TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Troika discouraged from opposition meetings by May referendum, says ECB

The Troika will not be meeting opposition parties during their latest visit to Ireland – despite doing so during previous reviews.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire/Press Association Images

DESPITE MEETING with opposition politicians during previous reviews of Ireland’s bailout programme, Troika officials from the EU, ECB and IMF will not be holding such meetings during their latest review.

A Troika team is currently in Ireland to carry out their latest assessment of the state’s loan agreement programme.

A spokesperson for the ECB told TheJournal.ie this afternoon that the forthcoming referendum was the reason behind the decision.

The spokesperson said that while it was good to meet with people for talks in general, “now that the referendum issue is there and the timing is in place, it would not be the appropriate thing to do.”

It is understood that once the referendum on the Fiscal Compact Treaty is over, further reviews will involve meetings with the opposition parties and other groups such as Social Justice Ireland.

Fianna Fáil Senator Thomas Byrne, who was involved in previous Troika meetings including that of January 2012, described the decision not to meet with the opposition as a “retrograde step”.

“Hiding Troika officials and keeping all business behind closed doors will do nothing to encourage public confidence in this process,” Byrne said. “I am appealing to the Finance Minister Michael Noonan to change [the] government’s approach and facilitate proper political and media engagement with the Troika while they are here.”

His Oireachtas colleague Michael McGrath TD said it was “deeply disappointing that the Troika has decided not to meet opposition parties during this visit.”

“It is highly regrettable that they would refuse to engage with the largest opposition party at a time when this country is facing a series of critical economic issues – not least the ongoing intransigence of the ECB to ensure there is an equitable sharing of the burden of bank debt.”

Meanwhile, Sinn Féin’s Gerry Adams criticised the decision as “an affront to democracy and an insult to our mandates and electorate”.

The Louth TD said that the party had contacted the Department of Finance ahead of the Troika visit and was informed that on this occasion, Troika officials would not be meeting with opposition parties.

“Sinn Féin then contacted the European Commission and IMF permanent representations in Dublin to see if a meeting could be organised but were told that the review delegation would not be meeting political parties,” he added.

“It is not yet clear whether this refusal to meet opposition parties was a decision of the Troika alone, or a decision taken on request of the government.

A spokesperson for the Department of Finance said that the IMF decides who it will meet and that the department facilitates such meetings.

“They come over and set up their agenda in terms of who they want to meet,” he said. It’s a matter for the Troika themselves, and that’s the same with the press conference at the end as well.”

The ECB spokesperson told TheJournal.ie that it is up to the Troika to decide who to meet with and that “this time it was a Troika decision not to [meet with the opposition]“.

Read next:

Comments (36 Comments)

  • If all we are doing is implementing the troikas conditions then there really is no need what so ever for a government. Just fax through the instructions to the various civil servants departments on a Monday morning and be done with it. Unless the government actually start representing our point of view then its utterly pointless and only serves to enrich their cronies matrs and further influence decisions than further their cause in the future.

    Reply
  • I can imagine that smug Quisling Barbara Nolan advising the Troika to take this stance

    Reply
  • Fianna Fail complaining about hiding Troika officials and keeping all business behind closed doors! You couldn’t make it up. The markets may have no memory but the people do.

    Reply
    • I as a concerned citizen am extremely worried about Fine Gael and their European counterparts keeping business behind closed doors, when they were last here Fianna Fail did not stop any opposition going into talks, so why are FIne Gael. We are talking about Troika whose only interest is getting money off us and FIne Gael who are only interested in keeping their masters in Europe happy and all you can do is use the fact that no one can go in and oppose them as an excuse to bitch at Fianna Fail. This country is screwed.

      Reply
    • Fagan's 17/04/12 #

      Marcella. The criminals and traitors of FF spent long enough talking to the IMF when they were arranging to hand over our hard one sovereignty to them, in exchange for protecting their friends and donors in Anglo. Who can forget Wormtongue Lenihan lying to us up to the very last minute.

      I’d feel that the other parties in opposition should meet with the Troika but the Traitors Party – FF should be consigned to the dustbin of history. They have destroyed this country lets not afford them a chance to pick the corpse clean on the way out.

