TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Reform could mean dramatic overhaul of ministerial responsibility

Brendan Howlin will shortly receive a policy paper outlining how laws can be changed to make ministers more responsible.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Archive

A LEGAL REVIEW about to be presented to the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform could lead to major reforms in how ministers are held responsible for government decisions – and ensure that a single individual is held responsible for every government decision.

Brendan Howlin will shortly receive a policy paper surrounding the working of ministerial offices and government departments, outlining ways in which laws could be reformed to ensure greater responsibility.

The policy paper follows a review of the “current accountability framework for ministers and civil servants” ordered by Howlin last year, following a pledge in the Programme for Government to ensure that specified people are named as being responsible for executive decisions.

The review will see an overhaul of the Ministers and Secretaries Acts, which are behind the legal creation and existence of government departments, and the Public Service Management Act which ensures that ministers are responsible for the acts of their departments.

In response to written Dáil questions from Sinn Féin’s Aengus Ó Snodaigh, Howlin said the proposals would enshrine the principle that all decisions made by a Department would be attributed to either a named civil servant or the minister themselves.

The minister in charge of the Department would also have to account for the degree of supervision and oversight they carried out over their department.

Howlin said a public consultation process would be carried out once the policy paper had been completed and published.

The minister added that the process would take inspiration from a Labour party policy document, ‘New Government, Better Government’, which Howlin wrote while he was Leas Ceann Comhairle and Labour’s spokesman on constitutional reform.

Read next:

Comments (25 Comments)

  • Exactly

    Reply
  • So as things stand, it would appear that nobody is actually held responsible for anything. Is that what he’s saying? Where else would you get it, eh?

    Reply
  • Watch for the mass retirement application,s if this policy is ever implemented ,our civil service will be halved ,nobody will take the lead job,s ,they will be just standing position,s

    Reply
  • It probably will happen, its like this shower are thinking their time is nearly up and they’re probably going to get wiped out in the next election so they’re setting the trap for the next shower. If this is what it takes to make polidicheads accountable for their actions well so be it.

    Reply
  • Devlin report 1968, SMI and the Public Service Management Act, Ministers wanting to take the glory for success and ascribe the blame for failure…

    Reply
  • Blah blah… Will never happen!

    Reply
  • I have a dream…………………………one day our leaders will be accountable to us……………. Na just a dream.

    Reply
  • Liam 01/03/13 #

    This will never come to be, or at least will never be effective, the government knows that their incompetence will undermine them if it does.

    Reply
  • A few days late for the disability transport grants. Imagine if this were in place when Reilly announced those cuts, at least the lift got its own back. Better still imagine if septic Phil Hogan were responsable for the household charge mess. That would be Edna hold over FG gone.

    Imagine if responsable Government were real.

    Imagine responsable politiicians.

    Okay enough daydreams back to trying to figure out which bill to pay, the food or the heating.

    Reply
  • Minister increase car tax …..Sure god love him sure take an extra 50 k a year in case u get stressed with that decision on your shoulders

    Reply
  • How about a law if government forces austerity and misery and betrays the people they can be executed.

    Reply
  • It wouldn’t matter a toss. Even if there is a named proponent of every law, if it goes tit’s up that person would never be sacked or god willing have a conscience and resign.

    Reply
  • Seeing as how the HSE are an extra-departmental excutive kept at arm’s length from the Dept of Health, will James Reilly now be accountable for decisions made by the HSE?

    Reply
  • Sure it will provide jobs for a few cronies for a few years but will never come to pass, it will be swept under the carpet in leinster house with a lot more of the crap, its a wonder they can get into leinster house at all with all the crap thats been swept under the carpet.

    Reply
  • LOL! When has our politicians ever taken advice or guidance from reports? Advice and guidance that would better the lot of the average tax paying citizen? Honestly, they may make changes.. However, the changes will be all cosmetic and responsibility will linger in Pergatory so that no one will be blamed for failure.

    Ireland is a very special place. Unlike other !st World Countries…. Our politicains can do no wrong. Our politicians are never held accountable. Our politicains are paid more than other politicians for less productivity. Our politicians never resigns. If a politician were to be found to abused his\her office or the law… Finding them guilty could bankrupt the country,because an expensive tribunal must be completed before going to the police for duplicate investigation.

    Face it folks…. I don’t care what you think… For a First World Democratic Country…. We are living in the Dark Ages.

    Oh well… Other than our over paid and skillless politicians, health system, Bank Debt, poor public transportation and LOL! When has our politicians ever taken advice or guidance from reports? Advice and guidance that would better the lot of the average tax paying citizen? Honestly, they may make changes.. However, the changes will be all cosmetic and responsibility will linger in Pergatory so that no one will be blamed for failure.

    Ireland is a very special place. Unlike other !st World Countries…. Our politicains can do no wrong. Our politicians are never held accountable. Our politicains are paid more than other politicians for less productivity. Our politicians never resigns. If a politician were to be found to abused his\her office or the law… Finding them guilty could bankrupt the country,because an expensive tribunal must be completed before going to the police for duplicate investigation.

    Face it folks…. I don’t care what you think… For a First World Democratic Country…. We are living in the Dark Ages.

    Oh well… If you don’t consider our over paid and skillless politicians, health system, Bank Debt, biased legal system and unemploment… This is a great country to live in!

    Reply
  • Of course for all the extra responsibility and pressure of being held accountable for departments that they run, it is only fair that the cabinet get a well deserved hike in their remuneration package when the time comes.

    Reply
  • Why all the ministers, we don’t have 40 million+ people in this country. Its 04 million+, being all teachers, you’d think they could count?

    Reply
  • Just more white wash . To keep the peasants quite

    Reply

Add New Comment