TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

‘Ireland is a special case’: Kenny and Merkel commit to improving bailout

Enda Kenny and Angela Merkel issue a joint statement describing Ireland as “a special case” financially.

Enda Kenny and Angela Merkel speak to reporters after a meeting in Berlin last year. The two have issued a joint statement today acknowledging Ireland's financial situation is
Enda Kenny and Angela Merkel speak to reporters after a meeting in Berlin last year. The two have issued a joint statement today acknowledging Ireland's financial situation is "a special case".
Image: Michael Sohn/AP

TAOISEACH ENDA KENNY and the German chancellor Angela Merkel have issued a joint statement affirming that Europe remains committed to splitting Ireland’s banking and sovereign debts.

The statement comes after the two leaders spoke by telephone this afternoon.

Their joint communiqué says the pair had “discussed the unique circumstances behind Ireland’s banking and sovereign debt crisis” and the deal reached by EU leaders four months ago, where they agreed to end the ‘vicious circle’ of banking and sovereign debts.

The two “reaffirmed” that deal, where heads of state told the 17 Eurozone finance ministers “to examine the situation of the Irish financial sector with a view to further improving the sustainability of the well performing adjustment programme”.

The statement said Ireland was recognised as “a special case”, given the circumstances under which Ireland was frozen out of the bond markets, and said the finance ministers would take this into account when examining how to improve the terms of Ireland’s bailout deal.

The communiqué comes after Merkel appeared to throw a spanner in the works of attempts to improve Ireland’s financial situation, and help it to return to international money markets, when insisting that the Eurozone’s new permanent bailout fund could not recapitalise banks retrospectively.

Though Merkel had been asked about how the issue would concern Spain, the move was seen as a blow to Ireland – though the door remained open for the bailout fund, the ESM, to perhaps acquire some of the Irish state’s shareholding in the banks it has paid €64.1 billion to save.

The acknowledgement from Merkel that Ireland is a ‘special case’, however, will encourage the government in its bid to improve the state of Ireland’s financial outlook – particularly as the statement refers to the “unique circumstances” behind Ireland’s debt crisis, in which state aid for struggling banks had played a major part.

Kenny and Merkel: the statement in full

The Taoiseach Enda Kenny and Chancellor Angela Merkel spoke together this afternoon.

They discussed the unique circumstances behind Ireland’s banking and sovereign debt crisis, and Ireland’s plans for a full return to the markets. In this regard they reaffirmed the commitment from June 29th to task the Eurogroup to examine the situation of the Irish financial sector with a view to further improving the sustainability of the well performing adjustment programme.

They recognise in this context, that Ireland is a special case, and that the Eurogroup will take that into account.

Read: Rabbitte slams ‘orgy of negativity’ over bank debt deal

Read next:

Comments (158 Comments)

  • Actions speak louder than words… Please get on with it !!!

    Reply
  • As informative as this article is, I can’t get past the ?64.1billion.
    Makes me sick.

    Reply
  • Ok well that seems a bit more positive that her last statement. If they don’t do this though we will never get out of this hole!

    Reply
  • Positive sounding statement. Hopefully we see the action in due course.

    Reply
  • less talk more deal

    Reply
  • Special case more like basket case !!

    Reply
  • I really wonder what has been promised in return.

    Reply
  • If this turns out to be a deal on the debt that is not ours, fantastic, until then these are just more words being used to kick that much battered can!

    Reply
  • Seems like positive news. Now for the standard cynicism that generally gets commented on here…..

    Reply
    • Oh yeah. The web is just full of cynicism. I was built for cynics. Ignore then

      Reply
    • Cynicism is a necessity in today’s EU. I’ll believe It when I see it. My guess is we will be spun along with vague promises for years until every cent has been paid back to German and French banks only then to be told to suck it up. If you believe anything else you a being very naive.

      Reply
    • SShh..don’t be disturbing Polyanna. Realism not allowed…bad for confidence. And ya can’t have white-collar confidence trickery without yer confidence.

      Reply
    • @Derek… the web is full of cynics? I’ll believe that when I see it.

