TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Workers who get sick on holidays ‘are entitled to another holiday’

That’s according to the Court of Justice of the European Union, which said today that if a worker becomes ill during annual leave, they are entitled to take that leave at another date.

Image: Matt Rourke/AP/Press Association Images

AN EMPLOYEE WHO gets sick while on paid annual leave is entitled to another period of leave to make up for this, a European court has said today.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that a worker who becomes unfit for work during his or her paid annual leave is entitled at a later point in time to a period of leave of the same duration as that of his/her sick leave.

Employees are entitled to the right irrespective of when they get sick, the court ruled.

The ruling was made following a case brought relating to Spanish law, which did not address situations in which the period of leave coincides with sick leave on account of temporary disability.

It came about after a number of trade unions representing workers brought collective actions before the Spanish courts. These were to recognise the right of works to paid annual leave, even where it coincides with periods of sick leave where they have a temporary incapacity for work.

The Asociación Nacional de Grandes Empresas de Distribución opposed the claims and said workers are not entitled to take leave at a later date.

The Court points out that, according to settled case-law:

entitlement to paid annual leave must be regarded as a particularly important principle of EU social law, a principle expressly enshrined in the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The right to paid annual leave cannot be interpreted restrictively

It also said that the purpose of entitlement to paid annual leave “is to enable the worker to rest and enjoy a period of relaxation and leisure. The purpose of entitlement to sick leave is different, since it enables a worker to recover from an illness that has caused him to be unfit for work.”

In its judgment today, the Court stated that the point at which the temporary incapacity arose “is irrelevant”.

Consequently, a worker is entitled to take paid annual leave which coincides with a period of sick leave at a later point in time, irrespective of the point at which the incapacity for work arose. It would be arbitrary and contrary to the purpose of entitlement to paid annual leave to grant workers the right to paid leave only if they are already unfit for work when the period of paid annual leave commences.

In that context, the Court pointed out that the new period of annual leave may be scheduled, if necessary, outside the corresponding reference period for annual leave.

Read: ISME: Hot weather ‘doesn’t lead to rise in sick leave’>

Read next:

Comments (39 Comments)

  • Thought this was always legislated in employment law??

    Reply
  • I wonder how this would work for those who don’t get paid for sick days such as a lot of the service industry?

    Reply
  • This is policy in my company already. If, for example, I produce a cert for 3 days while I’m off, I get the 3 days back. Neat eh?

    I’ve never heard of anyone availing of it though. The type of people who would be willing to do this, in my experience, are they type of people who pull sickies. Often, these are the type of people that cause less work for everyone else in absence, than they do in attendance.

    Reply
  • Mel that goes for all workers, I’m 15 years in public sector and I have not one sick day taken,

    Reply
    • 15 years there and not one injury from the money fights you guys have.

      Impressive.

      Reply
    • Wolfgang I work in an area of Dublin where you would crap yourself if you had to pass through, I’ve been spat at by junkies assaulted and threatened with blood filled syringes and after 15 years without going sick I feel lucky and proud if I’m to be honest, but you go paint all public servants with the one brush and I hope nothing happens in your ideal world where you need me or my colleagues

      Reply
    • Yeah but in fairness I wouldn’t take a job that involved working with junkies or in bad areas.

      I do have a solution to such areas though, a final solution:)

      The sheer number of red thumbs my last comment got would suggest there’s quite a few public sector employees here that should GET OFF THE INTERNET AND GET BACK TO WORK.

      Reply
  • Private sector worker,if i’m sick during my holidays i get them again.

    Reply
  • Down with annual leave, sick leave, maternity leave, compassionate leave, down with a living wage, welfare payments and all that other pinko shite. Bring back slavery and child labour.

    Reply
  • louise 21/06/12 #

    Must try that

    Reply
    • Why would you try getting sick?!nThis has been the case in Ireland for ages, but where sick days are not paid most employees choose to take the time off work as paid vacation anyway, unless it’s more than 3 days and they want to go through the bother of claiming of social welfare.

