TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

‘Welcome to Northern Ireland’ signs spark political row

Two signs have already been illegally removed and Sinn Féin representative Phil Flanagan said they are “a waste of money”.

One of the signs on the Belcoo - Blacklion border
One of the signs on the Belcoo - Blacklion border

TWO SIGNS PLACED in border counties welcoming people to Northern Ireland have been removed as a political row breaks out between Sinn Féin and DUP representatives.

The Roads Service said signs have been erected to remind drivers entering the country that speed limits are displayed in miles per hour and these signs were being supplemented with ‘Welcome to Northern Ireland’ signs to “indicate the change of jurisdiction”.

Nine signs have already been erected at a cost of around £1700 and three more will go up in the next few months. The Roads Service said the two signs that have been taken down will be replaced in due course.

Sinn Féin MLA for Fermanagh and South Tyrone Phil Flanagan told TheJournal.ie that the signs were a “waste of money” and one of the main problems he has with them is “the manner in which they were put up”.

“There was no discussion whatsoever with the people in the communities and people living on the borders are impacted on by partition every day,” he said. ”They need to stop, slow down and talk to people.”

Flanagan said there will be a considerable amount of money spent replacing the signs that have been taken down and this money would be better spent on improving the quality of roads in Northern Ireland.

However Alastair Ross, DUP MLA for East Antrim said he rejected Sinn Féin’s argument that it was a matter of money and said it is “a political issue for the party”.

“It’s high time that those who are stuck in the past in Sinn Féin realise that Northern Ireland is a country and the Republic is a different country” he said. “They’re fighting a political battle that their electorate has abandoned.”

Ross said it is important that tourists are informed that they are entering a new jurisdiction and said he was horrified at the idea that people were removing signs.

“Regardless of whether or not you support it people should not take the law into their own hands,” he said.

The PSNI said there has been no official complaint made to them about the removal of the signs.

Read: Dissident republican groups merge to form ‘new IRA’>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (248 Comments)

  • They don’t need the signs, I got all the warning I needed with a €15 roaming charge for 10 minutes checking Google Maps

    Reply
  • Anyway, you’d think they would be more creative about it and tipex out the “Northern” bit!

    Reply
  • “WELCOME” seems to be the hardest word,,

    Reply
  • I think it’s disgraceful that ‘Northern Ireland’ is written entirely in BLOCK CAPITALS. That’s precisely the kind of SHOUTY RHETORIC I thought we’d all voted against…or something.

    And I’m really not sure about that font. Comic Sans would be more welcoming no? Might take the edges off the whole block capitals thing.

    And what’s all this black text on a white background? That’s just laughing in the face of health and safety so it is. Everyone knows that black and yellow provides optimum visual contrast.

    I remember when people instantly knew they’d crossed the border because the road surface suddenly improved. But those days are long gone now so they are…

    Reply
  • Can someone quietly turn the signs around the other way but don’t tell Darragh Quinn.

    Reply
  • sometimes i think that people look for things to be offended by………

    Reply
    • Rob 07/08/12 #

      Any political signs are too much. They are an obnoxious, irritating, constant droning in our faces filled with 1/2 truths, complete fabrications, and super-egos. The time spent watching/listening to political ads is time that will never be recovered.

      I am less likely to visit the north with signs like these.

      Reply
    • and as if to prove my point along comes Rob :)

      Reply
    • Barry 07/08/12 #

      Rob, its not political its the area’s name.
      Whatever you do don’t use google maps and search for “Northern Ireland, United Kingdom” you’ll get very upset.

      I suppose the paranoid people out there might think Google are siding with the english government on all of this and other such nonsense,

      Reply
    • Rob 07/08/12 #

      DisgruntledCitizen,

      Most of the posters on this article are stupid.

      The truth is that these signs create division. They won’t last long. People will remove them.

      Now go join your Unionist buddies all you right-wingers. You can emigrate there anytime.

      Reply
  • Barry 07/08/12 #

    Lads, like it or not its a different country for now so its only right there be signs up showing this to make people aware of it. Grow up you bunch of children!

    Reply
    • Exactly. People need to be aware of when they are crossing the border. Apart from our trivial little things like roaming charges, there are more serious issues at hand. For example, a non EU citizen touring Ireland could inadvertently cross the border and therefore be illegally in the UK.

      Reply
    • Barry,

      so which ideas would those be then?

      Start recognizing the facts surrounding the colonization of OUR land.

      You are parroting the ideas of Ian Paisley, not the free Ireland.

      Reply
  • Tim’s top 5 comments

    “I presume you were dropped on your head as a baby”

    “How placid are you?”

    “It’s our country. The problem lies with the politicized Roads Service who decided to open up sectarian division by erecting these signs. Hopefully someone uproots them.”

    “Northern Ireland is a disputed territory”

    “Were you born yesterday Kevin?”

    Profound contributions from a supporter of Sinn Fein Youf.

    Reply
    • Just to clarify, not my comments, the other Tim… :)

      Reply
    • You mean the one with the lovely British protestant name, Tim Jackson???
      The one who seems to hate the Brits but has a very British name unless hes hiding his true self??

      Reply
    • Shameless sectarianism Tommy. What just because someone has a “British protestant name” they can’t be a republican? – Tone, Emmet, Mitchel, Pearse ring any bells?

      And having nationalist/republican views does not equate to “hating the Brits”.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      Gearóid, I couldnt care less where someone is from or what their religion is.
      NI is separate to the Republic and the beauty of NI is that the people who live there can determine for themselves if they are irish or British. They can even be both and more power to them!
      What i cannot stand is sectarianism and this ‘its our country’ crap is utter bull too. The 6 counties are part of Britain. The majority of people in NI in recent polls seem happy to stay as part of Britain too. Let them decide their own fate, it should not be decided by people in ROI as we are not affected by how those in NI live their lives.

