TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

SIPTU: More than ‘hot air and windy rhetoric’ required for Croke Park agreement

In a strongly-worded statement, the trade union said that they were prepared to go to war with government.

General President of SIPTU, Jack O'Connor (file photo)
General President of SIPTU, Jack O'Connor (file photo)
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

SIPTU HAVE HIT back at the recent protest by the ’24/7 Frontline Service Alliance’, saying that it will take more than “hot air and windy rhetoric in basketball arenas” to reach agreement.

The general president of SIPTU, Jack O’Connor, accepted that members were “justifiably concerned” about the current talks, admitting that some were “doubtful that we should be involved in the talks at all.”

There is a view that bellicose statements and refusal to participate would yield better results.
The fact is that we are facing a government with an overwhelming parliamentary majority which is itself confronted with the most serious economic crisis in our history.
Indeed, the crisis is of such a scale that it actually continues to threaten the very solvency of the State.

Calling on the “hawks on the government side” to acknowledge the reality facing public service workers, the head of SIPTU said that the union’s response to being pushed “into a war” would not be conducted over the airwaves or in sports arenas.

Proposed solution

O’Connor said that a solution to government pay problems existed, and involved a “substantially greater contribution” from the rich in the form of taxation. Based on governments reluctance to implement a wealth tax, however, he said that all sides continued to explore the possibility of a “negotiated settlement.”

Accordingly, our team at the talks are working day and night striving to achieve an outcome that would be better for all the workers employed in the public service than a legislated pay cut or what we could reasonably expect from a protracted industrial battle.
However, failing a reasonable outcome we will actually go to war. We are prepared for it. It will involve protracted strikes and all that goes with them. While we may not win, the Government will not win either.

A deadline of the end of February had originally been set for talks over extending the current Croke Park agreement.

Today’s talks are focusing on premium payments, with government hoping to get agreement on a three-year freeze on increment payments and a commitment that staff will work at least 37 hours a week.

Read: ‘We have no more to give’: Over 3,000 attend Frontline services rally >

Read next:

Comments (85 Comments)

  • Jack O’Connor that hot air and rhetoric you talk about is the fundamentals behind all trade unions, namely defence of the workers rights. It was SIPTU that told Paramedics and FireFighters that they were to insignificant a group to represent. It’s the ICTU that are preventing the groups that actually are effected by the croke park “renegotiation” (a term that is as inaccurate as the Nazis calling concentration camps work camps! ) from participating in the negotiations.
    Mr.O’Connor are you commenting because you are genuinely concerned for frontline workers or are you more annoyed that the frontline staff are stepping out, identifying themselves as unique and vital which hinders your agenda to sacrifice them in favour of your high earning “majority members” civil servants who have grades, who don’t work for premium payments, Sundays or public holidays ironically all the points on the agenda to be sacrificed? I have a feeling it’s the latter

    Reply
  • I presume Jack O’Connor plans to expend more hot air and windy rhetoric than 4,000 people could ever do.

    He has had plenty of years of practice.

    Reply
  • SIPTU, part of the problem, not part of the solution.

    Ultimately we have to accept the the senior civil service salaries and pensions will be preserved and the most vulnerable will suffer.

    Reply
  • Two points.
    1. Why did Jack not remind the Government that the Croke Park Deal runs until this time next year and that the Govt. said it would honour the agreement. Why didnt he go to war when they told him they were reneging
    2. What pain will Jack be taking after he negotiates reductions for others
    “Hot air” Jack dont make me laugh.

    Reply
  • But will we go to war Jack…..I doubt it very much?

    Reply
    • We will and we won’t need I’m alright Jacks approval

      Reply
    • Yep,

      O’Connor has threatened “war” again and again over the past 5 years but never lived up to his word – in spite of significant wage cuts to his union’s members.

      In fact, when Vincent Browne pulled him up on his hypocrisy, he threatened to walk off Browne’s TV show.

      A windbag and the worst possible face of Irish trade unionism. Just when the ordinary Irish people think of protesting against the mindless austerity of the past few years, they look towards union leaders to seek leadership and what they see is Jack O’Connor. Needless to say, they then don’t protest.

      The government, IBEC and their media cheerleaders couldn’t have gotten a better union leader facing them over the past half-decade.

      Reply
    • Two of Siptu’s negioaters are paid up Labour party members.

      Reply
  • Typical labour party member attacking the workers. You’re an embarrassment O’ Connor!!!

    Reply
  • Siptu/jack o Connor, I could go on writing a long message here but ur not worth my time, u know what you and Siptu have done. Sell outs

    Reply
  • First the Labour Party sell out the working class and now the unions have turned into govt lackeys… The inmates have truly taken over the asylum!

    With clowns like him (and highly paid ones at that) at the helm, what chance is there for the working man, Ireland’s new working poor?

    God help us and save us….

    Reply
  • Bought and paid for lap-dog. How much is he in again? Does anyone seriously think that he will rock the boat?Workers should get out of these “unions” and form their own co-ops.

