TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 5 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Minister and Taoiseach ‘did not mislead Dáil on HSE difficulties’

The Health Minister was responding to claims from Deputy Micheál Martin that he ignored warnings from HSE chief executive Cathal Magee about the health budget.

Image: Sam Boal / Photocall Ireland

THE MINISTER FOR Health, Dr James Reilly, did not ‘mislead’ the Dáil on difficulties facing the HSE, his spokesman said today.

He added that at no stage did the Minister or Taoiseach Enda Kenny mislead the Dáil on the issue.

The comment comes after Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin claimed that Minister Reilly needs to be questioned immediately “about why he withheld vital information for months on end about the escalating health budget crisis”.

The Irish Times said this week that HSE chief executive Cathal Magee had repeatedly written to Minister Reilly about policy directions on the health deficit, and that his requests were not met.

Martin said yesterday:

Dr Reilly has a duty to the public and to the Oireachtas to explain why he ignored warnings from Cathal Magee since March, and why he fobbed off the Dáil on several occasions when concerns were raised about the health budget.  He also needs to outline now how he intends to ensure that frontline services and patients do not suffer as result of his financial mismanagement.

Investigation

Deputy Martin added that the “series of failures that have come to light this week regarding the mismanagement of the health budget and the preparation of flawed health estimates must be investigated urgently”.

The health budget is out of control and Minister Reilly cannot get away with continuing to put this extremely serious matter on the long finger

Minister Reilly’s spokesperson said that regarding media reports on the correspondence between the Chief Executive of the HSE and the Secretary General of the Department:

The Department worried too and the Department worked to produce progress. The Department of Health have had breakthroughs on both these issues.

Progress

He said this progress included a new deal with insurance companies that will yield €125 million, and a deal with pharmaceutical manufacturer representative organisation IPHA, which has produced €10 million immediately.

It also includes imminent generic drug substitution legislation which it is hoped will help save over €70 million this year.

The spokesperson said that “considerable worry” remains on the issue of service cost overruns.

The maintenance of financial control over the service is the legal responsibility of the Chief Executive of the HSE as the Accounting Officer.

The spokesperson said that a number of separate initiatives have been mounted by the Department of Health to assist the HSE in this regard, including the establishment of key new personnel in the HSE and the Department of Health “who will strongly enhance the financial control capability of the organisation”.

Read: New HSE chief appointed by Minister for Health>

Read next:

Comments (36 Comments)

  • The last paragraph …… A new layer of management will be established in the hope of controlling costs. Those costs presumably after the costs of the new layer of management……. bizarre ….

    Reply
  • Who do we believe?
    Head of HSE said this was going on for months and he wrote to minister and got no reply.
    Minister said it is not his job…
    Oh what a fine mess

    Reply
  • Reflecting on the opening ceremony of the olympics , how proud the Brits are of their NHS ; i don’t know anyone who is proud of our Health Service. In fact I am a frontline worker ( I treat patients ) and every day I am embarrassed and mortified about state of our health service

    Reply
  • Did not mislead the Dail? As in the same way FG said Roscommon A&E would not close?

    Reply
    • In fairness a politician will pretty much say anything to get elected. Everyone knows that so to be surprised is nieve in the extreme.

      Reply
    • And by closing Roscommon A&E the health service is paying more per year for the ambulance service that spend more time on the roads from Roscommon to Galway than if they left a Newly refurbished A+E open each Ambulance on a call is out for a minimum of 4 hours and up to 5 hours per return trip for Roscommon emergencies so minister Reilly what the he’ll are you talking about it was you who lied in the Dail about why you closed Roscommon A+ E Put the records straight and stop the lies fir once and for all liars this government are

      Reply
  • Continuity Fianna Fail in action once again. Ridiculously overpaid ministers who are responsible for nothing despite being in charge and everythings always everybody elses fault.

    Reply
  • The buck stops with the minister he afterall sacked the board of the HSE . It would be typical for a FG minister not to reply..

    Reply
    • The reality is that it is impossible for the CEO of hse to control the budget because the minister has the power around policy Reilly made all sorts of policy decisions in the budget that were meant to save money for hse but actually never followed through in enacting the policy while expecting hse to stick to budget allocation dependant on the policy being enacted. Magee position was impossible all the responsibility but no power unfortunately the power rests with an incompetent buffoon

      Reply
  • More Lies & Spin from the looney Blushirts running this septic isle, there is no gutter these reprobates, Edna & Dr Jekyll, will sink to, in order to hide their total ineptness & incapability of even running a pee up in a brewery.

    Dr Jekyll who is listed in Stubbs Gazzette, cannot even get his own private finances in order. How can he ever get the country’s health system functioning correctly. And as for Edna, a failed school teacher in charge of the whole lot.