      Reply
  • I work in the public sector and every sick day has to have a certificate or get no pay after 3 days. I also think that a lot of workers in my area are stressed as they are doing jobs of people that left but never got filled due to embargoes. I often see 3 staff trying to look after food for a whole hospital; patients and staff and because of this can’t always be surprised that people get sick.

    Reply
    • i work in the private sector. and the minimum sick leace is 3 paid days per year. anything extra is at an employers discretion with moth service sector employers only paying tue statutory legal minimum. certified or not. and any one taking longer than 3 days uncertified is open to disciplinery action .

      Reply
  • Not wide open for abuse at all. If an employer is in a position to pay sick leave and they find that abuse takes place do u think they will tolerate it…. Some smart a#rse pulling a fast one could lose the benefit for an entire workforce ! The thought that getting sick being a positive thing sums up why we are where we are as a country :-(

    Reply
  • that doesnt affect irish employment law. as we already allow for that.
    an employee in ireland who has a certified sickness during that leave is entitle to have the leave re stated as sick leave and re gain the holiday days.

    Reply
  • I am currently working in spain in leroy merlin which is one of the companies which have been doing this for a long while but its not only the case with being of sick they were also doing it with maternity leave cos under our charter you are assigned your holidays at the start of the year so tecnically you could be given say your holidays in september but at the end of august you have an accident in work and you lose your holidays or get pregnant and on maternity leave and you lose your holidays, there are no labour laws like in ireland, here there are charters which are negotiated by collective bargaining but in my company there is a yellow union who agree to every demand by the company without anything in exchange, just recently my union won a court case against the.company when they tried to cut the weekends from 5 to 2 per year for people who less than six days a week(thats right we work six days a week with one off a month) it was declared discrimitory so its not only left wing loonies its common sense cos here if you have a work related accident to get paid by the company you need to go to the.mutua (a private clinic paid by the.company) they have to declare you unfit to work (rarely more than 48 hours.rest) but the company will always.tell you to go to the public.clinic, you.wont get paid the.first.three days pay then you get 100% of your salary from the mutua or 70% from the social security so is it fair?

    Reply
  • What about sun burn?? Seriously, I burnt my feet real bad in Lanzarote last year and was stuck in the apartment for 3 days, couldn’t walk and the day I finally head out to the pool was the same day the spanish topless girls headed home :(
    So do they cover sun burn?

    Reply
  • I work in Hungary where all sick days must be certified so little room for abuse. “Light-hearted” comments on “”pulling sickies” pervade Irish media and society, most recently heard in relation to a couple days sunshine from a morning Ireland presenter. To quote someone, the Irish need to “change their mentality”!

    Reply
  • You have to love the delusional, utopian world of lefties where ‘someone else’ has to pay for everything that befalls them. Even Marx would throw his eyes to heaven on this Ivory Tower judgement. Mental.

    Reply
    • Would Marx really do that? I think he’d be more concerned about the self-emancipation of working class people. He also spoke about how fighting for refrorms helps develop a revolutionary consciousness amongst workers. So I’d say he’d be chuffed with this.

      Reply
  • mel 21/06/12 #

    Public servants here don’t even have to be sick to take a sick day,great work if u can get it

    Reply
  • No wonder Spain is broke

    Reply
  • mcbab 21/06/12 #

    Ludicrous. Wide open to abuse. It will cost employers a fortune, not to mention the amount of litigation, meetings and general time wasting that any refusal will set off.

    Reply
  • I feel like a bollox for saying this but is it not tough titty if a person gets sick on their holiers?

    Reply
  • Very lefty judgement. “Business leaders” everywhere shudder. Yay

    Reply
  • Ah leave off!

    Reply
  • If Joan Burton gets her way employers will have to pay employees three times for their Holidays !!!

    Reply
  • The paid sick leave here is already abused by those in low skilled/entry level jobs. Publicizing such a fact as in this article will only cause even more abuse by these people.

    Reply
  • bah. we don’t get that here unless you’re one of the privileged few public sector (government) employees that have that entitlement in their union contracts.

    Reply
  • I’m out sick from work at the moment with pay how would that work now with me I wonder??!

    Reply

Add New Comment