor information. Sigh, really pissed off with the old generation of this world reaching the end of their lives and destroying the freedoms and technological advances which can make the world a better place.

    Reply
    • We need this government to go! I just hope everyone realises that sooner rather than later. Every single day that passes we lose chances to make Ireland the great country that it deserves to be. This is our time. We need to take it back before its gone :-(

      Reply
    • there is no way we can get them out. We have to wait 4 more years and endless more stealth taxes and charges and increasing cost of living. How this is going to get our economy back is beyond me. But we are stuck with them. Irish politicians have no morals or feel they should do the right thing. Look at the UK, scandal happens, people take responsibility and resign. Our politicians go into hiding, wait a week or two and its forgotten about and they stay have their job. Happy days. And they are able to sleep at night. I wouldnt be able to sleep at night if I was doing some of the things they are doing to the disabled and elderly and weak in our society. But we cant do anything about it. There is no alternative.

      Reply
    • Totally agree with you both, but how can we get rid of them TheVoiceOfReason?
      I’ve tried protesting & occupations, but it’s useless. The only form of protest there seems to be popular support for is ringing Joe F***ing Duffy!
      The media keeps telling us that there’s a brain drain, which kinda implies that I’m a thicko for deciding to stay. Many who *say* they love the country, leave until it “sorts itself out”…. I’m not what you’d call patriotic, but where’s the fighting for what’s right. Fighting to retain democracy.
      Please tell me the reason voice?

      Reply
    • Totally agree voice this goverment has declared war on its people ,people of ireland WAKE UP

      Reply
    • BTJunkie was rubbish anyway you need to get to the Bay!

      Reply
    • Would it work if we demanded a referendum and voted no against this treaty b••••••t. I don’t agree with anything merkel, sarkozy and co. do, since the recession began they seem to be purposely trying to make things worse for us, the people of Ireland need stand up against them and at the moment this is the quickest road I can see us taking.

      Reply
    • Every problem has a solution .
      John Stevenson , with all due respect , please don’t be so defeatist ,please.
      First off stand up and decide not to be afraid, then do nothing . I mean do not
      register and do not pay the house hold charge or the septic charge
      They want to set up a data base with all our details , to assist them in property tax .
      Our best weapon is our refusal to co operate .

      Reply
    • I see that non compliance with the household charge is a people’s referendum.
      We may not get to ballot on the fiscal treaty , so let them know how annoyed we all are by not registering and not paying …….
      They are already backtracking …… Septic bank charges BUT <BUT < but they still want / need you to register , so don't .
      Don't be afraid, I am not any more .

      Reply
    • John Stevenson, while your frustration is understandable, such a defeatist attitude is precisely why Ireland has sunk to the depths of despair.

      There is much we can do but it must begin with the individual taking responsibility for their own situation.

      The only power that this small group of people have over 4 million of us is the power we grant them through apathy and blind, distracted compliance with the corrupt system they operate.

      Research this system and you will quickly realise that it is a charade that we can choose not to engage with.
      If we choose to question everything that established society throws at us, make up our own minds and take back our individual and collective power by doing the right thing as opposed to always taking the socially acceptable, politically correct or populist path, then very quickly things will change.

      However it will never happen through the game of politics – this is simply another sideshow.
      Take individual responsibility, take back your power.

      Reply
    • The Romanian people just got rid of their government through mass protest. It can be done, just too many people think otherwise in this country. Although if more governments fall through these actions things might change here.

      Reply
    • Ardo Ci 07/02/12 #

      Right on bro!

      Reply
  • Who’s going to regulate all these regulators?

    Reply
  • And Eurasia was always at war with Oceania…

    Reply
  • jimbo 06/02/12 #

    baloney!

    Reply
  • Make no mistake that this is the second step towards State controlled media ( The first being ISOPA / ACTA ). To assume that everyone except them can not be trusted full access to other forms of media that we actually have control of is huberis. Our enlightened Tsars are leading us down the road to 1984

    Reply
  • Seriously! Has this man nothing better he could be doing? The country is near crisis and he’s writing new legislations for media. If its not that, it the Internet that’s bothering him. Quit trying to validate your existence in government and do something ‘actually’ useful for this country please!

    Reply
  • The only legislation need regarding the media is too make all forms of censorship illegal, and access to all information a basic right.

    Reply
  • The new media would be hard pressed to find anything to destroy when the idiot politicans get done with our society, Mr Crosbie.

    Reply
  • Sounds like the Communications Clinic has been pulling at strings again.

    Reply
  • @TheJournal.ie Since this if enacted would affect your publication, may I ask what your take is on Crosbie’s & Rabbittes comments?

    Reply
    • Good question. There isn’t an official line on this here so this is just my view, but I think we’d have to wait and see exactly what would be contained in any regulatory guidelines. Rabbitte didn’t give a lot of information about how much regulation would be involved and there’s a huge spectrum for what he could choose to introduce, so it would be premature to get into it too much before we know anything.

