TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

#Áras11: The Monday question for Presidential candidates

Each day this week, TheJournal.ie will be hosting Tell Us Why’s question campaign for clarity on the seven candidates’ priorities. Today: why they think they deserve to be President.

Gay Mitchell and Martin McGuinness mull something over at today's Inclusion Ireland debate
Gay Mitchell and Martin McGuinness mull something over at today's Inclusion Ireland debate
Image: Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland

THE VOLUNTEER INFORMATION group TellUsWhy.ie has asked each of the Presidential candidates a question for each day of this week to discern their priorities for the office.

TheJournal.ie is hosting the question – and answers – each day.

Question 1:

What one personal experience or achievement do you feel qualifies you, as opposed to any other, to be the President of Ireland?

David Norris:

I am the only candidate who has actually used the Constitution to help protect a marginalised minority. I have established businesses that created employment and set up counselling services to help people in need. All my life I have stood in solidarity with the marginalised and protected the human rights of children and adults. None of my opponents can offer what I offer in terms of my track record.

Mary Davis:

Of all the candidates who are standing for the presidency, I am the only completely independent candidate, having never been a member of a political party. My earnings and the positions I have held are in the public domain and on my website. I have nothing to hide.

Furthermore, I am the only candidate who has direct experience working with president of the day, providing constructive constitutional advisement through my position on the Council of State. In terms of international experience, for the last 25 years I have been involved in a leadership capacity for a large social enterprise working across 180 countries. I have sat across from EU representatives and negotiated
a better future for people with disabilities.

I believe the presidency belongs to the people. I am not a celebrity or a politician. My life’s work has always been in the service of others.

Michael D Higgins:

My personal journey from small farm to factory worker to clerk to teacher to womens rights and social justice campaigner to public representative has taken me through many aspects of Irish life and I think given me a certain compassion and understanding.

In terms of achievements I would probably cite my experience as Ireland’s first Minister for the Arts in 1993-97, which proved that I was not merely someone who expressed aspirations for change, but someone who could deliver practical and imaginative transformation, often in the face of strong opposition.

In just five years as Minister, I moved Irish film from an 11 million industry into one worth 186 million – it is now worth €390 million last year and provides 1,695 fulltime jobs. I joined up our waterways with the result that  Ireland now has over 1000 kilometres of navigable waterways, supporting employment and tourism in many rural and remote areas of the country; I removed the censorship of Section 31 of the Broadcasting Acts, and contributed to the emerging Peace by allowing the voices if all to be heard by all.

I established TG4 supporting the democratic rights of those many citizens who wish to raise their children in the Irish language and I also established a network of local arts venues right across Ireland to support greater access to creativity for every citizen.

I see the same potential today and will bring the same vision and practicality to the very different opportunities offered by the Presidency.

Martin McGuinness:

What I have to offer the people of Ireland is leadership, experience, a vision for the future which is based on equality and the rights of citizens and my willingness to stand with the people at this time of grave economic peril.

Gay Mitchell:

My international experience in Europe means I have more contacts than any other candidate among world policy makers, so I can get worldwide access for this state. I am the only candidate who has been elected to an international post – as an MEP. While my colleagues in the race have national experience, or international experience in one or two countries, I have international experience across 27 EU states and beyond, and that is what will deliver benefits to Ireland.

Seán Gallagher:

Electing a President with a proven track record in enterprise and job creation sends a very clear message to the country and also internationally that Ireland is open for business. My experience in farming, youth and community work as well as enterprise gives me a unique perspective. I am young and energetic and I know that I can make a positive contribution. This is not about me, it is about the challenges faced by our country and how we can put our strengths to work to overcome these challenges.

Dana Rosemary Scallon: Failed to return an answer to the question.

Question No. 2 will be answered tomorrow morning: “Past presidents have had a main focus while in office (eg Mary Robinson and human rights). What would be your main priority as President? Why do you feel that you need to become the President of Ireland to pursue this cause?”

Read TheJournal.ie’s coverage of the Race for the Áras>

Read next:

Comments (25 Comments)

  • Can one of the questions to the candidates be what they think of the two constitutional referendums which the media are almost completely ignoring at the moment?

    Reply
    • Hi Mark, You might find Susan Ryan’s explainer read to the referenda at the weekend interesting… http://www.thejournal.ie/what-are-the-two-referendums-about-your-guide-to-the-27-october-ballot-250697-Oct2011/

      Reply
    • Hi Susan,
      Thanks, I’ve read that and others over the last few weeks and I think I’m fairly up to speed on them.
      But this is about the candidates, not the referendums – what I’m interested in seeing from the candidates is what they know about the proposed referendums and what their opinions on their merits are – given that these are amendments to the Constitution, which they ought to be au fait with at least!

