TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Dutch vote to test EU popularity in tough times

As the nation heads into elections this week, observers are wondering which of the two Netherlands will emerge: the EU guiding light or the harbinger of European disarray.

Dutch Prime Minister and Liberal Party leader Mark Rutte
Dutch Prime Minister and Liberal Party leader Mark Rutte
Image: AP Photo/Peter Dejong

THE NETHERLANDS HAS long been a source of inspiration for closer European integration — and a bellwether of European discontent.

It was one of six nations that forged fledgling European unity from the ashes of World War II, and a force behind the treaty that created the euro currency. Yet, along with France, it also put itself at the vanguard of the euro-skeptic tide by rejecting a proposed European constitution in a referendum.

As the nation heads into elections on Wednesday, observers are wondering which of the two Netherlands will emerge: the EU guiding light or the harbinger of European disarray.

The answer could be an indication of the very direction of Europe.

The European mood

“Every Dutch election has been at the forefront of what is the mood everywhere in Europe,” says political analyst Piotr Maciej Kaczynski of the Center for European Policy studies.

In 2005, Dutch voters deepened a major continental crisis by rejecting a historic EU constitution just three days after the French gave their historic “Non” — effectively killing the charter. In the upcoming elections, the Dutch are pondering even greater existential questions for Europe — whether to stick with the union and its currency or try to fix both from the inside.

Not surprisingly, the most extreme view — ditch the European Union — comes from firebrand populist Geert Wilders, who first rose to prominence with strident anti-Islam rhetoric that resonated across Europe. At the other end of the spectrum is outgoing prime minister Mark Rutte, a staunch believer in EU integration who also hews closely to the hardline budgetary conservatism of German Chancellor Angela Merkel.

In between are a slew of euro-skeptic parties that are also nonetheless conscious of the bloc’s importance to the Netherlands, a nation whose economy is built on exports.

‘A more social Europe’

The leader of one such party is Emile Roemer, who heads the left-wing Socialists. His campaign symbol is the tomato, after the rotten fruit his supporters feel to be the just desserts of the EU-loving political establishment.

Roemer gained fame during the campaign by saying that, if he joins the next Dutch ruling coalition, the Netherland would pay fines to Brussels for missing budget targets “over my dead body.” At a recent campaign stop in his home town of Boxmeer, a verdant town in eastern Netherlands close to the German border, Roemer handed out tomato-flavored ice cream and said he wants “a more social Europe.”

His Socialists polled strongly throughout summer campaigning, before falling back to third place in a complicated race that will likely lead to long negotiations to form the next ruling coalition.

Labor Party leader Diederik Samsom, whose criticism of the EU is more moderate, has now taken over from Roemer as the torch bearer for the left going into Wednesday’s vote.

There is nothing moderate about Wilders, who argues that Europe has turned into a costly charity project for his country. He says that wealthy northern European nations like the Netherlands and Germany have spent billions bailing out debt-ridden governments in Greece and Portugal, which he casts as profligate beyond reform.

“The best days of the Netherlands are ahead of us if we no longer pay southern Europe, if we become a master of our own house, and are able to take our own decisions again,” he said during a high-profile televised debate at Amsterdam’s Carre theater.

Fluctuating polls

Polls have been fluctuating over the past months, and the latest indicate that Wilders could lose up to a fourth of the 24 seats he won at the last Dutch election in 2010. Rutte’s party tops polls, with Samsom’s Labor trailing close behind.

The Netherlands and an expanding EU were long a perfect match for this centuries-old trading nation.

In the wake of World War II and ensuing hunger, Sicco Mansholt, a Dutch farmer who became the fourth president of the European commission, formed a vision of a united Europe in which nations would work together to stave off famine. He was the architect of a common European farm policy that eventually evolved into deeper economic union.

The Dutch government also was one of the driving forces behind the 1993 treaty that ushered in monetary union and, eventually, the euro currency. The treaty was signed in the picturesque southern Dutch city of Maastricht and still bears its name.

But the 2005 “No” vote on the EU constitution and anti-EU resentments that have deepened ever since show the Netherlands now to be possibly at the forefront of a continental tipping point.

Certainly, the generosity that once accompanied the EU’s expansion into poorer nations has largely evaporated.

And the way the Dutch vote on Wednesday will be parsed for potential insights into the outcome of elections next year in a much more important rich northern European country: Germany.

“This is the prelude before the huge elections we will have next year in Germany,” Kaczynski said.

Read: Ireland making ‘such good progress on all fronts’ – Van Rompuy>

Read next:

Comments (23 Comments)

  • EU? It’s no longer a European Union that serves the people, it has become a Banking Union that only serves the rich.

    Reply
  • We need to lessen the power Europe holds over Ireland not strengthen it !!!