    Reply
    • Good idea. “Bought & paid for lap dog” is right. What does he know what austerity really feels like compared to the low to middle income earners ?

      Reply
    • He was on 125k a year salary in 2009. But he made the ultimate sacrifice at the time and refused a paycut – in case his taking a cut lead to cuts elsewhere and he didn’t want to undermine domestic demand. I wonder has it risen since then? By the same logic he might have suffered a pay rise in his efforts to encourage higher pay for the workers and to stimulate greater demand in the economy.

      To be fair he was on much less than Begg and McClone in 2009.

      Reply
    • €140,000 now

      Reply
  • Well in ready for that war when it comes. I have no choice this next cut will push me over the line and Into poverty. My mortgage will be in arrears and loans not payed so a war as he calls it is all that is left. You can push an Irishman/woman only so far before they push back which many foreign invaders found throughout history and now it’s our own government making those same mistakes.

    Reply
  • All fart and no shit…..

    Reply
  • Traitors the lot of them. Jack the man of the people, paid many times more than the people. He’s due to step down just before Croke park II is agreed (dictated). What does that tell us…

    Reply
  • Incidentally he has no right to be negotiating anything until the current deal is over…2014 !

    Reply
  • Jack o connor do you hear it.Its the sound of Jim Larkin turning in his grave .you’re a sellout mergent

    Reply
  • What is the point in having an agreement when one side does not even fulfil the last agreement?

    Reply
  • Typical pre agreement speak from O Connor the game from SIPTU now is to frighten his members into accepting more of the same talk about war and strikes and worse saying you can’t win before you start this man is negotiation on croake park 2 while croake park 1 still has a year to run he has no mandate from his members to be in these talks he never bothered to consult them he slated the front line union’s who did consult their members Time for SIPTU members to withdraw their subs in mass and stop proping up this extension of the labour party

    Reply
  • The union leadership should be wary of doing the governments dirty work for them. Not saying the don’t have the members best interest at heart but the unions are doing little to resist this failing Austerity policy and agreeing further cuts for the membership will incur the wrath of the members.
    Let the government do what they must do and take the entire blame from the working class.

    Reply
  • What irony in this year the 100th anniversary of a real union leader Jim Larkin and the great lockout . O’Connor and Begg should get out of the arena and and stop regurgitating the governments mantra, And there is another way – the Iceland way.

    Reply
  • While the Dublin Fire Brigade were on all out strike in 1988 and Jack OConnor was their union official from the Federated Workers Union of Ireland, the then Minister for Environment Padraig Flynn told the press that the strike was sorted. Totally untrue. At a general meeting, my late father, fireman Willie Bermingham stood up and proposed that the entire membership of the FWUI march on the Fianna Fail Ard Fheis in the RDS and expose this blatant lie. This proposal brought the striking firemen to their feet in support but poor Jack nearly died. His face drained to pure white and he struggled to dissuade such a march.
    It seems to me that Mr OConnor never really had the courage to defend workers rights but was always a lickarse and lackey to the politicians. Maybe I’m wrong but ask the former Irish Ferries staff.

    Reply
  • Find it interesting that SIPTU have to utter the same lies as spouted by the government whilst some of their members are frontline staff, it’s more than likely related to the fact that their allegiance lies more with the disgraced Labour Party than their members. They have failed to state that those who walked away from the talks were never part of the talks as they’re not part of ICTU. They have failed to state that frontline workers will be cut the most of all public sector workers by agreeing to CHANGING the terms of an agreement that was already made which in some households will amount to €1400 per month. They have failed to state that frontline parents are only getting 29 days per year together as a family inclusive of annual leave not required for childcare reasons due to changes in rosters as implemented by this agreement whilst 9-5 parents get 104 days per year not including annual leave or public holidays including Xmas. SIPTU are failing to tell the whole truth and seem to be singing from the hymn sheet written by the government. Clearly the government are starting to feel the pressure if they need SIPTU to speak out on their behalfs in yet another spin campaign against frontline workers. I guarantee your Labour Party will never allow you go to war SIPTU, the public can see through this facade!

    Reply
  • Jackass siptu in favour of the house tax in bed with labour dont start me horrible dis honest man

    Reply
  • KMart 24/02/13 #

    Siptu + Impact+ICTU= A complete Joke.

    Jack O’Connor = overpaid government puppet.

    Reply
  • What are ministers and union leaders being paid to be in talks on a sunday

    Reply
  • The man, in common with his counterparts at the top of other unions is a bench marking poodle of the highest order

    Reply
  • Siptu leadership collaberators, hang your heads in shame

    Reply
  • What’s scaring front line workers is that some of the cuts been talked about will specifically hit us and not the majority of public service who might be asked to ballot on an agreement and we will be hit again very hard. Why would someone working 9/5 care about shift and extension of duty rates if they don’t do it but which make up a significant percentage of front line staff wages ?

    Reply
  • The comments speak for themselves. Do not underestimate people. People will see through the spins of government and the so called negotiating Unions. Croke park was a deal made untill 2014.

