TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Study shows even moderate drinking in pregnancy can affect child’s IQ

Alcohol Action Ireland said there are no known safe levels of alcohol during pregnancy and their position is that pregnant women should abstain.

Image: 2nix via Shutterstock

DRINKING JUST ONE or two glasses of wine a week while pregnant can influence a child’s IQ, according to a new study by researchers from Oxford and Bristol Universities.

The study, published in PLoS ONE, shows that even moderate alcohol consumption can lead to a reduction in a child’s IQ, if the child has certain genetic variations that affect their ability to break down alcohol.

A spokesperson for Alcohol Action Ireland said their position is that there are “no known safe levels of alcohol during pregnancy” as alcohol crosses the placenta.

A report published by the Department of Health in February this year explored how alcohol exposure can affect the foetus through the occurence of a range of disorders.

The most serious effects are the intellectual disabilities associated with the adverse impact of alcohol on foetal brain development and the central nervous system.

The report said “screening for alcohol consumption should begin at the first antenatal visit for all pregnant women and be reviewed throughout the pregnancy”.

Previous studies from around the world on the effects of moderate alcohol intake on a child’s IQ have produced conflicting results. This may be because it is difficult to separate the effects of moderate drinking from other lifestyle and social factors, such as smoking, diet, affluence, and mother’s age and education.

This study, believed to be the first substantial one of its kind, used genetic variation to investigate the effects of drinking 1–6 units of alcohol per week among a large group of over 4,000 women. Heavy drinkers were not included.

A small, 125ml glass of wine is around 1.5 units while a pint of beer of standard strength is approximately 2 units.

Researchers in the study identified four genetic variations that had an adverse affect on a child’s IQ. The child’s IQ was on average almost two points lower for each variation they possessed.

There was no evidence of this among mothers who abstained during pregnancy, strongly suggesting that the exposure to alcohol in the womb lead to the difference in IQ.

The mothers’ alcohol intake was based on questionnaires completed when they were 18 weeks and 32 weeks pregnant.

The children’s IQ was tested when they were aged eight using a shortened version of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children.

Related: Childhood behavioural problems linked to smoking during pregnancy>

Read: Over 220 million women have an ‘unmet need for family planning’>

Read next:

Comments (46 Comments)

  • Remember hearing how women years ago were encouraged to drink a glass of stout to keep their iron levels up..we’ve come a long way.

    Reply
  • Best off just not drinking at all for 9 months, it’s only 9 months, is it really worth risking your child’s health for the sake of a glass of wine?

    Reply
  • EJPC 15/11/12 #

    It says something about you if you can’t go 9 months without using any recreational drugs

    Reply
  • Moderate drinking during pregnancy says more about the mothers IQ.

    Reply
  • Logic would tell you that alcohol has to effect the baby somehow. I just dont understand how its so acceptable to give pregnant women the flu jab with no talk of how this effects baby.

    Reply
  • jn 15/11/12 #

    If you would not give alcohol or cigarets to your 1 year old or 2 year old …. Why would you give it to your unborn baby???!!!! Some say ah sure what harm will one drink do?! I say I don’t wanna find out!!!! And btw what good will one drink do to a pregnant woman?!

    Reply
  • Is this not something we have heard before ?

    Reply
  • I personally would not have a drink while pregnant because alcohol is not healthy so I don’t want to give it to my unborn child but I do not judge a person who has a drink with a meal or something, haveing a drink and getting pisssd drunk are too very different things

    Reply
  • Sorry but there is so many variables in regards of a child’s development in the first few years that these study’s can be taken with a pinch of salt

    Reply
  • Men’s sperm are effected by drink ! And … It takes two components to make a baby .!!!
    Lets worry about the mans health for a while .!

    Reply
    • its about drinking ‘during pregnancy’ not pre conception. it has nothing to do with the quality of male sperm. anyway, alcohol damaging male sperm counts will effect conseption not the IQ of the child thats created. please stop trying to deflect.

      Reply
  • Bullshit.They have these studies every couple of years and then roll back on them.Eggs are good for u,then eggs are bad for you and now chips cause cancer.

