TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Shatter indicates pardon on the way for Irish deserters who fought in WWII

Thousands of Irish soldiers fled the Defence Forces to fight for the Allies in World War II. They were persecuted upon their return to Ireland.

Alan Shatter
Alan Shatter
Image: Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland

JUSTICE AND DEFENCE Minister Alan Shatter has indicated that thousands of Irish soldiers who deserted from the Defence Forces to fight in World War II will be given a pardon later this year.

Shatter has now received legal advice from the Attorney General on the issue of a potential pardon for an estimated 5,000 Irish soldiers who joined the Allies in World War II and were persecuted upon their return to Ireland.

The issue is the subject of a campaign to have the men pardoned. They were denied all Defence Forces’ pay and pension rights upon their return to Ireland and were prevented from working for the State for a period of seven years.

The so-called ‘starvation orders’ were issued at a time when anti-British sentiment was high in Ireland and the government feared civil unrest unless action was taken against the men, analysts have said.

Speaking on RTÉ’s Morning Ireland Shatter said that the thousands of men who had left to fight for the Allies against Nazi Germany had “contributed to the future of freedom and democracy in Europe”.

He said it was now a time to revisit the issue of pardoning the men, the majority of whom have since died.

“I believe it’s now right that we revisit historically how this issue was dealt with,”he said. “There was a motion passed, which I welcome, in the Stormont parliament this week, supported by all sides, calling for a pardon.”

The Justice Minister said that legal matters needed to be considered and that having received advice from the Attorney General he would be discussing the issue with Cabinet before making a statement later this year.

A number of TDs and Senators have backed the campaign to have the Irish soldiers who deserted pardoned.

Labour TD Gerald Nash has previously said that the behaviour of the government of the day towards the men “is not only a stain on their honour but on the honour of Ireland.”

Shatter considers pardon for Irish soldiers persecuted for fighting Hitler

Read next:

Comments (21 Comments)

  • At a time when these men would have been shot in any other army been put on a blacklist wasn’t that bad. The fact it’s dragged on for so long is silly.
    Forgive and forget and ask the ones still alive if their ready to fight the Germans again

    Reply
  • Great news this. Proud men of Ireland that should have a lot of recognition for the effort to fight the nazi regime…

    Reply
  • Disgraceful that these people had to wait so long for a “pardon”.

    Reply
  • A bit late

    Reply
  • I wonder if those men were still alive would they accept a pardon from the present government.

    Reply
  • About time. It always troubled me that Ireland stayed out of doing her bit. Many Irish citizens then knew they had to do the right thing. Fair play to them for doing the right thing. As the article indicates, Ireland was a different place back then. Ah, well -

    Reply
  • This is good news.

    Although I have a question. Why has it taken so long? Many of those men fought the good fight against an evil, evil person. The fact that they joined the British army is irrelevant. They (the Allies) defeated Hitler. For that they should have been honoured. Imagine what the world would be like today, if Hitler was allowed to continue doing what he did.

    It’s sad that many of those men will never know that they have been pardoned, but at least it has been done Better late than never I suppose, and maybe their families will take some peace from it.

    Reply
  • They signed up, then they broke their oath and neglected their duties by deserting. Then upon return they were not tried or charged, as they would be any where else but the state did say ” fool me once, shame on you” and decided not to take a chance with them again and left them get on with their lives.

    They got one pardon already, why do they need another?

    Reply
  • i agree Tim. they already got a reprieve by not being arested. by the way, the Irish army has never been conscripted !!! the chose to enter and didn’t get a proper discharge. also, Irish men where specifically allowed to join the British army by the Irish free state treaty so they had a right and a choice from the beginning. Army’s must have a code of discipline, if they don’t, they are not an Army. Shatter is once again engaging in an exercise to keep himself in the papers.

    Reply
  • Fair play to them for fighting for a country that occupied Ireland for hundreds of years.

    Reply
    • They were fighting against German Nazis. WWII wasn’t just England and German war.

      Reply
    • A very narrowminded view to have, Eamonn C. They went out to fight against Nazism & did their best to do the right thing. I understand your sentiment but there are times when a country has to man up & do the right thing. Your sentiment belongs in the past in many respects. Those brave men did the right thing for the common good.

      Reply
    • What did the nazis/Germany ever do on us? The british army and government have done a lot more damage to Ireland?

      Reply
    • Eggfuel 25/01/12 #

      Eamonn
      the germans had a plan to neutralise Ireland using the Connemara area for detention centers for “treatment”

      I think you should realize that we never did any harm on germany but I’m afraid neither did many countries at the time so it has little to do with their agenda…
      How close we came to destruction is not worth thinking about..
      It was because of many fine man and women that we bask in freedom now
      . I respect your views but a fact is a fact and its a fact that we are v lucky as a nation that the allied fought for us….

      Reply
    • Exactly, Eggfuel.

      Reply
  • I have another question. After WWII Ireland granted asylum to ‘war criminals’ in the years after 1945. How could it happen?

    Reply
  • F F and greens to be included ?

    Reply
  • About time too.
    As a Brit, I recall the agonies and horrors my parents / grandparents would tell me about WW2. I could not imagine, added to that, the absolute despair and suffering these brave Irishmen faced when they returned after fighting tyranny and helping to free Europe; to then be faced with victimisation and personal abuse. It beggars belief …. but it was another time with other views!

    Reply

Add New Comment