      It would also be interesting, for the same reason, to hear their thoughts on the the changes being talked about for the Constitutional Convention next year such as abolishing the Seanad, and maybe what they would like to see changed in the Constitution if they had carte blanche to change it – would they like to see direct democracy brought in? Would they want to see the Seanad abolished or the Oireachtas changed in other ways? Would they like to see the party whip system made unconstitutional (as it is in Germany) so that the Dail would have more control over the Cabinet? And so on. The only real powers of the President relate to the constitution (rejecting bills has to be done by the President on grounds of constitutionality), so I think these questions get to the meat of how suited they would be to the role.

      Reply
    • Dario Fo 18/10/11 #

      Mark, run yourself and talk about real issues..

      Reply
  • Dana is still trying to think of something decent to say.

    Reply
  • Oh Dana you’re such a tease!

    Reply
  • Can we remind the candidates, especially Norris, hat we are not all idiots and harping on about creating jobs, fixing the economy, protecting the constitution from the evil governments/EU/IMF/anybody else with a view and protecting the poor etc. is not part of their job description. Instead, would you ask them to stop talking a load of nonsense and speak about things they can actually do such.

    Christ almighty is it any wonder why people are fed up with the election. Fianna Fail took us for mugs for years, we finally booted them out and now we have a selection of candidates and some think that we are stupid enough to think they can fix all our problems and be the sun, moon and stars for us for years to come.

    Reply
    • Conor 17/10/11 #

      Article 26 means that protecting the constitution is arguably the most important power the president has. Instead of a citizen or group having to take an expensive court case to prove that an act of the Oireachtas is unconstitutional, the president can challenge it before it becomes law. All the more reason we need an independent president in the Áras.

      Reply
    • The Constitution is open to a variety of interpretations, be they literal, historical, liberal or indeed downright creative. All of the candidates have the protection of the Constitution in mind, but not necessarily in “the permafrost of 1937″. Except for Dana.

      Reply
  • Dana didn’t answer cause her legal team are trying to sue any person who asks her any questions,
    Don’t you know she’s exempt from any questions except the questions she permits you to ask her,
    How dare anyone ask her any questions in her presidential campaign, I believe in God and that should be enough for this god fearing nation now anymore questions and you’ll feel the full force of my legal team :D

    Reply
  • I’m not sure how SG’s farming experience will help in the Aras because according to his own website at age 21 he bought a farm of under 20 acres but couldn’t afford any animals so instead he painted farmers sheds and fences. He received a cow as payment but his farming career was prematurely ended following a car accident!!!!

    Reply
  • Looks like a dragon as a president God help us is there nobody in the race with any pedigree?
    I see Gallagher received nearly a million from enterprise Ireland.
    We live in a country where some people have no heat others are hungry while a lot have no light and SG gets 160,000 to pay for patents last year. Someone has got to be arrested for this corruption.

    Reply
  • Bazza 17/10/11 #

    SG > "proven track record in Enterprise" …. Ehhh, where exactly Sean ?????
    One business opened and an appearance on telly ????

    Lets talk about the funding Sean ??

    Lets talk about the property development on the Cooley Pennisula Sean ???

    Reply
    • CMD 17/10/11 #

      Co Louth got 100 jobs for round about 1000e investment. (20k grant less 19k repaid). Not bad value for money! Never mind the tax n RSI these 100 people all contributed to the exchequer. I call that inspirational enough. As for Cooley, he’s not the only investor to have bought land in the good times n r now left with something of a white elephant. I wouldn’t hold that against him. At least he had the guts to try. He wasn’t cocooned in a cushy government job paid for by the tax payer in some form or other like the majority of the other candidates.

      Reply
    • AH no sure God love poor Sean G . He knew nothing.He was only part of the FF National exec ….. He is as much an independent as Gay Mitchell, I am amazed at how gullible people in this country are.

      Reply
    • @CMD – I never quite understood how a mere 20K (or 1K he never bothered paying back) was able to create 100 jobs.

      Reply
    • It is the miracle of the loaves and the fishes or just another fairy tale …..

      Reply
    • How many jobs have u created Bazza??

      Reply
    • Bazza 17/10/11 #

      Thats none of your business Thomas,
      oh and theres one small difference….

      I’m not a candidate for Uachtarán na hEireann and trying to fool the electorate by building some fiction around being an ‘entrepreneur’

      Honesty and credibility count for a lot with me Thomas, where do you stand on those qualities ????

      Reply
    • Well Bazza I only asked…and as you didn’t seem too impressed with Sean Gallaghers performance I thought you were going to impress us all with some great feat of employment….You’ve been going on so much about lightweight and blah!! What candidate do you think has the answers??

      Reply
  • Jesus these candidates are woeful.

    Reply
  • David Norris protecting human rights of children, what a joke. Remember Isreal?

    Reply
  • I can confirm that Martin was thinking about giving Gay a big hug, cause he felt that he was looking a bit glum.

    Reply

Add New Comment