TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
: °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Teens believe cyber bullying is worse than traditional bullying

Teens feel like it’s the worst kind because they “can’t escape it” and pictures and messages can be spread so quickly.

Image: Sylvie Bouchard via Shutterstock

TEENAGERS BELIEVE THAT cyber bullying is worse than traditional bullying.

The paper ‘Living in an ‘electronic age’: Cyberbullying among Irish adolescents’ by Pádraig Cotter and Sinéad McGilloway from NUI Maynooth took a closer look at cyber bullying in Irish schools.

They interviewed 122 pupils, aged 12 to 18 years, in two co-educational schools in the south and explored four main forms of cyber bullying - text message, email, phone call and picture/video clip.

The results revealed that 17 per cent of students admitted to being victims of cyber bullying while 9 per cent admitted to being the perpetrators.

Video clips

The teens surveyed said cyber bullying was the worst kind of bullying because they “can’t escape it”, even when at home and because pictures and messages can be spread easily and quickly.

Pictures, video clips and phone calls were the worst type of cyber bullying according to the pupils, and less likely to be noticed by an adult in comparison with traditional bullying.

More than a quarter of cyber victims did not know who their cyber bullies were. Of those who did, the bully was typically a single female or a small number of females, from a different class, but in the same year as the victim.

Most respondents indicated that cyber bullying was short term, lasting only one to two weeks. However, four reported that it had gone on for a period of six months up to several years.

Confide

Cyber victims mostly confided in friends and parents, however six respondents said they had told nobody.

More than half of teens felt that banning mobile phones and internet use in school would not be helpful, as students would engage in bullying in private or after school.

Although cyber bullying was found to be less frequent than traditional bullying, mostly short-term, and seems to be lower in Ireland than in other countries, it’s becoming more prevalent because of the easy access to electronic forms of communication.

The study comes after three girls, Erin Gallagher (13) from Donegal, Leitrim teenager Ciara Pugsley (15) and Lara Burns Gibbs (12) from Kildare are believed to have taken their own lives after being bullied online.

Read: Teens urged not to respond to cyber bullies >

Read: Over to you: Have you ever been bullied? >

Read next:

Comments (24 Comments)

  • With cyber bullying there is HARD EVIDENCE the child/teen is been bullied / harrassed, save all the evidence all the texts/emails take screen shots of facebook pages and then inform the parents of the bully and the teachers at the school, if they dont do anything or if its really bad bring the evidence to the guards…

    Reply
  • ECP 30/11/12 #

    It is blatantly obvious that some of the people on here have never been bullied.

    Reply
  • I believe cyber bullying is potentially a lot worse than physical bullying. The victim of physical can escape the bully when they close their front door but cyber bullying is more invasive. Even if they don’t turn on a computer, smartphone etc. their friends and other potential bullies can see any posts about them. Their friends may believe any lies posted and isolate them as a result and potential bullies will see them as fresh meat and jump on the bandwagon. I am sure some of the victims feel compelled to log on to see what is being said about them just so they will know what to expect the next day in school and to know what they are defending themselves against. It must feel like being stuck in a maze and not being able to find the way out.

    Reply
  • alan 30/11/12 #

    cyber bullying is simply bullying in a different form. all bullying is equally bad from teh point of view of the damage it does both to the victim and the perpetrator

    Reply
  • When adults are rude, off hand and often abusive online you wonder where they get it from.

    Reply
  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qH6yp9rZt5M
    Watch this great video from a young Irish woman who was being bullied on ask.fm – shows how you can be strong about it, and she is asking others to connect up with her for support… go Siomha!

    Reply
  • A recent study has shown that most children who are seen as ‘cyber bullies’ are actually the victims of bullying in the real world. Many of them use fake profiles to fight back against these vile real life bullies, who make their lives a living hell.

    Reply
  • Have these kids never heard of an “off” switch?

    Reply
    • They can’t turn off the bullys PC

      Reply
    • you can’t turn a bully off, it would be great if you could, some kids can’t look at a text without feeling worried, or look at their facebook page, twitter account or email without being worried, they can’t cross the road, go to the cinema, go to school, go into town, without feeling worried, your comment does not help these kids. you can’t turn off a bully….. they are everywhere the kid goes, either in a true physical form or in their mind dictating every safe move the kid can make without running into their tormentor/s.

