We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Catherine Connolly

'Damning verdict' for Irish government: How foreign media has covered Catherine Connolly's win

In the Middle East, coverage centred around Connolly’s position on Israel and Palestine.

LAST UPDATE | 26 Oct

INTERNATIONAL COVERAGE OF Catherine Connolly’s election as president of Ireland this weekend has mostly focused on her stance on international affairs, including her opinions on the United States, Nato, the European Union, Israel and Palestine. 

Some outlets also noted the high proportion of spoilt votes and cast Connolly’s win as a rebuke of the current coalition government. 

In the United States, the Irish Star, which bills itself as “the voice of Irish America”, covered Connolly’s impending victory by drawing attention to her past comments about Donald Trump and US imperialism. 

The paper also described her as being “widely perceived as the underdog” in the race, a characterisation Connolly and many others would likely disagree with.

It also said “Connolly’s liberal views have put her in the favour of young people in Ireland,” referencing her support for Palestine and referendums on same-sex marriage and abortion.

Politico, a US-based online political news outlet, focused on Connolly’s opinion of Nato and her opposition to past European Union treaties. 

Its article also said Connolly had been “accused of offering propaganda boosts for dictators from Russia to Syria”.

Comparing Connolly to President Michael D Higgins, it said: 

“Connolly has been outspoken in condemning Israel for its two-year war in Gaza — a certain vote-winner in a country that openly sympathizes with the Palestinians and has wretched relations with Tel Aviv.

“But Connolly has gone farther, defending Hamas’ right to play a future role in any Palestinian state,” the article said. 

It went on to say that Connolly’s “Nato-critical stance on Ukraine” could generate “the most awkward headlines for an Irish government caught between the state’s official neutrality and its support for EU efforts to bolster Ukraine”. 

In the Middle East, coverage centred around Connolly’s position on Israel and Palestine. 

Qatari news organisation Al Jazeera described her as a “pro-Palestine candidate” in its article about the election, while The Times of Israel newspaper described her as “anti-Israel”. 

Al Jazeara described how Connolly’s campaign has been “especially popular among young people, who approve of her declaration that reunification with Northern Ireland is a ‘foregone conclusion’, her strong pro-Palestine stance, her commitment to social justice, and criticism of the European Union’s growing ‘militarisation’”. 

The Times of Israel said her victory has come “despite backlash over her apparent support for Hamas”. 

“Connolly, in particular, has attracted attention for her outspoken criticism of Israel and her controversial remarks about Palestinians and Hamas,” the article read. 

“Connolly later clarified that she ‘utterly condemned’ Hamas’ actions, while also criticizing Israel for what she described as ‘genocide’ in Gaza, a claim strongly rejected by Israel.”

Another Israeli publication, The Jerusalem Post, focused on Connolly’s description of Hamas as “part of the fabric of Palestinian life” while arguing the group should have some say in the future governance of Gaza. The article also quoted Connolly’s description of Israel as “a terrorist state”. 

The Australian ran a piece describing Connolly as “a nutter” and said her election was “the ultimate joke”.

“There’s a colourless establishment technocrat on one side, and an absolute nutter on the other. And if the polls are right, the nutter is going to win,” it said. 

Closer to home, in the UK, The Guardian cast Connolly’s success as a response to the current coalition government. 

“Anger over a housing crisis and the cost of living, campaign blunders by Fine Gael and its ruling partner Fianna Fáil, rare unity among leftwing parties and deft use of social media combined to make Connolly a symbol of change,” its article read. 

In a later analysis piece, Rory Carroll of The Guardian said Connolly’s win was “a stunning political feat that humiliates the establishment but does not signify a national swerve to the left”.

“The ruling parties sabotaged themselves,” Carroll said. 

“In Britain some have compared Connolly to Jeremy Corbyn and marvel – or groan – that an EU state has veered left when so many other countries have drifted right or far-right,” the article read. 

Euractiv, a publicly and privately funded news outlet that receives some of its budget from the EU, described Connolly as a “controversial” figure who “has long described the EU as neoliberal and undemocratic and has opposed Ireland’s ratification of several EU treaties”.

“Some predict her strong left-wing views on foreign policy, social justice and housing could cause friction with the conservative leaning coalition government,” it said.

Germany’s national news outlet DW said Connolly’s election was “a damning verdict for Ireland’s centre-right coalition government”.

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Close
80 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel

     
    JournalTv
    News in 60 seconds