      @Tom- naive? Not me sir…. Enda Kenny cares personally about me, my family and my future… didn’t he go to my Granny’s cousin’s funeral and he gave me a secret wink one night when he was on Primetime.

      @Damien- I agree that we have to be realistic… positivity at the expense of fact and likelihood is tiring and false. However it seems that the vocal online tend towards glass half empty more often than half full on here. Hopefully it’s a step in the right direction.

      And yes…. I will hold my hands up and admit that I Googled ‘Polyanna.’ I’m now going to square peg it into my daily conversations as a metaphorical slap in the face to the uninformed. #smug

      Reply
  • These spin speeches are worse than the repeated Jobs action plans we keep getting every month

    Reply
  • da rant 21/10/12 #

    We are a “special” case alright. To have paid all the unsecured bondholders, “special” isn’t the word!!! Lets see the deal that saves us first before we cannonise Enda!!!

    Reply
  • Irish Times now picked up this story.

    Its nothing more than Spin.

    From the Times.
    Taoiseach Enda Kenny and the German Chancellor Angela Merkel reaffirmed tonight the commitment made on June 29th to task the Eurogroup “to examine situation of the Irish financial sector with a view to further improving the sustainability of the well performing adjustment programme.”

    FFS, how long to they need to “Examine the situation”.

    Spin, Spin, Spin to keep the Irish happy just at a time when we were actually starting to question this government.

    No dates, No deadlines, Just Spin.

    Reply
    • MrKnow 21/10/12 #

      your correct, it is a spin. The fact is the government has run out of ideas a long time ago and they are going to try and milk the taxpayer for what they have.

      Reply
    • Real Ireland the time required to examine the situation is until all the bond holders are payed. So not this year and not next year as we will be paying 17 billion to bond holders next year. Not sure if we have more bondholders to pay off in 2014. But what ever once we have done that we will be cut loose.

      Reply
  • Special because we done what was needed thank you all the people like myself who just done what was needed instead of moaning. Hard work always pays off

    Reply
  • Talk is cheap, lets see action and no more broken promises from FG/Labour!

    Reply
    • Stephen
      You are correct , talk is cheap. This is nothing more than spin. Kenny saw the reactions of people on friday evening and on saturday and he got worried the cash cow aka Irish tax payers were going to waken up to the fact that we are being robbed . He got afraid and rang his boss to get help…

      Reply
  • StemC 21/10/12 #

    Delay delay delay and all the while we are still forking out for bond payments. Christ almighty they must think we’re stupid. Greece needs 13.5 billion euro In further cuts next month so that will top the agenda until the new year and we will be put to the back of queue all the while paying off more bonds

    Reply
  • Hon Kenny !

    Reply
    • Sadly, WE know that this is window dressing. Germany and the EU have zero intention of taking the European banking debt back off the Irish shoulders. Why should they, we have already made it soevereign. They can renegotiate the loan over 50 years, but that will still mean that 20% of all Irish tax paid over the next 20 years will go to pay off the banking debt.
      The Emperor has no clothes, and trust me, Enda Kenny in the Nip is not something any of us want to see… Photo Op or Not.

      Reply
    • I don’t see anything particularly positive in that statement. Queen of Europe wants to help us get back in the markets where we can borrow money from German banks rather than borrow it from the Troika. There is nothing concrete about what we really need – debt restructuring.

      Reply
    • Their taking the p— !

      Reply
    • We need considerably more than debt restructuring.

      The system is unfit for 21st century purpose, its still running on a 19th century imperial Great Gameplan. Primitive minds in pin-stripes won’y solve the raft of planetary shit heading for the fan.

      Read a little history. These cycles are unsustainable, the oscillations are getting more extreme. These people have invested their careers in a redundant model, they won’t abandon it now.

      Reply
    • If Merkel wants us to borrow from her banks, then why is she asking us to close our deficit?

      What you’ve just said makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.

      Reply
    • Its clear what germany wants David, to give Ireland a small bit of breathing space to allow us to continue to pay off debt thats not ours. This will happen and your leader and noonan will hail it as a victory.

      Reply
    • Yeah, Merkel just loves being forced into a clarification on a Sunday afternoon by a country a fraction in size of her own and with herself up for election in a matter of months…..

