TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Argentina accuses UK of sending nuclear sub to Falkland Islands

Argentina says Britain has deployed a nuclear sub, the Vanguard, to guard the islands; Britain has refused to comment.

"Malvinas we will get back with power of the people" - a protester sprays graffiti outside Britain's embassy in Buenos Aires.
Image: Natacha Pisarenko/AP

ARGENTINA INSISTS it has information that Britain sent a nuclear-armed submarine to the South Atlantic near the disputed Falkland Islands, in the latest verbal salvo in a dispute over the territory.

Argentina’s foreign minister Hector Timerman told reporters at the United Nations that a submarine called the Vanguard with nuclear weapons was recently sent as part of Britain’s deployment in the Falklands, which Argentina calls the Malvinas.

HMS Vanguard is one of four British submarines armed with nuclear missiles.

“Argentina has information that within the framework of the recent British deployment in the Malvinas Islands they sent a nuclear submarine … to transport nuclear weapons to the South Atlantic,” said Timerman.

He said Argentina asked the United Kingdom through diplomatic channels if it had introduced nuclear weapons to the South Atlantic, but “thus far, the UK refuses to say whether it’s true or not.”

He said the deployment of nuclear arms in the region would violate the Treaty of Tlatelolco for the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons in Latin America and the Caribbean, designed to create a nuclear-free zone in the region.

Britain’s UN Ambassador Mark Lyall Grant said later at his own news conference responding to Timerman: “We do not comment on the disposition of nuclear weapons, submarines”.

“I don’t know how he knows about submarines,” he added. “I certainly don’t know. The whole point of nuclear submarines is that they go all around the world and you don’t know where they are. That’s why they’re a deterrent.”

As for the treaty, Lyall Grant said that there would be no violation as long as nuclear submarines stayed out of Argentine waters.

Anniversary

Argentina and Britain fought a war over the islands that killed more than 900 people in 1982. With the approach of the 30th anniversary of the start of that conflict, which began when Argentina invaded on April 2, tensions have risen between the countries over the status of the British overseas territory.

Argentina claims the islands they call Malvinas, as well as the British-held South Georgia and South Sandwich islands, farther off its coast. At stake are not only the islands themselves — where sheep far outnumber people — but rich fishing grounds and potential undersea gas and oil in the surrounding seas.

Timerman said Argentina accepted an offer from Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to mediate with Britain. Lyall Grant said there’s nothing to negotiate, because the Falklanders have now been there for nine generations and don’t want change.

Britain’s defence and foreign ministries also refused to discuss Timerman’s claim about nuclear weapons, citing long-standing government policy not to comment on the deployment or movements of the country’s submarines.

Britain’s navy has 11 nuclear-powered submarines, seven armed with conventional weapons, including Tomahawk missiles, and four that carry Trident nuclear missiles, which can deliver warheads more than 4,000 miles (6,400 kilometers).

“We are not looking to increase the rhetoric. We have not started a war of words.” said Lyall Grant. “But clearly if there is an attempt to take an advantage of the 30th anniversary of the Falklands War, we will obviously defend our position and defend it robustly.”

Argentine President Cristina Fernandez initially dispatched Timerman to formally complain to the UN Security Council that Britain has created a serious security risk by sending the destroyer HMS Dauntless, one of its most modern warships, to the region.

Britain called the actions – which include the deployment of Prince William on his RAF search-and-rescue duties – “routine”.

- Anita Snow

Read: Argentina lodges UN complaint as UK denies ‘militarisation’ of Falklands

Explainer: What’s going on in the Falkland Islands?

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • What on earth would the UK use nuclear weapons for? I think a nuke on the Argentina mainland in the event of an invasion might be a slight overkill and highly improbable. I think as others have said elsewhere, if you mention the word nuclear, people listen.

    Reply
    • Reg 11/02/12 #

      The UK never discloses where their nuclear armed submarines operate. Even if there is one deployed in the South Atlantic, nuclear weaopns would never be used in a small regional conflict. It’s far more likely that the UK deploy attack submarines there on a regular basis. These are not armed with nuclear missiles.

      Reply
  • And if it was the other way round..they will b calling UN and america to stop all aid to argentina…..

    Reply
  • There would still only be 22 royal marines stationed on the falklands but for Argentina actions in 1982

    Reply
    • You are aware they did have a dictator, anyhow Argentina is dedicated to the return of their islands through peaceful means, alot can be said for the UK nuclear weapons is totally inappropriate but then again the UK does have a history around the world for careless invasions. Hopefully peace will resume soon.

