TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 2 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Britain’s top Catholic in ‘inappropriate acts’ row: report

Cardinal Keith O’Brien is due to vote on Pope Benedict XVI’s successor.

File photo of Cardinal Keith O'Brien
File photo of Cardinal Keith O'Brien
Image: Andrew Milligan/PA Wire/Press Association Images

BRITAIN’S MOST SENIOR Roman Catholic cleric, who is due to vote on Pope Benedict XVI’s successor, has been reported to the Vatican over claims of inappropriate behaviour, the Observer reported today.

Cardinal Keith O’Brien, leader of the Catholic Church in Scotland, contests allegations by three priests and a former priest which were sent to Rome a week before Pope Benedict’s resignation on February 11.

Claimaints

The four claimants, from the diocese of St Andrews and Edinburgh in Scotland, reported to nuncio Antonio Mennini, the Vatican’s ambassador to Britain, that O’Brien had committed “inappropriate acts” going back 33 years.

One priest claims he received unwanted attention from the cardinal after a late-night drinking session. Another alleges that O’Brien used night prayers as cover for inappropriate contact, according to the paper.

O’Brien has a vote in the forthcoming papal conclave. The claimants, who are demanding the cleric’s resignation, are worried that their report will not be properly addressed if he is allowed to travel to Rome.

“It (the church) tends to cover up and protect the system at all costs,” said one of the complainants, according to quotes published by the Observer newspaper.

The church is beautiful, but it has a dark side and that has to do with accountability. If the system is to be improved, maybe it needs to be dismantled a bit.

O’Brien, who is due to retire next month, has angered the gay community with his conservative stance on homosexuality.

He recently said that same-sex marriages would be “harmful to the physical, mental and spiritual well-being of those involved” and has long voiced opposition to gay adoption.

- © AFP, 2013

Read: Catholic priests should be able to marry: British cardinal>

Read next:

Comments (52 Comments)

  • Nothing shocks any more. And yet we are to take instruction about morality, charity and humility from pampered men dressed in horrendously expensive lace, gold fabric, fancy hats and big-name designer shoes; men who revel in titles like “prince” and whe demand pomp, ceremony and subjugation; men who live in obscene opulence while millions starve; men who protect themselves from criminal prosecution for criminal acts by using their own “cardinal law” that amounts to little more than a rebuke and a glamour downgrade. These men have NO right to tell the rest of us how to live.

    Reply
  • Re his conservative mindset, it seems ‘the lady doth protest too much’

    Reply
    • To quote Hitchens ‘whenever I hear some bigmouth in Washington or the Christian heartland banging on about the evils of sodomy or whatever, I mentally enter his name in my notebook and contentedly set my watch. Sooner rather than later, he will be discovered down on his weary and well-worn old knees in some dreary motel or latrine, with an expired Visa card, having tried to pay well over the odds to be peed upon by some Apache transvestite.’

      Reply
    • Now thats a hat, feck the lot of ya’s. Im gettin me of of them.

      Reply
  • Wow, there’s a shocker.

    Man who loudly proclaims opposition to homosexuality, is accused of homosexuality.

    All that’s missing is that he’s not an American Republican politician.

    Reply
  • On the other hand you might wonder if this is a conspiracy by the Church itself to smear him. A cardinal saying he’s in favour of married priests would bectaken seriously, especially as there seems to be a groundswell in favour of it. What better way to discredit him than this? After what we know about the skulduggery that’s been going on nothing would surprise me.

    Reply
  • Liam 24/02/13 #

    This organisation is rotten to it’s core.

    Reply
  • I agree with john (ruddy). That is the point I was making. I resigned from the church through that website. It’s really up to parents to allow their children decide for themselves when they are 18.

    Reply
  • The pope sells you the idea of heaven. Yet drives around in a bullett proof vehicle trying to avoid heaven as long as possible. Religeon is pathethic

    Reply
  • It’s the hypocrisy of people like this that is really annoying. He’s gay…he should just admit it!

    Reply
  • This is the same man who was being praised by some a few days ago after saying priests should be able to marry?

    Reply
  • There was a time when religeon ruled the world. It was called the dark ages.

    Reply
  • And then they wonder why the Catholic Church is declining ! The Church is in need of a new young pope with more liberal views if it is to survive ! But men should as him would prefer to see the church to due out rather than go against ‘man made’ rules!!!!

    Reply
    • Sorry should read ‘such as him’

      Reply
    • The Roman Church is not declining – 84% of Irish people claim to be Roman Catholic. As long as people continue to mindlessly adhere to this disgraced institution (much as they continue to elect disgraced and corrupt politicians to office) the Roman Church will view this declared following as a vote of confidence in it’s corrupt administration.

