Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
SINN FÉIN MEMBERS in Dublin North West were warned last month that they would be subject to disciplinary action if they spoke to local media – on any subject – without approval from HQ.
Additionally, the party’s city councillors were emailed this week by a senior figure telling them not to answer questions from journalists about internal matters.
The email was sent on the same day Ballymun councillor Noeleen Reilly announced she was quitting the party after a much-publicised dispute with local TD Dessie Ellis.
Reilly said on Monday that she was resigning with immediate effect, citing a failure of the leadership to deal with what she described as an “orchestrated bullying campaign by a number of people in Dublin North West”.
The dispute between Ellis and Reilly has been rumbling on for months. In late December, Ellis, who has been a TD since 2011, told the Irish Independent that the party’s approach to issues like bullying and social media wasn’t up to standard.
The dispute came to a head over last weekend, when the party announced that its leadership board had decided to suspend Reilly for six months following a complaint from a fellow councillor and to ‘censure’ Ellis for comments he had made to the media about Reilly.
That announcement was made on Saturday night. Reilly announced her resignation less than 48 hour later.
The messages sent to Sinn Féin members and councillors since the start of the year show how the party attempted to keep the matter out of the headlines by imposing strict rules on the parties involved and on other members who may be asked to comment.
They followed a directive sent to all members in Dublin North West last September that they should “desist from issuing any further emails (or social media posts) relating to internal Sinn Féin matters, or by way of comment on the situation resulting from the breakdown in relationships amongst party members in the area”.
A letter seen by TheJournal.ie and sent by Sinn Féin national chairperson Declan Kearney on 11 January said:
Unfortunately that directive has not been adhered to by all members and matters internal to the party in the Dublin North West area have again been raised on both social media and other media platforms.
It went on:
I am therefore issuing a further directive, with immediate effect, that party members are not to discuss internal party matters on any media platform.
Party members are instructed not to engage in any direct or indirect contact or correspondence with any journalist or media outlet in relation to internal party matters.
All party members in Dublin North West should only have contact with the local or regional media on the basis of press office approval.
Any breach of this directive will be subject to disciplinary action.
A message emailed to Dublin councillors on Monday by Nicky Kehoe, a former councillor who has taken on an organising role with the party in the capital in recent years, said that “the papers are ringing named councillors” about an alleged incident that had happened in Dublin North West several years ago, and told councillors to direct all queries to the national press office.
A Sinn Féin spokesperson said last evening:
As the party was attempting to bring about a conciliatory resolution in the area, representatives were asked not to engage with the media as it could have been considered inflammatory by others.
There have been a spate of resignations from Sinn Féin in recent years, with allegations of bullying repeatedly cited as the reason.
Mary Lou McDonald is due to officially take over from Gerry Adams as party leader at a special art fheis in the RDS later today.
Speaking in December, the Dublin TD said her aim would be to create a “respectful, friendly, comfortable, professional relationship” within Sinn Féin if elected leader.
She said: “I am very conscious of the fact that our party has grown very substantially and very quickly, particularly in what is called the south. That has been a huge boon for our politics. It’s brought energy and positivity, but it’s brought some challenges too.
There is a challenge for whoever is leader of Sinn Féin to manage that transition from a smaller party to a larger party. That’s not a unique challenge… I’m very anxious we get it right.
McDonald said that she had heard the criticisms being levelled against the party and had spoken to people at grassroots level to get a “deep sense” of the problem.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Any other party losing 10% of its elected officials due to allegations of bullying etc would be considered in crisis.
@Honeybadger197:no crisis just weeding out the weak and vunerable, leaving just the killers, oh sorry that was a poor choice of word.
Usual predicable rubbish comments above
@David Huston: Usual vacuous point above, that conveniently ignores the content of the article. Deflect, deny, distract….
@Rex Butts: SF have a strict policy of weeding out all victims from their Cult/Party.
And now they need permission to voice any opinion they have. Jesus they are one step away from a full dictatorship in their ranks . The furthest thing thing from a progressive party
@David Huston: usual predictable response from you.
@David Huston: To be fair losing 10% in a party this large is a crisis. These things do happen in other parties but much less infrequent. I don’t understand when people blindly follow a political party and fail to accept their obvious shortcomings. It’s nearly treated like its fake news, which it clearly is not. If this was happening in FF or FG it would be reported just as much.
@David Huston: dessie ellis is convicted of terrorist activities. He’s a thug and has the party over a barrel. When the likes of Gerry O’neil in west wicklow are forced out to make way. The party has no real future in serious forward thinking political circles when this is the standard way of dealing with threats to other party members fron murderers and those threatening to hang the party out to dry to get a pay check
@David Murphey: the truth hurts
@Honeybadger197: All political parties went through the same thing. The more established parties encountered plenty of in house fighting during their inception and for many years after. In fact FF & FG only came about because of the difference of opinions in the original SF party. To say this type of political game playing is a SF phenomenon is utter codswallop!!!