      Reply
    • The Irish nation is homogeneous group that has historically inhabited the 32 counties of Ireland, hence “it’s our country”. You might find that fact banal, but it’s true. If people consider themselves British, let them at it, but they have no right to impose an arbitrary border and maintain a military presence in Ireland. The 6 counties are not “part of Britain”, Britain is a separate island. As regards polls, the very existence of this arbitrary border ensures a Unionist majority, thus denying the nationalist community a fair and just say on the national question. Furthermore, why shouldn’t we have a say in how the 6 counties are run? Roughly 40% of people who live there are Irish citizens, and god knows Britain have been meddling for long enough. Also, the border has had an adverse affect on the Irish economy, the border area in particular, and any potential United Ireland we will all have to live in, so it does affect us.

      Reply
    • Tommy C,

      Having a British name doesn’t necessarily entail I am a loyalist. In fact, if that’s all you’ve got, then stay at home.

      Reply
    • Paul Lanigan,

      Sometimes it’s best to shorten my comments for stupid people. For example, you and your right-wingers on this forum see me as being a SF supporter just because I oppose these signs. That in itself is a form of intellectual stupidity. But I do NOT care what you or anyone like you thinks…. I will not be subverted by intellects. I shall give my view if I see fit. Not to satisfy you or any right-winger like you.

      Reply
    • Gearóid. Your assertion about the Irish people is twaddle. We are from all over, not just Britain but Asia, Eastern Europe and, significantly, Northern Spain. The strong Spanish connection was recently proven throughDNA research. I’m not at all surprised that you have it utterly wrong. But do us a favour. If you’re going to bang on and on about something, at least do us the courtesy of checking your facts.

      Reply
    • I’m well aware of the origins of the Irish people. It’s a rich tapestry, as are all nations.

      By going back into pre-history, essentially what you’re saying is: that there is no basis for modern nation states, thus no need for borders – Surely you find the border in question absurd then?

      Reply
    • Our British, Celtic, Norse and, largely, Spanish blood is from historical times, not pre-historic. God knows where we’re from originally.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      Gearoid, you just said we are homogenous but now we are a rich tapestry. WHICH IS IT?

      Reply
    • Both. Our origins are diverse, but over time these differences become subsumed into one homogeneous group. Unless you’ve seen any Normans or Vikings around lately?

      This debate is getting very abstract now…

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      SO by homogeneous you mean we can have red hair, blonde hair, brown hair, black hair and we can have green, grey,blue,brown,hazel eyes? Some of us can have pale skin, sallow skin, freckles? Yeah thats real homogenous. Pretty much like the spanish or Italians who actually do tend to be homogenous.

      Reply
    • Culturally homogeneous. I wasn’t eluding to any kind “ethnic” nationalism, which I strongly disagree with. Anyway, this could go on all night so this will be my last comment.

      Back to actual article in question, perhaps a compromise could be if the sign read “Fáilte go dtí Thuaisceart Éireann!”

      Reply
  • The sign in Belcoo has already been taken down it seems. This is great news when the roads in Fermanagh have potholes big enough to hid a couple of Chilean Miners down them, the Roads Service will waste its money putting this sign up every time the locals of Belcoo decide to take it down every time they leave the pub.

    Why didn’t they replace the Welcome to Fermanagh signs instead? they were looking a bit dirty.

    Reply
  • What’s the problem with them? Northern Ireland is a state, separate from the Irish republic.

    And the Shinners have to recognise this, as the sit in the Northern Ireland Assembly and the Dail.

    Reply
    • Northern Ireland is a disputed territory.

      Reply
    • Sorry Tim. You’re wrong. The Republic of Ireland gave up its claim to Northern Ireland with the signing of the Good Friday Agreement.

      It’s far from a disputed territory

      Reply
    • @Sean Cafferkey you`re wrong the rep of ire gave up the north when the free state was formed and we`ve been fighting for it since

      Reply
    • Sorry Philip. Facts have proven you wrong. Amendment 19 of the Constitution of The Republic of Ireland states: “Allowed the State to consent to be bound by the British-Irish Agreement done at Belfast on 10 April 1998 and provided that certain further amendments to the Constitution, notably to Articles 2 and 3, would come into effect when that agreement entered into force”

      Before 1998, Articles 2 & 3 state:
      Article 2.
      The national territory consists of the whole island of Ireland, its islands and the territorial seas.
      Article 3.
      Pending the re-integration of the national territory, and without prejudice to the right of the Parliament and Government established by this Constitution to exercise jurisdiction over the whole of that territory, the laws enacted by that Parliament shall have the like area and extent of application as the laws of Saorstát Éireann and the like extra-territorial effect.

      After 1998, Articles 2 & 3 state:
      Article 2.
      It is the entitlement and birthright of every person born in the island of Ireland, which includes its islands and seas, to be part of the Irish nation. That is also the entitlement of all persons otherwise qualified in accordance with law to be citizens of Ireland. Furthermore, the Irish nation cherishes its special affinity with people of Irish ancestry living abroad who share its cultural identity and heritage.

      Article 3.
      1. It is the firm will of the Irish nation, in harmony and friendship, to unite all the people who share the territory of the island of Ireland, in all the diversity of their identities and traditions, recognising that a united Ireland shall be brought about only by peaceful means with the consent of a majority of the people, democratically expressed, in both jurisdictions in the island. Until then, the laws enacted by the Parliament established by this Constitution shall have the like area and extent of application as the laws enacted by the Parliament that existed immediately before the coming into operation of this Constitution.

      2. Institutions with executive powers and functions that are shared between those jurisdictions may be established by their respective responsible authorities for stated purposes and may exercise powers and functions in respect of all or any part of the island.

