TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Taoiseach: No new report on children’s hospital commissioned

Enda Kenny reiterated that a decision on the location for the National Children’s Hospital would be determined within the next two weeks at Leaders’ Questions this morning.

Enda Kenny speaking in the Dáil this morning
Enda Kenny speaking in the Dáil this morning
Image: Screengrab

THE TAOISEACH HAS denied that the government or any minister has commissioned a new report to assess the suitability of potential sites for the National Children’s Hospital.

At Leaders’ Questions in the Dáil today, Enda Kenny reiterated that it was the government’s intention to make a decision on a site for the hospital within the next two weeks and denied reports that the government was seeking further assistance in making this decision.

RTÉ had reported this morning that former Dublin City manger John Fitzgerald had been approached to assess the suitability of potential sites but the Department of Health denied this and RTÉ later amended its story.

Fitzgerald could not be reached for comment but speaking in the Dáil following questions from Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin about the reports, Kenny said that he had “no interest in the speculation or the rumour or the innuendo that goes in the general mix of things”.

He said that neither the government nor any minister commissioned any report into possible locations and said that this process had already been undertaken by Frank Dolphin whose report has been sent to the Minister for Health.

“This is one of the major projects of this government’s terms of office,” Kenny said in relation to the hospital, later adding: “There is no other independent report or reports commissioned by government or ministers in this regard.”

There followed a series of heated exchanges as Martin accused the Taoiseach of not answering the question directly about whether any “independent person” had been asked to assess locations.

“Why is there an inability to tell the truth to the house?” Martin asked before being met with howls of derision from the government benches.

“Sometimes when you keep interrupting you blnd yourself to the truth,” Kenny later responded saying that there was “only one process here… and it will be more independent then the one that went before” referring to the previous administration’s choice of a site at the Mater hospital, a site rejected by An Bord Pleanála.

The Taoiseach later said that the Dolphin report would be published as soon as the government had made the decision which he said would be within the next two weeks.

Read: Department denies report of further review of Children’s Hospital

Read next:

Comments (14 Comments)

  • It’s now eight months, almost to the day since the decision by An Bord Pleanala to refuse permission for the original Mater proposal. A redesign of the Mater proposal in response to the planning concerns was completed five and a half months ago. If the government had stuck by the original decision on the Mater site they could have planning permission secured at this stage and be well on the way to starting on site.

    As it stands it’ll be another two weeks before a decision is made and if that decision is for any other site than the Mater it is likely that the design team will have to be stood down and a new procurement process instigated for a new design team. This design team will have to start the design process from scratch with a full re-breifing from the stakeholders. This will be followed by a whole new planning process on a new site with new issues to be resolved. It’s hard to see this happening without adding an additional two years to the process.

    Given the way this has been handled it is hard to believe the Minister and his government colleagues when they talk about the urgency of providing a National Children’s Hospital. It seems to me that the urgency is in ensuring maximum political gain from the decision.

    Reply
    • I dont agree Ciaran and I welcome the care and effort that has been taken this time to make sure the right decison is made. This project has been 7 years in the making…2 more weeks to make its bullet proof is time very well spent….

      Reply
    • You miss the point Declan. It’s not just two more weeks. If the site is changed at this late stage it will cost another two years at least. None of the alternative proposals have owned up to this fact in their submissions and have shown a lack of understanding of (or have deliberately obfuscated) the procurement and design process in assuming that the current design can be simply applied to another site and that the project can pick up where it left off in February. (btw this project has been a lot longer than 7 years in the making)

      Reply
  • Is there a day where kenny doesn’t blame the previous party! Jesus get on with it FFS we are all sick to the back teeth of the blame game, build the bloody thing!!!

    Reply
  • snooch 24/10/12 #

    This is absolutely crazy. The amount of time and money being ploughed into choosing a site for an absolutely necessary hospital. What a waste

    Reply
  • andrew 24/10/12 #

    You’d think that Enda Kenny was in charge. Doesn’t he realise that Eamon Gilmore is running Europe (and maybe beyond, he hasn’t clarified this yet)

    Reply
    • Not sure if Gilmore is in charge of much either but isn’t there talk of Gilmore commissioning
      a report on Primary care sites ? Sorry ,I don’t mean to change the subject ,but I know where you are coming from !

      Reply
  • And they’re off ………

    Reply
  • Kenny Please just get on with it . Or will this be just another wind up for an even bigger let down ? As Micháel Martin asked ” Why is there an inability to tell the truth to the house?” ”
    I bet you any thing that the report if it is good will be held til the day or maybe two days BEFORE the referendum, and if it is not so hot then it will be held up til AFTER the referendum …
    Fine Gael is NOTHING if not transparent !

    Reply
  • snooch , Mickey Martin is a fine one to be giving out about commissioning reports.

    Reply
  • The government will read the report and will either follow it’s recommendations or keep on commissioning more reports until they get the answer they want. Another likely scenario is that they will ignore all reports and common sense and build it in Mayo to keep Enda happy.

    Reply
  • if the new children’s hospital were going to be built anytime in, say, the next 20 years why is all that new construction going on at Crumlin?

    Reply

Add New Comment