TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Cautious optimism as US senators meet on immigration reform

Republican Senator John McCain told ABC news he was “guardedly optimistic” they can unite on reform.

US Marine Lance Crpl. Benjamin Rodriguez displays his certficate of Citizenship after taking the oath of citizenship
US Marine Lance Crpl. Benjamin Rodriguez displays his certficate of Citizenship after taking the oath of citizenship
Image: Matt York/AP/Press Association Images

BITTERLY DIVIDED US lawmakers have expressed optimism that they could unite on immigration reform that would provide a pathway to citizenship for more than 10 million illegal migrants.

“I’m confident, guardedly optimistic, that this time we can get it done,” Republican Senator John McCain told ABC News, confirming that Republican and Democratic senators had been meeting on the issue in recent weeks.

McCain, who once championed comprehensive reform but backtracked during his failed 2008 presidential run, said there was a greater willingness to address the issue after last year’s election, in which the increasingly important Hispanic vote swung strongly behind President Barack Obama’s Democrats.

“I’ll give you a little straight talk – look at the last election,” McCain, who represents the border state of Arizona, told interviewer Martha Raddatz.

We are losing dramatically the Hispanic vote, which we think should be ours, for a variety of reasons, and we’ve got to understand that.

He added that “we can’t go on forever with 11 million people living in this country in the shadows in an illegal status.

We cannot forever have children who were born here – (or) who were brought here by their parents when they were small children – to live in the shadows as well. So I think the time is right.

Cautiously optimistic

Democratic Senator Robert Menendez of New Jersey, who attended a meeting on Friday between Obama and congressional Hispanic leaders, said he too was “cautiously optimistic.”

“I see the right spirit. I see things that were once off the table for agreement and discussion being on the table with a serious pathway forward,” he told ABC News’ Raddatz.

Obama will travel to the state of Nevada next week to push for rapid immigration reform, one of his top priorities for the next four years.

During the trip, his first since being sworn in last week for a second term, Obama will “redouble the efforts to work with Congress to fix the broken immigration system this year,” the White House said.

A bill backed by Obama that would have legalized the status of many of the estimated 10 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States died in Congress at the end of 2010 because of Republican opposition.

Reforming America’s aging immigration system is the only issue that has generated some degree of political consensus since the November elections.

Hispanics voted massively for Obama, flexing their growing political heft in several key states, and since then Republican leaders and well-known conservative commentators have jumped on the reform bandwagon.

Read: Immigration in Ireland: Approximately 88,000 visa applications received in 2012>

Read next:

Comments (16 Comments)

  • The Irish government has been lobbying the US to permit illegal Irish to become legalized American Citizens for years. However, the Irish government has done nothing to make it easier for Americans who are already living legally in Ireland to become naturalized citizens.

    Why is this? Is tbis fair?

    Reply
    • good enough question, but it’s hardly equivalent is it? And how many Americans are living in Ireland illegally?

      Reply
    • There may not be any illegal Americans in this country. However, the Irish government made it very difficult to get my own citizenship in this country. Though I came to this country with the approval of the government, with highest Visa possible… The difficulty and stress was outrageous.

      I believe if the Irish government want illegal Irish in America granted legal status… Then they should create a restaprosdity program that permits Americans, in good standing, a smooth path to citizenship if they meet minor requirements.

      Reply
    • How would allowing Americans to become citizens turn Ireland into Ethiopia ? They are more than welcome here as far as I am concerned.

      Reply
    • I sympathise, Marlon. I have an American friend going through the same thing. I’d personally make it much easier for you to get citizenship in Ireland, but I don’t see any hypocrisy in Ireland’s government wanting America to legalise its illegal aliens, although it certainly might be wrong. I don’t know why they are pressing for that. Mexico does something similar with Canada – and I can’t figure out why one country uses diplomatic pressure to offload its citizens on another, other than for purely financial reasons.

      Reply
    • Marlon, I’ve been waiting for 12 years to hear this announcement. I’ve not been home to Ireland in all that time.This is the third time legislation has been introduced so I’m still sceptical,(the bill proposes a 5 year probationary period, a huge fine, payment of back taxes and no government benefits for the full probationary period.) They are not just handing out green cards here.

      I know how you feel, hiding in the shadows and feeling like your on the outskirts of society. There is no dole, health insurance, driving liscence, holiday pay or overtime for us; when I’m out of work, I’m out of luck to quote Elvis.

      If the Irish Government supports a path to US citizenship for the likes of me, its because people like me have been begging them to support a bill like this so that we can come home to visit our families.

      I truly hope the good, decent, hardworking foreigners in Ireland get a chance to stay in their adopted country but the Irish governments concern for its native sons and daughters exiled abroad should be respected.

      I wish you all the best sir.

      Reply
    • Last comment was for abby the racist who has not got the guts or the education to spell out her feelings

      Reply
    • I’m not sure Abby… Was your comment an attempt at an insult?

      Reply
    • Adrian… I use to live in Boston for a number of years. I lived in Dorchester and in Southie… Loads of Irish friends legal and illegal. However, my issue isn’t the illegals…. But the double standards of the Irish government. .. Who made it almost impossible to get my Irish citizenship.

      Adrian… I hope every thing you hope for comes your way.

      Reply
    • Great to have you here Marlon, ignore the idiot and her racist comments.

      Reply
    • Abby, I have read your comments today on the journal and I have to say that you are coming across as a ignorant person.

      Reply
    • Thanks Gavan.. There are idiots and racists abound. However, as an optomist I believe that such people will either learn better or get their just desserts. Regardless, people of good nature, character and integrity will always make the difference.

      Thanks again for the welcome!

      Reply
    • @Declan: Yea, I’v noticed her too. She may have something to say with regards to the economic impact immigration, but it’s tainted with racial/ultra nationalist bigotry. So I think her opinions are fueled by hate or lack of humanity.

      She seems to be a simple minded, arrogant, totalitarian racist with a tribal view of the world. I hope she voices more opinions so they can be ripped apart.

      Reply
  • Hey Marlon, sorry but what does restaprosdity mean?

    Reply
  • Enda Kenny supports illegal Irish immigration to the US which is why he speaks highly of sorting out this “issue”.

    An Amnesty would mean they would have no chance to vote against FG in the next election as they would be swept away FOREVER.

    Reply

Add New Comment