    What’s even more galling is there are people in this country who believe the sewage coming from their mouths…Complete Lunatics running the Asylum…!!!

    Reply
    • “This septic isle” Enough with the insults on the country eh? To say the country has been run by tools is fair enough but I’m getting tired of people constantly dissing the place. Syria is septic, we just have problems.

      Reply
    • I completely agree faceless we have plenty problems in this country but as a peoria we have plenty to offer po if you really hate the place do something about it action not bile is what is needed get involved in protest suggest solutions of course we need to vent our anger at the incompetent and dishonest that have run this country but we have to have hope and a vision of how it could be better

      Reply
    • Any protests that are held are ignored by the state owned broadcasters and the O’Brien holdings in media.
      Any protests that are held are dismissed by the few as the loony left …how insulting is that to the people who do care ?
      People are still afraid of standing up and saying Enough Is Enough .
      They feel that there is nothing they can do , but people are wrong , if they stand together and attend the protests and support their community the government will have to take notice . Stop being such a defeatist .Listen out for the POSITIVE . I love my country and will never leave . I will continue to protest against unfair and unjust laws.

      Reply
  • “Minister’s spokesman said”? This seems to happen so often! Would be nice if the Minister used his own tongue to answer queries.

    Reply
  • Are people finally getting the message now,that no matter who you vote for,the outcome is always going to be the same.Same circus,different clowns.

    Reply
  • James Reilly is the most inexperienced minister in government circle after Mr Hogan & as long as he stays in post, HSE wouldn’t be able to cope with the messy. God help Ireland!

    Reply
  • Aside from the hypocritical sight of career FFers (like Mr. Kearon) making hay out of this; there is a bigger issue at play here.

    Two of the most incompetent ministers in the government are only there because they were loyal to Enda in the infamous pre election heave.

    Hogan and Reilly aren’t up to the job, and have proven themselves incompetent, detached from the public they serve, and prone to bouts of selective thinking when it comes to their own finances.

    Don’t hold your breath waiting for them to step aside, or be pushed, though.

    Reply
  • Ah now then Michael ,don’t be so quick..
    We all know where the mismanagement started ….. with yourself and Harney and the rest of the FFail ures . Having said that , it does not take from my opinion that Minister Reilly is an incompetent . It is clear that this man can not manage his own finances, (Stubbs Gazette is proof of that) so how is he allowed continue on with the destruction of our health service. I truly believe that only for the very good work and concerned talented people we have working at all levels of the HSE in hospitals Health care centres ,day care centres , Palative care , Cancer / diabetic care etc etc., a lot more people would be in a terrible state if all the rules imposed were being strictly adhered to.The man should be made resign his ministerial position .

    Reply
    • Eileen you set such high standards that perhaps you mean yourself to be included in the rigid disciplines that should be adhered to by the proletariat. Perhaps you could tell us what you work at so we can understand the reasons behind such a brutal demand…taking a persons job away from them when the failures (should they exist) are the responsibility of someone else according to their employment contract. Or would it be fair to say Eileen that your standards are simply those of a Left Wing Party hoping to see your intellectually bankrupt pals in power and therefor your criticism is biased?

      Reply
    • Ha ha . Mick, What is your point . What agenda do you have in asking me so many personal questions?

      Reply
  • And mr Martin did a fantastic job as health minister….NOT

    Reply
  • Sinn Fein wish to thank FF and FG for their illustrative display, and for the additional voters sent our way as they continue their glorious struggle with the tiller of the Ship of State.

    Reply
  • Get rid of SF/FG/FF/Labour, then we will be on the road to ridding ourselves of Corruption. They are, out of date, ideas and policies. Its time for new parties, new thinking and honest politics. Rise up people, lets rid ourselves of the rot in politics!

    Reply
  • We cant afford to have a gov doing an average job with the state the country is in. Enda sais that any ministers not performing would get the chop but these to are clearly not performing but because they supported Enda during the big push against him he is staying loyal to them at our expense. Great leadership by our so called leader.

    Reply
  • All lies

    Reply
  • Enda is part of the problem just as much as this man,

    Reply
  • Darren 04/08/12 #

    Minister Martin ??? Typo

    Reply
  • That’s So Irrational And Stupid , The Gov Keeps This Country On A Straight Path , Fundamentally We need a gov , The People Can’t Lead Them Self , We Let The Gov Have Power For Referendum And I Think the People Mad The Wrong Decision For The Niece And Lisbon 1 And 2, So how can we get rid of the gov . The Gov Is doing an Average Job , Better them Ff , Too Much Cridism For FG , When They Do Right They Never Get Praised And If/When The Do Wrong They Will B Judged And Put down !

    Reply

Add New Comment