      Reply
    • Didn’t see anything in the article about the frau being ‘forced’ to do anything David, and I doubt inda would be the person to do it considering he wouldn’t even face ursula halligan in a debate pre-referendum.

      Reply
  • Greece gets a 100 billion write-off of its debt, and Ireland gets a vague statement declaring that we are a special case. Meaningless platitudes. Kenny gets a humiliating pat on the head from Sarcozy, and today on page four of the Sindo, we have Noonon getting a pat on the head from the Eurogroup president Jean Claude Juncker. This is beyond humiliation.It is absurd, grotesque and utterly shamefullof our so called leaders.

    Reply
    • It’s just insulting to those adults who get patted on the head like school children but its devastating for us who put our faith in them to deliver us from this nightmare and now find that our future was placed in the hands of people who pretend to be tough when seeking office but turn out to be something entirely different. A confidence trick. Performed by Con Men.

      Reply
  • The key issue in terms of timing is the upcoming Budget. If our fiscal situation improves after that it might be too late for the likes of some elderly people who will be denied home help etc etc.

    Reply
  • mike 21/10/12 #

    If he pulls this off we might let Mayo win the all Ireland next year.

    Reply
  • Senan 21/10/12 #

    Good to see the government force a statement on this from Europe – well done

    Reply
  • Got to play hardball with theses Eurocrats Kenny

    Reply
  • more political hype believe it when it happens

    Reply
    • Isn’t it extraordinary that we have so many people whose only outlook on life and politics is so negative. Do most of you not realise that when the Taoiseach is in Brussels at Meetings as serious as this one that he need all the support he can get rather than the appalling criticisms that are actually undermining the Irish position.
      We are so ignorant as a people with the childlike belief that we can make public comment about the most powerful European policing by accusing her of being a Nazi and a Fuhrer and think it doesn’t matter or it won’t bet back to her. We then go on sites such as this and abuse the politicians who have to negotiate with these people with such a tainted and embarrassing background.
      Sometimes you get the resuLts you deserve!

      Reply
    • Put the cork back in the bottle Paddy !! Or Mick ……

      Reply
    • Absolutely deluded Paddy, no wonder are country has been sold out to the highest bidders with spineless Vichyites like yourself who unquestionably follow our “great leaders” (debt collectors) and their German overlords.Your not even worth this comment.

      Reply
  • One good thing may come from this.

    Enda clearly has been feeling the pressure all weekend, Obviously he has had to get off his lazy arse and contact Merkel and somehow manage to get her to make a statement about us being special.

    Hopefully Enda may now realise that when backed into a corner the Germans also cave in and if he pushed harder for a deal we may just get one.

    Time to fight Mr Kenny and force something from them. No more Mr Nice guy, the milky bar kid is in town.

    Reply
  • Arbeit macht frei.

    In fairness to Kenny though, at least he puts huge effort in. Biffo would have gone on the beer for the weekend.

    Reply
  • Has there been a soft landing? Have we just turned another corner? Not one red cent? Frankfurt’s way or Labour’s way? Wear the green Jersey? Jobs Boost? 3.2% growth this year? Bank Deal? or is just more bags of smoke? One thing’s for sure CPA is go. Death to the taxpayers!

    Reply
  • I think this is just spin, I think that merkal is going to sell out on.ireland as she has her own interests to protect (german.elections,next year)

    Reply
  • Has Enda found the G spot ?

    Reply
  • If you all can comment so well on this site why don’t you get out there and do something about what is happening to this country . If we allow our supposed leaders to continue to do as the EU and the bankers want we will have to eventually default on our debt. There is no way as a nation we can ever pay these debts we are accruing and we are only getting in deeper. We need to look to our nearest neighbours Iceland for the solution as to what I and others suggested doing three years ago and we could be well on our way to getting out of the austerity the E U and others want us to give in to. We are only selling on this debt to our children and our children’s children.

    Reply
    • The reality is that every Government sells debt on the their children and their children’s children. Debt is constantly rolled over and reissued. That’s how global markets work. In ireland’s case the problem is that the bank guarantee loaded too much debt too quickly.

