TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Colorado suspect ‘was seeing university psychiatrist’ before massacre

A court in Colorado has seen disputes over whether medical privilege covers contact between James Holmes and his doctor.

Image: Ted S. Warren/AP

THE SUSPECTED Batman movie premiere gunman was seeing a university psychiatrist specializing in schizophrenia before the shooting that killed 12, court documents showed this evening.

James Holmes sent a notebook to Lynne Fenton, who teaches at the University of Colorado’s medical school and heads student mental services there, that included details and drawings depicting his planned mass killing, according to reports.

It was unclear when the package reached the school, and officials remained tight-lipped due to a gag order imposed by the judge overseeing the case.

But the judge unsealed a defence motion to order the government to grant access to the “package from Mr Holmes addressed to Dr Lynne Fenton.”

The motion also said Holmes’s constitutional rights had been violated by the “breach of confidentiality and privilege”.

In a preview of likely battles to come, the defence lawyers also argued that the contents of the package should not be used as evidence because “Mr Holmes was a psychiatric patient of Dr Fenton, and his communications with her are protected.”

Holmes, who was studying neuroscience in a doctoral program at the University of Colorado Denver, is expected to be charged with 12 murders and 58 attempted murders at his next court appearance on Monday in connection with the July 20 shooting.

Fenton’s research focuses on schizophrenia and other major mental illnesses.

- © AFP, 2012

Read: Colorado suspected gunman ‘can’t remember’ shooting spree

Read next:

Comments (32 Comments)

  • Mentally ill but still had no problem getting an arsenal. Mad!

    Reply
  • Two statistics I would like to see. Firstly, how many Americans are killed by other Americans every year by legally held weapons, versus the number of Americans killed by foreign terrorists. Secondly, the cost of enforcing US borders against foreign ‘threats’ versus the cost of implementing proper gun control regulations.

    Reply
  • Kevin 27/07/12 #

    This story is becoming stranger an stranger. You only have to look at the footage of him in court to know that he was in some SERIOUS medication; he looked like he was tripping balls!

    Reply
  • Correct me if I am wrong here but doesn’t crazy and shooting lots of people for no reason not go hand in hand. Is he not mentally ill by definition? Say he is crazy but was sane enough to plan this thing, would he also not be sane enough to preemptively plan a legal defense based on claims of insanity?

    Reply
    • Violence and murder are NOT symptom of schizophrenia. They may co-exist, just as someone with asthma may also have repetitive strain injury in the elbow.

      I wanted to say that, in defence of people who suffer from schizophrenia, the vast majority of whom are harmless, frightened, withdrawn little craythurs.

      This murderous “Joker” in the US has no excuse whatsoever for his behaviour. No amount of “voices” in a schizophrenic’s head will prevail upon them to murder anyone.

      I know someone who suffers from schizophrenia. Whenever he is very unwell with it, he thinks he is being spied upon by a certain individual. He thinks that person is stealing his stuff, has cameras in his bedroom to spy upon him, etc. etc. Yet, never once, in the 30 years he has has schizophrenia, has he in any way hurt, assaulted, pulled a gun or done anything agressive to his imagined persecutor. Instead, he just withdraws and regresses into himself and keeps his own company, walking around in circles, talking to himself, etc.

      The above example is typical of the schizophrenic.

      Reply
  • To make things worse gun sales have gone through the roof. I am afraid to imagine what kind of catastrophe it takes to make these idiots think guns should not be available!

    Reply
  • It’s a candle you eejit.

    Reply
  • Whats the jar of piss for?

    Reply
  • Why is he only now known as James Holmes, why was the’Eagan’ dropped in the media….another triple barrelled named shooter ?

    Reply
  • This article sickens me, total media sensationalism!!! The vast majority of Schizophrenic suffers are not violent and those who are generally tend to hurt themselves or family members. This article sends out such negative connotations regarding Schizophrenia and does nothing but make the lives of those suffers even more unbearable!!!

