TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 2 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Donegal bishops made “significant” errors dealing with child sex abuse

The Catholic Bishop of Raphoe in Donegal described the abuse committed against children as “horrific” and said that there had been “very poor judgements and mistakes made”.

File photo of Bishop of Raphoe Philip Boyce
File photo of Bishop of Raphoe Philip Boyce
Image: Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland

A REPORT INTO child sex abuse allegations against Catholic priests in Donegal has found there were “significant” errors made by bishops in the diocese in dealing with the accusations.

The current bishop of the diocese of Raphoe said that there had been “very poor judgements and mistakes made” and described the abuse committed against children as “horrific”.

The report into how allegations were dealt with in the diocese of Raphoe, which covers most of Donegal, looked at 52 allegations against 14 separate priests since 1975.

All of the priests are still alive. Eight have left the priesthood or are no longer serving in a ministry. Four of them have been convicted of offenses against children or young people.

The only priest named in the report is Eugene Green, one of the most notorious paedophile priests in Ireland, who abused more than 20 boys over 20 years.

The review of the Raphoe diocese is one of six reports, two from Northern Ireland, which are being published today.

Philip Boyce, bishop of the Raphoe diocese, said in a statement that there had been “frequent” cases of delays or non-reporting of allegations of child sexual abuse.

He admitted that the needs of victims were often ignored, “often in the misguided attempt to protect the reputation of the [Catholic] Church”. He apologised for the “terrible deed that have been inflicted on so many by a small minority of priests”.

Speaking on Highland Radio this morning, the Bishop said that he believed the diocese could have the highest levels of allegations against priests in the country.

He said that he will be making “added efforts” to get in contact with survivors of abuse in the diocese who wanted apologies or counselling.

The report was conducted by the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church, which was set up in the wake of the myriad child abuse scandals.

The report had originally been due to be published in August but was delayed when the head of the investigation asked for additional time to seek more information from Catholic authorities.

The board is reviewing every diocese in the country to examine how Catholic authorities dealt with allegations against priests.

Read next:

Comments (47 Comments)

  • “He said that he will be making “added efforts” to get in contact with survivors of abuse in the diocese who wanted apologies or counselling.”
    How about those who want justice?

    Reply
  • in the media today they repeated that they ‘lacked training’ in safeguarding children and protecting children.
    to bugger and rape little children is a crime and always was.
    training does not take over the natural instinct to protect the young, and know right from wrong.
    when you hear of child rape and other heinous crimes, you instinctively remove the perpertrator, call the police and have the guy punished/ end of story.
    training, my a….tell me the mother or father who needed training in protecting their children from harm?

    Reply
    • Ann you are so right . Even ‘dumb’ animals protect their young , and who trains them :) These people make me physically sick with their holier than thou attitude .Have they no shame ? These people are sick!

      Reply
  • Again, Too Little Too Late

    Reply
  • It is important to note that this report, and the other five released today, were edited by the bishop before publication rendering them somewhat suspect.

    Reply
  • The report was conducted by the *National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church* In other words, catholic church investigating the catholic church, seen by and edited by the same bishops who are found to have made “significant errors”. No wonder Hegarty ‘retired’ last month, no doubt he’ll be unavailable to answer any awkward questions! Same old story with this mob, they do all they can to avoid, hinder and refuse to cooperate with investigations then they delay them for as much as possible before finally letting them out heavily edited and cleaned up by the bishops they criticise and then we get the usual bleating and sorrow routine which by now is so well practised by these bishops etc, that they are totally meaningless. Today we also hear that Brady has settled out of court with the remaining victim whom he silenced back in the 70′s and which allowed the evil predator priest Smyth to carry on abusing just as McFeely, Hegarty and Wallace did nothing to stop Greene. These bishops yet again have failed to protect children and yet again they failed to deal with the pedophiles who they knew only too well were abusing children, the ‘significant errors’ are in fact children, not errors they are children who because of the bishops inaction and cover up’s have been abused, raped, buggered, that’s the reality of it. Whilst these pathetic bishops dress it up with words the real truth is that they like so many others in the higher echelons of the Irish catholic church put the protection of the churches reputation above that of the children who were being abused by monsters like Greene and many others, As for saying it was a ‘minority’, Raphoe: 52 allegations reported to gardaí against 14 priests. Tuam: 25 allegations reported to gardaí against 18 priests. Kilmore: Seven allegations reported to gardai against seven priests. Derry: 31 allegations reported to gardai against 23 priests. Dromore: 35 allegations of abuse against 10 priests. Ardagh & Clonmannoise: 14 allegations reported to gardai against 13 priests. Even one pedophile is one too many and these bishops must know that along with everyone else. They have once again been shown up for what they are, morally bankrupt with zero credibility and they certainly have no right to preach to anyone about decency or morality given their own moral failures!

