TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

White-tailed eagles found poisoned in Co Cork

Two eagles were found poisoned near Glengariff; one of them dead. It’s the twelfth white-tailed eagle to be poisoned since 2007.

The dead white-tailed eagles
The dead white-tailed eagles
Image: Irish White-tailed Sea Eagle reintroduction programme

TWO WHITE-TAILED Sea Eagles have been poisoned in Co Cork – one of them fatally.

The dead female eagle was found on the sea shore near Glengariff, having been released in Killarney National Park, Co Kerry, in August 2010 as part of the reintroduction programme for the species.

The eagle had spent much of last year in south Kerry before moving to the Beara peninsula between Adrigole and Glengarrif in December 2012.

Sadly, on 18 January of this year, the eagle was found by a local man on the water’s edge near Glengariff, having apparently been washed up there. A post-mortem was carried out by staff from the National Parks and Wildlife Service based in Glengarriff at the Regional Veterinary Laboratory of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.

Test results showed that the bird had been poisoned, presumably from eating carrion (a dead animal).

The week before the poisoned eagle was found, another dead eagle was found at Derrynan, near Caherdaniel in Co Kerry, but in this instance it was not possible to determine how it died.

Very serious

Minister for the Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, Jimmy Deenihan, said:

The poisoning of an eagle in County Cork is very serious. Eagles are protected by law, they are majestic birds of prey, and their reintroduction to Ireland is an important and very worthwhile project. My Department is providing any assistance it can to the Gardaí in the investigation of this matter.

Illegal poisoning continues to be a problem for Ireland’s eagle population, Dr Allan Mee, Project Manager of the White-tailed Eagle Reintroduction said.

Last year we lost two birds to poisoning in Mayo and Donegal so this latest loss suggests that the problem hasn’t gone away. Over the last few years we feel we have made good progress in tackling the poisoning problem in Kerry, with the cooperation of the farming organisations and Teagasc, so we are disappointed to lose another bird to poisoning.

“We realise that landowners have in the past used poison to control crows and foxes especially around lambing time. However, we would like to remind people that use of poisons or other substances for the control of foxes and crows is now illegal,” he said.

The Golden Eagle Trust produced and distributed an advice leaflet to all sheep farmers in South Kerry and West Cork in 2011 and 2012, thanks to cooperation from Kerry IFA, ICMSA, Teagasc and the DAFM.

White-tailed Eagles nested in Ireland for the first time in over 100 years in 2012, when a pair laid eggs in a nest in Co Clare. Sadly, this nest failed to hatch a chick – but Dr Mee said hopes are high that 2013 will be the “breakthrough year” for the reintroduction project.

Dr Mee said they know of six pairs that could build nests and breed in Ireland in 2013.

This would be the start of what we hope will be the next and most critical phase of the reintroduction: establishing a small but viable breeding population. As we are no longer releasing birds into the wild it is vital that we now start producing our own chicks in the wild to replace any birds that are lost and maintain the population.

White-tailed eagles found poisoned in Co Cork
1 / 3
  • White-tailed Eagle poisoning

    The clenched talons are an indication of poisoning in the White Tailed Eagle. Photo:Valerie O'Sullivan
  • White-tailed Eagle poisoning

    Two of the dead White-tailed Eagles. Photo:Valerie O'Sullivan/Golden Eagle Trust
  • White-tailed Eagle post-mortem

    Cosme Sanchez, Pathologist at Regional Veterinary Laboratory, Cork. Photo:Golden Eagle Trust

Read: White-tailed eagles killed in Mayo and Donegal>

Read next:

Comments (49 Comments)

  • This is terrible, one step forward two steps back, stunning birds.

    Reply
  • The people who do this are ignorant.
    Shameful act.

    Reply
  • Disgraceful.

    Reply
  • As an Irish citizen, and a Kerry woman living rurally in Kerry I am utterly furious at the lack of respect people have in this country for our natural environment. Farming and other industries must be sustainable and preserve what is left of our natural environment for future generations to come. But sadly this message is not getting through.