      Reply
    • Marcella, trust me I share your view regarding FG / Troika arrogance and blatant disregard for the people of this country. It’s matched only by Fianna Fail who are an opposition party in name only when it comes to the economy. I’ll stop bitching about them when they put the countries interests before party and members interests, so I suspect it’s going to be a while unless they eventually die out as a party.

      Reply
    • @ Marcella: This is the sixth review. All of the other reviews (carried out under FG/Lab) have had press conferences and meetings with the opposition parties. This is the only one that hasn’t. Don’t paint FF as our saviours.

      Also the Troika’s only interest is not “to get money off us.” It is to ensure that we are spending the money they lent us correctly so they can get those loans back.

      Reply
  • Obviously have a lot to hide. Just another slap in the face by the Troika, unwilling to enter any debate – just do as your told attitude! Well two can play at that game………..my vote is NO!

    Reply
  • I wonder what exactly they are trying to hide from the Irish electorate. We know the leaders of the Vichy government will never tell the truth but the independents and SF would have no qualms about letting people know what’s really going on.

    Reply
  • I just love it. The old order cannot help reveal itself. It is on its last legs. They cannot but show themselves for the arrogant sociopaths they are. Keep it up!

    Don’t meet with our opposition. It’s not going to be so cozy when Sinn Féin/ULA are truly representing the people of Ireland after the next GE. I’ll give FG/Labour another budget.

    So Troika, give us your worst/best report. Let Enda have the pleasure of sticking it up on his fridge. Pathetic excuse for a man!

    Reply
  • of course they won’t meet those who oppose them. Its logical. Why would a bunch of financial cowards want to meet anyone who criticises them., As far as they are concerned its not necessary to talk to those they view as subordinate. We should just stop them physically from entering the country. We should do something other than sit and listen to them dictate to us like slaves.

    Reply
    • Fagan's 17/04/12 #

      Well FF do not oppose them they invited them in and handed them the title deeds.

      What’s the betting McGrath and Micheal Martin would only use it as a chance to canvas for a job in the EU.

      Reply
  • ”democracy?” hahhahaha

    Reply
  • I understand the difficult choices the government have had to make and i won’t be voting based on these issues. What i cannot agree with is the actions and attitudes of Shatter and Hogan who have treated the people of this country like bold children. If they are still in their positions when this referendum comes I will be voting no.

    Reply
  • This Government is Planning on Rigging a yes Vote, by cheating the Irish out of a Fair Vote referendum, it has been all planned, and they want us to vote again on the Defeated Abbylara Kangaroo Vote that we all voted know on, We need to Watch Shatter, and Burton, they are trying to reverse the Kangaroo Vote that we defeated last Oct . We had one for the Judges Pay and the Other for the kangaroo Court Referenda, Alan shatter said that we didn’t understand the Vote, and asked Judge Feely to bring it in as Law, we said no, and Phil Hogan didn’t send the treaty to be demolished, so we have to say no again as it undermines our Human rights and democracy of freedom of speech, and abuse our good name and give more power to this government, we must stop these Traitors from betraying our People of Ireland, a pack of lies they have told us all since they got into Government, do we want to be sold out to the slaves, wake up Ireland, Rita Cahill

    Reply
  • censored 18/04/12 #

    I am discouraged for democracy.

    Reply
  • mcbab 17/04/12 #

    I would imagine one meeting with Adams would be enough for a lifetime. Yuck!

    Reply
  • Well, You Know labour never Got Rid of their Voting machine, and that is a true fact, so it might not be Labour, but other parties know of Labours Voting Machine, and that they still kept it, from last election.Rita Cahill

    Reply
  • Good lad Jimbo, good lad.

    Reply
  • If there was a press conference and meetings with the opposition, as has happened on all the previous reviews, people on here would simply be complaining about it being a waste of time. And would then probably complain further about the Troika bullying us into voting Yes.

    Now there’s no press conference and meetings with the opposition and people on here are still complaining.

    Some people are never happy.

    Reply
  • Can you blame them when it means sitting with Fianna Fail to hear their views :P

    Reply

Add New Comment