      We’re never going to get all of that debt taken away. Any deal will only remove some of this debt but the reality is that if some of it can be removed instantly and the rest can be put on the long finger, inflation will reduce the amount of debt in real terms. Also over a longer period if the economy grows the ratio of debt to the value of the economy shrinks as well.

      Reply
    • One other point. Iceland didn’t have a huge gap in the fiscal spending when their banks collapsed. Therefore they didn’t need to plug a hole in their finances in 2007/8. We not only had to pump money into the banks, we also had a yawning fiscal gap because Government spending was being pumped up on the back of unsustainable tax revenues.

      However because the Icelandic currency collapsed they now have a debt to GDP ratio higher than Ireland and a budget deficit every bit as big as ours. That should be a lesson for all those people who tell us we should leave the Euro because that’s what would happen to a new Irish pound.

      Reply
    • Do you have some links about Iceland’s fiscal spending at the time Jim?
      I’ve never heard that before, the only reasoning I’ve ever heard is because of our membership in the Euro.

      Reply
  • German verb einstellen had dual meaning that is “to adjust” or to “abandon”. Let’s hope she means the first, either way at least fianna fail are gone!!

    Reply
  • Until we actually see a renegotiated deal on our debt this is mere empty rhetoric from Merkel. This statement should not be lauded as a win for Kenny, as it will no doubt be spun by the government.

    Reply
  • Simple answer is, Get a journalist any journalist will do , and ask the German finance minister this, Is Ireland getting a retrospective deal on its banking debt Yes or No …..

    Reply
  • I wouldn’t be surprised if we didn’t see any straight talking until after the german election next autumn, an meybe not even then

    Reply
  • Hopeful more than positive….it’s very hard to believe a word that comes out of either of them. I get the impression tht Merkel is saying ths just to shut Kenny up and to stop him frim ringing her….I’d be sceptical although would hope to be proved wrong.

    Reply
    • I wouldn’t care what the reason is. If it was because of the 6-1 soccer result, it wouldn’t matter. If it was to shut Enda up, fair play to him. It’s another step in the right direction.

      Reply
  • GROW A PAIR ENDA INSTEAD OF GROVELLING LIKE THE WIMP YOU ARE TAKE THE ECB TO THE EUROPEAN COURT,,WHAT THEY DID TO US WAS AND IS ILLEGAL,,AT LEAST THREATEN THEM WITH THE COURTS YOU SPINELESS IDIOT

    Reply
  • Just throwing us a few crumbs to keep us under the thumb and working for nothing… cheers Enda!

    Reply
  • MrKnow 21/10/12 #

    It really looks like enda in the photo is thinking ‘oh shit, we really are f#%ked’

    Reply
  • One of Merkel’s advisers obviously saw that her weekend speech- in which she outlined her clear intention- had caused some political difficulty for her most obedient little poodle among the PIIGS leaders. To fob him off without committing anything whatsoever, the advisor scripted this meaningless hot air – interchangeable with statements to Greece, Spain etc, so now Enda looks slightly less of a spineless failure than everybody knows he is. It’s all blah blah until we LEAVE THE EURO.

    Reply
    • Leave the Euro? You think its bad now, it will be 10 times as bad if we leave the Euro!!

      Reply
    • @ David, sadly, you’re absolutely right. This would be possibly the very worst moment to leave the Euro, saddled with debt that would still be in Euro, and with very little worth on which to base a new currency on. It “might” have worked as an alternative to accepting a bail-out, but the country needs to recover a sizeable amount before considering this.

      Reply
    • The country with the most to lose from a break-up of the Euro is Germany. Factor that into our negotiation stance. We would be leaving all this unplayable debt behind if we did leave, but it is more likely the debt would be written off before we got to that point. Unfortunately.

      Reply
    • Ireland would grind to an economic halt if we left the Euro.

      People may think that Goverments can print unlimited amounts of money but the reality is they can’t. A new Irish pound would devalue hugely against every major currency thus increasing our debt level because our existing debt would be in Euro and other foreign currencies. Our import costs would rise accordingly, interest rates would go up significantly triggering massive mortgage defaults and our banks would have no access to the liquidity that the ECB is currently giving them so they’d probably collapse. In effect we’d be exactly where we were in 2008 and the four years of hardship that we’ve already suffered would have counted for absolutely nothing.