    Shame Irish people don’t  care about wildlife as something worth treasuring in its own right- Irish people see our natural environment as something to use and abuse- that’s our psyche. Yes of course there are Irish people who care about wildlife, conserving biodiversity and habitat etc. But the reality is, is that such people are in a minority.

    Gathering or no gathering perhaps the only way for Ireland to wake up is for tourists to start boycotting this country until we start to live up to our green image. We may not give a fig about wildlife but we do care about cash. 

    Reply
    • There are allot more people then you think who care about the natural environment, but the problem is that those people aren’t generally owners or operators of the land. It’s the people that own acres of land around this country that are the ones that need to change their psyche and get involved with conservation.

      Reply
  • This is because some irish farmers are living in a famine era mindset and are just too thick to get their heads around the positive aspects of natural conservation and how they can benefit from it. I’d call it the Healy-Rae gene myself. I come from a rural background by the way.

    Reply
  • Shameful day for Ireland and wildlife. Additionally, Irish whale and dolphin group reported that the dolphins washed up in achill were dumped there by fishermen after becoming entangled in nets. We are one of the worst countries in Europe for wildlife destruction. So much for our ‘green’ image.

    Reply
  • This is very sad. A very bad reflection on Ireland. Any person who deliberately poisons animals or birds should be ashamed of themselves. Such persons should be brought to justice.

    Reply
  • So sad to see this kind of thing happening in this day and age.. Mindset of some people, it just beggars belief. These beautiful animals must of suffered such an agonizing death.. Their talons curled in pain..

    Reply
  • Don’t people have to sign when purchasing poison ? Can’t this be traced back to place of purchase ?

    Reply
  • We spent a week watching these birds in Derrynane and have photos of them feeding on freshly caught fish. Very sad to hear they are dead

    Reply
  • This is a sad comment on the values of Ireland as a nation !
    These poisoners are known in their communities ,they should be outed ,dragged through the courts and do prison time!o

    Reply
  • Shame on WHOEVER did that disgusting!!!!!!!!!

    Reply
  • I had watched this project through media and internet etc over the last few years. RTE did a very good documentary about it a few years back. These birds were given to us by the Norwegian Government on behalf of the Norwegian people as a mark of friendship and elements of our shared history. A huge amount of time, effort, expertise, and dedication along with a not insignificant amount of money went into trying to ensure that this project succeeded. It was a personal quest for some involved who asked for very little in return and was staffed by a lot of volunteers….. Nice to see some gombeen farmer can just piss away a fairly huge international effort just because he’s a f*ckin moron! If you have a fox problem get a shotgun and spend some time and effort in plugging the bastard yourself! Same with magpies or grey crows. No excuse for poisoning! They’ve all been well warned! Catch the bastards and tear them to shreds as an example to the rest! Start with criminal proceedings then remove every grant available and increase inspections on their farms! A poison amnesty shud be called to to ensure there are no stocks left lieing around on farms from before the ban.

    Reply
  • Farmers and Greed, come before Nature again. We are a plague on this planet, all for the mighty money!

    Reply
  • So sad, it’s spectacular to see these animals! They are so majestic! America’s Bald eagle have returned from the brink of extinction to the point where they can be seen over the Hudson River near Manhattan. Hopefully Ireland will enjoy these amazing creatures to some day.

    Reply
  • Very sad to see this, such a fabulous bird.. harsh penalties for those responsible, poisoning the land is not the answer..

    Reply
  • Big ignorant poxy stupid farmers.

    Reply
  • A selfish gombeen healey-rae-mindest farmer strikes again. I called out the previous government in The Indo a few years ago, saying the government was an ass.
    A mate found a deliberate raptor trap up north, reported it, and the farmer got little more than a scolding.
    Meanwhile, neighbouring Mid-Wales tourism thrives because of their birds of prey.
    I’ve spent a good bit of time in the fjords of Norway photographing golden and white-tailed eagles. They are truly majestic. Tourists pay a lot of money to legally get within 20 yards in a supervised manner. It brings business to rural areas … if selfish tossers like this are dealt with, if the birds are allowed to settle, and if the program managers play it right.
    The organisers message is education. As an educator of sorts, I can say many are willing to learn, but some people like to sit in their hovels if ignorance and greed. There’s only two ways to deal with people like this: punish them or play to their greed. Seminars and leaflets won’t cut it.

