TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Protest at Papal Nunciature over treatment of Fr Tony Flannery

About 120 people have attended a demonstration calling for fair treatment for the Redemptorist priest.

ABOUT 120 PEOPLE have attended a protest outside the residence of the Papal Nuncio to Ireland, in Cabra in Dublin, over the treatment of Fr Tony Flannery.

The liberal Redemptorist priest, who founded the Association of Catholic Priests, has been taken out of ministry while the Vatican investigates his involvement with the group.

The body has been outspoken in its calls for an end to clerical celibacy and the right of priests to marry – as well as seeking an overhaul to church teachings on sexuality and on the method of selection for bishops.

The 66-year-old has been ordered to sign a document confirming his adherence to Church teachings before he will be put back into active ministry – but he has refused to do so, saying this week he would be unable to look at himself in the mirror if he did.

The Papal Nuncio, Archbishop Charles J Brown, is not present in Dublin today; he is in Cork attending the ordination of William Crean as the new bishop of the Diocese of Cloyne.

Protest at Papal Nunciature over treatment of Fr Tony Flannery
1 / 3
  • Protest at Papal Nunciature

    Photo: Amy Croffey (@amycroffey)
  • Protest at Papal Nunciature

    Photo: Amy Croffey (@amycroffey)
  • Protest at Papal Nunciature

    Photo: Amy Croffey (@amycroffey)

Read: Fr Flannery ‘couldn’t look in the mirror’ if he signed Church statement

Read next:

Comments (42 Comments)

  • Aren’t real Christians supposed to question Authority? Like the way Jesus questioned the Pharisees?

    Fair play to Fr. Flannery. We need more like him

    Reply
  • the Vatican ordering silence on something hmmm where have we heard this before

    Reply
    • @tom don’t be so gullible the rate is way above 2%,and worse again is nearly all priests and bishops knew it was going on and covered it up..to this day noone knows how far it stretches due to priests been moved to other parishes and sent as missionarys not taking into account still the people who are to ashamed to come forward due to media attention

      Reply
    • I say, Let the church be and they’ll be crucified in time!

      Reply
  • Big up to Fr. Flannery, nice to see a priest who questions his own Institution on its own outdated teachings and beliefs.

    Reply
    • As far as I know Fr Flannery hasn’t questioned any of the church’s core teachings & beliefs. His main issue is with being told that certain subjects can’t be discussed e.g. women priests. He is not another Martin Luther & would not thank you for saying so.

      Reply
  • The Roman Catholic Church remains true to character.

    The Roman Catholic Church is an authoritarian, dogmatic and repressive institution, convinced of its own infallibility. That is not a good outlook from an adaptive and survival perspective.

    Some day in the future the indoctrination of its erstwhile supporters will start to diminish. The fracture lines are emerging and the suppression of information concerning child abuse was just one of the fracture lines.

    Reply
  • The RCC is an outdated dictatorship. The ‘real’ God would not have a ban on women being priests.
    End of story.

    Reply
  • Saw him interviewed on CNN last week.. What a man he is , wouldn’t it be lovely to have afew more of him and his ideals around. A good soul & person …

    Reply
  • I have heard Fr Flannery give a sermon and he is incredible to listen to. He is such a humanitarian, and a priest on the ground! I think he is on UTube, if they loose him they really have their heads in the sand!

    Reply
  • Fair play to Fr Flannery for being true to his calling ! ” if wicked men insult and hate you , all because of me , Blessed Blessed are you “

    Reply
  • Well done Fr. Flannery. There’s a lot of politicians could take a leaf out of your book.

    Reply
  • Still haven’t seen the light!
    Still haven’t seen the errors of their dictatorial past !
    The Catholic Institution run by dinasaurs is over.
    Long live freedom of speech and democracy !

    Reply
  • Expel the nuncio – what a loss if we had no diplomatic relations with the theocracy of the Vatican

    Reply
  • down with this sort of thing!!

    Reply
  • In many churches the pews control the pulpit and it lessens the harm that can occur. When the pulpit controls the pews anything goes as we have seen. The nuncio represents a golf course sized hunk of land with about 1,000 citizens, all adult male, allegedly celibates, called Vatican City. It came about with a contract between a now dead pope, and a butcher named Mussolini.

    We lost a priest out here in Colorado because he went around acting too much like Jesus. One day it, and all of its pretensions, will be part of the past, just like the god Mithras, a fellow with Jesus’ bio, but predating him by 900 years. The Vatican sits on what was, in Roman times, the Hill of Mithras, the virgin-born savior god, who was precocious as a child, raised Hell with the priests of his day, was killed for it, and rose from the dead after a three day hatch time underground. This all came from ancient Persia about 900 BCE (before the common era), and we are still stuck with it.