      Reply
    • when michael collins signed the treaty he signed away the 6 counties so we could form the free state

      Reply
    • Yes Philip, Collins did do that in the 1920s but up until 1998 the Republic held a territorial claim to Northern Ireland. They gave that up in 1998 with the above Amendment. Facts are facts. Can’t be disproved

      Reply
    • Since when has the Irish state given a hoot about the North? They’re more interested in feathering their own nests, and defending some pseudo independent “state”, rather than an actual viable Irish nation. Just because it’s in “Bunreacht na hÉireann” doesn’t mean it some immutable truth. The articles you quoted are nothing more than connivance with an imperialist British state and the subversion of Irish nationhood.

      Reply
    • And that’s why 72% of the turnout (81%) in Northern Ireland voted yes while 94% of the turnout (56%) said yes in the Republic. Idiotic comments Gearóid. Quit living in the past and come enjoy the present with the rest of us

      Reply
    • They were voting on a peace agreement, not on the national question. The GFA doesn’t legitimise partition, nor can any other act of underhanded British diplomacy.

      Reply
    • Seán Cafferkey,

      The 6 counties are a disputed territory politically. Irish political parties across the 32 counties did Not give up their claim. A fact often overlooked by loyalist settlers like you and your supporters on here.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 08/08/12 #

      I reckon anyone with the surname Jackson is of ‘settler’ stock Tim. Its not really a traditional Irish name now is it?

      Reply
  • what’s the big deal everyone calls it northern Ireland so what’s the problem???

    Reply
  • Ah it’s August. This is one of those silly season stories.

    Reply
  • I think it was utterly pointless putting them up. I live about 5 miles from the border in Fermanagh I passed sign in Belcoo on Sunday. I think its utterly pointless mainly because there are big signs already saying welcome to Cavan/Fermanagh Already and road signs telling you about the speed changes.
    The border is such an arbitrary thing. If you think there is a difference between a field in Cavan and a Field in Fermanagh then you are an idea. Politicians on both sides of this arbitrary line should be working out how to bring the counties of Derry,Donegal, Tyrone, Cavan,Monaghan Fermanagh, Louth and Armagh together instead of pointing out a division that some eejit thought it was a good idea to impose 90 years ago

    Reply
  • It’s a terrible shame that the comments section of anything relating to NI here is always reduced, almost instantly, by the uninformed, to arguments on whose grandad was at fault or who said what first by those who’ve never read, never mind know the details of, the Good Friday Agreement which was democratically accepted in 1998.

    Is no one else a bit pissed that it cost £1700 to put up nine signs??

    Reply
    • It’s less than 200 quid a sign, and with the cost of metal these days (plus labour) that’s not bad.

      In fact I wouldn’t be surprised if they were taken for their scrap value rather than for sectarian values.

      Reply
    • you could have filled a dozen potholes for the cost of each sign. And im not factoring in the weekly cost to the roads service putting the signs back up and cleaning them of Graffiti.

      Reply
  • Get real ffs. What a silly thing to argue about.

    Reply
    • Were you born yesterday Kevin?

      Reply
    • Rob 07/08/12 #

      @ Kevin O’Sullivan

      what crack are you smoking?
      Your first sentence is ungrammatical. It should read “what a silly thing to place in Ireland” rather than “argue about”.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      Tim and Rob, get a room!!

      Reply
    • There is some nonsense on here about road signs, what we should be doing is applauding all those people from all parts of the island who come together to play rugby, cricket, hockey boxing , athletics, equestrian motorsports , golf and many more sports . The can all play on one team and are all irish of one degree or another, despite the politicans on both sides continually stirring it up. And despite 3 bigoted rowers from coleraine. . I think that a compromise flag and anthem is the way to go in these sport and then see what happens.in soccer . But keep the sinners and the dup far away from these sports people.

      Reply
  • The IQ of your average SF/IRA person is questionable as they seem to think that signs cause divisions. BOMBS ON INNOCENT PEOPLE CAUSE DIVISIONS.

    Reply
    • That goes for LOYALIST TERRISTS who bombed Dublin & Monaghan.

      Oh wait, your eternal smug hubris convinces you… You are a typical illiterate, ill-informed bigoted unionist.

      Reply
    • That goes for LOYALIST TERRORISTS who bombed Dublin & Monaghan.

      Oh wait, your eternal smug hubris convinces you… You are a typical illiterate, ill-informed bigoted unionist.

      Good luck with these signs if it gives you an even bigger ego.

      Reply
    • @Tim – I pointed out your SF loyalties because you have ‘liked’ three separate SF groups on you FB profile. You say I’m ‘right wing’ but if you knew anything you’d know that right wingers are traditionally opposed the change (conservative) and its the shimmers in this thread that seem most opposed to changed.

      But reading your contributions I am reminded of the Mark Twain quote “never argue with a fool, they will bring you down to their level and beat you with experience”

      Silly me :-)

      Reply
    • Paul: I could swear some of your political leaders idolize Adolf Hitler. Maybe I’m wrong, but they sure seem to be following some of his policies on these controversial signs.

      Reply
  • Driving through Tyrone last week I was glad to see that the locals had the good sense to paint over the “londonderry” signs

    Reply
    • I remember hearing someone mention that too. They said they used a steel blade to permanently scrape/engrave out the ‘London’ part so that the Roads Service couldn’t simply come along without forking out several £££ on a new sign!

      Reply
  • So where’s the ones saying welcome to the republic of Ireland ?

    Reply
  • Who cares??

    Reply
  • Seems pretty reasonable to inform people they are entering a different country.

    Reply
  • mcbab 07/08/12 #

    Shinners in denial? What else is new.

    Reply
  • paul 07/08/12 #

    should say “beware. your in northern Ireland”

    Reply
  • SF Minister says something is a waste of money :P

    Reply
  • Correct me if I’m wrong but is Belcoo not in Northern Ireland and Blacklion not in the Republic of Ireland? What’s the big deal SF?

    Reply
  • The 6 counties make up an area known as Northern Ireland regardless of anyones political affiliation, thats what its called. If you dont like it, tough!