      Reply
    • 84% had no choice in the matter. Most people are born catholic if their parents follow through with tradition. So the most anti gay cleric in Scotland is also gay. Well that speaks volumes for the corrupt nature of this so called church.

      Reply
    • No choice? What law, rule or regulation requires one to declare themselves to be Roman Catholic on the census form?

      Reply
    • Getting into most schools.

      Reply
    • Sorry John, it’s not as simple as that. Most of us are christened as babies and from that point we’re ‘on the books’. There was a way out of the CC which was advertised in recent years thru a website countmeout.com – the church spotted the loophole and have stopped further cessations. You can write and demand that you want out but there is a ruling which allows the bishop to decide that you don’t really understand the consequences of your request.

      I’m not making this up – it’s mad, Ted!

      And while, yes, i can comfortably claim to be whatever the hell i want in life, if something were to happen to my wife and i tomorrow, and we weren’t legally prepared, the church would have a say on how we should be interred…

      Reply
    • @John – Most people are just identifying with their religious background not actual ideology/beliefs.

      Reply
    • Aw man… This just gets weirder & weirder!
      Yes, the website ‘countmeout.ie’ used to assist people in defecting from the Roman Church until parish clergy were ordered not to cooperate with it by their bosses. That’s all that happened there. You can still do it yourself if you want to take the time and bother. What some loon in a big hat wants to think you are is up to himself!!

      Personally I couldn’t a monkey’s curse what happens to me when I kick the bucket or who mutters what nonsense while they dispose of me in some hole or whatever. What does bother me is that the Roman Church is given to believe that it has the support of 84% of the Irish population in it’s discriminatory, corrupt and abusive influences while I’m alive!

      Reply
    • I was lucky enough to get out before they found the loophole, you couldn’t make this stuff up, they now say its not possible to leave. So though I have a letter from the bishop confirming I’m out, I don’t know if I am or not. I need to consult a canon lawyer or maybe the tooth fairy might know. If all else fails I’ll send a letter to Santa.

      Reply
    • Nonsense. I have been out of the catholic church for over forty years. They don’t bother me and I don’t bother them. They have no hold over anyone other than the parents of small children who are seeking education for their sprigs. This is now changing, albeit not quickly enough.

      Reply
    • Hear, hear! And Ada, it’s great that you’re out of the church. You were ahead of your time :)

      The point, though, is that at present, outside of excommunication (which is harder to obtain than you think) there is no way to officially remove yourself from the register. So, as John rightly pointed out, the church continues to look strong, and Ireland continues to look like a staunchly catholic country.

      Which, in turn, also contributes to some ‘interesting’ political decisions by our masters, but that’s by the by…

      Reply
  • At least this time, it is an alleged abuse of power in relation to priests and seminarians, not the sexual abuse of children.

    The Roman Catholic Church and its adherents are sexually obsessed despite their advocacy of chastity.

    Reply
  • Religion…..2013……..wake up people, read a science book, use logic and unburden yourself.

    Reply
  • Strange how this comes hot on the heels of his statement that priests should be allowed to marry if thy wish. What a snake pit that Vatican is!

    Reply
  • Im tired of religion and I tried leaving the RC church through that website mentioned above, but unfortunately was too late on the uptake.
    Can you have your name taken off the register another way ?

    Reply
    • Excommunication is one method but you would have to murder a bishop or cardinal and I don’t advocate that.

      Reply
    • Nah, it actually pretty easy to be excommunicated and it usually happens automatically. They don’t even have to tell you. Technically I’ve been excommunicated, would LOVE to have it in writing. I’d have it framed!

      Reply
    • My great grandfather was excommunicated on the initiative of Archbishop McHale because he was so active in his participation in the Land League.

      In fairness, supporting the rights of tenant farmers was appalling behaviour and endangered mortgage repayments by large landowners to the Roman Catholic Church. So he deserved his excommunication.

      I managed to get out before the website was closed down. I personally don’t favour supporting child sexual abuse organisations. It is no coincidence that the Roman Catholic Church don’t allow female priests. Women tend to to be hostile to and intolerant of child sexual abuse and would find it hard to adjust to the reality of the ethos of the Roman Catholic Church priesthood.

      The fact that comment will prove more outrage than the sexually predatory and rapacious conduct of Roman Catholic clergy will confirm my views of the moral blindness of the Roman Catholic Chuch.

      Reply
  • When I heard hin say he was in favour of married priests I thought he might have a mistress or a child (or both). (See my comment in the previous article).
    Very, very sad for the people who have put their faith in this rotten-to-the-core organisation.

    Reply
  • ‘Zeitgeist’ on YouTube or Nerflix

    That is all.

    Reply
  • God save us.

    Reply
  • Buggered to bejaysus.

    Reply

Add New Comment