Advertisement

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

An angry jobseeker outside the mayor's office in Lomas de Zamora, 20 miles from Buenos Aires on 2 January, 2002. Diego Giudice/AP/Press Association Images
VOICES

Column What happened when MY country defaulted on its debts

Argentinian businessman Andres Blumenthal describes the panic and chaos that preceded the Argentinian default in 2002 – and the slow rebuilding of a country in its aftermath.

AS IRELAND TRIES to renegotiate the interest rate it is paying on its EU/IMF bailout and a Greek default is never off the cards, Argentinian businessman Andres Blumenthal describes what it is like to live in a country that defaults on its sovereign debt.

The Argentinian default in December 2001 was the largest debt collapse by an industrialised country in history at $82 billion in principal (€57bn). Blumenthal describes the run-up to ‘D Day’ or the day of the default – and how the country, very slowly, is only beginning to now emerge on the other side.

One Year before ‘D Day’: Quasi currencies.

The provincial and local governments, who were running high fiscal deficits, lose their capacity to borrow. Meanwhile, the national government makes an arrangement with the bond holders and IMF. They call the deal the ‘Megacanje’, which guarantees the national debt, but doesn’t include the debts of the provinces.

As a result, the provinces starts to pay salaries, pensions and suppliers with their own currencies. The country is juggling almost ten different types of quasi currencies: Patacon (Buenos Aires local peso), Lecor (Córdoba local peso), Lecop (National peso for government suppliers).

There are unofficial exchange rates within all these currencies, but most of them are devaluated against the Argentinean peso.

The main problem is that Argentina is not allowed to print money. Unlike in Ireland where you are paid in euro and use euro in the street, the government in Argentina arranges with the big supermarkets that people could only buy with these government dollar bonds. So you had this black market of these bonds where people tried to buy them but instead of one peso for one dollar, you could only get 30 cents of the dollar.

My family and I have a small business supplying raw materials to the food industry so we manage to stay dealing through that. The country is starting to get scared about the devaluation and the black market for bonds gets bigger.

One month before ‘D Day’: Corralito.

Argentina is seeing massive transfers of money from banks to safes, to offshore accounts and even to under the mattress. We hear stories about armoured trucks full of dollars leaving banks at midnight. People are afraid that they won’t be able to get their money out of the bank if the government decides to default so there is panic about getting your hands on cash.

The financial system runs dry, and the original idea that one Argentinian peso would be exchangeable for a dollar goes bust. The national government restricts the amount that a person could take away from his or her bank account to a maximum of 250 pesos per week per person.

This step is highly resisted by population. After the announcement, people are out on the steets, tapping saucepans on the sidewalks as a sign of their discontent.

I go to the bank near my place of business and it looks more like a fortress than a bank. They have replaced the glass windows with metal panels because people are trying to break in and get their money. Because we deal with ice-cream shops who only use cash, we are lucky enough to have access to money but during the following days there are riots against supermarkets and government facilities. Almost 30 people are killed.

There is looting in the suburbs and in the centre of Buenos Aires, around Plaza de Mayo, there are riots and violence. Everyone is scared.

‘D Day’: Default.

Two days before ‘D Day’, the president resigns and escapes by helicopter from the government house.

We have four different presidents who each last an average of one and a half days in power. One of them, Adolfo Rodriguez Saá, goes to the Congress, and in a historical speech declares the default.

There is joy in the country at the announcement and 300 Congressmen and most of the country clap the president. He resigns one day after that.

But despite the initial euphoria over the default, the situation on the streets is still one of anarchy. That is why there is such a high turnover of presidents. I am 23 at the time, a graduate, and there is 20 per cent unemployment. A lot of my friends leave to go to Spain, Italy and other places.

Three months after ‘D Day’: Devaluation.

Argentina is used to devaluations of the peso but there has never been one like this. Production almost stops everywhere for a year. Our family business has to try to get paid through some suppliers in another countries.

The IMF asks the government to adopt a free float currency model and the result is a devaluation of 400 per cent.

The Argentinian salaries and wages went down 70 per cent in USD dollars. Cash is the only instrument to sell or buy goods. Any type of credit disappears. Most credit contracts (mortgages, loans, etc.) are broken and restructured.  Mortgages aren’t that common in Argentina but it is pretty much impossible to get one now.

Were these four steps to hell, or heaven?

In the years since the default, the country has restarted – very slowly – its productive and financial capabilities. I could never say that defaulting is a good thing. Argentina was living in a fairytale with the dollar so it’s impossible to compare our default with Ireland’s for example.

Argentina’s GDP has grown almost 8 per cent per year for the last eight years since ‘D Day’. There are different explanations (high commodities prices, low international rates, populism and national government, “it’s not growth, it’s just recovery”, etc, etc.)

But for better or for worse, perhaps ‘D Day’ has something to do with that.

Column: What happened when MY country defaulted on its debts
1 / 14
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    A demonstrator holds a cross as he kneels in front of a police vehicle using its water cannon during anti-government protests in Buenos Aires' Plaza de Mayo in December 2001. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Demonstrators throw stones at an armoured vehicl in December 2001 at Plaza de Mayo in Buenos Aires as the government prepares to default. (AP Photo/Walter Astrada)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Demonstrators banging pans and empty bottles in Plaza de Mayo, Buenos Aires, to protest the banking freeze in February 2002. (AP Photo/Daniel Luna)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    A group of Argentine depositors, whose bank accounts were frozen by the government, demonstrate in Buenos Aires in June 2002. (AP Photo/Pablo Aneli)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    A police line protects a La Noria bridge behind a barricade set on fire by jobless workers during a national protest against the government failure to pull the country of of economic crisis in Buenos Aires, May 2002. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Life goes on: Argentine soccer fans react in a Buenos Aires, Argentina pub in June 2002 as they view the Argentina-England and Japan-Korea 2002 World Cup soccer matches. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    A man searches for food in the garbage of the largest wholesale fruit and vegetable market on the outskirts of Buenos Aires in May 2002. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Fruit seller Jose Romanelle puts up prices at a Buenos Aires market in May 2002. The Argentine government announced that the inflation rate soared 10.4 per cent in April 2002, the largest surge in a decade and consumer prices rose 21.1 per cent in the first four months of 2002, while wholesale prices rose sixty per cent since January. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Waiting in line trying to obtain food tickets distributed by the Argentine government in Lanus, Argentina, in April 2002.(AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Police guard a closed Dia Discount supermarket branch after a looting attempt in the suburb of Ciudadela, Buenos Aires in March 2002. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Masseuse Guillero Reta massages mechanic Daniel Salgado in exchange for fixing his car in March 2002 in Buenos Aires - the scarcity of cash in the economy leads to a barter economy. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    People wait to enter currency exchange houses in Buenos Aires in February 2002. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Unemployed people wait in line to apply for an office boy position at an unemployment agency in Buenos Aires in January 2002. (AP Photo/Diego Giudice)
  • Argentina: Scenes from a national default

    Argentine citizens camp outside Spain's consulate in Buenos Aires in January 2002. Citizens with near ancestral ties to Spain and Italy went to the embassies hoping to find a way out of Argentina during this economic crisis.(AP Photo/Diego Giudice)

Author
Andres Blumenthal
Your Voice
Readers Comments
28
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.