TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Emergency medics lash out as trolley numbers hit eight-month high

The Irish Association of Emergency Medicine criticises the failure to end waits on trolleys, as 385 wait for admission.

Demonstrations outside Leinster House in 2006, when the number on hospital trolleys reached 495.
Demonstrations outside Leinster House in 2006, when the number on hospital trolleys reached 495.
Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

AN ASSOCIATION representing medical staff working in the country’s emergency wards has criticised the government’s failure to meet previous commitments that no in-patient would have to wait on a trolley for hospital admission.

The criticism comes as new figures published this morning showed that 385 people were on trolleys in hospital corridors awaiting hospital admission – the highest level in eight months.

The Irish Association of Emergency Medicine said James Reilly had promised to end the “scandal” of having patients forced to wait on trolleys for hospital admission by the end of 2012, but that this commitment has not been met.

“In spite of the clear commitment given to adopt a zero tolerance policy to ED overcrowding,” the body said in a statement this afternoon, “little of substance has actually happened.”

The numbers on trolleys today include 38 in Beaumont Hospital alone, with a further 29 in the Mater, 24 in St Vincent’s Hospital, and 20 in James Connolly hospital in Blanchardstown. In all, 115 people are on trolleys in the HSE Eastern region.

A further 28 are on trolleys in Cork University Hospital, 27 in Mid Western Regional Hospital in Limerick, and 23 at Midland Regional Hospital in Mullingar.

The IAEM said those people could “be forgiven for asking whether this major public health issue is being taken seriously by those responsible for managing our Health Service”.

“The clear evidence over the last decade is that it isn’t,” it said.

The body cited comments by a HSE spokesperson last month, who said the increased in numbers on trolleys was ‘not a cause for concern’, as an illustration that the government had abandoned its zero tolerance approach to hospital overcrowding.

Last July, the chairman of the Oireachtas health committee James Buttimer claimed Reilly was “winning the war on trolley numbers” when the number on trolleys had fallen to below 250, its lowest levels of the year at that point.

Read: Minister for Health “winning the war on trolley numbers”

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • I was in the A&E in the CUH a couple of weeks ago and it was like a war zone. There was people on trolleys everywhere. The staff in the hospital were brilliant but you could see they were at their wits end with where to put people next. The sad thing was that there was loads of beds upstairs but as the nurse told me there was not enough staff to open the wards. James Reilly is no different than what came before him

    Reply
  • No doubt Reilly will be out rubbishing these claims just as Shatter rubbished the claims of the commissioner yesterday.

    Reply
  • Isn’t it obvious to everyone by now that Reilly has lost control of his brief? He has been a complete failure and is so out of his depth. Maybe if he spent less time trying to interfere with lists of potential clinics and more time actually doing his job he might have some chance of ending this farce! The Irish health system is meltdown, it is third world in all but name and yet the minister is being paid one of the highest salaries (not to mention pensions, expenses etc) in the western world, go figure folks!

    Reply
  • What is worse, is the Management at the hospitals will open a ward and clear A&E if the minister for health pays a visit! It’s ridiculous!! The place could be crazy every other day but when he arrives the place looks empty, and he prob thinks that all is gravy!! It’s a silly policy to make management look good but it never gets the problem solved!!

    Reply
    • That’s exactly true Steven!! Ive seen it numerous times and its disgusting….

      Reply
    • A relative was in The Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda last week, the official figure for those on trolleys was around 60 and at one stage they ran out of trolleys but a member of staff told her that the true number was much higher, closer to 100. She said they had several “overflow” wards around the hospital to place people on trolleys and even these were full, they had no nurses, doctors or any other staff to care for the patients in these wards and only 4 nurses for the entire A&E Department. But hey, management had a great Christmas.

      Reply
    • I was one of those in A & E in Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital last week. I was given the Triage bed at 11.57p.m. I was on O2, intravenous antibiotics and other medication. Doctor came around 9.00a.m. and discharged me – hired a taxi and sent me home! They knew my age 85 years, living alone and no relatives. I am still waiting for them to make contact with me to see if I am dead or alive.

      Reply
  • I was in the Louth County Hospital today, fine, clean, bright and airy place. Trouble was there was hardly anyone there! It is a stroke hospital now with a day unit for some procedures. As you walk through the hosp all you see are empty beds. Go to our lady of lourdes in drogheda and it’s like grand central station in NY, it’s despicable. If I had got sick in the Louth today they would have moved me to drogheda. James Reilly is an ass

    Reply
    • Same here in Roscommon since Enda and James closed our A+E in July 2011 and the Roscommon People have a round trip of a minimum of Three and half hours to the nearest A+E Thanks Enda and James yea are a disgrace

      Reply
  • I don’t want to be flippant,but those on trolleys are actually the lucky ones. The mother of a friend of mine was siting on a chair for over 24 hours before she was admitted. And the same thing happened to my father about 11 years ago in the Mater. Absolutely nothing has changed. Catch James Reilly or any of the elite sitting on chairs or lying on trolleys. It’s shameful, that’s what it is!

    Reply
  • The trolleys are full in Public hospitals because all the private health plans went up so now people with chi can avail of public beds and pay cheap plans on private insurance I spent 30 hrs with my husband in the mater hospital in a&e even though he was admitted straight away sat on a chair for 30hrs before Xmas then 12 hrs in beumont 2 be sent home on heavy pain killers even though he is waiting on serious surgery iv seen it all the last 4 mths

    Reply
    • @Doreen Mc Allister : re your comment on ‘cheap plans’ in private health insurance & private patients taking up beds-insurance is not cheap,private patients are on long waiting lists too. Public Hospitals charge €1,250 on average per night to insurance providers.Public patient free on Med.Card,€75 without. I wait as long as you for essential treatments Beaumont-& have to travel from NW!

      Reply
    • Well I watched a programme on tv3 Wednesday morning and 1 of the women who is an economist needed a procedure done she was with a private health insurance company she got 2 options 1 to go 2 a private hospital which she said was beautiful but her plan she was on she had 2 pay a lot towards it but she opted for public hospital same job done same consultant and her insurance covered her so I think that speaks for itself

      Reply
    • Hii Doreen, It doesn’t matter whether you have private cover or not, if you have to go into A&E the waiting time is the same as everyone else. But I do agree that take up of beds by private patients plus the problem of adequate care plans on discharge, particularly for the elderly means that there is an inadequate bed supply, and don’t get me started about the closure of wards because of lack of funding for staff to run them. The government in this country should hang its head in shame at the mess that’s been made of what used to be a pretty good health service.

      Reply
  • The staff on the wards are brilliant,the staff levels in admin are insane,2000 in HR alone get Michael O’Leary in there and sort out the madness.

    Reply

Add New Comment