      Reply
    • there is a huge confusion over what the problem is, it is not the medium. The media however love using the word “Cyber” as it sells well.
      The problem with this conception is that it misses the point. Cyber bullying isn’t a new type of bullying, it’s the exact same as old bullying, the only difference is that because we are now connected to one another on a near constant basis one is no longer freed from one’s tormentors by mere physical distance.
      If cyber bullying were just about mean comments being posted to Facebook that would be one thing, you can just turn that off. That’s not the point though, because cyber bullying is simply an extension of the social isolation or physical intimidation that is occurring anyway in the “real world”.
      There is another side to this though. Kids are thick, they often don’t understand how the internet works, and that stuff they put up here is public and often easily traceable. Schools need to use this to their advantage, both to hunt out bullies but more importantly to identify those being bullied so that they can be helped before really bad things start to happen.

      Reply
  • Aside from the obvious difference between online and physical abuse, would they not both be equally bad?

    Reply
  • Support 30/11/12 #

    Thr children in the survey say they ‘cant escape’ cyberbullying. Unlike traditional bullying you can escape cyber bullying. Turn off the mobile, twitter and facebook account until you are strong enough or old enough to handle the bully. Dont get sucked into gathering evidence. This will harm you more thsn the bullying. Be the first to run and sabe your life. This is not a sign of weakness.

    Reply
    • As another commenter above pointed out, they can switch off the pc / phone but that doesn’t mean it stops.

      So they avoid Facebook, next day in school everyone’s pointing and laughing, they don’t know why.. It’s because someone shared a really nasty picture / rumour / video about them on Facebook the night before and EVERYONE saw it – except them..

      Just saying “switch off the pc / phone” is like the “just walk away” we got in school when I was a kid.. Thing is, when you’re surrounded by a group and there’s no exit – how is “just walk away” supposed to help? If all of your year are seeing the bullies posts, the victim turning off their devices does nothing but bury their head in the sand..

      Reporting and taking screenshots are actually a far more beneficial thing to do. It empowers the victim, allowing them to feel that they have *some* control over the situation, no matter how limited. It also gives them evidence to ensure that the bully is punished for their behaviour.
      The punishment however needs to work on actually discouraging the behaviour rather than making it worse (might be worth bullies being forced to take courses on emotional development to encourage their empathy and hopefully make them think about their actions).

      Reply
  • Kids these days need to toughen up!

    Reply
    • thank you, finally someone pointing out that while steps need to be taken to overcome bullies, people needs to strengthen themselves too. It’s a cruel world out there, and telling and treating them like it’s not is doing them a disservice.

      society doesn’t exists solely for the individual.

      Reply
    • Ah ya, sure there’s nothing like a bit of Victim Blaming. It’s not the bullies who are the problem, it’s the victims for not being tough enough or some bullshit.

      Reply
    • True, kids think a few mean words on the internet are bullying, theyve gone soft

      Reply
    • John and Stephen.
      It’s not just about a few unkind words. If you think it is then it’s your misunderstanding of the situation that’s at fault here.
      Read the article, there’s texts, newsfeeds, pictures and videos.. So this includes;
      •Threats received via any medium
      •Pictures of the victim being circulated – perhaps an embarrassing picture, a picture of them being bullied, an edited picture of them intended to mock them etc
      •videos would be quite similar – videos of bullies picking on victims, videos of victims being demeaned..

      It was one thing when we were growing up, a gang of bullies corners you and humiliates you and all they can do is spread a rumour, these days they can capture the whole event and share it with the world.. Which they delight in doing.

      Your lack of compassion is quite disturbing. Perhaps you were lucky enough not to get picked on at school – or maybe you did and you have buried it so deep inside that you can’t allow yourself to be empathetic to the victims in case you have to face how it made you feel.
      Kids do need to have their self confidence aided and developed, but many parents are simply useless at doing this or don’t care at all, and it’s THEIR kids who get bullied..

      For goodness sake have a heart.. These kids are still growing and learning, their egos haven’t developed to the same level of excess that you guys obviously have.

      Reply

Add New Comment