TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

‘Worrying’ level of overspending at Irish universities, says TD

A Cork TD has expressed disbelief at UCC’s €138,000 taxi bill.

Image: Kman999 via Flickr

FOLLOWING REVELATIONS THAT Ireland’s seven universities spent over €1 million on room hire and another €377,000 on taxis during 2011, a TD has called for third level institutes to be more thrifty.

The figures released by the Department of Education before Christmas highlight a worrying level of overspend and waste, says Labour TD Michael McCarthy.

The money used by all seven of Ireland’s universities on ancillary areas such as room and taxi hire, legal fees, staff agency costs and remuneration for visiting lecturers were published after McCarthy asked Minister Ruairi Quinn for a breakdown of spending in a Dáil questions-and-answers session.

“At a time when the third-level sector is struggling to fund itself, such costs cannot be justified…The figures show how the State’s main universities need to achieve greater economies and efficiencies in how they go about their business,” McCarthy said in a statement to TheJournal.ie.

The deputy was particularly critical of the University College Cork’s €138,000 spend on taxis in the 12-month period.

“It has to be asked who authorised this kind of spending on taxi hire – what travel was involved, and what level of accountability there is for it,” he said.

[The college's] central location, and its close proximity to the train station and the airport, calls into question the college’s high taxi bill and there needs to be further clarification on the reasons behind these startling costs.”

The other six institutes spent between just €25,000 and €54,000 on taxi hire during 2011.

Trinity College Dublin spent over €550,000 on room hire costs – the most of any of the universities. In contrast, University Limerick did not spend anything on hiring rooms for the year and did not pay expenses for visiting lecturers.

McCarthy has called on Minister Quinn to examine the spending of universities to ensure that money is not “wasted”.

Third-level colleges are regularly critical of the level of public funding they receive. With this in mind, it is vital that taxpayers are assured they are getting proper value for money.”

Read next:

Comments (13 Comments)

  • How the hell can UCC justify nearly 400 euro a DAY on taxi’s!! Imagine the taxi firm with that contract?! What an earner!

    Reply
    • A case of a University using neither its head nor its feet.

      Reply
    • I guess the question should be who were the taxis for? Obviously University staff should be responsible for their own transport. However it is very common to have lecturers from other Universities come to give talks, which is done free of charge, though transport and accommodation is usually provided by the hosting institute. €400 a day equates to about 20 round trip fares from UCC to the city and 20 visiting lecturers isn’t an inordinate number to have at any one time. This free and open exchange of ideas and information is what academics is based on and if Universities were to adapt an industrial business model the charge for someone to come give a talk would far exceed a return taxi trip. I’m not saying that UCC isn’t being reckless with its spending, just that we need more information before making any harsh judgements.

      Reply
    • Why dont they have a car and driver for any visiting lecturers to drive to and from the campus ….. Or is that too far outside the box for our scholars ?

      Reply
    • Well if you add up the cost of salary, vehicle, insurance, fuel and then multiply it by two because the daily need for a driver would most probably span more than an eight hour period, I’d imagine the cost would be comparable (ish). But then the headline would read ‘UCC pays over €100,000/year for fleet of personal drivers’ and the deluge of reactionary statements would be pretty similar I’d guess. But again, this is only a guess.

      Reply
  • We should now get a detailed breakdown and explanation for that sort of spending, why it was justified. Heck, we should get that from every state agency and body and recipient of public funding as a matter of course!

    And what’s up with Trinity that they spent €1,500 a day on room hire? They could have rented a second campus with catering for that.

    Reply
  • Minister put a stop to this flagrant abuse immediately !

    Reply
  • At TCD all Christmas parties were suspended in 2008 no bonuses no overtime no benefits they are not the worst. However universities not only educate but also launch successful companies to give back to the economy which is a worthwhile investment I think. Agree with accounting but think people should properly understand the modern universities place in society.

    Reply
    • With 500k unemployed, the universities are having some impact. Read in the Irish Times that Science Foundation Ireland is funding 3000 people in the universities. Launch successful companies to give back to the economy. Really? That’s the stuff of IDA fiction. How many per annum? At what cumulative cost? Number of employees?

      Reply
  • Ciaro 09/01/12 #

    Withdraw the increase in student fees until they get their act together……let’s say a 5% increase in fees in return for a 5% saving in costs.
    Likewise for Irish rail, Dublin bus, bus eireann, RSA and so on.

    Reply
  • I’d say they must of had a cracking christmas party at taxpayers expense.

    Reply
  • So this is the reason our college fees have seen a hike over the last few years! This would make you sick

    Reply

Add New Comment