TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Woman charged with hate crime after man pushed in front of NY subway train

The woman told police that she pushed the man in front of the train because she hated Muslims and Hindus.

A train passes through the 40th St - Lowery St station in NYC where the man died after being pushed onto the tracks
A train passes through the 40th St - Lowery St station in NYC where the man died after being pushed onto the tracks
Image: (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

A WOMAN HAS been charged with committing a hate crime murder after she allegedly pushed a man in front of a New York subway train.

Erika Menendez, a 31-year-old woman from Queens in New York, was charged by police last night over the death of Sunando Sen, a 46-year-old man originally from India.

Sen was pushed into the path of an oncoming train as it approached the platform at the 40th Street – Lowery Street station in Queens at around 8pm on Friday night.

In a statement from the Queens District Attorney, the suspect was quoted as saying that she was motivated by her hatred of Muslims and Hindus after 9/11. She told police:

I pushed a Muslim off the train tracks because I hate Hindus and Muslims ever since 2001 when they put down the twin towers. I’ve been beating them up.

District Attorney Richard A Brown said that Menendez had been seen talking to herself while seated on a bench at the station before the incident took place. Sunando Sen was standing with his back to the suspect as the train pulled into the platform. Police said he would not have seen who pushed him onto the tracks.

“The defendant is accused of committing what is every subway commuter’s worst nightmare – being suddenly and senselessly pushed into the path of an oncoming train,” said Brown.

The victim was allegedly shoved from behind and had no chance to defend himself. Beyond that, the hateful remarks allegedly made by the defendant and which precipitated the defendant’s actions can never be tolerated by a civilised society.

Mendendez has been charged with second-degree murder as a hate crime. If convicted, she faces a maximum of 25 years to life in prison.

Sen was the second person to die after being pushed in front of a train in New York this month.

Read: Second person pushed in front of New York subway train >

Read next:

Comments (49 Comments)

  • Sandy 30/12/12 #

    Poor man.

    Reply
  • Jerry 30/12/12 #

    Brother living in New York , telling me phone he was travelling subway Saturday . Everybody with their backs to the walls . Never seen it as bad so many people on edge looking around them at everybody

    Reply
  • This was a horrible crime. On the issue of widespread Islamophobia…..I think its not too bad in NYC. Saw a facinating sight in Times square last Friday which I would not believe had I not seen it myself. A guy takes out his prayer mat, lays it on the sidewalk between two vendors so hes blocking no one, faces mecca I presume, removes his shoes, kneels and proceeds to do his prayers! No one says a word to him….he gets alot of second glances but nothing else! I never thought it would be possible but I guess anything is possible in NY!

    Reply
  • Second degree? How is it only second degree?

    Reply
  • Michael j Collins
    I agree If she is mentally ill she would be deemed unfit to stand trial. However the fact remains she killed a man so she should be held in a secure mental facility. I’m not sure she will ever be well though. It’s very difficult to cure ingrained hatred.

    Reply
  • One can see and hear this hateful message all the time by the presenters on Fox News , with their redneck bible thumping advocates of a “Christian” only America.
    Some People are bound to lead , as a result , to the point of committing “Hate Crime” themselves.

    Surely some broadcasting standards need to be set to contain what these type of people like Bill O’Reilly , Limbaugh etc, can be allowed to spew on the airwaves ?

    Reply
    • Well said Eddie, Bill O’Reilly infuriates me…

      Reply
    • @ Eddie.. So many agree with you.. I DETEST Rush Limbaugh.. What a dangerous man he is.. I’m surprised he gets away with so much… O Reilly, Hannity, Limbaugh.. most (but not all) at Fox News really… You’d be surprised how many DONT agree with them too.. There is hope!!

      Reply
    • Spot on Eddie, Fox News is a disgrace with O’ Reilly the most obvious example of redneck, bible thumping, gun totting America’s woes! We have the same here with Sky News, The Sun and the Daily Mail…..Hate Rags!

      Reply
    • There are a lot of hate crimes being committed in Africa, the middle east Pakistan Indonesia where it is open season on Christians and now they will be second class citizens in Egypt and the new Syria.
      I may may add there is a lot of hate towards Christians printed here on the journal too
      The world is full of nut cases. And this unfortunate man fell victim to one.

      Please refrain from printing more hate by your vitriolic finger pointing and name calling.
      The label “RED NECK” is an offensive and Racist remark, no two ways about it. Because it is directed against White people is seems to be ok to use it.
      Every white person who goes out on a sunny day with a shirt on will get a red neck.
      It is no matter what colour the name caller is,I say it again “RED NECK” is an offensive and Racist remark.

      Reply
    • I think John that you are completely missing my point .
      It’s the misusing of the word “Christianity”in a hateful manner towards other races and religions which is the particular bone which I’m picking at.
      These people’s version of being an American is being racist white , a misinterpreter of the bible , English speaking only , gun toting , lack of respect for the environment , showing disrespect for Mr Obama , The Democratic Party & most of all , a total disrespect for women .
      Sounds like Fox News – doesn’t it ?

      Reply
    • While I agree on Fox News and its craziness this woman wouldn’t be a red neck, now would she?

      Reply
    • Eddie you can’t help your self can you , I see you as just another product the the current school system , which is dominated by left leaning feminists ,
      You and your ilk ,use the open and relatively free society we live in to criticise all those who want to keep some of the remaining ethos that built the modern world.
      All over the western world,there is a whole tribe / nation of your ilk ,word for word letter for letter you all spew the same vitriolic hatred as if you were one person, and you so frequently and loosely use the same terms of hate, you are every bit as bad as those you deem others to be.

      Reply
  • The poor man. Islamophobia is frighteningly common in the US and Europe.

    Reply
    • And being fanned by forces scapegoating and diverting attention from their own criminality.