    Reply
    • John what does Jesus mean to you? Your relationship does not depend on the faults of others in the past. You won’t be asked to account for what others did. Didn’t Jesus say ‘do not judge’? Calm yourself and try and relate to others who have faults like yourself but who ultimately God loves, as He created us all.

      Reply
    • Jesus was a man or a myth, and he had some wisdom, and plenty of ignorance, like the rest of us. According to Matthew he thought castration, to avoid temptation (19:12), was a good idea, and Paul probably did it. His system of justice was stupid…reward a thief with more goods, instead of restitution and punishment. He was a bigot toward the woman at the well, comparing her to a dog, because she wasn’t a Jew, and never said a word about education, art, or thinking for oneself. The list goes on, but this is enough to show his humanity, or the human part those who created him.

      Reply
    • @Kevin. You should try and relate to john and myself and understand that it’s hard for us to believe in the bible and Jesus Christ son of God.

      Please empathize that we lack the faith that you are so blessed with… Unfortunately for us, we learned about things such as evidence, reasoning, human culture, history, theology and myths and probably lost our chance of having faith in the bible and Christ.

      Reply
    • @Kevin. You should try and relate to john and myself and understand that it’s hard for us to believe in the bible and Jesus Christ son of God.

      Please empathize that we lack the faith that you are so “blessed” with… Unfortunately for us, we learned about things like evidence, reasoning, human culture, history, theology and myths and lost our chance of having faith.

      Reply
  • The pope owns 177 million acres of land. Of course, he’s not interested in wealth or power, he has his mind on ‘higher’ things. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I read somewhere that the Vatican owns about 20% of land in Italy.
    ‘There are no pockets in shrouds’.

    Reply
    • The pope does not own such land. When he dies it cannot be passed on to his relatives. The office of the pope may have an interest in land but not the pope personally.

      Reply
    • You’re quite right Kevin. You would imagine that the supposed servants of God would be appalled, sickened, scandalised or perhaps even just embarrassed at the amount of wealth the Vatican possesses, not only the gold & cash in its bank vaults but in its museum and gallery treasures but then this is not a religion. Its a business and businesses exist to make profits. The pope recently gave $250,000 from his own vast personal fortune to misogynist defectors from the Church of England. Note his use of U.S. dollars, not pound sterling or euros. Very interesting.

      Reply
  • Julie 27/01/13 #

    Lets have an article about the over 200-300 people who turned out in ballyhea today well done great turnout .

    Reply
  • Blah blah blah, in front of the fire, watching a movie, 2 dogs chilling, boyfriend up the stairs in bed in our newly purchased home, pay tax, blah, blah, have parents, siblings, problems, issues, debt, debt and some more debt!!!!
    Who bloody cares??
    Let’s discuss some real news!!!!!
    A man heads out to work and is shot in the head, killed doing his job, it brings tears to my eyes.
    245 people dead in brazil, again; tears.
    Church, women saying mass, men marrying men, does NOT bring any dampness to my eyes!!
    Let’s have some perspective

    Reply
  • BCE, before common era, the new attempt to eradicate Christ from our history and lives. Please do not use this as an attempt to be trendy!

    Reply
  • Protestants find themselves at the wrong address.

    Reply
  • Mahony’s Legacy
    By Vinnie Nauheimer

    Let’s hear it for Cardinal Mahony!
    Never was one so full of baloney;….

    (more) http://mnsnap.wordpress.com/vinnie/

    Reply
  • Ferg 27/01/13 #

    Another poor soul caught up in the cult of personality…

    Reply
  • This is very simple. Fr. Flannery needs to remember his vow of obedience and sign the document and abandon this ridiculous ACP.

    Reply
    • With all due respect Lieutenant, he needs to obey his heart and his inner guidance, not misguided, archaic system!

      Reply
    • That is not an option when you make a vow of obedience. If he cannot keep this vow surely this affects his overall credibility.

      Reply
    • Molesting young children is not enough to affect credibility but saying the catholic church is a bit immoral in certain aspects is? Well… Credibility doesn’t mean much to me in this context.

      Reply
    • The S.S. were obedient to Adolf Hitler, and we all know what transpired there. Would you blindly obey a system if it went against your beliefs?

      Reply
    • Obedience is not about just doing what you are told. Maybe for catholic priests it is as it gives them an excuse not to have to think, and like Ireland’s Cardinal Brady, it means he can reassure himself he did all he could when he swore two young children to secrecy over the violent, inhuman, demonic and savage rapes they had been subject to at the hands of a catholic priest.,, “I was only following orders”. However any decent human being is ordinarily a dutiful and obedient person except when he/she is asked to do something that goes against his/her conscience – that’s morality, pure and simple.

      Reply
  • Shouldn’t the signs read Dialogue Yes, Science No?

    Reply

Add New Comment