TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 5 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Filmmaker questioned as protests continue over anti-Islamic movie

Meanwhile, Al Qaeda has called for more attacks on US embassies.

Afghans burn an effigy of U.S. President Barack Obama
Afghans burn an effigy of U.S. President Barack Obama
Image: Nashanuddin Khan/AP/Press Association Images

A MAN LINKED to the film that has sparked massive global protests by Muslims has been questioned but not arrested, US authorities have said.

Fifty-five-year-old Nakoula Bassely Nakoula was interviewed at a Los Angeles sheriff’s station but was not detained.

Nakoula has previously been convicted of financial crimes and, as part of his sentence, he was banned from using computers or the Internet. Officers are now examining whether he broke the rules of his probation.

It is understood that the film itself does not violate any American laws.

Federal authorities in the US have identified Nakoula, a self-described Coptic Christian, as the key figure behind ‘Innocence of Muslims’, a film denigrating Islam and the Prophet Muhammad that ignited mob violence against US embassies across the Middle East. It has also sparked protests in London and Sydney.

The 14-minute trailer for the film depicts the prophet Mohammad as a womaniser, a child molester and general buffoon. It was first uploaded to YouTube in June but was later translated into Arabic in the week before the 11 September anniversary.

US website Gawker has interviewed members of the cast of “Innocence of Muslims,” who say they were duped into appearing in what they thought was a fictional epic, only to discover their lines had been dubbed over with anti-Muslim propaganda. It also was named the film’s director as 65-year-old Alan Roberts.

Violent protests set off by the film in Libya played a role in mob attacks in Benghazi that killed US Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other American officials. US Embassy gates in Cairo were breached by protesters and demonstrations against American missions spread to Yemen on Thursday and on Friday to several other countries.

Meanwhile, Al Qaeda’s branch in Yemen has praised the killing of Stevens and has called for more attacks. In a statement published online, the terrorist group encouraged more assaults to expel American embassies from Muslim nations.

Protests continued in Egypt, Afghanistan and Pakistan today with massive anti-American sentiments.

Filmmaker questioned as protests continue over anti-Islamic movie
1 / 8
  • Afghanistan

    Afghans shout anti-US slogans in the city of Jalalabad, east of Kabul, Afghanistan today during a protest against an anti-Islam film which depicts the Prophet Muhammad as a fraud, a womanizer and a madman. (AP Photo/Rahmat Gul)
  • Afghanistan

    Afghans burn an effigy of US President Barack Obama during a protest in Khost, south-east of Kabul, Afghanistan today. A few hundred university students protested against an anti-Islam film which depicts the Prophet Muhammad as a fraud, a womanizer and a madman. (AP Photo/Nashanuddin Khan)
  • Pakistan

    Pakistani traders burn a representation of a US flag next to burning tires during a rally in Islamabad, Pakistan today. (AP Photo/Anjum Naveed)
  • Pakistan

    The banner at bottom reads, "'immediately hang the cursed man indulged in insulting the Prophet," while the banner at top left reads, "Oh blasphemer! Listen we are after your life," and the banner at top, second left reads,"we urge the government to stop US interference in the Pakistan." (AP Photo/Anjum Naveed)
  • Pakistan

    Supporters of a Pakistani religious group Fidaiyan-e-Khatim-e-Nabuwwat hold a demonstration in Karachi, Pakistan as part of widespread anger across the Muslim world about a film ridiculing Islam's Prophet Muhammad. (AP Photo/Fareed Khan)
  • Pakistan

    (AP Photo/Fareed Khan)
  • Pakistan

    Supporters of a Insaf Student Federation burn an effigy of US President Barack Obama. (AP Photo/Fareed Khan)
  • Afghanistan

    (AP Photo/Rahmat Gul)

-Additional reporting by AP and AFP

Earlier: Anti-Islam film protests spread to Australia>

Read next:

Comments (49 Comments)

  • I respect every religion but what this people are doing is just wrong, you just cannot kill people and burn a entire building because of a film, the people inside those buildings were workers.

