TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Gardaí warn that station closures ‘will change DNA of policing’

31 Garda stations will be closed as part of Budget cutbacks – a move that Gardaí say will destroy the ethos of community policing.

Image: infomatique via Flickr

39 GARDA STATIONS are to be closed permanently under cutbacks announced in the Budget – a move officers say will radically alter the “genetic code of policing” in Ireland.

31 stations will be permanently shut in 2012, as part of the moves announced today, while another eight stations which have already become non-operational will now not re-open.

A further ten stations in Dublin will lose their 24-hour service, as the Garda budget is scaled back by €114 million.

Justice minister Alan Shatter, confirming the cutbacks, said the closures were necessary if the government was to address “the dreadful financial legacy inherited from the previous government”.

The minister said that the reduced Garda presence would provide a challenge, but assured people living in the areas covered by those stations that Gardaí would still provide the “most professional and effective policing service possible”.

Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan said the police force had to find savings like every other part of the public service, and said local Garda managers would work with local communities to ensure the closures would not have an impact on local policing.

“There is a challenge there for us in managing public expectations and explaining that while a policing service may not always be provided in the same way as it was in the past, it is no less effective and our commitment to the community is not diminished,” Callinan said.

The Garda Representative Association, however, said it opposed the closures – and described the news as a “solemn development in the structure of how An Garda Síochána polices this country”.

GRA president Damien McCarthy said local Garda stations had always been “at the heart of the community” and that the local station had often been seen as the “physical embodiment” of the principle that policing came from within the community and not from outside.

To close the garda station in the community re-engineers the genetic code of policing in this country. The implications of such are that it will be harder to gather the information and intelligence that effective crime prevention, detection and investigation relies upon. Crimes become harder to solve. [...]

Can we no longer afford to have a small building designated as a garda station? Is this how far we have come as a nation?

In numbers: The first half of Budget 2012

Gallery: In pictures: day one of Budget 2012

Reaction: How Twitter reacted to Budget 2012

In full: TheJournal.ie‘s coverage of Budget 2012

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • no name 05/12/11 #

    Yes 79 million out of 100 cut in Garda budget in the Dept of justice…. I wonder how much will be cut to housing and feeding the assylum seekers in the overcrowded refuges and B&b’s dotted around the country….? They should be sent home!!! We cannot afford These people !

    Reply
  • Out of €100 million euro cuts to the Justice budget….€79 million in cuts is to the Garda Budget….and frontline services aren’t going to be effected? please explain.

    Reply
  • What a narrow minded decision to impose such a savage and brutal cut like that. They will regret this decision in the future. Shame on Fine Gael on Labour, the shower of liars.

    Reply
  • Have the gov reached agreement with criminals to drop their activity in line with Garda cuts?????

    It’ll be interesting to see Garda policing of the inevitable protest marches that WILL happen in this country.

    Reply
    • Yes they have. You see your average gurrier doesn’t get out of bed untill the afternoon and this was noticed in the mid 80′s, there was a slight improvement in the boom years when many of them felt the need to do a “bit of dis and dat”, this was later translated to mean anything from dealing, stealing or selling stolen goods and tended to revolve around drugs. During the boom years the drug scene flourished and the average gurrier progressed into this leaving the street gurrier behind, the average gurrier became a high class gurrier and amassed vast amounts of wealth during this period but still maintained his sleep pattern. The high class gurrier sold his product to the new average gurrier, who now became quite wealthy by Irish standards, but still maintained his sleep pattern. He in turn sold his drugs to the street gurrier who used them at every available opportunity and slept mainly during daylight hours, in order to pay for them he robbed from anyone around him and mugged anyone who crossed his path, the elderrly were preferred. This didn’t slip past the attention of the gardai who notice everything and over the years passed all this information on to various Ministers of Justice, none of them took any notice, untill one day one did, but there was a wee problem. The boom had gone, the high class gurrier had fallen on hard times, there wasn’t many of them left now, quite a few average gurriers though and no shortage of street gurriers and they all maintained their sleep patterns and the MOJ, we’ll call him Alan, read the reports. Alan had a meeting with senior gardai and discussed this with them, how the gurriers didn’t get up untill the afternoon, and he had an idea. If the gurriers are in bed the gardai may as well be in bed too so he made something out it, he closed loads of garda stations and closed others at night. Yeah, the MOJ, Alan made a mistake, he didn’t know the difference between am and pm so when the gurriers are up and about doing their thing there’s none of his gardai about to stop them. Oooopppss, big mistake. As he said to Enda, do you think anyone will notice?

      Reply
    • Fuk me! I thought REM was a rock group from Georgia USA. So all along it was a subliminal transition in the late morning sleep patterns of drug addled skangers and Guards.

      Reply
  • FG soft on crime never mind cutting Garda numbers but to close stations is laughable! No replacement in old clapped out vehicles so how can an area with a station closure be protected?.. Wonder just how much will they save in closing a station because that’s the price they have put on our safety. It will push more people into crime because that is what the government is supporting! Do the crime and get bail/more crime no room in prisons so go back out to create more crime! Well done FG/LB high five

    Reply
  • Guards on duty 24/7 outside liam cosgroves house since he left government .he must have cost a few million in security since then .it takes 4/5 guards a week just to cover this and they do nothing except sit in their tardis like box everyday waiting on their dinner to be sent up from rathfarnham station.

    Reply
  • Hope these cuts will be reflected, the next time there is a protest or a bit of a squabble around the funny farm.

    Reply
  • How do you know for sure it was a bag of chips? Might have been a spice burger and a battered sausage..

    Reply
  • Any details on locations of the closures?

    Reply
  • howzat 05/12/11 #

    Hmmm recession equals more crime, but instead of increasing man power they close stations. Crime will go through the roof and it will be reversed in 6 months time. Why not outsource admin few guards needed those that stay do direct policing. Stop ridiculous check points on bank holidays (overtime earner) and install more cameras on cities. Stop jailing people for non payment of fines instead bring in bailiffs which can be outsourced and stop hiring midget cops….

    Reply
    • Bailiffs? AKA private Gestapo of the TV licence man, the council tax man, the water rates man, the banks etc……Do we really want to go down that route?

      Reply
    • I agree with you that jailing people for fines is crazy and should be dealt with by some sort of community service and stop clogging up the system with them. There are however serial offenders who never pay a single fine and rack up thousands so jail is probably the only option for them.

      Stupid checkpoints on Bank Holidays? Overtime? Why should drink drivers or criminals be given free rein on a Bank Holiday aside from any other day? And Gardai are rostered 24/7 so they already work Bank Holidays so nobody is on overtime.

      Reply
  • howzat 05/12/11 #

    Outside gaffneys after one of the dublin matches and this cop car races around the corner sirens blazing and stops outside a chipper me thinking it’s a fight or robbery . Female guard gets out and comes out two minutes later with a bag of chips to bring back to the station not a word of a lie group of us had a right aul laugh you couldn’t make it up

    Reply
  • howzat 05/12/11 #

    No point givin it thumbs up or down it actually happened what can I say

    Reply
  • howzat 05/12/11 #

    Not made up honest

    Reply
  • will this mean that the lads will be nearer their doughnut centre

    Reply
  • howzat 06/12/11 #

    Judging by the voting assuming Colm mooney didn’t keep pressing the button people want small gardai, jail full of people having not paid fines and gardai stuck behind desks writing up reports on little johnny stealing some sweeties from the local shop. What wonderful people we are…..

    Reply

Add New Comment