    Reply
  • Good Lord you can’t even erect a small simple road sign in that place and a huge sectarian row brakes out that rakes over the coals of the past, I’m sick to the teeth of the lot of them.

    Reply
  • In Blacklion and environs they could change it to “Welcome to Quinn Territory”

    Reply
  • Rob you should be careful what you wish for. What would you do with all your free time if Ireland were ever to get back the 6 counties? Where would all that anger and indignation at inanimate objects go?
    When I was going into China they took my Lonely Planet guide book and tore out the pages that referred to Taiwan as independent and separate. This furore is far more amusing. But just as pathetic.

    Reply
  • I’m not against these road signs per se, but a lot of people do seem to be very upset by them. A lot of people in the areas obviously aren’t ready yet to accept such signs, so instead of them being put up and taken down over and over again, just stop wasting money on them. No need to create a problem where there was no problem in the first place. They are not essential and can be lived without… now a much bigger issue was the mad idea to change all the signs that said Dingle to An Daingean!

    Reply
  • I think they should take the offending road signs down, and as as a sign of equal good will, the Welcome to Free Derry wall should be painted white, for peace. Will the Sinn Fein supporters please get ALL the chips off their shoulders and try to catch up with the real world of 21st Century Ireland where people north and south voted unanimously for peace.

    Reply
    • Joe,

      How exactly does opposing these signs violate the peace process?

      Reply
    • Lamb 08/08/12 #

      Tim, Ireland signed a treaty ceding claim over Northern Ireland, this is not a disputed territory any longer, the Republican movement were involved. I was there watching Gerry Adams and Sinn Fein and a big precession celebrating it through the streets of Dublin, mostly Republicans. Time to move on.

      Reply
  • mcbab 07/08/12 #

    This gets so wearisome! Up in arms over road signs ! Everywhere you go in the world there are signs telling you when you are entering a different jurisdiction. Why are these simple things such a problem with some people. They must have little to worry about. If I was a tourist I would certainly like to know when I have driven into a different jurisdiction.

    Reply
  • ECP 07/08/12 #

    Virginia you are also hanging out in a country you don’t belong in- it is a native Indian land that was also colonised by England, all the Indian communities were destroyed, your legacy is the same as Dylan’s, your a decendent of a colonising force. You are also adding uneducated fuel to a fire. I am not living in the north, I was born and raised in Dublin and I know that being antogonistic is NOT THE WAY FOrWaRd. Do people shout at you for living in a country that was colonised by people you never met cause that’s your situation too

    Reply
  • When you enter Wales and Scotland from England are there signs? Everything has to be anylised and taken apart. Northern Ireland is a seperate country so let them have their signs. Third world problems

    Reply
  • If Alistair Ross and other Unionists were really willing to extend a welcome to people residing in 26C he might consider speaking out re burning of our national flag at their 12th July “celebrations”! I’d like to see Unionists start giving a bit rather than trying to antagonise republicans.

    Peace on our island is still very fragile. I’m not really feeling the “welcome”. Must try harder Alistair.

    Reply
  • Sad Shinners as usual. I suppose we should be grateful they’re not shooting the people putting up the signs.

    Reply
    • I presume you were dropped on your head as a baby.

      Reply
    • That’s just so clever. Damn, you’ve won the argument with a clever point like that!

      Reply
    • Rob 07/08/12 #

      @ Paddy Murray,

      Are you a unionist by any chance?

      In the past few years, the bizarre event is that the hard right, represented by many posters like you here and on the echo-chamber airwaves, have begun to borrow the most vile and disgusting habit of the 1920’s – painting yourselves as victims

      The media is bad
      Political signs are bad
      Right-wing nuts are bad
      Reporters hate Republicans..

      You on the other hand are pontificating from an isolationist position, Paddy.

      Reply
    • No I am not a Unionist. I am an Irish Republican who was ashamed to describe himself as such when psychopaths who hijacked the name, murdered hundreds of their fellow Irishmen, who didn’t share their point of view.

      Reply
    • Paddy for an old man ye still have a bit of growing up to do …… God bless ye !!

      Reply
    • If growing up means approving of sectarian murder, no warning bombs and killing children, I think I’ll stay the way I am.

      Reply
    • No paddy growing up as in not making a joke out of people being shot….. You say your Irish republican can you explaine what this means thanks and just bear in mind the whole notion of republicanism comes from military action be it American , French , Irish ect , what part of all that are u proud of thanks ??

      Reply
    • Darren 07/08/12 #

      No paddy growing up as in not making a joke out of people being shot….. You say your Irish republican can you explain what this means thanks and just bear in mind the whole notion of republicanism comes from military action be it American , French , Irish ect , what part of all that are u proud of thanks ??

      Reply
    • Darren,
      Dictionary definition: 1.
      of, pertaining to, or of the nature of a republic.
      2.
      favoring a republic.
      3.
      fitting or appropriate for the citizen of a republic: a very republican notion.
      4.
      a person who favors a republican form of government.

      Give us a shout when you come across the bit about no- warning car bombs, disappearing people, sectarian massacres and murdering children.

      Reply
    • Darren 07/08/12 #

      Paddy I never agreed with and never will agree that car bombs or killing of children are anything other than wrong simple as that ……
      However you need to leave your hatred of certin people where it belongs in the past….. As we all move on

      Reply
    • Darren 07/08/12 #

      P.s paddy your definition of republican was wonderfull except the part about how the actual republic was formed bombs guns killings all the stuff from which most republics come from …..
      Again leave your hatred in the past where it belongs !!

      Reply
    • You are confused. I hate nobody. I hate murder.
      Criticism or even condemnation do not translate into hatred. Shooting men dead at Teebane and Kingsmill does. And don’t say it’s in the past because it’s not for the families.

      Reply
    • Darren 07/08/12 #

      Paddy that’s family’s on Both sides ……. So where does that leave us .? Should we all just give up and start fighting again ??