    Reply
  • “terrible deed that have been inflicted on so many by a small minority of priests”. I’m sick of hearing this small minority of priests crap, yes it was a small minority of priests that abused children .. but there was a lot more involved in the cover up! That’s where you really see the catholic church for what it is.

    Reply
  • Now, let’s be reasonable, we’ve known for a long time that the first rule of the Let’s Abuse Kids Club has always been ‘don’t talk about abusing kids’

    Reply
  • This says it all:
    “The report had originally been due to be published in August but was delayed when the head of the investigation asked for additional time to seek more information from Catholic authorities.”

    They still block and obstruct and have no respect for the law of the land.

    Reply
    • In other words, re-check them so that anything in them, is taken out for fear of public liability and evidence to back any cases further up!

      This is a somewhat PR exercise for them. They cleverly/wisely decided to release all the reports on the same day.
      So that they could get it all over in one go and that all the reports couldn’t probably be read in detail by critics/politicians/media orgs/etc in just a few hours.

      This organisation is not stupid when its wants not to be.

      Reply
    • Why were they allowed edit these reports ?

      Reply
    • They are their OWN reports.
      They can say what they want (they do!), praise whom they want (and they did) and leave out they they like (We will never know?).

      Reply
    • Correction:

      They can say what they want (they do!), praise whom they want (and they did) and leave out WHAT they like (We will never know?).

      We are only getting to see the tip of the iceberg I and many suspect!

      Reply
  • “The board is reviewing every diocese in the country to examine how Catholic authorities dealt with allegations against priests.”
    Pointless exercise if the best they can come up with is that there were “significant” errors made by bishops. They should start by acknowledging the systematic cover up, from the top down, of crimes against children by predators into whose care they were entrusted.

    Reply
  • The catholic church is dying in Ireland and in 20 years will be gone for good, no-one to blame but the people running it, These bastards should be squeezed and then thrown in jail with the hardened criminals, never mind a special wing for themselves where they’re protected.

    Reply
  • They just love to jump on the bandwagon and try and make us feel bad about criticizing them that priest who was slandered by rte that was tragic sloppy opportunistic journalism but ultimately who was to blame the bishops and the hierarchy of the catholic church they think they have a god given right to make mistakes apologize and its all right whereas if rte get it wrong pull the program off the air and launch investigations and fire everyone involved which they should but the church should do it first otherwise shut the f*£& up

    Reply
    • Niall Mulvany@ You are so right . I agree with every word you say. Don’t you feel bad about criticizing them .They were all involved in the cover ups. They left a lot of people hurt and confused and damaged . They who are so determined to protect each other would not protect innocent children.Men of God my a–e.

      Reply
  • The catholic church is a disgusting, preposterous, redundant, evil, hierarchical, misogynistic, homophobic organisation, which preys (as opposed to prays) on the vulnerable and the ignorant. And the successive governments (in this country and in others), and their agencies and adherents, too, who have for decades turned a blind eye to its nefarious activities, are just as culpable. This has never been about ‘a few bad eggs’. It’s rotten through and through. If you are a believer, read the words of Jesus, unmediated by these huckster middlemen in dresses. Enough is enough.

    Reply
  • All of the red-tumbs and not one of them had the courage to state their opinion. This seems oddly common in any story on the RCC.

    Reply
    • Alan, I think I stated my position very clearly.

      Reply
    • That’s because anytime someone actually states their belief in god they’re called stupid, dumb, idiots etc. Slag off the church all want over what’s happened but leave the ordinary people alone. It’s people like yourself I’d bet actually “pray” for more revelations to come out about the church.

      Reply
    • *all you want

      Reply
    • Diego Attley
      I don’t think that is altogether true, I believe in God , I believe in Mary Our Mother .However I do not believe in the Catholic Church .The Catholic Church is in the business of protecting its assets and itself. I cannot believe that I grew up near one of those ‘magdalen’ laundries and a school for boys run by the ‘Christian’ brothers and we never knew til years later what had been going on there…Sick b’s . They should all be made live the way they made those poor children live ,but they would never know the fear those children endured. They talk about how bad the Nazis were during the 2nd world war , but the Nazis did not pretend to be doing ‘God’s work’…

      Reply
  • “Significant” ???

    Understatement of the year right there!

    Reply
  • I’m an atheist, thank god (!).

    Reply
  • Diego, please run along to mass and say a few wee prayers to your imaginary god, there’s a good fellow.

    Reply

Add New Comment