      Anti-Islam is the new antisemitism.

      Reply
    • Sunando Sen? The poor man wasn’t even Muslim….

      Reply
    • What on earth did the Hindus have to do with the Twin Towers??? Seriously, you have to wonder just how stupid some people are.

      Reply
    • That is truly appalling. They should throw the book at this woman (though not the death penalty).

      Reply
    • Anti-Semitism is alive & well still these days, as you well know Damien. But these days it is often hidden behind the politically correct face of Pro-Palestinianism. These friends who don’t care when Palestinians & Musilms are killed in Syria but are outraged by far minor numbers killed in Israel/Palestine.

      Reply
    • Why not the death penalty/ She is clearly a dangerous idiot. The worst kind of idiot. Let’s give her more hugs. Christ above, what has Hinduism got to do with 9/11? I hope she never reproduced and her genetic code dies with the idiot.

      Reply
    • Not sure where your going with that tendentious coat-trailing Reggie..do elaborate for the readers edification.

      If antisemitism is alive and well I’d say its largely thanks to the ever more rightward march of Bibi&Co with their settler mission-creep contempt for all and any international attempts to get them see their own interests. They seem determined to alienate all and any reasonable advocacy of a just settlement for Palestinians.

      Would you disagree?

      Reply
  • Judging by his name he wasn’t a Muslim. And why should she hate Hindus anyway? They weren’t responsible for the Twin Towers. Nor were the thousands of Muslims who live and work peacefully in the US. This woman obviously has mental issues. So sad for the family of the man who died. It’s good she was caught as she would do the same again probably, if she hasn’t already done something similar.

    Reply
  • damian 30/12/12 #

    Wow! I used to live right beside that subway station! It’s a nice enough neighbourhood as well… Platform isn’t that big though. Poor man. RIP…

    Reply
  • BTW I meant she should be in a secure mental hospital due to her crime. I do not think people with mental problems in general should be locked up unless they are a danger to others. But as I said in new York there seem to be a lot of people who should at least be supervised by the state as they don’t seem to look after themselves very well and I would come to the conclusion that many are off their meds

    Reply
    • If people commit crime and end up in a psychiatric unit they tend to get double the punishment. I found that out a while ago

      Reply
    • You really don’t know much about so-called mental illness Shirley do you? Perhaps you confuse mental handicap with mental illness, because you really cannot tell who has been labelled and who has not.
      1) First and foremost you are assuming that this pig-headed woman is mentally ill because of her crime…. that’s quite a leap.
      2) There are no objective tests to show weather someone has a mental illness or not – **only** subjective ones.
      3) There is evidence that mental illness drugs lead to suicide and homicide (e.g. Seroxat) – drug companies have admitted the increased suicide risk and it’s now listed as a side effect on …… yep….. antidepressants :) !
      4) Even when people are branded with stigmatizing mental illness labels, the research shows that outcomes are worse on the medication.
      5) If someone breaks the law they should be held accountable for it, and made do the normal length of time. Not imprisoned without trial, and left in a legal limbo.

      Reply
  • All hate crimes which result in death should carry a mandatory life sentence. It should in my opinion be treated as first degree murder as many hate crimes are spur of the moment opportunistic crimes, but they are generally something the perpetrator has wanted to do and feel little remorse for in the aftermath. This woman made an assumption without proof, with regards to the man’s religion and he died as a result. If she is mentally ill she should be in a secure hospital. It’s shocking how many obviously mentally I’ll people are roaming new york streets with no apparent supervision or treatment

    Reply
    • Shirley
      If she’s mentally ill then she shouldn’t be held accountable for any crime and should be treated in a secure institution until she is well.

      Reply
    • Maybe she, like so many other ill-educated swastika-toting racists, was a product of her environment? Maybe she was high? Why assume she is mentally ill? I’ve heard plenty of people talking to themselves in moments of stress. Can’t lock them all up. It might be a fair enough point that too many mentally ill people roam the streets without care but isn’t this a bit of an assumption in her case?

      Reply
  • ptriley 30/12/12 #

    I hope no one ever gets pushed under the DART.

    Reply
  • Wow, she certainly sound like an intelligent and well educated woman! The stupidity and ignorance or some people amazed me!! Bloody Hell!

    Reply
  • Lock her up in Guantanamo

    Reply
  • @ Gordon Lucas as I posted above please note the word IF in my posts. No I am not a mental health professional ( although I am married to one). But my conclusion is that she is either suffering under delusions or as you implied terminally stupid.

    Reply
  • Azul 01/01/13 #

    Islamaphobia – you’d think from this PC terminology, that there was nothing abhorrent about aspects of their religion which has given rise to generalised fear or dislike:
    – Absence of rights for women (supression) & homosexuals (Death Sentence)
    – Practice of enforced wearing of the Burkha/Veil OR acid thrown in face for dissenters etc
    – Violent behaviour – cult of the suicide bomber targeting civilians as shaheed or martyr
    – Demand for segregation of children in western schools – intolerance towards host populations and host countries
    – Public beheadings, public whippings and hand choppings – Saudi Arabia and Emirates
    – Absence of any rights under law for non-Muslims in Islamic ‘Sharia’ countries – Saudi Arabia and Emirates
    – ‘Honour’ killings of women and others who disagree with their radical conservatism ref: http://www.asiaone.com/News/Latest+News/World/Story/A1Story20121231-392542.html
    etc

    …Ken Bigley, Margaret Hassan etc…

    Reply
  • Leigh please note the use of the word IF in my comment. It would seem likely considering her behaviour before,and statements after the crime but I’m not jumping to conclusions. I’m sure we will find out more in due course.

    Reply
  • Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned

    William Shakespeare

    Reply

Add New Comment