      Reply
    • You don’t get it do you? Of course it doesn’t mean fighting. It means stop spending your time waiting to be offended by slightest little thing. Get on with it. Help the disadvantaged. Use your considerable energy to help others. Patriotism is wonderful. Nationalism is a curse.

      Reply
    • Good man Tim. Utterly inaccurate, juvenile, the kind of argument I would expect from your ilk. Oh. It’s also libellous

      Reply
    • Hey! Ladies calm down and put your differences and handbags aside.

      Reply
    • You as a Labour Party Supporter , One would have expected a little more rationality from a person with Socialist and your stated in further blogs – your stated Republicanism, instead of a Labour Party personal anti SF rant.
      Are Labour Party Members so afraid of the future of the Party arising from your Coalition contamination with FG , that you are already pre-electioneering , by attacking below the belt, the sole Socialist principled Party left in the Country – all 32 Counties, I might add!

      Reply
    • ……. or the loyalists, those taking them down.

      Reply
    • Oh. So murder is ‘principled’ is it? Kneecapping? Bank robberies? Killing gardai? Is Three Homes Adams, who flies First Class to the States at socialist?

      Reply
    • My God Paddy – as a declared Republican , you appear to have forgotten that the war is over – with an Internationally recognised treaty in place – SF are sharing Government in The Six Counties and are gradually rising % wise, in most every Poll taken in the 26 Counties – you as a Labour Party man surely knows the effect that this will have on what will remain of the Labour Party – when then have been further contaminated by Coalition with FG – like after the 1997 election.

      It looks like SF will be the second biggest Party electorally on the Island of Ireland in the next five years.

      Interesting times ahead towards the uniting of the people living on this Island of Ireland of ours.

      Isn’t this really what your hatred of SF is about ?

      Reply
    • Tim, Darren and Rob. The Larry, Curley and Moe of thejournal. At least be funny, lads, would ye?

      Reply
    • Paddy your constant oversimplification of the conflict in Ireland would be amusing if it wasn’t so disrespectful. You persistently try to portray the Republican Movement as a group of people who just decided one afternoon to take up arms for a laugh.

      We outside the realm of right-wing lunacy know that Republicanism, such as the Republicanism that demanded an alternative to the constitutional arrangements that existed pre-1998 in the occupied 6 counties was legitimate. It is also evident that the armed struggle employed by the Irish Republican Army was undertaken as an option of last resort.

      Now nobody in their right mind could support every action of the IRA, indeed some acts where cynical, unnecessary and some just plain wrong, and as a Sinn Féin member I have no problem condemning such actions. But to imply that the Republican Movement as a whole where perpetually hawkish, while ignoring completely the hostile forces of British Occupation, demonstrates either one of two things in my opinion.

      Either, you literally have no knowledge of Irish history or more likely that you wantonly ignore the realities of Irish history due to your political opposition of what Irish Republicanism stands for.

      Reply
    • Antoin. You might let me know which IRA murders were acceptable to you. Teebane? Kingsmill? Bloody Friday? Warrington? Claudy? You might give me a list of the people who you believe the IRA was right to kill or maim.
      I know my Irish history very, very well.
      I have never excused or justified the murderous excesses of the Brits. The difference is, that the IRA murdered in my name and they hijacked my flag.
      It is wonderful to hear Shinners quoting history while at the same time telling us to ‘move on’ from the death and mayhem perpetrated by the IRA.
      Sinn Fein, rightly, wants an inquiry in the murder of Pat Funicane but resolutely fefuses to come clean on its campaign of mass murder.
      Remember the IRA killed more Irish men, women and children, than the Brits, the RUC and Loyalist terrorists combined.

      Reply
    • Firstly, Sinn Féin have never engaged in armed conflict,it is a political party. Secondly, Sinn Féin have stated that it supports a truth an reconciliation process for all the victims of the conflict. I understand your agenda to imply Sinn Féin and the IRA are the same, but once again your understanding of the situation and the reality of the situation are two very different things.

      Its certainly not my place to clarify what actions taken during the conflict were legitimate. My opinion is that the conditions that existed in the 6 counties from the 20s to the late 60s led to a situation of revolt and counter revolt and the logical consequence was armed conflict.

      I make no apologies for believing that within that framework, armed struggle was on the whole justifiable.

      Reply
    • There is nothing more disrespectful than the taking of human life, few things more hypocritical than endorsing murder and claiming to be Christian.
      It IS up to you to justify what murders you think legitimate. It is you who has differentiated between ‘mistakes’ and otherwise. You are clearly no braver than First Class Adams or McGuinness when it comes to acknowledging what the IRA did.
      As for your organisation, Sinn Fein, being separate from the IRA, I presume the cross membership, Adams cheerfully telling us they hadn’t gone away and carrying the coffin of the Shankill bomber and other murderers is nothing but an unfortunate coincidence.

      Reply
    • Tim Jackson SF minister of diplomacy

      Reply
    • Once again Paddy a chara, you are creating your own little bubble of belligerence. Why not address the issues that I have raised, and stop trying to pull on the heart strings to justify your argument.I am aware hyperbole is your bread and butter but still, I hoped for some meaningful discourse. Once again you blissfully ignored the fact that Sinn Féin have called for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Martin McGuinness has expressed disgust at certain IRA actions.

      My point about the Armed Conflict in general was that it was an inevitability, and Republicanism had no other recourse. When a sustainable peaceful strategy was negotiated the Republican Movement was to the forefront in making that peace work, even today Sinn Féin strives to propagate a lasting peace based on equality.

      Presumptions are inherently subjective and considering your proclivities against Sinn Féin, it would be fairly safe to say that your presumptions about Sinn Féin and the IRA are probably a little bit biased.

