Skip to content
Support Us

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

nikitabuida via Shutterstock

Opinion What do crystal and bread rolls have in common?

We already recognise geographical reputation for foodstuffs but we should do likewise for local crafts – it has cultural and economic benefits.

WHAT DO PRODUCTS like Connemara Marble and Waterford Glass have in common with foodstuffs such as Connemara Hill Lamb or Waterford Blaa?

They are both Geographical Indications, or names linking a specific product with a specific origin.

What makes them different? Geographical Indications for foodstuffs are protected under a special European law, while geographical indications for non foodstuffs or industrial products are only protected under local Irish law.

The question of whether we should retain this distinction is not simply a legal one – it’s also about hard economics.

Cold, hard cash 

Research shows that protection under EU rules is worth hard cash. A 2012 study for the European Commission examined the value of registration as a European GI in the foodstuffs sector. It found that GI-registered products had, on average, a premium rate of 2.23.

Put another way, EU-registered GIs sold at (on average) 2.23 times the price of comparable unregistered products.

Given that there are economic benefits in the food sector, should we not extend those benefits to the industrial sector? The argument advanced against this is that industrial production is different from food production, because industrial production can be moved anywhere whereas the qualities of foodstuffs – such as whiskey or cheese – are linked to the terrain and climate of the place of origin, and cannot be moved.

But this argument does not hold up.

People and tradition

For one thing, even in the food sector geographical indication is determined not so much by climate or terrain, but but the link to people and the traditional means by which those people make a product. Thus, the protection of Waterford Blaa is as much about protecting the traditional way of making Blaa in Waterford as about the terrain or climate in Waterford.

What is being protected is the reputation of a product traditionally made in Waterford.

Let’s take another example: Connemara marble is no less linked to the terrain than is Connemara Hill Lamb. The marble that is mined in Connemara is inherently linked to Connemara, not to any other geographical origin. It is essentially a terrain-based geographical indication.

The idea of geographical indications as applied to foodstuffs includes links between the product and the place of origin based on both reputation and terroir. The same can apply in relation to industrial products – although the likelihood is that, for many industrial products, the link will be primarily based on reputation. But that is also the case for foodstuffs, as illustrated by the Waterford Blaa example. And since both international and EU law recognise the importance of reputation, there seems no reason not to extend GI protection to industrial products.

The reputation of the community 

Which brings us to the social aspect of geographical indications. The reputation linking a product to a place is often the result of the efforts of many people over long periods of time. In that sense, the reputation is a collective reputation belonging to the community in question – the community of workers, of investors, of consumers. GI laws allow that reputation to be captured and protected. GIs are not like trade marks owned by one individual or company – in fact, they are not owned at all in that sense. Rather, they are a legal recognition of a reputation that is worth protecting. Anyone who respects the traditions can use the name. It’s about community, not exclusivity.

Now, the question of whether to extend GI protection from foodstuffs to industrial products is on Brussels’ agenda. A study financed by the European Commission recommended extending GI protection, and now the Commission has opened a Public Consultation and invited interested parties to respond by Tuesday 28 October. The public is being invited to answer a series of questions on the issue.

If you want to ensure that Europe protects our manufacturing traditions and culture in exactly the same way it protects our agriculture and foodstuffs, take a moment to have your say here.

Based in Brussels, Irish lawyer Bernard O’Connor is a partner in the firm of NCTM O’Connor and is Visiting Professor at Bocconi University and the University of Milan. His areas of expertise include industrial and intellectual property law.

The “Waterford blaa” is now a protected term

‘Boxty’ could be the latest Irish term to get EU protection

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Close
6 Comments
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute OU812
    Favourite OU812
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 7:42 AM

    Absolutely endorse this. The fact that Waterford Crystal is currently made in Poland, China & Germany is atrocious.

    It should be more than packaged here (current situation).

    70
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute David Evans
    Favourite David Evans
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 9:02 AM

    Every time I pass the Waterford Crystal show room I have a sudden urge to piss on their wall.

    15
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Ahippo
    Favourite Ahippo
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 10:30 AM

    The workers, in collusion with the company, put themselves in a situation in which their pay exceeded the value of their product. Same quality Crystal is made in other west European countries at significantly less cost. Hell, the Waterford Crystal workers set up on their own making the same Crystal at significantly less cost.

    7
    See 1 more reply ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute gkrell
    Favourite gkrell
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 11:55 AM

    Minimum wage laws are responsible for this. They increase the minimum wage and prices rise so they increase the minimum wage and prices rise again. Not matter how much they raise it, prices raise comparatively as who do people think pays for it?

    This has led manufacturers to abandon Ireland and go to an economy where they can produce products for less. Letting Eastern Europe countries into the EU has been handled disastrously. Also why is if fair that a minimum wage worker in a Burger King in Dublin is paid the same money as a Burger King worker in Offaly when the cost of living is significantly less in Offaly as rent is greatly reduced?

    There is NO incentive for a business to move to counties which would greatly benefit from them moving there as they still have to spend the same money on their workforce as if they stayed in Dublin.

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute PJ Maguire Kavanagh
    Favourite PJ Maguire Kavanagh
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 8:21 AM

    In my opinion the both contain carbon compounds…

    11
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Sugar Beet
    Favourite Sugar Beet
    Report
    Oct 23rd 2014, 12:24 PM

    When “the glass” was being manufactured in Dungarvan, a lot of the cullett (lead crystal waste) appears to have ended up on local farms as some sort of fill for roadways. You can see bits of it scattered around the fields. It has a high lead content, and when this lead ends up in the grain, you can eat it in local breakfast baps etc. This is what Waterford crystal and bread rolls have in common.

    10
Submit a report
Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
Thank you for the feedback
Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.
JournalTv
News in 60 seconds