      The rest of Europe including Germany would suffer if Ireland defaulted and left the Euro but our economy is a fraction of the entire EU economy so the effects would be fair worse here than anywhere else.

      Reply
    • Jim the point is that getting away from the Euro means getting away from the ECB. We have a valid point that the money we borrowed was forced on us and done to prop up foreign bondholders- ie it is “odious debt” and we can quite rightly repudiate it, and I would suggest to anyone to read up on how Ecuador did this successfully. A devaluation is exactly what we need, and as yet untapped oil could be leveraged against oil imports, the main problem with devaluation. It may involve finding new international partners, but any right-thinking person can see that the ECB, Germany, France et al aren’t partners at all, they are owners with nothing but contempt for us. It’s time we started seeing ourselves as participants in this mess whose actions can affect the overall dynamic, rather than frightened little children observing from the sidelines. And as for Germany, the biggest fear they have is their current customers devaluing their currency against them..who would they sell to? It would terrify them and they would have far more to lose than we would.

      Reply
    • @robin , you seem to completely ignore the mess our domestic finances are In which is the main reason we are in a bailout program , current levels of running this country cost about 20bn more per year than we generate in tax , that’s 100bn in 5 years , where can we access that level of capital if OT Europe , are you forgetting the reason we are in a program us because we can’t borrow on the markets , all the anti euro grandstanding sounds great and populous but you have not given a single credible workable alternative.

      Reply
    • Dave, there is no “credible” solution that maintains the wealth in the country, including the current path.

      Reply
    • Well trying to separate the debt , get a write down , readjust the current spending and get a bit real with running costs is route that if implemented might, FFS we still pay John Delaney 360000 to run football , mariane Finnucane 500000 euro to do weekend radio show and on and on it goes …….

      Reply
  • I think Merkel might be worried that Enda could be in trouble in the not so distant future about his fat income and pension. Time will tell.

    Reply
  • jazus i may stand corrected but the words unique and special are vague. after 3 days he has at least got a statement out of her

    Reply
  • So where is the deal?

    Oh wait we have to wait yet again for another round of talks, which will result in another round of talks and another round of talks and ……

    Yea right,

    If we have a debt deal give us a debt deal, We have a budget in 8 weeks time it would be nice for once to have a budget that isnt going to screw those who can least afford it yet again!

    Reply
  • Enda is Special ok,real Special.

    Reply
  • To those saying that this comment is just “spin” – why the hell would Merkel bother her arse? She had no reason to release a joint statement, unless it was meant. Ireland is a very small piece of the Euro crisis. The statements on retrospective debt deals is actually aimed at the big guns like Italy and Spain, ironically for future reference. The deal needs to be done but credit so far where it’s due to Kenny for baffling feathers in Europe to get our (relatively speaking) small issue on the agenda.

    Reply
    • To keep the markets happy tommorow morning.

      I have no doubt the plan is to get Ireland back to the bond markets and then dump us, tommorow our bonds would have jumped the wrong way if they thought we werent getting a deal.

      No they can rest easy because its back to square one, a promise that sometime in the future they will discuss the special country Ireland. Nothing more.

      Reply
    • She did it, and there was absolutely nothing substantive in the statement, because Ireland has been no trouble to Europe/Germany. We borrowed the money from them to pay back their bondholders and we will then be paying them back for decades, they will proffit greatly from our meek obedience, all they have to do is give us the odd gold star, not like the Greeks.
      Now if things were to change and our politicians were to be seen to be what they are, useless, and Ireland suddenly began to cause trouble, protests, strikes and mobs on the street maybe a new election, maybe the next lot would actually be a bit more militant. No, no, Germany couldn’t have that, they’ll protect their interests, their money, even if that means Angela Merkel appears to say something nice to Ireland, she may even throw us a few crumbs next to keep us content. Who knows?

      Reply
    • real Ireland: nail on the head

      Reply
    • She is afraid we will carry out the threat, no more Kerrygold Unless.

      Reply
    • They cannot afford for Ireland or in particular the Irish to start questioning any of this. We have to be be seen as pliable , compliant, well behaved and doing as we are told ….€64,000,000,000 Jesus we are pure idiots for not putting a stop to this nightmare !