    Reply
  • Harry C 06/02/13 #

    Ireland belongs to all the Irish people and not just the farmers. I hope the full rigour of the law is brought to bear on these selfish, ” don’t fly over my farm” pigs.

    Reply
  • Most of these birds are being poisoned with Nitroxynil (Trodax). It is used as a flukicide in cattle but some farmers use it to lace sheep carcasses to try to kill foxes. Instead however it kills the eagles and any other animals that ingest the poisoned carcass – they are collateral damage.

    Reply
    • @deidre.

      Eagles are being poisoned either by poor (and illegal) farming practices ( collatoral damage as you put it) or deliberately poisened by those who hold the mistaken ignorant belief that eagles kill lambs ( as indicated by local protests when eagles were reintroduced). Various interviews amongst farmers, portrayed in media indicate that there is a mixed view amongst farmers regarding the reintroduction of the white tailed eagle. Personally i have also heard these mixed views amongst local community.
      Regardless of whether the eagles are being killed through poor farming practices or deliberately, both acts are illegal. There needs to be stricter application of law, more thorough investigations and tougher punishments.
      We need to practice what we preach/ claim and be a ‘green country’.

      Furthermore, these eagles are part of our national heritage. They were wiped out by 1898 by landed gentry. It is up to everyone now to ensure this does not happen again. it is a criminal offence to kill these birds through illegal poisoning end of ( whether the poison was meant for the eagle or not). No farmer has the right to threaten our national heritage.

      Reply
    • Irene, I am not trying to excuse poisoning these birds. The opposite in fact. I am just stating the facts of the case. I agree that we should be protecting these species and indeed all wildlife, foxes included. I am just making the point that some people putting down Trodax do not realise the consequences of their actions. They think that by putting down the poison, they will kill the foxes who are killing their lambs. However, this drug is not species specific- it will kill more than foxes. As a vet, in the past 6 months we have seen 3 fatalities caused by Nitoxynil poisoning in dogs and I know that this is becoming a common occurrence in veterinary clinic throughout the country.

      Reply
  • Ahhh, yes.

    The Irish farmer … “Guardian of the countryside” … “Nature’s best friend” … “Defender of traditional ways” … blah, blah, blah.

    Reply
  • dominic 05/02/13 #

    Too many bog ignorant land and animal owners whose eyes are fixed only on the euro and any subsidy they can get.They surely would not recognise a wild flower,the few that remain,or a beauteous bird in flight.Sad that the stewardship of our countryside is in the hands of environmentally ignorant, tunnel visioned cute hoors and fools.

    Reply
  • @ joe

    Did you mean to say, this was ‘no’ accident?

    Reply
  • stephen 06/02/13 #

    Bring on the karma , you can’t poison a sentient being unless your a psychopath

    Reply
  • In this case it’s possible that this may have occured by mistake ;(

    Reply
  • Just because the eagle was from Kerry – this is taking the inter county thing a bit too far?

    Reply
  • Must be a more sporting way to reduce foxes if they truly are a threat to lambs. Western ranchers in the us are compensated for wolf kills.

    Reply
    • Farmers are already subsidised quite well by europe. It should not be up to any farmer to cull wildlife as they see fit. when they do… Well read the article, you can see for yourself. Neanderthal cowboy mentality is not an appropriate means by which farming and biodiversity can coexist.

      Impact of wildlife on farming and visa versa must be monitored and maintained by appropriate, trained personnell. Not cowboy farmers. Besides weaponry is not condoned here.

      Reply
    • Irene our ranchers are not neanderthals. A wolf is a completely different animal compared to a magpie or fox! Wolves were reestablished to the west but at a compromise that a rancher can shoot an animal that attacks his livestock. I’m simply saying there must be a better way to control fox numbers then poison. “Cowboys”, your funny!

      Reply
  • Should probably get our chicken mcnuggets analysed so.

    Reply

Add New Comment