      Reply
    • Well, Antoin, you have me there. I AM biased against murder.
      Typically, y ou avoid answering the hard question. Which murders were justified in your eyes?
      And as for truth?
      You are joking!!
      First Class Three Homes Adams won’t admit he was ever in the IRA. McGuinness has admitted nothing at all. This is the organisation which allowed the Birmingham SIx, Guildford Four, Judith Ward and others to languish in jail, while knowing all along who had committed the crimes for which they were wrongly jailed.
      Truth and Sinn Fein are not companies.
      They are fierce enemies.
      Justify murder all you like.
      I am done conversing with people like you who justify the taking of human life.
      Like all Shinners, you think you have some God given right to applaud the taking of life.
      You don’t.
      Only God does.

      Reply
    • @ Amy Duskwalker . You’d think a Shinner higher-up would take Tim aside and have a quiet word, he’s not exactly improving their standing any. Good name, but the way.

      Reply
  • Dec Rowe 07/08/12 #

    Down with this sort of thing!

    Reply
  • it is only a matter of time before they get vandalised for sure, they wont last.

    Reply
  • Fact is, it is a separate country. The signs should be there. I’m at a loss to come up with any argument to support why the border should not be indicated.

    Reply
  • How about Welcome to Ulster at the Meath/Cavan border etc and dump the provocative NI signs?

    Reply
  • You get a text on your phone to let you know and the road markings are different. It would fit them better to invest money in improving the roads along the border. The bog lands have destroyed the road between Newtownbutler and Belturbet for instance. Furthermore, there are usually flags erected to let you know either! The signs are pointless and an attempt to ignite futile arguments.

    Reply
  • Silly nonsense by Alastair Ross – who knows full well that a consensus must be achieved between both sides , before any signs are agreed and erected .
    Northern Ireland “a Country” ! – he is a laugh and needs to learn his geography and read The Good Friday Agreement too.
    It’s neither a Country nor a Province , nor Ulster, as he well knows.
    The Six Counties only represent two thirds of the Ulster Province, one of the Four Provinces of Ireland .

    Reply
    • And the area is still called Northern Ireland and not the 6 counties.
      Have you ever met someone on holidays who told you they were from ‘one of the 6 counties’when asked cos I havent. I have however been told that they were from Northern Ireland, regardless of their surname.

      Reply
    • Tommy C,

      As a matter of fact, I overheard someone say they were from county Derry yesterday. I also overheard that some were planning to pull these signs to the ground and sold to a scrap metal merchant afterwards.

      Reply
    • Alien8 07/08/12 #

      The country is called “Northern Ireland”. It has a de facto Capital. It is one of the countries of the sovereign state, “The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland” and is recognised as a country by the United Nations.

      For “Ulster”, all of the counties within Northern Ireland are a part of the province of Ulster, which is a non-political entity, similar to a “parish”, or “region” and has no standing outside of private organisations (i.e. rugby and GAA) that use the historical names of provinces to group historical counties.

      The country to the south, west and north of Northern Ireland on the island of Ireland is “Ireland”

      Where is our “Welcome to Ireland” sign?

      Reply
  • They should read welcome to the UK. It is part of that jurisdiction. Personally I’d prefer if they’d erect a wall and seal off the place. It’s a cesspit of human misery, bigotry and xenophobia.

    Reply
  • All this grandstanding and blustering! Bloody hell! I’m a nationalist but I would rather the North remain under British rule if it meant that there was peace on this island.

    Reply
  • tozyurt 07/08/12 #

    Last time I checked Northern Ireland is part of united kingdom not a separate country . Maybe they should indicate that in their welcome message …

    Reply
  • paul 07/08/12 #

    all you flag waving freaks can get the boat as far as I’m concerned.

    Reply
  • Haha. Some of the most ridiculous posts I’ve ever seen on Journal. It’s a sign that indicates a change of territory where the laws, currency and many other things are different. Like it or not it’s Northern Ireland all your little shouting and bullsh1t rhetoric won’t change that. Get over yourselves.

    Reply
    • It is changing. Population shift from 60% to just over 50% means the unionists can no longer proclaim an outright majority. This will continue to shrink over the coming years. Becoming desperate by erecting these signs as your last hope :-)

      Reply
    • Cool, couldn’t care less mate, there’d still have to be a vote in the Republic for it, and as much as I’m not arsed either way unification would never happen. Also I ain’t no Unionist either I’m simply Irish. sorry if I don’t conform to your belief or desires for Ireland. I’m sure you’ll come back with some comment slagging this and saying I’m this and that, but sadly for the people who want a unified Ireland it won’t happen for a good while yet. For the moment the sign simply serves purpose saying you’re entering a territory governed by different people to the one you’re leaving, makes sence. Take care man.

      Reply
  • really? there are welcome to Cork signs like, hardly screams WE OWN THIS LAND. not even a union jack on them, it IS northern Ireland like…

    Reply
  • How about “Welcome to the UK” as 84% of the people who live there said in a survey taken last year that they are happy to stay part of the UK.

    Reply
  • small minded people seem to think that if you state that your a republican that your automatically either sf ira or both, i am neither and i support a united free ireland 32 counties under the irish goverment for the support of the irish people and all who choose to call her home

    Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      And I wish more irish people learned their own language and culture than spent time worrying about the 6 counties.
      I think theres more chance that NI will become an Independent state than part of a united Ireland but as Im not from there, nothing that happens there politically, socially, tax wise, education wise, health wise etc affects me so leave it up to those who live there.

      Reply
    • It’s the gaelgoer set and their cultural fascism that keeps Ireland divided.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      Ah right, so you just want the ‘natives’ in Ireland but the one thing that makes them unique ie the language, you dont want any part of? Without a separate language, we are no different from the non native populations.
      What do you want? Ireland in name only?

