We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
JUSTICE MINISTER FRANCES Fitzgerald has said she has confidence in the board members of the Garda Ombudsman (GSOC) despite the publication of a report which finds no evidence to back claims that their offices were placed under surveillance.
She also said that the report published tonight will be “food for thought” for those who engaged in “heated discussion” at the time the bugging controversy arose when her predecessor Alan Shatter was still in office.
She was speaking after the publication of the report by retired High Court judge John Cooke into allegations that the headquarters of GSOC were bugged.
The report found no evidence to support the proposition that the offices of the Garda Ombudsman were placed under surveillance and much less that it was carried out by members of An Garda Siochána.
https://vine.co/v/MjMTElnvLYQ
Acting on the recommendations of the report, Fitzgerald said that the new bill to reform the workings of GSOC will clarify the legal basis under which it can initiate a public interest investigation as well as the threshold for such probes.
Fitzgerald noted that the report understood the concerns of GSOC members and that they acted in good faith.
“I do have confidence in the board of GSOC. GSOC are an important body,” she said.
The Minister said it was important to remember that there are “no findings of negligence or no finding of facts” against the members of the Ombudsman Commission.
On whether the report was vindication for her predecessor Alan Shatter, who said there was “no evidence at all” that GSOC was bugged at the height of the controversy in February, Fitzgerald said the document provides “food for thought”.
She said: “This report would give food for thought in relation to the way comments… there was very heated discussion at the time, as you remember. And certainly I would say we now have an evidence based report and I think everybody who made comment at the time should analyse this report and review how they reacted to it at the time. “
Fitzgerald said that the report underlined the need for “a new culture of cooperation” between GSOC and the gardaí, saying: ”The basic goal is clearly that there is confidence in the structures that are there, that’s critical – that confidence is built.”
She said it was “extremely important for justice in this country” that there is confidence in GSOC and the gardaí.
Hugh O'Connell / TwitterGSOC: We’ve just downloaded report by Judge Cooke following his Inquiry. We’re reading it now and will make a statement as soon as possible
— Hugh O'Connell (@oconnellhugh) June 10, 2014
Asked about the fact that GSOC has only just received a copy of the report, Fitzgerald insisted that the organisation was given it at “the appropriate time”.
The Minister also thanked the retired judge for the “very comprehensive, measured and evidence-based report”.
In the first opposition reaction, Fianna Fáil called for the judge to go before the Oireachtas Justice Committee to discuss his findings.
“Instead of relying on Government spin, I believe we now need to give Mr Justice Cooke an opportunity to present his report to the all-party Oireachtas Committee on Justice,” the party’s justice spokesperson Niall Collins said.
“This will allow a full and open examination of the findings and recommendations and a frank discussion of the process.”
She should be worried about her own critics instead of law breaking Shatters
Shatter was vindicated, so what? He was still found to be unworthy of holding political office.
He was in his hole vindicated. He may have been shown to be correct about some assumptions he made but he shouldn’t have made them in the first place!
I totally agree Mart but from a FG perspective they consider it a vindication.
All this statement is about is setting it up so Shatter can be brought back in from the cold by Kenny.
She’s turned out to be exactly what I expected – another Kenny loyalist who won’t rock the boat in her new ministry. Just what we needed (!!!)
At least she’s transparent. The rehab for Shatter number is so blatant
Exactly, the report in no way vindicates Shatter, still very inconclusive, yet she jumps to his aid unnecessarily, more of the same, party before people. Shame on you Fitzgerald.
It is food for thought about Shatter. If GSOC trusted him they would have gone straight to him or Callinan (just like the whistleblowers would have). It further justifies Shatter’s resignation and Callinan’s pretend resignation.
something that should be clarified Callinan was sacked
Whatever the outcome of the report I for one am still smiling at the fact that that Shatter creep is gone and in such a humiliating fashion. Arrogant f##k whit told so many porkys along the way I’d say he was surprised at the outcome himself.
What else can she say, she is just another yes woman for Kenny, Claire Byrne looked like she was afraid of her on prime time tonight, or maybe she is a FG supporter.
Cabinet reshuffle
Shatter back, all is forgiven
After all, we Irish have the memorys of goldfish with bad memorys.
Angela Kerins seems to be struggling a bit in the new job as a podium prepper; though must relish being behind the microphone these days rather than in front of it.
Enda must be upset having to give one of his trusted lieutenants the heave. Just goes to show what arrogance brings.
have your say