      Reply
    • Reg 11/02/12 #

      Dianna – what in the first place makes them Argentinian? Do you know?

      You do realise that the islands are about 500 Kms from Argentina. Does that mean that we should still be part of the UK or that the Canary Islands should not be Spanish?

      Reply
  • What did the Argies expect? They’ve imposed an economic blockade on the Falklands in all South American ports.
    Were they expecting kid gloves from the UK?
    That’s the way wars usually start.

    Reply
  • Give back Las Malvinas!!

    Reply
  • This is all part of the bigger picture that is happening around the world right now. Argentina are trying to distract miltary attention away from the planned invasion of Syria and Iran. After what happened in Argentina 10 years ago, they know who the enemy is, big financial institutions and everthing they control which includes media, military and big energy. Watch a doc on utube called the collapse of Argentina and try to understand how the world works cause the same forces are at work in Ireland. “We are living in a age that calls darkness light” a little quote from Arcade Fire but so true. The truth is coming out people hence the crackdown on free speach and the internet. Call me paranoid but theres plenty of evidence and books out there to prove it.

    Reply
    • Don’t forget your tinfoil hat before you go outside!

      Reply
    • Tinfoil would in all probability only increase the amount of “rays” absorbed by the brain so I’d advise against that Simon. “Argentina’s Economic Collapse” is an interesting video and should be learnt from. In ensuring such things may never ever happen here.

      Argentina is a good study into what could possibly happen here or or even somewhere in Europe through similar IMF or foreign influence to government. To think otherwise is naive, governments throughout history have turned on its people but smart ass people seem to think it wont happen here or to them in 2012.
      Currently we have out of touch lying politicians who have sweet feck all interest in the people but saving their own arse’s and party’s power who have no issue bending to foreign demands in how to governing our country.

      If anything, people shouldn’t be smug to disregard the idea but acknowledge it and be prepared for it happening to you. Democracy is being eroded across the globe by bending to austerity rules and financial institutions. Now is the time to be aware of its progression and do what we can as a unified public to prevent it, before we have no voice or say in how we are controlled and where any voice or criticism gets dealt with violence and beating to subservience. Its has happened many times before in all corners of the globe and to think it could never happen to you is more in need of a tinfoil hat than someone who is at least aware of the threat posed by current situations and the sequence of things that have happened in recent times.

      At the very least give thought to the idea of what happened in Argentina and what would lead to such a situation happen here. We owe it to ourselves to protect and ensure our future safety from those who only care about power and money and have showed disdain to us time and time again.
      When people declare “How could this happen here?” are those who ignore the signs and dismissed it when it happens to others… until it happens to them.

      Reply
    • Tinfoil hats are for people who believe in aliens and shit. Dont believe what they tell u day after day, do your own research and make up your own mind cause its happening right in front of u. I suppose people like Chomsky, Klein and such wear tin foil hats as well. Its getting old mate.

      Reply
  • “Argentina claims that the islands are theirs under an agreement when it became independent from Spain in 1811. They claim that the islands – known to them as Las Malvinas – were under their control until the UK exceeded its authority by expelling Argentine settlers in 1833″. If this is true then the Brits should do the honorable thing and give back what was never their’s.

    Reply
    • Reg 11/02/12 #

      But if you go by history, Britain first claimed the islands in 1690 or something like that. What really matters is the people of this islands who have lived there for many generations. The people who were there in 1690 or 1811 have long gone.

      Reply
    • limofax 11/02/12 #

      The Brits have a habit of claiming everything thats not theirs. It is well known that an Irish man from Wexford called John Joe Furlong lived with his hoor on the Falklands from 1486 to 1503 and claimed the islands for Ireland. He was credited with introducing sheep and syphilis to the islands,two things that the islands are now famous for.In fact the strawberry strain of syphilis that infects most of the british army can be traced back to John Joe.

      Reply
  • Sure of course it belongs to the UK, it’s only 6 or 7 thousand miles off its coast……

    Reply
  • Despite its defeat, Argentina still pursues its claim; however, UK policy supports the islanders’ self-determination to remain British citizens.
    And British citizens have my full support.
    At various times in the past, a number of other countries have had claims over these islands.
    Not just Argentina.

    Reply
    • I guess its all down to what the islanders themselves want. I suppose the majority decision overrides any other claim and the Falklanders themselves want and choose to remain British. I expect some Irish politician to stand up in the Dail soon and claim them as Irish territory!

      Reply
  • Las Malvinas son Argentinas.

    Reply
  • Mentions;
    Britain/british = 14
    UK = 3 (including the headline)

    Reply

Add New Comment