TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

In numbers: the PAC’s report on reviewing public allowances

The Public Accounts Committee published a report this week on reviewing public allowances. Here’s some of its figures.

Young teachers attend a demonstration last month seeking equal pay with older counterparts. Many younger teachers are not entitled to the same allowances as older colleagues receive.
Young teachers attend a demonstration last month seeking equal pay with older counterparts. Many younger teachers are not entitled to the same allowances as older colleagues receive.
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

THIS WEEK the Dáil’s spending watchdog released a significant report after seven weeks of hearings on public sector allowances – making a series of recommendations on how public money might be better and more appropriately allocated.

The Public Accounts Committee’s full report can be read here, but the following is a selection of the stand-out numbers from that report.

292,000 – The number of people currently on the public payroll. That’s down from 320,000 as of the end of 2008, and could be down to 285,000 next year.

8 per cent – The total proportion of public pay which is taken up by allowances. Allowances cost about €1.4 billion in 2011. Education allowances cost almost half of this, and accounts for about a third of the overall total of 1,100 allowances.

€244.86 – The weekly wage of a private in the Permanent Defence Force, the lowest-paid member of the public service.

82 per cent – The proportion of public servants who earn under €60,000 a year.

40 per cent - The proportion of public servants who earn less than €40,000 a year, including allowances.

€27 million – The annual bill for allowances which will not be paid to new appointees to the public service.

€395 million – The annual cost of the 235 allowances which will continue to be paid to those who served at a grade prior to February 2012, but which will not be continued.

98 – The number of allowances which will now be the subject of “intense negotiations” as the government looks for early elimination. This process is to be finished by February.

5 – The number of recommendations of the report, which are as follows:

  • That universal allowances which are paid to every member of a pay grade to simply be incorporated into core pay;
  • That the number of allowances be consolidated;
  • That the ‘long tail’ of allowances where small payments are made to small numbers of staff, be replaced by more generic allowances;
  • That all expenses (including those paid to Oireachtas members) be vouched for;
  • That the level and payment of allowances for Oireachtas members be determined by an independent body.

9,053 – The number of recipients of of the ‘Military Service Allowance’ – which is paid to almost all staff under the aegis of the Department of Defence, costing €52.7 million per year. 4,654 staff also receive ‘technical pay’ worth a total of €7.7 million.

€4,468,257.56 – The amount that will be saved by scrapping the Border Duty Allowance – the single biggest saving being achieved at the Department of Defence. It is currently paid to 761 staff.

120 – The number of days for which a member of the Dáil or Seanad needs to be in attendance at Leinster House in order to become entitled to the full complement of travel and accommodation allowances.

€1,388,913 – The unvouched payments made to Oireachtas members for ‘public representation’ and secretarial allowances.

16 per cent – The portion of the overall teaching pay bill which is accounted for by allowances.

41,500 – The number of teaching staff who receive the ‘supervision and substitution’ allowance, which costs a total of €118 million.

4,829 – The number of teachers earning the long service allowance, for having worked for over 35 years, which costs €11 million a year.

€3.15 million – The amount that will be saved by removing the ‘teaching through Irish’ allowance paid to teachers. This accounts for over a third of the €9 million savings from the Department of the Environment.

93.8 per cent – The proportion of staff from the Irish Prison Service who receive operation and rent allowances. 3,218 of the 3,429 personnel at the service receive each payment.

€1.3 million – The amount to be saved by withdrawing clerical allowance from the Gardaí who receive it.

30.38 per cent – The proportion of a Garda sergeant’s gross pay which comes from allowances and overtime.

2.6 per cent – The proportion of the total HSE pay bill which is made up by allowances (€166.5 million of €6.4 billion).

8,765 – The number of HSE employees who are receiving an ‘acting-up allowance’, in lieu of actually having been appointed to a superior position, at an annual cost of €17.7 million.

€7.95 million – The amount the HSE had, until recently, paid to consultants in allowances for them to continue their medical education.

