TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 19 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Parents misjudging their children’s weight, report shows

An expert from safefood said that assessing children’s body weight should be viewed in the same way as hearing or sight test.

HALF OF THE parents of overweight children believe that their child’s weight is ‘about right’, a new report says.

Safefood reports today that people’s perception of weight is different to the reality, with 54 per cent of parents of overweight primary school children, and 20 per cent of obese children, thinking that their weight was ‘about right for their height’.

When it came to parents of overweight teenagers, they were even less accurate in their judgement – 75 per cent of them thought their teen’s weight was ‘fine’.

Parents were 86 per cent less likely to be correct about their child’s weight if their child was overweight and approximately 59 per cent less likely to be correct if the child was obese, compared to parents of normal weight children.

Currently two in every three adults are overweight or obese on the island of Ireland, but less than four in ten adults actually believe they are overweight, said safefood.

Data shows that around a quarter of children, meanwhile, are overweight or obese.

Assessing weight

Dr Cliodhna Foley-Nolan, the director of human health and nutrition at safefood said:

Not recognising our own weight status or indeed, our children’s weight status represents a major barrier to making any future changes to our lifestyle. Being overweight now is the norm and as a society we must recognise our bodyweight before we can realistically begin to make positive changes, especially for our children.

The results are contained in Bodyweight Perception on the island of Ireland, which is available to read here.

The report showed that awareness is often considered a pre-requisite to positive change occurring, but with adults or carers not recognising unhealthy weights, they are unlikely to seek information and health from health professionals.

Dr Foley-Nolan said that bodyweight is an extremely sensitive and personal issue, and that among children, assessing body weight should be viewed in the same way as hearing or sight tests. She said it should be “as a measure of a child’s developmental progress and not in any way as a criticism of parenting”.

The report also notes that media framing of obesity may be important in determining recognition of bodyweight status, and blaming individuals can undermine efforts to address weight issues. It suggests that work should be done with the media to “address uncertainty, mistrust in experts” and confusion about what constitutes a health weight.

It also says that health professionals “lack confidence and training in measurement and communication of bodyweight”, and so recommends training programmes to address this.

Read: Forget the New Year’s diet? Being slightly ‘overweight’ extends your life>

Read: Healthy flag’ for schools could combat obesity, says TD>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (24 Comments)

  • The dilemma is that, on the one hand, a parent’s child may be overweight, but on the other hand, parents are now well aware that low-self-esteem connected to body image can lead to all sorts of disorders, and they might bite their tongue rather than add to the self-esteem issues. A case of where what parent’s say might not be what that parent thinks, due to not wanting to harm their child.

    Promoting healthier eating, regular exercise and less fear of the big wide world outdoors are really the only ways to improve the situation.

    Reply
    • I heard a woman on the radio say not to let kids go around in tracksuits with elastic waistband but to keep then in trousers and skirts so when the buttons fly off you know they have put on a flew pounds without having to throw them on the scales (paraphrasing a little)

      Reply
    • That’s great advice for preteen / young teen girls when they start getting a womans figure they think a size 8 is fat because they were a size 6, they think they are obese if they then need a size 10.

      Girls are supposed to get curves anywhere from age 10 up depending on puberty and are not supposed to look like boys.

      Reply
  • siobeli 12/02/13 #

    The parents that don’t think their children are over weight are either over weight themselves or, won’t admit that it is their fault that their child is over weight….for example if a 8 year old is obese, it is not the fault of the child, teacher, school or media- it is the parent feeding their child crap because it is easier for some parents to get a take away than cook from scratch.
    Drives me mad when research like this comes out and the solutions are always more education on healthy eating….!! It’s just condescending…who would think curry chips from the take away is as good for them as mashed potatoes and a cooked chicken!!!
    It’s pure laziness!!!!

    Reply
    • Agree with some of what you say. Not always laziness though. Parents on low incomes may have to balance between paying accumulated debts or stuffing young Johnny with processed muck as they just can’t afford a nice and healthy roast chicken dinner. Working long hours and extensive daily commutes may sap their motivation to cook. Nutritionally processed mashed potatoes ain’t that great either. There are better and healthier options. Some of them can even be produced reasonably quickly. The parents need to be educated too. They do need to lead by example but their sedentary lifestyles and long working hours/commutes may disadvantage their own dietary and exercise needs being met. Thus the problem is a more macro societal issue I believe.

      Reply
    • siobeli 12/02/13 #

      Keith I take your points, but as a working mother, with crèche fees and a mortgage etc healthy food can be gotten cheap! Fresh fruit and veg in aldi and lidl are very reasonable, (for example I got 1kg of salad potatoes for 49 cent!), a large chicken-I get a roast dinner, leftovers next day for stir fry and broth for a soup…that’s 3 meals. I often prepare dinner at 6am and have oven on timer to cook food, very cheap meat can be slowed cook for a stew.There are days when the frozen pizza and chips are done or a take away chipper, but it’s rare, as both cost too much!!