      Reply
  • Will resist the urge to be sceptical & cynical (for now!).
    This statement makes no concrete commitment & sounds an awful lot like the typical FG spin HOWEVER I’d rather support it for now.

    Reply
  • Since when did herr mearkel become the leader of Europe come back Churchill we need you

    Reply
  • Good man Enda, Keep letting them shit on your head and saying thanks for the hat. That’ll get us places. Cap doffing eejit

    Reply
  • Embarrassing.

    Reply
  • Puppet

    Reply
  • Now line up all the critics all the moaners and all the whingers together with all the politicians from Fianna Fail and Sinn Fein in particular and offer a public and a sincere apology to the Taoiseach for the abuse heaped on him constantly sine he assumed office but particularly since he returned from Brussels.
    Where are they……………..slinking off into the long grass to hide from the responsibility they need to accept for continually running down the efforts being made on their behalf and specifically making that task harder through their ignorance and stupidity.
    Well done Mr Kenny and colleagues. We owe you a DEBT …..of gratitude.

    Reply
    • Senan 21/10/12 #

      Spot on Paddy, well done lads, hopefully they can leverage this statement to get an agenda item on the next meeting of finance minesters

      Reply
    • Please, spare us! I’ll be the first in line to congratulate them if they get a decent deal on the debt, and by that I mean a write down, not stretching it out for 50 or 100 years!
      There’s nothing in that statement but posturing, when is this change going to happen; WHEN are they going to take it into consideration that Ireland is a “special case”???
      And when (if) they eventually get around to it, who says they won’t come to the same conclusion anyway.
      Nothing to be happy about here, we don’t owe them anything, but between this lot and the last shower, they owe us 10′s of billions.
      Get a grip!

      Reply
    • Paddy, go to bed and have a good sleep.

      Reply
    • Paddy apology for what?what deal has he got?If something isn’t done about our debt,people in this country would rise up.All this statement is for is to keep us calm for another while.As another commentator on here said there never was a deal,Merkel never agreed a deal.The only people saying she agreed a deal was our government.

      Reply
    • this statement doesnt change a thing. there is no commitment to do anything only looking at our situation and taking it into account. she didnt confirm anything on the deal the gov are harping on about. i will give credit where its due but none due yet.

      Reply
    • An apology for what. They have said nothing new only reaffirmed the statement from June which is worthless. She was clear on Friday that there will be no retrospective recapitalisation of banks. FFG/Labour can come on here in droves and try to spin it otherwise but there is not one word in that statement to indicate that she has changed her mind on this. And there is no way Spain or Portugal will accept having to pay out if we got a deal and they didn’t.

      Reply
    • Get real, thank Kenny my hole, I didn’t hear the magic words and that statement was dragged out of her after a lot of wrangling through fear of the markets hammering our bonds in the morning!

      Reply
    • Paddy there is only one word I can use to describe your comment.

      PREMATURE.

      Perhaps you should wait until there’s actually an official statement before you rush to congratulate, celebrate and demand apologies..

      Reply
    • @Paddy
      When you realise that the ‘deal’ Edna Kenny is talking about is a restructuring of the time frame of the debt, not a write down, I’ll give you a screen grab of that statement you have just made, so that you can see in the cold light of day, just how ridiculous it actually is…

      Reply
    • Hi Joe, restructuring the time frame is as good as a reduction of debt. It’s known as inflating away the debt. Lots of countries have done it.

      Reply
    • Seeing is believing—- Action speaks louder than words—-how many times before have we had broken promises!!

      Reply
  • NOT

    Reply
  • “Go Enda… It’s your birthday…”

    *doin’ the Dad dance*

    Reply
  • We so lucky to have Mr Kenny in charge.

    Reply
  • How do you know a politician is lying? Their lips are moving!