      Reply
  • Well now what else can they think up to control. There is no media in this country that give all sides of any story, they are obliged to write utter tripe at times to suit the ” directed history” and the usurpers of our powers. The people give the government a certain amount of power to work for the “common good”, but how can they assume powers that were never bestowed on them. The people themselves did not have that power to begin with. If one looks at the gradual erosion of our freedoms and liberties over the last decade or two, it does not bode well for diversification in the media. The people are treated as gomeens, a danger to themselves and to everybody else, so how could they use their intelligence and logic to suss out what is the truth when there is no unbiased media, except on the Internet. While the Internet offers an alternative view is it not accepted that most will read all sides and decide what is the truth for themselves. I sure don’t want to hear about the Virginia Caucus or any other rubbish from the US being dished out by our state controlled media. Inch by inch the Internet is being silenced, because of those with the spin and agendas to promote. They are losing the battle and what better way to stifle the opposition media i.e. little bits of legislation at a time until little is left only Madonna, or football. Look how the UK blocked Iranian TV, which also removed it from us. I’m not standing up for Ir Tv, but at least I should have as much choice as possible, but no, I haven’t matured enough, I’m stupid, and need guidance from those who know best. God help us and we to our brows in debt, nothing like a distraction.

    Reply
  • They got their hands caught in the cookie jar and they’ve been found out. Same thing happened in the thirties but they got away with it through the New Deal, WW2 and propaganda.Their ***ked now because every one knows war and the news is bullshit and they cant have debt forgiveness as debts are different now compared to the thirties through multiple sell ons. Internet is their biggest enemy. Expect wide spread unrest worldwide over the next few years and better days there after.

    Reply
  • Rory 07/02/12 #

    Believe it or not, I agree. I am against the current Sopa SI, but people can be defamed too easily by certain media online. Magda. The student falsely accused of dodging a fare. It’s very easy for us here to have a mob mentality, and to call people scum to their names.

    Reply
  • Ah for fsake Crosbie why did you give this twat ideas, hope your companies loose all their value overnight if this plan goes ahead.

    Reply
  • This is the most authoritarian government we’ve had in recent history. I’m literally speechless.

    Reply
  • And what of the recent YouTube case eh? At least in traditional media it is always easy to establish who the author of defamatory content is. Online it’s not easy at all. The guy was criticised by many for taking the action, rather than just owning up – and then it transpired he was completely innocent when someone else owned up instead. Yet the trial by YouTube comment would have found him guilty had he not taken the court action.

    While I think Crosbie is certainly exaggerating in his comments, there are plenty of completely new issues here to be examined. Likewise with the recent legislation aimed at stopping piracy. When it is a big company such as a record label that is losing money through their copyright being evaded, it doesn’t matter. But when it is a small scale blogger or musician or artist or whatever, then its a different story. And yet the law can’t and shouldn’t discriminate.

    I see people claiming this is censorship. Yet is removing a hateful or false comment on here counted as censorship as well?

    Reply
  • Here we go again!

    What is wrong with expression? Why does this government find the need to hamper freedom of speech and expression online?

    Reply
  • Ardo Ci 07/02/12 #

    Someone said here ‘refuse to co-operate’. It is the most powerful weapon of the proletariat. Peaceful refusal to co-operate – nothing more powerful in the world.

    Reply
  • Hang on, ‘Madga’ was defamed by an article in the print media – not online!

    Reply
  • I am surprised to hear they aren’t already, I can’t count the number of times some said I was defaming one celeb or another on Boards.ie or the like.

    Reply
  • Censorship!

    Reply
  • C’mon guys are you genuinely being serious in suggesting that digital media should be completely unregulated.
    On a daily basis every leading Government politician is slandered to such a degree that if the same were to take place in newsprint the authors would be dizzy from the revolving doors in the Four Courts. It’s only a few days since I had to hide from the threats of a deranged contributor to these pages and you all want to continue with this wonderful freedom?
    Freedom is earned and with much of the behavior witnessed just on this publication you guys are in debt up to your eyeballs rather than being in credit for balanced and respectable comment.

    Reply
    • And are international organisations going to be so nice as to observe our ‘new media’ regulations.

      I sure hope they do, would hate to see them blocked

      Reply
    • @Mark
      “Enda Kenny is a liar”. That is a slanderous statement, afaik. So are you now going to hold the Journal.ie, Facebook, Twitter or the ISP responsible for me saying that!!! That’s the issue.
      I’m one person and as with online media, before you trust what I’m saying you will probably first establish if it’s worthwhile listening to me…. or are you one of the people who answer the “I’m a Nigerian Banker” scams?
      In relation to politicians being slandered I guess you are referring to the likes of twitter. True politicians are slandered by the like of me there. Same as slanderous statements would be spoken in a pub – are you going to hold the publican accountable for that?
      The real issue here for the politicians is that social media expands the anti-government thinking by by-passing the state-controlled media. It gives democracy and spreads information, which the politicians across the EU are afraid of. They are trying to avoid their electorate at every turn.
      Perhaps you are correct about freedom being earned, which is probably why we are loosing it. Somebody voted FF and FG all these years leading to tiny political spectrum steeped in dogma on both ends.

      Reply
  • Proper order.

    Reply
  • What?

    Reply

Add New Comment