    Reply
  • Listen, if everybody in America who saw a psychiatrist couldn’t get a gun, nobody would have guns, the entire race there suffers from small penis syndrome – including the birds – but I do think that it could possibly solve the employment crisis there if they hired new coppers to investigate every citizen that sees a psychiatrist, as it would become even a bigger industry than their whole Jesus thing they constantly parrot on about.

    Reply
  • While the exact details of the recent massacre in Colorado have not been revealed yet, if James Holmes was seeing a Psychiatrist the chances are he would be on prescription drugs. Psychoactive medication eg “anti-depressants”/SSRIs can lead to suicide, VIOLENCE or mania (according to a paper by honest Psychiatrist Peter Breggin).

    Professor of Psychiatry David Healy also does a lot of work in highlighting the dangers of these drugs. He gave a lecture in Trinity College recently where he reveals that the results of negative clinical trials are hidden by Pharmaceutical companies.

    This video highlights the fact that some of the young people that carried out past massacres in America were on Psychoactive drugs.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XHNJyti1gE&feature=player_embedded

    There is also a website called http://www.ssristories.com which was set up by Ann Blake-Tracy.

    These drugs are powerful but also can be dangerous. Never stop any medication or make changes without consulting a doctor, due to withdrawal. Dr David Healy has done a lot of work in the area of drug withdrawal.
    Do not be fooled by mainstream Psychiatry. It is a pseudo Science. Psychiatrists mainly prescribe drugs. And these drugs are mainly based around marketing as opposed to Science. Some of the drugs have lawsuits against them.

    GlaxoSmithKline has to pay $3bn in US drug fraud scandal, the largest healthcare fraud settlement in US history. “The sales force bribed physicians to prescribe GSK products using every imaginable form of high-priced entertainment, from Hawaiian vacations [and] paying doctors millions of dollars to go on speaking tours, to tickets to Madonna concerts,” said US attorney Carmin Ortiz.

    Reply
  • While the exact details of the recent massacre in Colorado have not been revealed yet, if James Holmes was seeing a Psychiatrist the chances are he would be on prescription drugs. Psychoactive medication eg “anti-depressants”/SSRIs can lead to suicide, VIOLENCE or mania (according to a paper by honest Psychiatrist Peter Breggin).

    Professor of Psychiatry David Healy also does a lot of work in highlighting the dangers of these drugs. He gave a lecture in Trinity College recently where he reveals that the results of negative clinical trials are hidden by Pharmaceutical companies. Scan down this page for a podcast of the lecture:
    http://www.nursing-midwifery.tcd.ie/events-conferences/events-schedule/

    This video highlights the fact that some of the young people that carried out past massacres in America were on Psychoactive drugs.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XHNJyti1gE&feature=player_embedded

    There is also a website called http://www.ssristories.com which was set up by Ann Blake-Tracy.

    These drugs are powerful but also can be dangerous. Never stop any medication or make changes without consulting a doctor, due to withdrawal. Dr David Healy has done a lot of work in the area of drug withdrawal.
    Do not be fooled by mainstream Psychiatry. It is a pseudo Science. Psychiatrists mainly prescribe drugs. And these drugs are mainly based around marketing as opposed to Science. Some of the drugs have lawsuits against them.

    GlaxoSmithKline has to pay $3bn in US drug fraud scandal, the largest healthcare fraud settlement in US history. “The sales force bribed physicians to prescribe GSK products using every imaginable form of high-priced entertainment, from Hawaiian vacations [and] paying doctors millions of dollars to go on speaking tours, to tickets to Madonna concerts,” said US attorney Carmin Ortiz. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-18673220

    Reply
  • Death Penalty

    Reply
  • @mattoid.
    including people with red hair in a list of disabled,mentaly ill and sexual orientation says more than enough about your own frame of mind…regardless of what point you were trying to make.what UTTER tosh!

    Reply
  • Mk ultra ?

    Reply
  • It’s amazing if your a white person and you kill a load of innocent people your declared mentally ill. If he was from the middle east would they be saying he’s mentally ill? No he would be called a terrorist!! The guy should be given the death penalty end of!

    Reply
  • Why can’t I post here?

    Reply

Add New Comment