      Reply
  • ECP 07/08/12 #

    I find it interesting that a sign can spark such a hefty discussion, the sign is indexical surely, the sign is never just a sign. The border is a psychological one, and this needs to be remedied too, the psychological border is one we negotiate ourselves. In this way the sign you are discussing is a decoy which diverges from the psychological aspect we should all be addressing. Think a moment about the geography of this island then travel north or south and you will reach a border, this border of the mind is harder to cross, So Virginia it is just as hard to cross for the ” real Irish” as you call them as it is for somebody living in the north as part a of great Britain

    Reply
  • There is a great article in the latest Phoenix magazine on how Nationalists will soon outnumber Unionists in the six counties. We will see a United Ireland in our lifetime, thank God. I know that will disappoint the assorted Fine Gaeler’s, Unionists, royalists and Norman west-brits who post here. We can count them by the number of thumbs down.

    Reply
    • A majority. There will be more in the North (that’s Northern Ireland) in favour of unity. But by then there’ll be a majority in the South against it.

      Reply
    • I wonder what would happen if that happened. The people of Northern Ireland voting to join the Republic of Ireland. Will it happen peacefully or will it lead to a long period of shootings, bombs and death? Is it something the Unionists will resist that way? Just a question, not a view one way or the other. Also, in any vote to separate from the UK, would they/should they also have the choice of becoming their own independent state? I really would like to know the views from people in Northern Ireland on this, because I have noticed there can be a fair bit of animosity shown towards the people from Northern Ireland by some people in the South (including Catholic/Nationalists)… so should we take it for granted that all the people in Northern Ireland we would expect to vote to join the Republic, will actually do that?

      Reply
  • “You’re welcome to Northern Ireland”

    Reply
  • I spent some time in “Northern” Ireland last year and live in the US. I thought it a slap in the face seeing the Union Jack flying high throughout these Counties and a stark reminder that the Orange walk mentality is so pervasive and the deep hatred towards the “real” Irish persists.
    Paddy I definitely think your responses are from a very threatened and fearful group of “Orange Walk” folks and it is a pointless argument. Let’s remind these folks Ireland belongs to the Irish and these folks should be respectful of it!!!!

    Reply
    • Dave 07/08/12 #

      The Unionists excel at flagwaving. Take a drive through Carrickfergus and take a look. But what actually hits you is that it’s a huge case of insecurity. As for the “oh, im not from there, doesnt bother me” brigade, do try think of your fellow Irish people who have to put up with this and the burning of our flag on a ritual basis.

      Reply
    • Thank you Ms. Kennedy. God bless Ireland and America.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      A slap in the face? Seriously, an American on here moaning about land being taken from the natives.
      Dont make me laugh Virginia. There are enough rednecks in your country for you to concern yourself with rather than concerning yourself with the one I live in.
      I see the American flag flying high all over the US. Is that a slap in the face for the native Americans? Are you going to stop flying the US flag incase it insults the natives?95% of posters on this topic are from the Republic of Ireland. DO not tell us how we should feel or act.

      Reply
    • who are the ” real Irish”?

      Reply
  • “Welcome to Occupied Ireland”

    Reply
    • Reg 07/08/12 #

      Who’s it occupied by? The people that are living there and that have lived there for years?

      Reply
    • Who? The biggest mass murdering terrorist group in history – The British Army.

      Planting British colonists doesn’t make it any less part of Ireland. No more than areas of Britain with significant Irish communities makes said areas any less part of Britain.

      Reply
    • Reg 07/08/12 #

      Well that’s strange Gearóid because I just spent the weekend in NI and didn’t see a single soldier. Just saw plenty of people going about their normal business and getting on with life.

      What was done two or three hundred years ago can’t be changed. What would you like to do, send them back to Scotland or wherever they cam from? Time for a dose of reality for you Gearóid!

      Reply
    • Rob 07/08/12 #

      Reg,

      They are pulling it over eyes without you realizing. It’s part of a slow process of institutional sectarianism which most posters on here are too dumb to even realize.

      Reply
    • So because you didn’t see any British soldiers they don’t exist? Impeccable logic there Reg. The British Army, MI5 and all their other colonial apparatus still maintain a presence in Ireland.

      And what part of my argument suggested sending people “back to Scotland”? The Unionist community have every right to be here, but not to subvert the will of the Irish people. The partition of Ireland was created by a criminal act of gunboat diplomacy, it is unjust and illegitimate. Perhaps it’s time for you to take the quasi-unionist blinkers off.

      Reply
    • Reg 07/08/12 #

      Oh I’m sure they exist alright Gearoid. Using emotive language like occupation is just emotive nonsense. Is Scotland occupied because BA soldiers are based there?

      Reply
    • How is it “emotive nonsense”? When exactly were the British Army invited into Ireland? It may not suit your apologetic point of view but the facts bear this out. I suppose your one of those people who think the British Army was some kind of benevolent peacekeeping force in Ireland.

      One could arguably make the case that Scotland is under occupation. I wouldn’t though, as Scotland has had a completely dynamic within the Union which doesn’t equate with Ireland. However, Alex Salmond famously said the British government was “a government of occupation” imposed on Scots.

      Reply
    • *different dynamic

      Reply
    • Reg 07/08/12 #

      You seem to be in a bit of a time warp Gearoid. Fast forward to 2012 and you will find that both Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own parliaments with many devolved powers. Still a work in progress though. The status of NI has been settled for the time being and until the people decide otherwise. That’s democracy.

      Reply
  • Many of the above comments show that there are two things in life that the Ulster Loyalists can always depend on…(1) The Orange Order (2) The contempt that west-brits in the free state have for the nationalists they abandoned in the north.

    Reply
  • Rob 07/08/12 #

    These signs create division. They won’t last long. People need to remove them.