    • I just cannot get my mind to go back 2000 years to the thinking of these ‘religious’ murderers…… Ohhh this is religion? That peaceful, love all crap? To me, it’s in each individuals heart…. You believe in God or not…. Simple…. Just my opinion….

    • Why do you respect them when they have no respect for those who choose not to?

    • Why? I respect religious beliefs as much as I respect homophobic or racist beliefs! I find religion offensive and insult to our intelligence. No intention of burning down mosques anytime soon though. Freedom of speech is important. Even if it’s offensive! If someone isn’t allowed say something because Muslims will run amok then my right to hear that something (even if it offends me) has been taken from me.

  • Im not religious at all but, If your faith is so fragile a crap film can damage it, well then it’s no faith at all.

  • There believes don’t suit the western world but it will all come to ahead at some stage our believes of lack of
    them don’t suit there way of life and with islam being the fastest growing faith in the world something has got to give.

    • Its not looking good. Thousands upon thousands in several countries screaming for the death of all of us. All over a dopey film. I have nothing left but contempt for these people. A storm is coming I fear.

    • Think for a minute, Adrian.
      This film is like a last straw following a century of colonisation, support of sectarian regimes like the Saudis(source of the fundamentalist sectarian bigotry behind al CIAda set up by the US to sabotage soviet support for a mildly socialist/progressive Kabul regime which was actually doing what America now claims to be doing in Afghanistan).
      Since 9/11 the ‘coalition of the willing’ has hijacked the UN and run a raft of wars from Pakistan to Libya and ongoing…all in the name of a spurious democracy while ‘democratic’ Israel continues its repression in Palestine with a nuclear green light despite non-compliance with non-proliferation but non-nuclear(as yet) but compliant Iran is pilloried and demonised in preparation for Tel Aviv driven invasion which will leave it in a similar mess to Iraq.
      Lots of ignorant knee-jerk rants running…and not a little provocateur deliberate disinformation smearing.
      First lose your contempt…thats exactly what the propaganda is designed to stir. Now watch the contemptuous red-thumbs. Think oil, think blocking China and Russia, and think of the profits being made by the likes of Halliburton, who rose from the ashes of Vietnamese napalm to install Cheyney&Co for just this scenario. The details are there to be found if you care to do a little searching. Its called the business of war. You could start with googling Smedley Butler and his book ‘War is a Racket’. But don’t tell anyone.

  • I’m a firm believer that people are people. I’m pretty sure the majority of Muslims are like your average Christian or Jew – they believe what they believe and they are happy to talk about it, but generally don’t force it on others.

    Sadly in every one of these religions (and no doubt other religions or lack thereof) there are extremist elements who get the most attention and make all of their bretheren look terrible. I believe it’s called the spotlight fallacy..

    Having said that, it would certainly benefit some religious groups to work on their sense of humour, in a world of free speech everyone becomes the butt of the joke at some point, how you respond determines how much more jokes and taunts you will receive.

    • Well written. I completely agree

    • I disagree, when the Life of Brian was made Christians obviously protested, but they didn’t go storming embassies and murdering people, on an almost weekly basis you will see violent protests by members of one religion for frivolous reasons. And while it may be a minority of Muslims involved in these protests, you rarely hear the moderate ones condemning the violence, their silence speaks volumes.

    • Although there does appear to be a higher percentage of mad eegits in the Muslim faith. Higher even that the mad eegit bible thumpers in the southern states of the US. Its sad also that there will never be reasoning with the extremists of any religion.

      Religion! So many have been killed or murdered because of this concept.

    • The life of Brian was sattire. The film thats pissed of the arab world was not sattire. It was nothing but insult and mockery. I don’t think its fair to compare the two.

      Having said that the response is ridiculous. It’s sad to see so many still held in the dark by organised religion.

    • So nobody here has seen Family Guy…
      Black Jesus;
      Jesus & Chris Tucker with the weed

      Yep. Apparently that was our queue to riot.

  • They get annoyed over a film but have no problem flying planes into buildings and murdering foreign diplomats…….go figure.