    Reply
    • Yes Brian.. and that was the point I was trying to make… You put it across better than I did .. and in response to some of the comments posted in reply to my earlier comment … I always thought you had to have a certain amount of intelligence to go to college.. I didn’t make it to college, school was never my strong point but i work with the public and im good at that and i love it..Im not the academic type and also I’m not implying that anyone who doesn’t go to college is stupid I never said that.. and yes.. an occasional glass of Guinness, and I say Guinness because they say its full of iron and that has benefits in itself, not spirits because EIMEAR .. I would prefer the Guinness as being the lesser of 2 evils if a pregnant woman is having a drink.. I don’t judge those who drink or don’t drink during their pregnancy….

      Reply
  • Watched a documentary on foetal alcohol syndrome while pregnant it terrified me I wouldn’t even have a sauce with wine in it after its just easier to abstain I think. You are responsible for this little babies life and its development surely people can manage to stay off the drink for the few months. Maybe the people who feel they shouldn’t miss out on their festive drinks over Christmas and new year for example should have thought about that before they got pregnant!

    Reply
  • We need an alcohol tax because we have a big drinking problem. Residents in Cork and Galway have repeatedly complained of abusive, loud drunken people and the Government still ignores the Health ramifications during pregnancy. Alcohol is cheap by comparison to our purchasing power and needs a tax increase. As for the idea that people will then head up to the six counties, good luck at forking out €1.25EUR for every £1.00GBP not to mention the higher gasoline prices.

    Reply
  • It’s all a load of BS…. The rules are made up as they go along it seems to me! One minute they say its fine to have an occasional drink and then they say you shouldn’t touch anything at all.. I think that an odd glass of Guinness is no harm, I DEFINATELY wouldn’t condone drinking vodka or hard spirits.. That’s just plain irresponsible.. I know plenty of women that drank during their pregnancies on and off an some of those kids are in college now…

    Reply
  • A pregnant woman is carrying something that is only 50% hers.

    Surely she should have no right to drink without first getting the permission of the partner in the pregnancy

    Reply
  • Even more nanny state blarney

    Reply
  • Lucky women can smoke weed during pregnancy with no ill effects

    Reply
    • A study of the development of 59 Jamaican children was conducted with the children being monitored from childbirth to age 5 years. One-half of the sample’s mothers used marijuana during pregnancy; they were paired with non-using mothers who matched age, parity, and socioeconomic status. Testing was done at 1, 3, and 30 days of age with the Brazelton Neonatal Behavioral Assessment Scales, and at ages 4 and 5 years with the McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities test. Data was also collected from the child’s home environment and temperament, as well as standardized tests. The results over the entire research period showed no significant differences in development testing outcomes between using and non-using mothers. At 30 days of age, however, the children of marijuana-using mothers had higher scores on autonomic stability and reflexes.

      There the study explained for all you dislike people

      Reply
    • That study was conducted over 20 years ago. If you look at more recent studies then the effects (if any) are subtle. However there are suggestions that the cognitive abilities of a child could be affected. In general though you should think to look up more recent findings before making a better judgement. I’m not saying smoking it definitely has an adverse effect, but other studies suggest it could.

      Reply
    • Eh… Kevin…. Really….

      Reply
    • All the more recent studies have included tobacco with the cannabis cigarettes . Which yes does harm we all know that. Cannabis on the other hand is even used by babies in places such as America for various medicinal reasons, we are behind the times with our cannabis laws

      Reply
    • siobeli 15/11/12 #

      I’m guessing you don’t have children? Trust me as soon as your partner gets pregnant, you will change your opinion!
      That your tiny baby’s developing lungs and organs being affected by smoke and drugs?
      People will justify their own selfish addictions when preg with stats like you are putting out there…like the one line that “it would do the baby more harm if I gave smoking as id be stressed”

      Reply
  • harm.

    Reply
  • In the pub where I work all the women come in to meet someone to get pregnant after courtship of course.

    Reply

Add New Comment