Read: PAC report: System of public sector allowances ‘not fit for purpose’

Want more? Check out our previous ‘In numbers’ pieces>

Read next:

Comments (22 Comments)

  • gardai nurses paramedics etc, frontline staff should all be paid top salaries get rid of all the quangos and pen pushers the senate and wasters.

    Reply
    • Why?
      Our nurses are the highest paid in the World. Put aside stupid emotion and pay the average for the poorest five Nations of the Eurozone and we’d be paying them forty per cent less. Why pay any more?

      Reply
    • Garry, all sectors in Ireland are among the highest paid in the world, public or private. Cost of living in Ireland is among the highest in the world. Minimum wage is among the highest in the world.

      Reply
    • Garry Ireland is a pretty expensive place to live how do you expect them to live also our politicians are possible the best paid in the world. Why not start with them rather then useful member of society?

      Reply
  • Pity it never stated the lowest pay of apprentices in the defence forces. I started off on 62 pound in first year then 82 then 112 for third year. Wages not great still after nearly serving 21 in the force. The allowances help keep my head above water. Barely. Bad state of affairs when colleagues I work with are entitled to FIS

    Reply
  • If the Senate is abolished as promised then we will be saving 400 million a year anyways all them Senators have other jobs.

    Reply
    • #Denise Friary , Its a joke the money that them Senators get and they are not elected by the people.

      Reply
    • @Denise: I am not sure where you picked up a figure of €400m for the Seanad. Last report in June of this year claimed it costed €120m for the Dail and Seanad combined. That same report indicated it was less than €20m for the Seanad alone.

      I would agree with you that we need to consider if serves any purpose and possibly abolish it, but lets not get overoptimistic about money saving.

      Reply
  • 82% earn 60k or less
    What’s the average if the other 18%
    And
    Why does the ex general secretary of FG land the 168k job the run the ” gathering”. Jobs for the boys again !

    Reply
  • Yeah Gary, why pay nurses at all! I mean all we do is sit on our arses all day……………

    Reply
  • You’re playing a blinder these days Richard. Keep it up.

    Reply
  • HSE “acting up allowance”. Is this real . You get an allowance for NOT being promoted ? Why did the person not get promoted ? Overskilled?

    Reply
  • So will these new teachers be happy if wages and allowances are cut to older teachers on previous deals to make them all even and earning the same. Answer- No they wont.

    All teachers would then join forces to strike for better pay and extra perks.

    Reply
    • As a teacher I have never understood why subs and supervision isn’t part of our contract. It would seem an integral part of our job to me. Take it away. There won’t be many of us who complain.

      Reply
  • We have a ludicrous allowance system for Gardai on top of their well-paid salary.

    Reply
    • Which allowances are ludicrous Joe? Night duty, Sunday and public holiday allowance maybe? Would you work unsocial hours for no extra pay? Unlikely.. The other available allowances are earned by so few as to hardly matter. A rank and file Garda earns € 48,695 gross after 17 years service. They pay 11% out of this towards a pension and like all workers pay PAYE, PRSI and USC. On average a Garda on the top pay scale will take home about €500 per week. Considering the potentially dangerous and demanding nature of the job and the high standards a Garda is expected by society to display at all times €500 a week is barely adequate compensation if you ask me.

      Reply
    • #Joe,so who will you be calling if your house is robbed. The Gardai are the best police in the world..I listen to Joe Duffy every day and the Gardai are allways praised very highly.

      Reply
    • Best police in the world??? It’s not 1st April is it. Morris tribunal, Smithwick tribunal, corrib gas “policing”, Fr Molloy murder. And do a Google search of garda? caught for bringing false charges against people. Just last week there was another before the courts. Anyone who has been burgled will tell you how uninterested they are. So no they are a long way from being the best police force in the world.

      Reply
    • Alberto 25/11/12 #

      ah Joe the troll!!!!!! a vendetta against the gardai! there’s a lyons tea bag for you, all talk!!!! start backing your claims up my friend, all waffle

      Reply

Add New Comment