@Paul Linehan: It claims to be the same party that was founded in 1905 by Arthur Griffith. That’s a long bedding in period unless it was only founded in 1970 and has no connection with the original party?
@George Oscar Bluth: And parties like Fianna Fail and Fine Gael claim to be founded from true republican values… Who’s pulling who’s leg???
Is anyone supposed to be surprised by this?
@Rex Butts: ah sure it’s a Democratic Party that allows free speech lol lol lol
@D’Murph: The Church of Sinnfeinology doesn’t allow free thought or communication. Anyone who attempts this will be deemed an SP and treated accordingly.
@D’Murph: Free speech and living on the average industrial wage
Not as transparent as they tried to make themselfs out…
@Paddy: More transparent than your faceless fake profile at least ;)
@Stephen Desmond: typical deflection tactic used here . Wer jammin and many, mamy other faceless SF bots on the journal every day of the week . But you can ignore that fact ;) the cult has spoken ;)
@Gordon Hughes: If people want to post their vitriolic opinions why do they have to hide behind a veil of fake profiles? That’s a cowardly act in itself. Surely having such courageous opinions should warrant a real name/real profile to go with it.
@Gordon Hughes: The SF heads always want to know people names and addresses. Wonder why that is? Nothing but thugs.
@Stephen Desmond: Hahaha! The irony of a shinner complaining about faceless cowardly acts.
@Stephen Desmond: your 100% .. and the vast majority of SF contributions come faceless troll accounts that you speak of
Aaaaaand another Sinn Féin headline from The Journal to get all the people clicking :)
@Stephen Desmond: but they’re so news worthy, or should we just ignore the fact the party has major issues with bullying right across the country.
@Stephen Desmond: yes because we shouldn’t report significant things and should sweep them under the rug. Did you see the Fianna Fáil one yesterday they did. When it happens report it. It’s not the journals problem that Sinn Fein have a lot of them.
They’re always going to have a lot of these issues when theyre a party that breed armchair republicans, knakers, troublemakers, murderers, violence, bombings, terrorism, Celtic jerseys, awful economic policies and don’t recognise the law and cover up sex crimes and bullying whilst being hugely disorganised and have mess ups all the time.
I’m not saying Any other party are good they’re ALL terrible but to support Sinn Fein you’d want to be a new type of loser.
Our true freedom fighters would turn in their graves.
@Paddy: How to deal with bullying .
Threaten sanctions if they dare voice an opinion without asking for permission first .
Ask for permission first !!! A cult has less rules ffs
@Chris Finn: lol their MINISTER FOR POLICING cut off a clamp the other day like I can’t laugh hard enough at that. If that doesn’t tell all what does…….Oh wait your minister for policing went to jail for attempted bombing of innocent people.
What an absolute joke of a party. A vile organisation that also are an utter laughing stock who can’t get their sxxt to together
@Chris Finn: With anti-Republican hyperbole like that you’d definitely need to have a fake/faceless account to post here :)
@Stephen Desmond: your mean 100% facts chris has just commented with ?
@Stephen Desmond: you dont consider this worth reporting ? You might be right. Murders and drug dealing are far more news worthy activities of Ellis and his mates
@Paddy: But you all hate the party, do you not? why all the interest?
@Chris Finn: They are no more vile than FG/FF when they were part of the Irish Republican Army. Did their members not also go to jail for bombings murders etc. No difference between the old IRA and the IRA of 20 years ago. Both were fighting for their country, both had blood on their hands. The nonsense about the clamp is not even close to funny, you are easily triggered, most normal people who could get something to remove a clamp would.
@Tom&Gerry: eh no, the ‘old ira’ never targeted civilians
@Tom&Gerry: your comment suggests I think Fianna Fáil/ Fine Gael are ok. Did you not read my earlier comments saying they’re ALL bad but Sinn Fein just are an extra low.
Also are you saying ah sure we’d all do it as an argument for minister for policing taking off a clamp for illegal parking (who bet went to jail because of attempted mass murder). Lol let me get this straight this is hilarious. Can you please please repeat again your comment saying we all would do it lol!
@Stephen Desmond: you see the general public who voted for Sinn Fein are not allowed to comment on issues that affect them ,or the SinnFein party in other words we will accept your votes but not your comments
@Chris Finn: I really can’t speak for anyone else, but i think you would be a right eejit to leave a clamp on your wheel if you had the means to remove it, i know i certainly would remove it, it would be stupid not to, don’t you think?
@Tom&Gerry: If that’s your point you’re an utter joke
All parties are bad but Sinn Fein are a different type of low
@Chris Finn: Sorry, I think you mean FG, the party that only represents their own class, and detest the underprivileged. Now that is a different kind of low.
@Tom&Gerry: it’s bad by Fine Gael sure but I’d take it over a party that has a policing minister who was put in jail for attempted bombing of people lol. How is that so hard for you to grasp
Stalin would be proud of SF tactics
There really is a fear of the growth of SF..
@Willy Malone: What growth Willy?