    Reply
  • Actually Alister Ross, DUP MLA for East Antrim comment is incorrect. He states “It’s high time that those who are stuck in the past in Sinn Féin realise that Northern Ireland is a country and the Republic is a different country” he said. “They’re fighting a political battle that their electorate has abandoned.” Northern Ireland is not a country. By his and his own parties admission, he wishes Northern Ireland to remain part of the UK. Ergo Northern Ireland is not a country it is part of a country, As for a political battle that their electorate has abandoned,that is subjective reasoning. Sinn fein’s mandate has not changed and they continue to be elected both north and south in increasing numbers. If “their” electorate had abandoned the political battle as Alister stated then sinn fein would no longer be in government. As it stands and with their stated aims in place they continue to grow on both sides of the border. I am forced to wonder what reality Alister Ross is living in

    Reply
  • Donegal is in northern Ireland.

    Reply
  • Tommy C. That’s hilarious being called a Redneck. Actually, I was born and raised in Donegal and carry an Irish passport. I am returning to Ireland this year to take up the cause LOL

    Reply
  • Rob 07/08/12 #

    Disgrace. Hopefully people frequently vandalize them so that it costs more to replace them than is deemed worthwhile. The Roads Service clearly has blue noses working for them.

    Reply
    • mcbab 07/08/12 #

      Rob. You need to calm down !

      Reply
    • Rob relax there and reel your neck back in. You know nothing about my beliefs or political views so dont judge me. I can clearly see where you stand and that is your right, whether or not I agree with it does not give you the right to call me or others stupid. Let them put up signs, will it change anything, no. Has anybody ever asked the people of Northern Ireland what flag they wanted to salute?

      Reply
  • Dylan does it not bother you the English transplanted you in Ireland for the sole reason as a “buffer” between the real Irish and the English.. The real Irish should start erecting signs saying” welcome to the “Real Ireland” in the Republic and in the North… “welcome to buffer country” as a reminder of your status. You are people without a Country hanging out in a Country you don’t belong in!!!!

    Reply
    • Tommy C 07/08/12 #

      She is home! Shes in the US. Pretty much like anyone who is from NI is home regardless of them being a Republican , Loyalist or whatever. What happened in the past is done and for an American to claim that a person from NI of English, scottish heritage or whatever is a ”foreign settler” is the pot calling the kettle black.

      Reply
  • Amy:
    It DOSENT feel good when the tables start tipping in the opposite direction. Can you get an inkling of how an Irish Catholic felt in NI back in the day.

    Sent from my iPhone

    Reply
  • fao paddy murray how did you get your free state? was there never a shot fired, no murderers and no innocent ppl killed

    Reply
  • Ah.. the northern saga again…. Some day no one will give a shit. But for now let’s give them Cavan and Monaghan too.

    Reply
  • darren u may ha ha at it but for someone who came from the north to live in the south financialy and political the north are better off. even the brits could do a better job of running the country than ur so called lot of gombeans.

    Reply
  • Why you are just as racist!!! and running scared knowing that day will come when your walking papers will be handed out to you. I live in a neighborhood where Black, Arab, Polish, Italian, Hispanic, Irish, French American Indian live together sharing each other’s culture. I hang the American flag and the Green white and Gold flag together blowing in the wind. Americans have enormous respect for the Irish flag and the Irish people… Such a sharp contrast to what I experienced as an Irish Catholic in Ireland where people’s Civil rights were non-existent,treated as 2nd class Citizens in our own Country, where deplorable hatred from the Protestants was practiced on a daily basis. The English have you in their pocket and laughing at you for being so easily manipulated for hundreds of years.. Now you are a monkey on their shoulder… Insecurity leads to Agression and Agressors you are. Are the real Irish getting to close for comfort. A cornered Rat you are LOL

    Reply
    • Tommy C 08/08/12 #

      Thats great! So you live in a mixed area but youre going to come to ireland and insist that its not mixed! Youre the worst kind of migrant, a hypocrite and a bigot.
      You hang the green white and gold? Its green white and Orange Virginia. Do yu have a clue what the orange represents? The protestant people of this Island. They belong on this island as much as the rest of us regardless of religion or political affiliation/
      .My surname is O’Murchu by the way, just in case you were interested. Dad from Cork, Mam from Monaghan and Im born and raised in Dublin.
      Remeber that you and all those people you share a community with are settlers on native American land. How does that feel?

      Reply
    • Tommy C 08/08/12 #

      Americans do not have respect for the Irish people.I have seen that joke of a website irish central. The worst kind of bigots are on that site. Complaining about British people, Irish people having kids outside marriage, claiming the church has nothing to hide, complaining about contraception, migrants into Ireland. Disgusting.
      The fact that we have cars and electricity seems to upset them.
      They wont be happy until we are living in the Quiet man set. The might respect the irish of the 1950s but heaven forbid we have a contemporary culture!
      People like you just cannot see how you being a settler in the US is no different to those people of British lineage. You have more in common with them than anyone else.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 08/08/12 #

      the fact that you even use the term ‘real irish’ is disgusting.
      So I bet jason Sherlock, Paul McGrath, Phil Lynnott wouldnt be the ‘real irish’? What about our legend of a sports person Katie Taylor? her dad is from Yorkshire. Does this mean Katie isnt one of the ‘real irish’?

      Reply
    • Ms. Kennedy,

      Tommy C is a loyalist in disguise. They frequent this website anytime the issue of our 6 counties arises. Irish people LOVE America and Irish-Americans. Sometimes, loyalist protestants are referred to as blue-noses over here. They are basically part of a shrinking minority. They once represented 60% of the population. Today, they are just over 50%. I bet Tommy C is going out of his way because he knows we are maddening him!

      Reply
    • such respect for the Irish flag that you don’t know its true colours>>>

      Reply
  • Your lack of Historical facts is unpresidented and it’s impossible to respond to such Rhetoric. If you want to get the last word in to feel better about yourself Fine. Knock yourself out. It’s so typical of the mindset that prevails amongst Scotch/Irish. Always having to be right unable to think things through by yourself. Youre a dime a dozen. The English are mocking you for your overwhelming stupidity…

    Reply
  • Banana republic anyway

    Reply

Add New Comment