    Reply
  • Attacking frontline protest is self defeating, some of his members are those same frontline staff
    Jack cuts to basic pay reduced the premium pay of your members also, premium pay is based on basic, wake up, frontline were right to protest
    However these comments suggest jacks negotiators aren’t looking after frontline interests , in which case they will have to look at their Siptu membership

    Reply
  • SIPTU, do you have any suggestions and make any pressure to push the government to deal with the core of the problem – the debt? How about burning bondholders, undergoing default and establishing own currency? Or how about raising these ideas with the EU to motivate them to help this country? I am baffled by how many people accept this situation without addressing the core of the problem.

    Reply
    • How would burning bondholders help in controlling our expenditure on on the public service? We’re spending more than we can afford, debt or no debt. This was a problem that was in the pipeline anyway, once the construction sector slowed down and with it, a huge proportion of government income – PAYE from income tax on construction workers; VAT on building materials; stamp duty on houses and all that. nnDisregarding the money we’re borrowing to pay interest on our loans, we’re borrowing to pay social welfare and pay public workers. The government want to reduce this money, so they have to borrow less. nnSetting up our own currency would mean crazy inflation and a worthless Punt, or whatever new currency you want us to use. We rely hugely on exporting products to earn our money, but unfortunately, we import much of the raw materials to make the finish products. A worthless Irish currency would make it hugely expensive to import these materials. nnthe price of oil and therefore energy would go up, making it more expensive again for industry and business. nnThere aren’t any simple solutions. nnn

      Reply
    • SMcB 25/02/13 #

      Does anyone honestly think that the EU gives 2 f**ks about Ireland? The EU have Ireland over a barrel. Lets stop pretending we have options whilst Ireland are still members of the EU.

      Reply
  • “We are prepared for it. It will involve protracted strikes and all that goes with them. While we may not win, the Government will not win either,” says Jack. Brilliant. So everyone will lose. How fantastically stupid but how utterly unsurprising.

    Reply
  • This “negotiation” is a farce. The unions are only there to rubber-stamp the govt line. They were there during the “gravy-train era” doing “tough” negotiating but watch them walk away now when things get a bit hot. Reality is finally here to show them the way, or at least the troika is.

    Reply
  • SIPTU- my arse . Jim Larkin must be spinning in his grave to see his political descendants throwing their lot in with William Martin Murphys political descendants and combining to destroy the pay and working conditions of ordinary workers . Anyone familiar with George Orwell’s ‘animal farm’ will see that the frontline workers are being treated like Charlie the horse who after long loyal service was consigned off to the knackers yard. SIPTU should be ashamed of themselves

    Reply
  • SIPTU leadership are the primary contributors to global warming. It is not just the hot air. The methane emanating from their secondary orifices is a major problem.

    Ask yourself this question. Are these bearded gentlemen inside or outside the circle of privilege?

    The leadership of SIPTU are involved in blatant self protectionism.

    Reply
  • I’m sure jumping jack is on extra expenses for working so hard over the week end.Not just 12 euro for Saturday.

    Reply
  • It’s about time somebody said something ! But he needs to publicly do something that demonstrates to everyone that the unions no longer cosy up to the labour party?

    Reply
  • Could someone who knows the answer explain how the 25 hour week has been operating to date?

    Are these part-time staff? Or is there such a thing as ‘full time’ meaning 5 hours a day in the public sector?

    Reply
  • He’s not even a man he’s a puppet hanging out of the governments strings. He and all of them sold us out a long time ago it’s just now we are standing up to him and the government united as one.

    Reply
  • Retire to rush jack

    Reply
  • was said already and i covers everything two labour ass lickers .and well paid to do the job for gov not the people who they represent,

    Reply
  • Don’t worry Jack most of us know you were one of the fat cats around Bertie’s social partnership table. You and your “partners” of that time got us all into this mess. Most of the rest from that table are gone but the union dinosaur’s.
    do us a favour and do what you think is important. Building a 26 story monument to your and David Beggs greatness. Less we forget what ye did to our country.

    Reply
  • If my name was Jack or O’Conner I would change the name rapid

    Reply
  • Five years ago Paramedics and Firefighters across the country seen the writing on the wall for what was to come. That’s why they left SIPTU to organise independent unions to represent the PROFESSIONALISM of the frontline employee of the National Ambulance Service and the Fire Service. Across this whole country these same professionals have been saying publicly that they believe this is the only way forward and yet to date they sit on their hands and on the fence and still will not commit to the only organisations that will represent their profession and no one elses. Make no mistake the front line services of this country provide a blanket of security and emergency care second to none. Too many front line personnel are involved with MABS, negative equity and the inability to retain a lifestyle of non-poverty. Enough is enough, find your voice, empower yourself instead of the fat cats of SIPTU and withdraw your membership that silences your voice and join NASRA and IFESA the only unions that will say NO, That will fight to protect your pay and conditions and who are neither in bed with the YES party of Fine Gael that’s Labour, or the union that cant hear your voice. When the ballot arrives if you remain in SIPTU you will essentially have no ballot, no voice and no say.

    Reply

Add New Comment