    Reply
  • Youi may laugh and scoff, but the realy sad thing about this is that this is the best he could do: yet another vague promise…

    Reply
  • I am suck of Politicians speaking from their very well written scripts and speeches,written for them by their over paid advisors They speak the speech and not with intelligence

    Reply
  • its all a load shit kenny and co said before been elected that not 1 cent would they get and guess what they haven,t just billions out of us all of them are looking after themselves and couldn,t give a shit about anyone else

    Reply
    • You’re wrong. FG said that no MORE money would be put into the banks beyond what had already been agreed. The existing payments would be honoured but that was it. And while you probably won’t believe it, that is exactly what has happened.

      Reply
  • “Special” is the German word for “basket.”

    Reply
  • Here here! United we stand. Divided we fall. Wize words and the founding cornerstone of the Eu. The sovereign must be split from the financial, the alternative is to fully create a financial system that is 100% public owned and minus any liabilities from the private era. Communism although a favourable ideal in many respects may fail again. Ireland Is getting out of the mess Europe is now finding itself in and not even Germany will be immune. Soon the Irish people will be asked to help Europe in the same way as we were asked to help Africa.

    Reply
  • I’ve got a solution. Sue the Germans for bombing the North Strand in WW2. With retrospective interest added on the settlement should clear our debt ;) hehe

    Reply
  • Spin? The only spinning here is from the usual anti-Government sources that pervade Journal.

    Yesterday they were almost gleeful in the fact that apparantly a deal wouldn’t be done for Ireland’s banking debt because it allowed them to moan at the Government. Today of course when it looks like something will be done they’re straight out with their “this means nothing” comments. Yesterday they were all about Enda “growing a pair” and “standing up for Ireland” and “talking to Angela Merkel”. Today when he does that exact thing they’re still not happy.

    To be honest its fairly clear that some posters here actually don’t want a deal because it doesn’t suit their narrow political agenda. They’d probably be far happier if no deal was done and no doubt when a deal is done they still won’t be happy.

    Reply
    • Those people are actually complaining that this statement sounds very much like what we have head before and are yet to see any benefit from. There is nothing concrete in the statement, just a “we’ll bear it in mind, we’ll see”. We are sick of weaselling, we want something definite. That’s all. If you have a problem with that I would question why.

      Reply
    • *heard before

      Reply
    • Yes it does sound familiar because its a reiteration of the statement that came out at the previous meeting which acknowledged that some form of deal had to be done to break the link between sovereign and banking debt.

      That deal is being negotiated and every single statement that has come out since is basically different government playing to their local markets. So the Germans and the Finns want to be seen to be playing tough. The Irish want to emphasise that a deal is being done and the reality is that the negotiations happen behind closed doors. The problem here is that every negative statement by the Germans and the Finns is being held up as reality and every Irish statement is being denigrated as spin. The truth actually lies somewhere in between.

      Reply
    • So you are in know now,explain how you know a deal will be done.

      Reply
    • I’m not in the know but the reality is that a deal will be done in some format that allows every side to claim something. Ireland needs to get back into the financial markets next year or else they will have to get another bailout. Nobody in the EU wants Ireland to have to get another bailout so it will be in everybody’s interest to do a deal that is satisfactory enough for the markets to believe that Ireland can go its own way from 2013 onwards. If that means some form of debt reduction so that Ireland’s debt to GDP ratio can be sustainable then that’s what they’ll do.

      Reply
  • Anyone notice its only Journal.ie covering this story.

    Nothing from RTE, Not even from the website of the Taioseach.

    Where did Journal.ie pick this story up from?

    Reply
  • How bout the begrudgers like urself Shane get up off ye’r arses, run for election and do a better job…. Put up or shut up! It’s easy to criticise and if u have a better plan, genuinely I wud like to here it.

    Reply
  • after November on the Childrens Referendum” Eu will Want A Bailout For Germany And France” the bailout is Sooner than ye all think”The Month Before December” but They need the Article of Justice Reform in the Childrens Referendum to Make The Complete bailout Legal as we will open the can of Worms to Fundermental Human Rights Exposure”

    Reply
  • I can’t help wonder if people would think the statement is positive if the media wasn’t presenting it as such.

    So they have a “view to further improving the sustainability of the well performing adjustment programme” and think that “Ireland is a special case”
    What bailout country isn’t a special case and who’d want to dis-improve the situation?

    Seems pretty meaningless to me.

    Reply

Add New Comment