@Willy Malone: there really isn’t.
@MK76: their is a strong possibility Miss O’Neill could be your next first minister…you will self combust with rage.
@Jane: Oh but there is, the desperation is pathetic, almost every single day.
Why not some other political party to bash? The answer is very easy, no other political party are a threat to FG’s hold on power, so the media print negative stories almost every day on SF. and FG devotees who are also scared their party will lose power use this forum to spout their venomous hatred.
@Tom&Gerry: in 2007 Sinn Fein got 6.9% of the vote, in 2016 it got 13.8%.
In the 10 years between FF brought us to the brink of collapse and FG brought in crushing austerity which was seen by many as grossly unfair. We’ve had health crisis after health crisis, the mess that is Irish Water, a homeless crisis, a housing crisis etc etc. In the midst of all that SF have increased their vote by 6.9%.
FF, the party that is generally accepted as having ruined the country increased their vote by 6.9% from 2011 to 2016. The same amount SF has grown in 10 years. Why are SF not hovering up votes? They put themselves up as the alternative to FF and FG but people aren’t buying it. I don’t see this fear that you talk about.
@Jane: lol super comment. Nail on head. Facts and stats. No progress even when opportunity was put on a plate for them. A weak party that will have the same numbers in 100 years time. Nothing to strive for
@Jane: It’s here on the journal, almost every day. FF are no threat so no attacking them, everyone knows this to be the truth, why all that energy attacking a party that are no threat to your hold on power, if you really believe that.
Sinn Fein will forever stay as a third party. They will go nowhere. 30 years from now nothing will have changed. Mark my words. Excited about the party now.
@Chris Finn: Don’t fool yourself Chris, you are terrified that SF will take the power from your masters, you are so desperate your fingers are being worn out making negative remarks about them, why do that if they are not a threat? Glad to hear you are exited about the party so am i.
@Tom&Gerry: literally nobody is terrified of that. The clowns couldn’t do it during the financial crisis, it’ll not happen now.
This dictat to gag victims or face punishment is a very poor signal from Mary Lou’s office.
Scientology operates in a similar manner, crushing any efforts to release damaging internal information.
Silencing people is not how you win their support or make the party an attractive proposition to voters.
I’m shocked, shocked! that a revolutionary socialist party would attempt to shut down dissent in its ranks.
I would be grateful for information on any political party on this island or our foreign neighbours in the UK who do not regularly employ 3 line whips and issue disciplinary penalties or dismissal for party members who refuse to adhere to party policy.
Individuals join political parties whose policies best fit their own agendas.
You really must correct me if I’m wrong.
@Brendan McLaughlin: I fail to think of any party in the world who’s minister for policing cut off a clamp and was put in jail for attempted bombing.
I fail to think of any party in the world that are as disorganised and have a constant list of mess ups and horrendous 1980s economic policy
I fail to think of any party in this country so connected to terrorism, violence, kangaroo courts, bombings, kneecappings, sex crimes covering up, armchair republican coward losers who wear bandanas.
The country and our men of history cringe for these absolute cowards and losers who follow this dirt party
@Brendan McLaughlin: delusional
@Chris Finn: but…..leo…..spin department…..FF are FG
@Chris Finn: “Our men of history cringe for these absolute cowards” are you for real. Have you forgotten the Old IRA members, FG and FF, were they not responsible for murdering and bombings and god knows what else. The IRA of 20 years ago was no different than the old IRA. Both had blood on their hands, go and learn your history.
@Tom&Gerry: I know my history. While all parties are bad none of those parties have a minister for policing put in jail for attempted bombing of people lol. Like what constitutes as vile for you.
I think we’re all in agreement that that minister is an absolute loser of the highest order
Darragh Brophy has yet another SF story on “bullying”. One could accuse Darragh of having an agenda or dare I say “bullying”.
@Cormac: So is it the journal’s fault for the billing and harassment FECKERS
@Cormac: Yes SF are the true victims here.
@Cormac: I know, it’s all so unfair.
@Ben McArthur: some of their ex members are any ways bullied out of the party with threats of punishment if they open their mouths
To be fair, is it any different from any other major political parties.
@John Fergus: To be fair, what other major political party has seen 10% of its elected officials resign due to allegations bullying etc in recent months?
It must be tough for the new young councillors going up against men who once planted bombs. Surely it’s ingrained in the old school Sinn feiners to do things “differently”. These gn run Sinn fein and can’t be disciplined.
Ye all should see some of the stuff these Cultists have got up to in Kilkenny/Carlow in the last year or so.
Issuing ‘Death Threats’ to people who left their Cult – And what did these ex-cult members do to deserve this ? Just spoke out on social media about their treatment inside the Cult.
Cultists threatening to Burn-Out defenceless women.. And approaching small business owners looking for ‘Donations’ , with a menacing undertone of “If you don’t donate, then you will get no protection ” ??
Just some of the Cultists activities in Kilkenny and Carlow ..
Ah The Cult at it again.
have your say