      Reply
    • Your great Siobeli. Especially if you’re managing all that around a full-time stressful job, long commute and with several mouths to feed.

      Reply
    • ‘You’re’……Just in case Martin O’Callaghan the grammar and spelling Nazi is still stalking me :)

      Reply
    • Lol

      Reply
    • siobeli 12/02/13 #

      I’m not the only woman doing it!! Numerous women out there also, stay at home mum’s too… I chose to become a parent, which is a full time stressful job in itself. It is the hardest job, but the most rewarding… The commute to work is my “me time” everyday, so it’s a joy and my paid employment is full on with a lot of responsibility with crap pay but at least i get a lunch hour and the opportunity to drink a cuppa hot!!

      Reply
  • Is not misjudging, its ignorance. To put it mildly.

    Reply
  • They are probably underestimating their own weight as well

    Reply
  • The education system could help too if it was facilitated with encouraging healthy meal options/discussion and if exercise classes were encouraged and increased. Perhaps they could replace religious education. Unfortunately the media encourages the consumption of crappy fatty and sugar/carb rich processed products. Ironically exercise increases endorphin and serotonin levels as well as encouraging team work so self esteem will improve naturally as an added benefit.

    Reply
    • Healthy eating is covered in science and SPHE. SPHE covers all kinds of health incl topics parents should cover like teeth brushing personal hygiene and a healthy lifestyle. The curriculum also has an hour of pe which can be dance, gymnastics or games. I think teachers are trying their best but I think a lot of parents need educating too. Times have changed and there are new challenges. Kids are more sedentary. I’d say we ate as much junk but we spent hours outside playing!

      Reply
    • I certainly don’t blame teachers. It’s the system but ultimately parental and State responsibility. An hour of irregular exercise won’t help much. Education around diet etc is practical but must be in unison with parental modelling and should be encouraged and fascilitated by the State. I’d rather see my tax euros pay towards practical lifelong healthy lifestyles for young people rather than the worship of supernatural beings.

      Reply
  • Parents should understand that if they bring up their kids at little bloaters they’ll have heart issues and probably won’t make it past 30.

    What parent wants to outlive their child?

    Reply
  • My daughter was overweight, she was born over weight weighing 9lb 1 at 39 weeks and the length of a 2-3 month old. She stayed above that percentile till she was 5, she was way over the 99th percentile for weight, She was tall but still heavy for her height. She was breast fed till she was 2.5. No one in the health care said she was overweight, they said she was fine. At 3 months she was the weight of the average 9 month old. At a year she was the weight of a 2.5 year old ( height of a 20 month old)

    Reply
  • Everybody should use the BMI scale, which is accurate and scientific, to determine their weight.
    The terms overweight and obese are medical terms, not societal judgements. I openly admit that I’m overweight but I’m not ashamed of the fact. As an adult I am aware of my health and am the only one in a position to do anything about it. This is the message parents need to give to their kids, call a spade a spade and don’t be ashamed of facts.

    Reply
    • Actually Donal I question the accuracy of BMI scaling. When I’d developed significant muscle mass from weightlifting a nurse attempted to tell me I was overweight according to these measurements. My fat levels were actually significantly below average.

      Reply
    • What Keith says is true, look at rugby players as well who have a high BMI but low body fat, BMI can be used as a guideline but is not always accurate

      Reply
    • BMI is a decent guideline, but seems to judge taller and more muscular people incorrectly – check the equation and you’ll see why. Most people know if they have a reasonably healthy lifestyle – are you out of breath if you have to run for the bus? Your self esteem message is ill advised, pretending there isn’t a problem won’t make it go away.

      Reply
    • Totally agree with Keith and Brianan, BMI is not a good measure, I’m a slim build and always an in the healthy range, even when i was carrying a lot of weight and had body fat of 33%. That was a huge wake up call and a better measure.

      Reply
    • BMI is completely inaccurate and misleading. Example: Brad Pitt in Fight Club. Overweight? Turns out he is obese according to the BMI scale. Professional football players? Overweight. Professional rugby players? Morbidly obese. It doesn’t take fat percentage, muscle density, water retention or sodium levels into consideration and cannot be relied upon in any way…

      Reply
  • Great to see a bit of debate about this topic. My own feeling is that an overemphasis on children’s weight causes body image problems and public health campaigns should focus on healthy lifestyle choices for all (not just those who are ‘overweight’ according to BMI measurements.

    If anyone would like to discuss this further, please join the Endangered Bodies Ireland facebook page.
    http://www.facebook.com/pages/Endangered-Bodies-Ireland/240757395980038

    Thanks

    Reply

Add New Comment