Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 18 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

Hogan hits back at claims government doesn’t care about climate change

Phil Hogan
Phil Hogan
Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

ENVIRONMENT MINISTER PHIL Hogan has hit back at claims that the government does not care about climate change following a report that indicated legislation was not a priority.

Today’s Irish Times reported that climate change legislation was to be put on the backburner by Hogan in sharp contrast to the policy of his predecessor John Gormley who sought to set statutorily binding targets for cutting carbon emissions before the government collapsed in January.

The news led to the Green Party, of which Gormley is a member, accusing the government of not caring about the issue of climate change.

Leader Eamon Ryan said in a statement this morning:

As well as the moral bankruptcy in their approach, the Government have shown they don’t understand the simple truth that cutting down on Greenhouse gas emissions is going to be good for our economy.

Ryan, one of two Green Party ministers in the last cabinet, also said it was “madness for the Government to be abandoning the big public transport and energy projects at a time when further deflation is the greatest threat to our recovery.”

Meanwhile, Fianna Fáil’s environment spokesperson Niall Collin accused Hogan of “dismissing environmental concerns outright and denying the impact of climate change on our domestic economy.”

However, Hogan hit back on RTÉ’s Today with Pat Kenny expressing his belief that the Greens in government had been “all talk and no action” and insisted:

My policy approach is going to ensure we get this policy position right and we’ll underpin it by legislation in due course rather than the other way round.

Hogan added that he was focused on shaping policy throughout the course of next year aimed at reducing the country’s greenhouse gas emissions in line with EU targets set by the historic Kyoto protocol established in the 1990s.

These targets specify that Ireland’s carbon emissions must be 20 per cent lower than output was in 2005.

Hogan added: ”Anyone that’s interested in progressing this policy agenda to a low carbon economy and that provides job opportunities to people can be assured that I will actually do what I say.”

Read Next:

Comments (20 Comments)

  • David Higgins 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    There’s more important legislation needed at this time. Hogan is right to put it on the back burner. The last thing we need is more regulations that will inhibit growth.

    And as long as the USA and China are out of any deal, it’s pointless in Ireland cutting back. Our contribution is a drop in the ocean. Why should we restrict ourselves while the rest of the world will plough ahead regardless?

    Cutting emissions will come about naturally as we seek to change our sources of fuel to renewables.

    Reply
    • Mark Dennehy 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Why should we restrict ourselves while the rest of the world will plough ahead regardless?

      That’s the same argument the US car industry made for twenty years about fuel efficiency.
      The Japanese didn’t waste time arguing, they just built more efficient cars, as did everyone else.
      As to the US car industry, well, you’ve seen how vibrant a city Detroit is of late, haven’t you?

    • David Higgins 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      that was a bad business decision and they’ve rightly suffered from it. What it shows is that there’s always a competitive market in these areas to allow the best ideas to become the most popular ones. Fuel efficiency is more popular now than ever. Car companies are investing billions in innovating to find the next breakthrough technology. We don’t need government intervention to push this. It’s happening anyway!

    • Yosser Hughes 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      What did the Greens do for us ? Let me think …. That’s right carbon no stealth tax..

  • Mark Dennehy 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    How long was Gormley a Minister before finally getting round to printing a Bill on climate change?
    Seems a fairly daft comparison, given that.

    Reply
    • Stephen Wall 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Gormley was tackling climate change from the moment he became minister, but new legislation takes frustratingly long to implement.

  • Adam Magari 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    A country of four million with not enough heavy industry to fit in a kettle should not consider climate change of pressing importance. A good covering of old-fashioned dirty industries would absorb a lot of the unemployed and generate business for SMEs.

    Reply
    • Michael E Doyle 05/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      we have one of the worst per capita GHG emissions in the EU, look at our ag sector and transport sector. Because of the importance of agri in this country and its sensitivity to the climate we should indeed look to the importance of climate change and embrace it in legislation.

  • Lou Brennan 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Not this rubbish again. What ever happened to those po-faced, do-gooder gob*****s known as the greens. If you’re still worried about the great con that is global warming you really need to go shove yourselves where the sun don’t shine.

    Reply
    • Robert Power 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      The evidence is mounting for climate change. Read the big science journals and you’ll see. People burying their heads in the sand is what caused the economic crisis. Its a mistake we can’t afford to repeat.

    • Ommm 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Lou, go educate yourself and find out how much the environment is worth to us in terms of health, economy, food production and funnily enough employment. Climate deniers have been thoroughly discredited even as recently as a report mentioned in The Journal last week.

      I am not a po-faced, do-gooder gobexpletive but I am green and I am extremely concerned about the change in climate. Should I call you a corrupt, ignorant, climate denier and mainstream party follower then?

    • Michael E Doyle 05/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      Lou, about 99% of the scientific community (the guys who know what they’re talking about) indicate antropogenic driven climate change is happening. now.

  • James Doyle 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    I think there is better things to be worrying about now rather than the green party tryin to get attention again,the worlds super powers should cut there emissions first before we a population of 4 million go down that route,the green party got there way with carbon taxes which are ridiculous given the harsh winters were getting,people can’t afford home heating oil cos of these gombeens that were in power

    Reply
    • Stephen Wall 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Are you happy that we continue to spend billions each year importing fossil fuels when we have some of the most plentiful renewable energy in Europe? Do you deny energy efficiency cuts business overheads and home heating bills? It’s possible to enhance the economy and tackle climate change at the same time. I don’t think Phil Hogan is the man to bring this about.

    • Ommm 03/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Are you for real? Heating oil has not gone up in price because of carbon taxes, noticed any wars in the middle east lately? Heard anything about the cost of extracting oil increasing as we have to go deeper to get at it? I know who the gombeens are and it certainly isn’t the Green Party.

  • James Doyle 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Ommm look up carbon tax budget 2010,there you will see kerosene oil 6.5 percent and gas 7 percent,petrol and diesel bout 5 cent per litre,so do your homework before you shoot your mouth off at me!!!!fool

    Reply
    • Ommm 04/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      James, the problem isn’t the carbon tax though it is the cost of the product in the first place. I pay it too when I heat my home same as everyone else but I have no problem with paying it. I’d prefer not to rely on fossil fuel though.
      There are many things wrong with the system in Ireland that are far more damaging to our pockets than a small Carbon tax. Like it or not we have to start becoming more responsible for environmental impact.

  • Lou Brennan 03/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Ommmmmmmm ……as I said. Go shove yourself where the sun don’t shine. Recycle your nonsense somewhere else coz were all stocked up on crazy around here.

    Reply
  • James Doyle 04/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Ommm first it was hole in the ozone layer,then global warming now climate change,humans impact a very little percentage of this,sorry to burst your bubble but we are a planet that revolves around the sun like the rest of the planets,of course the world is goin to heat up and cool down I cycles,this industry in worth billions to the worlds governments preaching bout carbon footprint,all the supposedly called scientists are funded by the governments to preach this crap cos it’s worth billions to them!!

    Reply

Add New Comment