  • Let’s go and burn down the offices of channel 4 and stab all the cast of Father Ted for disrespecting our religion! The entire Muslim world needs to sit down and watch an episode of Ted

  • If they hate they west so much why don’t they go back to the middle east, but they will take the west’s money quick enough

  • Anyone in the Muslim world ever heard the phrase Don’t feed the trolls? The film maker wanted this response and like trained seals they delivered. Stupidity on both sides. Deliberately provoking and being so easily provoked.

    • On the button..the embassies are being burned by al CIAda nutjobs..raised by Uncle Sam for ulterior motives in the region, and fed by Israel because Bibi’s nose is out of joint that Obambi is not as tame as Mitt the Tea-Bag man. They are mad anxious for a little ‘change’ in the white house…and straining to get the green-light for a Teheran strike.
      Obama is being damned awkward, not kosher.

      Dirty tricks and false flag country.
      And, wittingly or otherwise, most of our media are embedded to their press-release fed eyeballs. And the European Right is as complicit in this propaganda hate-drive as the evangelical yanks. Anti-Islam is the new anti-semitism. Same pattern, same program, different flags and wavers.

  • Religion is a shackle on the mind. Religion with lack of education and poverty allows people to convince themselves that it’s ok to treat others like this. The creator of this film is a radical Christian who is equally as bad as those he has infuriated.

  • Framing is everything. These ain’t getting much coverage:

    15 Photos Of Libyans Apologizing To Americans

    Pakistan’s Day of Moderate Disapproval

    Less sensational, I guess. Important to remember these are a tiny minority of Muslims – the religious far-right or Salafists. They don’t represent Islam.

  • Mjhint 16/09/12 #

    Islam maybe the fastest growing faith but these religions are now being challenged by free thinkers even in islamic countries. Islam like christianity can only grow so far. Its running out steam. The internet will stop it in its tracks. I cannot see islam overtaking this country. We have been bitten too badly by religion here.

  • I just wonder why the URL of this article is al-qaeda-attacks-us-embassy. It’s says nowhere in this article that they were actually behind the attack on the US embassy in Libya. And, I con’t find any conclusive evidence anywhere else that they were behind it. The whole matter is still under investigation.

  • You forgot to mention that before his financial fraud conviction he was convicted of cooking meth…

    • Not really relevant, it’s the disproportionate response that matters here, not the film makers history

    • Actually Gordan, this article is about the filmmaker. The fanatical response has been covered in numerous other articles.

    • Forget this particular article, the whole situation is what I’m talking about. The finer details of his past are irrelevant to the bigger ongoing picture. Oh and you may spell my name correctly if you feel the need to type it…

    • I left a comment in relation to this article. If you want to see my opinion on the protests check out my comments on the other articles.

    • No thanks

    • @Gordon
      Responding to someone’s comment by telling them to forget about the article… A bit unfair, don’t you think?

    • @Gordon
      Responding to someone’s comment by telling them to forget about the article… A bit unfair, don’t you think?

    • No Michael, I don’t, not in this instance anyway. I really don’t think the filmmakers history is in any way relevant, and it’s not really Barry’s comment that I was taking about, well, to an extent, but the article itself.

    • Gordon, if you don’t think the article is relevant then take that up with the journal staff. No need to criticise me for commenting on the subject of the article. The protests and murders have been discussed in other
      many other articles here.

    • Jesus Barry let it go! It wasn’t criticism, just a point in general. Don’t take it so seriously. I won’t dare comment against you in the future, I’ve noticed you’re other contributions in the past and you seem to be very full of self importance and take yourself very seriously! Later!

    • Feel free to comment in order to discuss or debate any points I make here. There’s plenty of times where my views have changed due to insightful replies to comments I make here. It’s what I enjoy about the journal. I just don’t like being criticised for adding a point I saw on many other websites that was omitted here.

    • Again, it wasn’t a criticism, not in my mind, just a quick reactionary reply. Also, a reminder of something you already know – on forums you will receive criticism, whether you like it or not. I didn’t mean to stir, offend or annoy. Can we move on now?

  • Fight fire with fire

  • But we should talk it out first, right??

  • Do you realise the irony in what you just said?