    Reply
    • So that another failed corrupt Government can take Ireland back into the dark ages?
      Come on people. You didn’t complain when the EU was pumping money into the country to build a better Ireland?
      Now you’re complaining when they have setup rules to how the Government spends the money lent to us so that we don’t starve!
      Has anybody really got a better plan?
      And if so, get up and speak for yourself. Let’s do something constructive and stop complaining.

      Reply
    • Fagan 09/09/12 #

      ”Stop your complaining” Says the man who also says: “So that another failed corrupt Government can take Ireland back into the dark ages”

      A historical perspective on the relative success of self-determination would reveal that the Irish Governments have actually been incredibly successful. In the roughly 90 years of independence Ireland has managed to become one of the most educated and advanced economies in Europe. Our relative success is fairly incomparable. A look at almost any statistical output confirms this, life expectancy, crime, even in relation to our obsession over road deaths Ireland is among the best in the world, only behind the UK and Sweden and far ahead of the US. For brevity’s sake I’ll just emphasise how the Economist ranked Ireland in 2006 as the best country to live in in the world.

      Lets compare this to conditions where we were not in control of our own affairs: Famines of 1740-41 (The year of the Slaughter), 1845–1849, and 1879. Rebellions in 1798 (United Irishmen), 1803, 1830-36 Tithe war, 1848 Young Irelander Rebellion, 1867 Fenian Rising, The Land War, , 1916 and finally 1919. If you go back again, its pretty much more famines and more rebellions. If you begin to wonder were these minor skirmishes without mass appeal then look at

      The overriding lesson from self determination is politics is not a benevolent process. Political pressures from the (domestic) selectorate will always override benevolent will and it would be foolish to think otherwise.

      Reply
    • Fagan 09/09/12 #

      I meant to add to *look at…* :

      Electoral results. The Irish vote was solid right through the 1800s. The population were in no doubt that self-determination was better.

      Reply
  • I often wonder if the Dutch would have voted in favour of the EU constitution if they were forced into a revote but that only happens to servile little non important countries.

    Reply
  • It’ll be interesting to see how the outcome of this election will impact on the previous decision to greatly curb the access of foreigners to the coffeeshops. If the limit/ban does come into effect next year the Dutch tourism sector will be decimated.

    Reply
  • @caroline Hughes Caroline you got it one and all these pro-european people will soon realise Europe will have us going around like drones we won’t be even allowed to think for ourselves with all their do’s
    And don’ts so pro-euros be very careful what you wish for !!!

    Reply
    • @ Grainne, Yes, could not have put it better! The EU is a ‘big government’ operation and has seized ‘competencies’ that they are not entitled to, because in the end that system is full to the brim with over paid incompetent people. Our government here are the same, a complete ship of fools attempting to ‘lead’ people who are far more enlightened. The reality is this-Ireland is a ship with the rudder chains cut. Until we have heroic, open minded thinkers in positions to do something, we will have this choice, Martin (idiot one) or Edna (idiot two) it really is Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dumber. We have to grow up- and fast-in our thinking. Another two years of this and we will not be able to pull back from the precipice, we will all go over the cliff into a hell on Earth called the fascist superstate corporation, where Rights will be erased at the point of a pistol, you think it can’t happen here-think again it is happening in America now! http://blog.alexanderhiggins.com/2011/08/21/america-is-a-police-state-the-handling-of-deadly-police-brutality-cases-proves-it-61511/
      America, land of the free and home of the brave? More like land of the fee and home of the slave! If we don’t wake up, it will be us next!

      Reply
  • I think many people are waking up to the reality that the EU project is going down a totalitarian and fascist road. All the petty ‘laws’ they keep foisting on the European peoples and the alarming rate at which our Rights are being diminished. Free speech is on the way out as well where everything is censored and sterilized of meaning. In reality the Euro failed back in 2008 and with it the ‘EU dream’ but the arrogance of the political establishment just can’t admit they got it wrong, mia culpa is just not in their book of words! As a gardener and self supporter I am sick and tired of EU interference in my way of living, with petty restrictions on vitamins, silly rules regarding the environment that have no basis in science. The EU is run by people who are technically incompetent-even the over paid ‘expert advisors’ come from vested interest groups and their ‘expert opinion’ can not be relied on as being honest or factual.
    End of rant!

    Reply
  • Love to see the United states of Europe project fall apart.

    Reply
  • …and watch countries turn to anarchy and turmoil? Eh, no thanks.

    Reply
  • Thanks for the History lesson Fagan!
    I’m not doubting Self Determination one bit!
    You cannot say the Government of the day has Self Determination! They are very much ruled by Brussels and Brussels is ruled by God Knows who !
    Do you think Ireland is the only country in the same situation? No my friend Ireland is not alone!

    Reply

Add New Comment